The Facilitators: On Engineers w/ Gareth Dennis & Justin Roczniak
Gareth and Rocz join Gregk to account for the many crimes of modernity’s slow, silent killers – engineers, technicians, and urban planners.
Follow Gareth and Rocz on Bluesky
Watch Well There’s Your Problem on YouTube
Watch RailNatter on YouTube
Blood Work is a Scam Goldin Production
This episode was produced by Thomas O’Mahony
Our theme song is ‘Dream Weapon’ by Genghis Tron
Our artwork is provided courtesy of KT Kobel
If you enjoyed this episode:
– Support Blood Work via Patreon
– Leave a rating or review on your podcast app
– Follow us on Bluesky / Instagram / Twitter
THIS WEEK IN VIOLENCE: The Pendulum
ALSO AVAILABLE IN AUDIO
This week, we’ve got two stories about different pendulum swings in the political world, and the people attempting to ride the wave and come out unscathed. They’re stories about elites in political media, and so there are no winners, only losers. But spare a thought for them, won’t you? Or don’t. They're all reprehensible.
Image: An overhead photograph of the ‘Futurama’ diorama presented at the 1939 World’s Fair created by Norman Bel Geddes with sponsorship from General Motors [GM].
Comments (23)
Coming back to this episode in September as the little machine shop I work in is suddenly inundated with orders; several of these orders are for Northrup Grumman, General Dynamics, and the lesser-known Woodward. Despite not knowing what exactly our products will be used for, most of us are struggling with the knowledge of what these companies make.
sad to report Gareth that the streets of san francisco are crawling with completely empty white jaguars … i even see them on the freeway now. most of them have no passengers! let alone a driver. eerie to see them lurk about with lights flashing in front of tent encampments and swerve deftly to avoid the roadside beggars.
To the point of Climate Change, the Government cannot admit that there is a real problem to solve and then and then attempt to solve it because solving it would require admitting the problem and the Government cannot admit that the Military is by far the worst polluter and always has been because that means they would have to end the military to solve climate change. ❤️🔥🎉 love this pod
The fundamental flaw in engineering is that we are trying to change natural reality to conform to our ideals, and create artificial systems which are often functioning in direct contradiction to natural systems. Those natural systems formed out of the natural functioning of reality, and thus are self sustaining. Everything in that natural system is able to function in a healthy way with the greater whole. Artificial systems on the other hand, which are built to achieve a purpose not provided by the natural system, fundamentally cannot be fully interconnected with every aspect of the world it exists in, and thus cannot be self-sustaining. These systems require constant human effort to keep them going, and the contradictions with the natural system often leads to harmful outcomes that make the functioning of either system less sustainable. And it is because we are trying to shape reality to conform with our ideas, ideas which are often contradictory with reality as it actually is. For example, the cities in the American Southwest such as Albuquerque or Las Vegas are highly populated urban areas in the middle of deserts. None of the resources needed to keep those cities functioning exist in that environment, and so water, food, and energy all needs to be shipped in to keep these affronts to nature functioning. This causes strain on the places where those resources are taken, such as the Colorado river, which supplies a necessary function to so much of the natural world around it, but which is loosing that water every year to feed these cities, thus creating ecological collapse which will affect all the other systems that make life livable in that area at all. And all this because humans had the idea, against all natural reason, that there should be these massive urban centers here, and attempted to make reality conform to that idea, and we see ourselves now reaping the consequences of that contradiction. Now of course we can engineer in a way that is more conscious and cooperative with natural systems, that is what a democratic, lived in society ought to be. But we have been so alienated, or rather the people with power to control development in our society have been removed from, the actual lived reality at this point that there is no chance of this sort of sustainable engineering happening.
I like the other podcasts that Justin and Gareth are on, and they have some great takes about their field, but I need to say that everything they speak to is from a civil engineer’s perspective. This is only a small corner of the profession (if you ask them ofc there is only civil Eng, nothing else counts) and doesn’t do justice to the whole picture
on the whole ‘ethics in engineering education’ — also entirely or almost entirely absent from computer science curricula in the UK
thank you for demonstrating that Roz really does know *everything* even if he doesn’t have slides
Roz’s monologue at the 58:00 mark makes me want to weep. So much is possible but is wasted on destructive processes.
I would love some episodes on the violence of climate change and biodiversity destruction
So the labor party and the democrats are like two sides of the same anglosphere coin: they want to be in charge but don’t want to govern
Most of my coworkers myself included compulsively save 6 months living expenses just incase they are asked to do something that goes against their already flexible morals and need to quit on the spot. We call it fuck you money because its the ability to say fuck you lol
Get these engineers on something useful to everyone... Like a self cleaning bong 🤞🙏
to the point about social engineering 25 mins in, it’s really interesting how similar the logic Secure By Design operates under is to the logic eugenics does
Listening to this episode while working a structural engineering job hit particularly hard. I have some points that I would like to make: • I took an engineering ethics course for my undergraduate degree. The extent of the discussions were never about the morality of engineering projects, but were how to perform the role of engineer in an ethical manner, i.e. don't falsify work, avoid conflicts of interest, etc. • During my earthquake engineering course in grad school, there was a brief discussion regarding blast engineering (the principles of blast engineering are similar to that of earthquake engineering). I made a sarcastic comment to the effect of “wouldn’t it be easier to have foreign policy where actors don’t want to blow up American infrastructure?” The professor gave me a non-response. Make of this anecdote what you will. • Rocz is spot on regarding the fact that as an engineer, you can make bank if you don't have moral scruples regarding employers. • It took me far too long to make the connections between my profession and the military industrial complex. • “The Facilitators” is a very good description of engineers. I struggle personally with the implications of that. • At around the 56:52 mark, Rocz’s statement on engineering talent being wasted hit deep for me. I feel this way at my current job. Thank you for having Justin and Gareth on as guests. I sincerely appreciate the discussions. There's so much more that I want to say, but this comment is already quite long.
The Nate Bethea cinematic universe seems to grow yet again
NOOOOOOOOOOO ROCZ YOU FUCKED UP THE MONTY PYTHON REFERENCE THE FRENCH USE A C A T U P U L T TO THROW AN ALIVE COW OUT AT THE SILLY ENGLISH KNIGHTS « cherche la vache!!! »
I thought it was a trebuchet?
I KNEW that publishing Slowboring is a violent crime, ARREST MATT YGLESIAS
not a defense contractor but I am a leftist, insane, and uuuuuh well I have good opinions about shit and I have the necessary skillset to defend them via a plethora of means
job ple?
Well I feel called out and am looking forward to this episode (Am an out of work leftist Defense contractor).
LET'S GO.
what if the Future was Trash? also have you ever seen a .303 British bullet skip, about 150m from you, off the side of a mountain full of slate and granite and such? would you like to? would you
