Luke! To be or not to be?

I'm going to start redesigning Luke's story.

Since of the first 4 stories his was apparently the one that had the least repercussions, I thought it might be an opportunity to change his profile a bit.

But I confess that now I was in doubt, because both versions have their appeal.

So I opened this poll so you can help me.

Should I keep the old Luke look or go with a new one?