UNCUT REACTION - Star Trek TNG S1E7 - Lonely Among Us
Comments (42)
Definitely one of the oddest eps of S1, but I have a bit of a soft spot for it. The anticans and selay were kind of irrelevant to the main plot, but they were amusing at least. Also the first (uncredited) appearance of Marc Alaimo in Trek as the main antican. Next time someone offers me a beyond meat burger, I'm gonna call it sickening and barbaric. Riker telling them how they substitute real mean is the first mention of replicators, though they're not directly named. Some interesting performances from the cast during their possessions, especially Stewart, who in a few scenes almost seemed to be channeling a little bit of Shatner. They also finally gave Troi something useful to do in the episode with the hypnosis and psych evaluations, rather than just saying how she feels constantly. The alien energy cloud creatures were interesting enough a concept, and I'm glad they weren't out and out evil, but it still still very uncool making a decision like that for Picard based on a shared curiosity. Also Singh I believe is the first death on the show. I find it's more unique elements make it fairly memorable, but I agree it's not particularly good. Ron Jones was starting to show his talent here though. Also just before the conference meeting, they used a reverse of the last shot at the end of the intro, with a different starfield to portray being at warp. Resourceful use of stock footage.
This episode perfectly illustrates my problem with the early episodes. A "B" plot that went nowhere and just took time away from the more interesting "A" plot. So glad that later they struck a much better balance.
Another episode that makes me wonder why Roddenberry created this series without a chief engineer, especially considering how popular Scotty was!
I think he was very sensitive to not just doing the exact same thing as TOS. Obviously, that sentiment goes away at a point and show gets much better.
It occurred to me that the "eating no real meat" thing is usually true but I remember on occasion that coming up, and some humans do still eat it. A minor issue, sure.
Great reaction, "I'm already blind!" So funny. I love watching these with you!
This species or one like it was encountered in Star Trek: Enterprise nearly 100? years before in: S2.E18 ∙ The Crossing (crew held captive by non-corporeal beings).
Your suggesting that the greatest detective was Batman instead of Sherlock Holmes now has me imagining Data giving himself a mask and cape and speaking in a low, grumbly whisper.
The only- and I do mean only thing that I remember about this episode is that the monkey guy alien looked exactly like my friend Chris the waiter from El Torito. Uncanny. Anyway. It’s not that it was a bad episode. It was OK it was entertaining but not memorable. I saw it once and never saw it again until this week. So this is as good a time as I need to address the issue of everyone’s hatred for the first season . I think the explanation is that it’s not that we hate it it’s just that we know what’s coming and we know what the series became and how frankly effing awesome it became. So in relief, the first season looks like shit. It’s so awkwardly written and acted. I mean come on Riker! Cut with the” if I may, sir” bullshit. All of this mawkish awkwardness is going to fall away like pimpley scabs in season two.
Listening to the rest, LeVar Burton was excellent in Roots and that is what will get him in the history books. Jonathan Frakes for me is a giant nothing, and while the actress might be good, watching this show I wouldn't know, Troi is such a terrible character it might not be possible for anyone to do it better. She is just a complete waste of time.
Wow, interesting as the series goes on I came to like Frakes/Riker, and in more recent years rewatching I came to appreciate him more. But if we're talking this season, no actor besides Stewart is that outstanding.
For me the star of this episode was the background music making the scenes take on an old fashioned suspense vibe, like a corny show from the 70s. I enjoyed that part of it and for me the pseudo-mystery is the best part of this episode. It reminded me of "Invaders From Mars" with the Wesley/Dr Crusher scene.
Another okay episode. The aliens kind of stole the show. There was a couple good character moments with Data and Picard. The overall premise was interesting but it does seem a bit boring at times. This episode is kind of season 1 in a nutshell. There's nuggets of gold in a lot of the episodes, but felt mediocre for whatever reason. Not bad. Just... flat. The actors did a lot to elevate the show early on. Even if the episode isn't the greatest, the characters are fun to watch at the very least.
When Data started his pipe-in-the-ready-room routine it looked like Frakes was having so much fun he didn't have to act lol. They really did a lot to bring this stuff to life.
Gene didn't want Worf, he wanted to avoid all TOS aliens at first. Worf was forced on him, since the other producers thought having a Klingon on the bridge was a great follow through from TOS when they were the villains. It shows, because at this point when Gene was largely in control, Worf is definitely on the back burner.
Kept hearing a music cue in this one that sounded like TMP where Spock nerve-pinched the guy in the thruster suit room.
Not only can Gates McFadden act, she can dance. She's also a choreographer, which may or may not come into play on the show.
Best part of Wednesday's is finding a new TARGET AUDIENCE TNG (TA TNG? TATNG?)
The best part of this episode is when they're debating whether to relieve Picard of duty. But it falls apart once Picard directly admits to Crusher that he's possessed, and she doesn't immediately relieve him at least temporarily to assess how much of him is still Picard. That seems like a no-brainer. It's an odd thing to say, but Turnabout Intruder did it better.
Worf was not initially intended to be regular character, more of a recurring character. That changed over the course of the 1st season and you'll see him have at least 1 episode focused on him later this season. I think Gene Roddenberry had the idea of putting a Klingon on the bridge more for fan service. He didn't invent the Kiingon race in TOS - that was 1 of Gene Coon's good creations.
