The Great Replacement Goes Global (Premium E339)
Annie Kelly takes the wheel for a deep dive into how “Great Replacement” theory went global. We trace how a once-fringe white-nationalist panic moved through Generation Identity, the alt-right, YouTube, the manosphere, Tucker Carlson, Stephen Crowder, and into mainstream electoral politics. For more insights, Annie talks with Dr. Michael Feola, author of The Rage of Replacement, about “melancholic nationalism,” “remigration,” and how demographic paranoia mutates into both political strategy and violent rage.
The Rage of Replacement
https://blackwells.co.uk/bookshop/product/The-Rage-of-Replacement-by-Michael-Feola/9781517916800?srsltid=AfmBOoqQCCb9joMKbbCv1TfrqMVH_3JmXeFzuFPLFxLMo-gE4enUaoBq
Thanks for subscribing to QAA on patreon.
Check out our new podcast series network Cursed Media! All episodes of Spectral Voyager Season 2 are out now! Binge the entirety of Truly Tradly Deeply by Annie Kelly and Megan Kelly as well as Science in Transition by Liv Agar and Spencer Barrows: cursedmedia.net
Produced by Liv Agar & Corey Klotz. Theme by Nick Sena. Additional music by Pontus Berghe and Jake Rockatansky. Theme Vocals by THEY/LIVE (https://instagram.com/theyylivve / https://sptfy.com/QrDm). Cover Art by Pedro Correa: (https://pedrocorrea.com)
QAA was known as the QAnon Anonymous podcast.
Comments (76)
Mr Beat is awesome 😎💯
Is there anywhere Annie Kelly posts regularly? I love her work and aside from the QAA/Cursed stuff I can’t seem to make the computer get me more.
“PLAY MOBILE HAIR”!!!🤣🤣🤣💀
Was that big kirky in the outro lol rip bozo
I cannot stress hard enough how much I’d love to listen to an Annie Kelly book report
Which Charlie was that at the AutoQ?
part of the root of pork being forbidden is due to the fact that pigs and pork were associated with lower classes, and were difficult to tax. Conservatism is very old.
61% of French people and Annie is surprised, she must not know very many French people.
Incredible timely episode
Sadly in my neck of the woods the British far right are currently enjoying another field day of using their parasitic power to try create another war in Ireland through immigration all through a horrific attempted murder of one guy by an immigrant which the far Reich sent their cretins out too burn and attack the homes of locals who didn’t have anything to do with the attack
Having grown up in south texas in the 80s and nineties, I must admit it mildly irritates me how northerners and east/west coast people tend to gloss over just how prevelent all of this GRT shit was then too.
It’s never too late and always morally correct to do something about the French
Exquisite Biden impression. Perfect!
Man, the BlackPidgeonSpeaks jumpscare took me back to 2017. I'm surprised the crew was unaware of the alt-right YouTuber incubation period of GRT as combatting said youtubers is how both HBomberGuy and Shaun got their start in Breadtube.
Annie mentions "The Camp of the Saints" and here's a little tidbit for y'all: Stephen Miller, Trump's point man on immigration, cites that as his favorite book. More about it here https://youtu.be/ImZKh3SqSmo?si=LN6XNLHD2nSAZhhA
Annie: Add Japan to the list of non-white countries experiencing a GRT moment.
Whoa man, how come John LeCarre is catching strays from Jake?
😅
Conclusion is the dog's bollocks (UK compliment)
Fuck/marry/kill: Mr Beat, Mr Beast, Mr Bean?
Mr Bean for all three
Just joined for this episode! Brilliant stuff and so needful as we see the rise of this rhetoric across the west and so prolific on social media. I recently came back to Insta from a break and I see comments beneath posts related to Glasgow (where I live) and the absolute racist bile is just shocking. It seems to be being actively promoted by algorithms.
The new narrative about vote rigging is basically the same as the Southern Strategy.
Oh shit. Here we go again.
