💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
September 25, 2026

Guilty Google Search Murder - Winchester, Indiana

This week, in Winchester, Indiana, a man is found brutally attacked, with several bags on his head, and some strange clues scattered around the house & his prize show car stolen. Detectives don't have much to go on, until an enormous clue drops into their lap, leading to a friend of the dead man, who has a scary history of fires & kidnapping. But he won't be easy to find, because he goes on the run, seemingly disappearing into thin air. This leads to even more crimes, and a very scary man on the loose!!

Along the way, we find out that Indiana apparently loves Hawaiian music, that you should never steal a very distictive car, and that arsonists, who kipnap, may just end up escalating to murder!!

New episodes, every Wednesday & Friday nights!!

Check us out on VIDEO Wednesday and Friday evenings on Netflix! www.netflix.com/smalltownmurder

Donate at patreon.com/crimeinsports or at paypal.com and use our email: crimeinsports@gmail.com

Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions!

Follow us on...

instagram.com/smalltownmurder

facebook.com/smalltownpod

Also, check out James & Jimmie's other shows, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!

Comments (30)

J
Joe the Cynic · October 7, 2026

As I’m listening I’m thinking Monty broke the heater to set things in motion knowing he didn’t have the funds to get it fixed

M
MisledChef · October 1, 2026

The mustang being found Marion is hilarious lmao

O
Orion Howard · September 30, 2026

GT40 lol

E
Eddie LeBoeuf Jr · September 30, 2026

Ford gt

M
Matt Fost · September 29, 2026

I from Winchester Virginia! This is the second time we’ve been mentioned on the show!

S
Sherry Stone · September 29, 2026

I know y'all hate Fla, but you have huge fans here, too. Can you please come here in the future instead of always going to the same venues? I would love to see y'all in person!!!

y
ya boi · September 28, 2026

NOT KINGMAN!

N
Nunya_bsnss · September 28, 2026

33:55 Caught me off guard while doing my little arts and crafts "NO GOD, WE'RE ALL FUCKED" 😂

T
Tasha · September 27, 2026

“A sentient piece of shit is less dangerous” 😂

M
Mary · September 27, 2026

James and Jimmie, please take care of yourselves! We need you!! Don’t overdo it, stop overdoing it, we can wait, you all are a treasure. ❤️

L
Lisa Conry · September 27, 2026

I cannot stop laughing at Jimmy's outrage that the money was borrowed.

T
Tasha · September 27, 2026

He was pissed about that! Jimmy does not play about them coins!

M
Mary · September 27, 2026

James’s imitation of Monte in jail with too much time and thinking was hilarious. Add a head cold and even funnier. “Hmmm.”

B
Bradley Geiger · September 27, 2026

The Midwest will get ya

A
ALL Panic…NO Disco 🪩 · September 27, 2026

“GTFO Green mile!!!!!” - another golden quote from our guy Jimmie!!

S
Sunshine · September 27, 2026

Lol ohhhhh my hometown is shipSHEwana or as we called it in high school shitifyouwana. Grew up with my dad working at one of the rv companies my entire life 😅

M
Madison Haddababyizzaboi · September 26, 2026

How did this guy not get the death penalty

7
70Boss302 · September 26, 2026

My husband is from a town of about 2,000 in Indiana. He's told me of at least 5 murders just from the 80s. Panhandles within trailer parks inside factories among pillbillies eatin possum.

J
Just Jamie · September 26, 2026

My former brother in law is on death row in Indiana State prison.

M
Michael Hinchley · September 26, 2026

Ford vs Ferrari. Watch it! Carroll Shelby built the GT40 to beat Ferrari & succeeded in 1966. The Shelby legend began. Sure the Cobra began a couple years earlier, but a small block & roofless. A GT40 is a supercar. Was a nemesis of the Vette until prices skyrocketed & the Vette came out with the new ZR1 & ZR1X. It is a crazy cool car. EVERY year it has been offered. I have had alot of built Mustangs. One of the best......03 Cobra Convertible with a Whipple. 700whp, but looked stock. I switched sides a few years back. Now 02 CETA (Trans Am) Convertible. Highly built, supercharged & nitrous, 850whp. Also looks stock.

7
70Boss302 · September 26, 2026

My issue with Mustangs is that they insist on having a useless back seat. Either make it an actual backseat or just go to a 2-seater. I have claustrophobic panic attacks just thinking about being back there.

J
Jill Royson · September 26, 2026

Charles Bronson, here in the UK, is a good example of going to prison then making it worse

M
Michael Hinchley · September 26, 2026

Winchester Speedway in Indiana is famous as the "World's Fastest Half-Mile" because of its extreme 37-degree banking on the turns. Steep Banking: The 37-degree slope allows race cars to carry immense speed through the corners without losing grip. Design: This high-banked asphalt layout creates a roller-coaster effect, leading drivers to compare racing there to flying "jet fighters in a gymnasium".Legacy: Located in Winchester, Indiana, it is one of the oldest and most legendary short tracks in American motorsports history.

J
James Mole Jr. · September 26, 2026

Nice work peezy and aisling. I came to see if anyone made the comments. Gran Torinos and galaxies are pretty sick. Performance wise raptors and the ford focus line ST and RS are pretty cool and quick

A
Aisling Warren · September 26, 2026

Their both right. Ford GT is the race car and the Mustang Shelby GT500 is 760 HP V8. They should visit Shipsewana, the Amish flea market center of the Midwest.

P
Peezy · September 26, 2026

99-04 is called the new edge mustang. the 05-09 is a S197. New Edge is considered classic at this point fer sure. S197s are not nearly as beloved. Also a Ford GT is a different car haha. just to help clear this up for everyone 😂😂😂. the car stuff had my crying laughing lolol.

K
Katerina Gilmore · September 26, 2026

Hands down the most hard working people in this business! Get well soon James!

M
Morgan Harris · September 26, 2026

There is in fact a race track here in Winchester. Also, our taco bell is easily the worst ever.

S
Savannah Malloy · September 26, 2026

I can totally relate to when they’re talking about body styles of Fords and Jimmie says “ah I’ve gone too far…” Every teacher and professor I ever had were even like, “chill with the critical thinking” 😂😂 which is even funnier now that my oldest nephew is at the point where he’s constantly like “why? But why? WHY?!” And I have to indulge him because my parents finally started asking me “why ask why?” And it drove me BANANAS.

M
Mary · September 27, 2026

One of my answers to the why’s of the why stage, when it fit, was “God and nature.” Might help a little. Kids can make your brain hurt.