From what I remember, before they turned to Roddenberry, another writer was working on a new Star Trek series idea. In it, one character was a Klingon "marine." Roddenberry wisely kept this idea for his TNG.
Everyone loved Data as Sherlock Holmes. Unfortunately, no one asked permission to use Holmes from the Conan Doyle estate which still holds rights to the character. This caused a legal hassle that led most to conclude Brent Spiner would never bring the great detective to TNG again.
It does show that some obvious conclusions are not always obvious. 🖖
TA is not a fan of Dramatic Irony apparently. =P Evidently, Patrick Stewart was fully ready to move back to England before he booked this show. He and his agent took it expecting it to not last much past a year. So, at this point he very well could've been looking for an out. TNG as "one of the greatest shows ever." Ehhh... Yes and no? TNG builds a great world, the cast are always great to watch and the characters are both inviting and comforting to return to. The episodes themselves though? Those can vary dramatically in quality. There is some top-tier stuff ahead. But also some boring as heck blah episodes too. All have SOMETHING to like, but in different measures. But that's what happens when you have many script writers with differing styles, time crunches and budget issues.
You guys are right about Akron native Gates McFadden being a great actress. She was in some real movies and unfortunately she is pretty neglected in TNG. However in Picard season 3 she absolutely CRUSHES it, no pun intended.
As much as I disagree with you both about TNG not being 'bad' yet.....it's always a pleasure to hear your responses to the franchise.
It’s true, there are lots of behind the scenes “feuds”, even on some of the Trek shows that come after, but the TNG cast were and are really great friends..and it shows. It elevates even the most mediocre episodes.
*cries quietly at the mention of Babylon 5.* God speed, tiny captain... Dog dudes and lizard guys. They make those great costumes and barely use them. To me you don't make lizard men like that unless you intend to get a good amount of mileage out of them. There's a story that has floated around for years that, in one of these early episodes Patrick Stewart blew up on a couple of the other cast who were goofing around. He was quite concerned about the dignity of the whole thing and took it... He admits he took it too seriously. The great thing about the TNG cast is they were always good friends. They don't have to act it out, it's there. There's a famous shot from one of the early making of videos that shows the cast gathered at dinner and you hear Frakes, as he raises his glass "To the new crew of THE ENTERPRISE!!!" And someone else replies "Live long and prosper!" So they were all jazzed about it.
Also, good luck getting those Galoob TNG aliens. You can get the six main cast pretty cheap, but the aliens were rare and they go for a lot of money. I don't know that i've seen a Selay in quite awhile. That's a strange figure line.
Ok you are still Batting almost 1000 in my opinion, as you didn't say Bad to describe this one. I'm glad you guys caught the Model of the TOS Shuttle Craft. I'll forgive the 30 seconds or so it took for you to point it out...as a long time fan (over 50 years). People like me Noticed it Instantly. One thing about this reaction that did surprise me was as a big Star Wars Fan Alex did not mention the Antican's Tool...A Mini Light Saber! 😮 My Fav part you also did not mention was Data and Sherlock Holmes. Here is a fun Fact for you Brent Spinner did do Comedy sketches before TNG. He was a character named Bob Wheeler on a few Night Court Eps. Really funny guy! You guys should check it out...I'm sure there is a clip on YouYube. Josh you are right I think Gates Mcfadden is a very good actor. Take Care 😀🖖
Good to see a quick appearance from a true fan favourite character from TNG!
Colm Meaney? ; )
Alex mentioning how professional Stewart was, there's a very funny story where later this season the cast finally got a little TOO out of hand and Patrick Stewart rounded them up to yell at them in his best captain's voice for being unprofessional on the set, that the Royal Shakespeare alumni would NEVER act this way...and finally very shortly after he's singing and goofing off just as much as the rest, and this lasted the following six years. As Frakes said, "We broke him."
Given the grueling work schedule (up to 18 hours days, sometimes for 10 to 12 days straight) it is understandable that the cast would need to blow off some steam on set.
Another meh episode in my opinion. A few good ones are coming up soonish though.
My words exactly. Agree on both counts.
Maybe the honeymoon is wearing off for Josh, we need to get some real good eps up in this bish soon.
🤣
Since you asked us to comment, it certainly won't be the last time a plot revolves around a species being considered for Federation membership, a couple exceptional episodes deal with that.
I’m so glad you gents comment on these episodes from a story construction perspective. You’re engaged with the characters, the ideas, the plots, but you’re also very adept at analyzing the narrative architecture. These episodes were written fast and on an assembly line- 26 episode seasons! The writers had to feed the production beast constantly and didn’t have the time to always perfect things at the script stage. I actually find this to be a charm of this era of Trek- it yields great episodes, it yields terrible episodes, it yields everything in between. And because of this, most of the big Trek writers are very candid about their feelings on some of the lesser episodes, totally owning that “we didn’t get the concept quite right, this A plot and B plot didn’t match up, etc.”
This one's a true Sci Fi story, love it :-)
There's a shortlist of shows that need 50+ eps before they find their footing.