Not a fan of the person Annie played clips from, he didn't have any class analysis. White folks are wrong for blaming immigration for their troubles and are wrong for believing in the great replacement theory. They're not wrong though in realizing that shit is being taken from them. The rich are the most robber baron they've been since the 1890's. Working people everywhere are being exploited. Right wing white folks are just blaming their exploitation on the wrong people. Julian is always good about bringing up that every conspiracy has a kernel of truth.
Just to illustrate how this ideology has permitted normie life I have an anecdote. I work at a Mexican restraunt in AZ. You could guess that the kitchen staff is very diverse, I stand out as a gringo. After my coworker and best buddy made a joke about being bullied as a minority. my manager, also a gringo, said "you know my son will be a minority when he grows up. he has blond hair and blue eyes." She was looking for solidarity with her racist ideology. I responded "we"re in Arizona, this was literally Mexico once, and before that it was Navajo land. not to mention that on a global scale I'm pretty sure white people are the minority sooooo." She thought she could share her racism with me just cuz im a white punk who looks like a skin head. she didnt expect that I'm perfectly happy and feel privileged to have grown up with Latin Americans and Natives in my life to share their language and culture. No one is illegal on stolen land. Chinga la migra! Viva la Raza!
as a brazilian I’ve to say that the anti-immigration rethoric is basically non-existent here and was not a relevant part of bolsonaro’s anti-democratic iniatives. I feel like this is mostly something that comes from the Global North, and in South America is seen mainly in Argentina and Chile against Bolivians and Peruvians, but that’s also a historical trend that precedes modern replacement theory
We gotta keep French guys named Camus away from minorities on beaches
If they love their families so much, why didn’t they just acquire the resources to bring their whole family halfway across the world with them?? Checkmate libs 😎
I do also think that Biden missed a chance to bring down the wall with big sledgehammers and an impromptu concert from David The Hoff Hasselhoff. Who wouldn't have enjoyed that?
Yeah....GRT is total projection, it's the result of an entire culture feeling the weight of it's past crimes against humanity's, in the form of colonialism, and fearing the same fate at the hands of brown-skinned people. It's the unprocessed trauma of what capitalism truly is: genocide on a mass scale.
While we're blaming French people, I think we shouldn't forget Michel Houellebecq and his 2015 book Submission which is about France electing an Islamic government. The far right also love this book, those of them that can read anyway.
Was that French racist in the castle the same guy that was interviewed by that Dark Enlightenment fuck? (can't remember his name, somehow remember that he was a minorly influential guy in functional programming before going bananas) IIRC his encounter with the contemporary far right held a lot of "wait, what?" on his part
“Melancholic Nationalism” just seems like a longer way to say Fascism. Dr Feola paraphrases Evola at 1:11 to describe the white nationalists pining for their imagined past as engaging in a “revolt against the modern age.” I think it is worth mentioning that Steve Bannon loved to talk about the stupid French novel Camp of the Saints before Trump took office. The fact that he could read and knew about the obscure European roots of traditionalism, fascism, & white genocide rhetoric made him more dangerous than the others in Trump’s orbit. About five minutes in, the hosts were talking about perceived demographics and actual demographics of the racist French guy’s beachside town. It reminded me of some racist US history; around 1880 at the height of Yellow Peril politicking there were anti-Asian civic groups, parties, newspapers, pamphlets throughout the country while the population of East Asian people in the US was about 0.25%.
I'll preface this by saying that I'm British, specifically English, but whenever I hear about anyone stealing my culture then it just makes me think about Morris dancing and I really hate Morris dancing.
l've said it before and l'll say it again, the closest l ever got to having white* babies involved socialized medicine. * l'm not entirely sure that France would consider any progeny of mine white. Even in the US l'm not sure they would still be considered white by the time they reached adulthood.
Hussein Kesvani's French Wario Is charging people for haram soup. His boss knows has known about it for years but won't discipline him because he's afraid of being unpatriotic.
