68 new paid members in one week: how PrintyJay built up to it all year

Maybe you've been posting for a while and giving your community plenty for free. But you're still not sure when to actually ask them to join as paid members, or whether your free work is doing anything to build toward that.

Kasia Grabowska, known on Patreon as PrintyJay, does the opposite of what you might expect: most of the year, she doesn't ask for paid members at all. Then, for short stretches, she asks clearly and directly.

Meet PrintyJay

Kasia designs collectible 3D-printed models: terrariums, aquariums, and ongoing series like Tiny Jungle and Tiny Farm. She left her day job in December, once her Patreon page made it possible to do this full time.

How did she get to this kind of paid membership growth? Through a rhythm: give generously for most of the year, then ask clearly and briefly, twice. This takes the pressure off of needing to see results constantly, and helps put focus on the right times for converting fans.

Build for months, convert for a weekend

Kasia splits her year into two modes. For about five-month periods, she's building: sharing models on MakerWorld (a free 3D-printing platform), posting regularly, and growing her free Patreon audience. For a couple of short windows, timed to her Patreon anniversary and Black Friday, she actively pushes people to upgrade or join as paid members.

Paid membership is always open, and some people join on their own between those two pushes. But the two planned moments are when she deliberately asks.

"Trust is built at the free layer," Kasia says. Everything starts on MakerWorld, where her models are free to everyone. Every one is tested and photographed rather than just rendered. She once spent a month building and photographing an orbital vending machine model to prove her mechanisms actually work. Every post on MakerWorld points back to her Patreon page for people who want more, or who want a license to sell prints commercially.

What free members get

On PrintyJay's page, free membership isn't a waiting room. It comes with:

• A genuinely new exclusive model every month, clearly tagged so it's easy to find

• An unblurred page, so visitors can see exactly what they'd be joining before they commit

• Collections and a welcome pack that orient new visitors and cut down on repeat questions

• One piece of a bigger series, free, with a note that paid members get the full set

"Someone who can't pay today may be ready in six months," Kasia says. "And when they are, they're already inside my world."

She treats free members as people who might join later, not a lesser tier, and delights them without expecting anything back.

Anatomy of her Starter Pack push

At the end of May, Kasia ran her Starter Pack promotion, one of her two planned pushes for the year. It had a simple, repeatable shape:

• A real deadline. The offer was open for a short, specific window, not "for a limited time."

• Exactly two emails: one introducing the offer, one final reminder before it closed.

• Real photography of the actual models people would get, not renders.

• One audience. She only promoted to her existing Patreon members, since her free tier had already warmed them up to join.

The result: 68 paid signups in one week, more than double her usual pace. Most of those members came up through free membership first, rather than joining as paid from a cold start.

Why the ask works

A short, once-in-a-while push only works because of what happens before it. Kasia's offering is consistent, so members know what to expect. Her page is clear, so no one is confused about what they're getting. And she doesn't expect conversion to paid all the time. She understands it's about building value slowly, then making the ask when it matters.

And by the time she asks, people have already felt the value for free, so they're ready to commit instead of still deciding.

Try this next

You don't need to overhaul your whole page to borrow from Kasia's approach. Start small:

Pick one thing to give away consistently. It doesn't need to be everything you make for free, just one thing on a rhythm your community can count on.

Put your next ask on the calendar. Choose one moment in the next few months, a milestone or a season, and commit to a real deadline for it.

Look at your page through a new member's eyes. Would they know what they're getting before they join? If not, that's the smallest fix to make first.

📌 How helpful was this material? Click to let us know: 👍 | 👎