Je suis Charlieboyardee
The Incels are lost in a house of mirrors
Gonna post a super rare divergence from Queen Annie Kelly: white Americans love to distance themselves from Ethnicity, it just just typically takes a couple of generations. And as a mixed Black person who is a native American English speaker I promise you, “what are you?” is a not a friendly, harmless question. It’s something POC americans disproportionately are queried by white americans. And heaven help you if you answer the question asked, “what’s your nationality” “American” bc they’ll just keep going until you tell them how you’re not white
Because we’re more race than class organized (vs the UK) the white ppl who are dipshits and who cannot immediately discern Your Deal need to know what box to put you in. I have literally had a white man code switch on ME and start using goofy “ebonics” upon learning my background and I wish I was kidding. wait twice that I’m thinking on it 🤦🏽♀️
« hypocrisy made paramount, paranoia the law… »–Lemmy
They're 'former actors' = they're fully failed actors lol
Full time larpers now.
the way i nearly had a shouting match with my el salvadoran immigrant mother begging her to exercise her right to vote after all the effort that went into getting her citizenship. i hate these GRT people so much.
I love hearing a man spouting made up science statistics about women’s bodies and lives 🫠
they always boil down to essentially just some rando saying « according to my source: a twitter post. » yeah it’s shit isn’t it
I’m so tired of hearing about manosphere babies and their endless whining I almost didn’t listen to this. I should have trusted that Annie and the boys would deliver an entertaining episode. Great work folks.
love Jake but he has to quit yelling
RAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH NIGHTMARE NIGHTMARE NIGHTMARE nah im just fuckin around lol
I wonder if conservatives would change their ways if Jesus himself would come down and tell them that they are wrong? Like would they change their ways if the things they’re doing is evil?
They would just call Jesus a fake, a commie traitor. Their cognitive dissonance truly knows no bounds, because they've always cared more about stroking their own sense of superiority than about the truth. And I would even go so far as to say that the ideology of superiority and supremacy REQUIRES delusion, because it inherently (and constantly) is debunked by reality.
Here for Annie’s full length book review podcast please!
What level Patreon gets me Annie’s hour long audio book reviews?
Every night, Jake looks to Joe Biden and asks for permission to bust, and every night, Joe Biden sadly shakes his head
this is the problem with Bidenomics, supply side semencinomics are a scam it doesn’t work!
There's a church near me in Troy, NY called Grace Baptist Church, during covid they went viral for having a ham at the front door that you had you touch before entering. This was meant to keep Muslims out. Mind you, it was also the middle of summer so it was just a hot old piece of ham sitting in the sun that everyone was touching. They will occasionally raffle off AR-15s to drum up controversy
What fucking weirdos
I wrote my master thesis on the great replacement theory in the Netherlands (analysis of tweets) and hoped (against all odds) it would die out at some point 😭
In the era of climate migration, it was always going to be the inevitable trajectory of supremacy ideology.
"youth unemployment" is a wild metric
To be fair, I've met more than one person who was vegan except for bacon... Or as a friend of mine once said "You can take everything from me but pork"
I hate you for making me listen to tuckums for that long.
🥰 The National Baby returns ! 🤗
Jake needs to get on E1!
Listening to the actual audio clips of these creeps makes it real hard to enjoy the show. Last eps preachers screaming about war and this one's endless misogynists...I guess I lean on the hosts so I dont have to hear it. Id rather hear jake do funny voices for the nazis and scumbags
But it gives a window into just how ghoulish these people truly are
Same as every week. You guys rock… less julian plz
*Trump leaning forward into the microphone and saying "WRONG" .gif
Honestly, being 11 as a human is an ass year, so it tracks that the 11th year of a century is ass (don’t come at me with math, I will beat you down, I remember the century math wars of 2000)
The 11th year of life is when you're 10 though
National Baby strikes again!
Yesssssss
Babe wake up, Jake and Julian are back together again~ P.S. Liv Agar
Ms Kelly!
ANNIE KELLY
