Christmas Movie Suggestions
I know it seems a bit early to be talking about Christmas, but the next movie poll will be for our Christmas special episode of Audience Cut! We will watch a Christmas related movie chosen by you, so drop your suggestions below.
Keep in mind we’ve seen most of the mainstream popular ones, so the more obscure the Christmas movie the better! Poll coming in November.
Comments (80)
Santa Claus the Movie. Terrible but entertaing!
Ok here is my Suggestion guys....A Christmas Carol 1938 is my Fav and I watch it every other year or so on Christmas. If you both have seen this one then never mind. The Star Wars one is not one I would suggest you watch....not during Christmas or ever. It will ruin Christmas not to mention Star Wars for you forever. That Star Wars T.V. Holiday Special was really Awful. However if you are interested in Completeness....it should be watched as the last thing on your Star Wars unwatched list if you have one. Even as a 12 year old when it came on T.V. I thought it was soo bad! 🖖
The Hogfather might be a thorough change of pace for you, and I’m curious what you’d think of it (good or ill)! …it is, however, very long. xD
Bad Santa and Bad Santa 2
Hercule Poirot's Christmas
The Family Man (2000) {Nic Cage!}
The Nutcracker and the Four Realms (2018)
The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe (2005)
Only a Christmas movie in part and would raise controversial questions about what a Christmas movie is and the role of religion in fiction. (For example, "Die Hard" is more unambiguously a Christmas movie than "LWW".)
It’s only 1/5 a Christmas movie, but I’d love to see the guys watch the 1972 Tales From the Crypt. The first segment is a post Edith Keeler Joan Collins as a murderous wife terrorized by a Santa dressed killer on Christmas Eve..pure camp mixed with horror.
Bad Santa
It's a Wonderful Life is the classic Christmas movie for a reason, but Gremlins, Tokyo Godfathers, Black Christmas, The Muppet Christmas Carol, The Lion in Winter, Merry Christmas Mr Lawrence, and The Night of the Hunter are good non-conventional picks.
Lion in Winter is a great unconventional Christmas movie
O.K. I’m going for old , obscure, and horror. The 1974 Margot Kidder Classic: Black Christmas A cult film if ever there was one.
National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation! A classic that never ages.
The Christmas Chronicles 1 and 2 with Kurt Russell as a very cool Santa.
"A Christmas Story" from 1983 is an absolute classic, and really very funny. Since it plays on TV so often, you guys have probably seen it.
They play A Christmas Story so much that even people who haven't seen it have seen it. It's burned into our blood.
Gotta be George C. Scott's 'A Christmas Carol' from 1984. By far, the finest portrayal of Dickens' story. Absolutely brilliant!
That is a great one.
Wait-you are wrestlers and no one has mentioned SANTA'S SLAY? Thats your movie!..Truuust me!! If you arent hooked in the first 5 minutes -I'll eat reindeer poop...
Yes!!!
You're most likely to have not seen some of the older movies, I would guess. A couple I like are: The Bishop's Wife (1947) with Cary Grant and Loretta Young Christmas in Connecticut (1945) with Barbara Stanwyck
The Bishop's Wife is a great classic movie.
It's hard to think of films that not everyone has seen, but I thought of 2 that are pretty under the radar and 1 well known one but a lot of people haven't seen. Krampus, a fairly recent comedy horror film. Trading Places, an old school comedy from the 80s. That one may be a bit too risque for this channel but was worth mentioning. And the more well known suggestion would be Jingle All the Way from the 90s.
I can only think of one movie that engulfs the heart and soul of both Christmas and the Target Audience. A movie with un-describable ( yes un) special effect and writing. Acting that is unmatched by any movie ever made. I am referring to of course: " Santa Claus Conquers the Martians". It also has the advantage of ( I am sure) never having been seen by the guys
It's also in the public domain due to a missing copyright notice, so they would be able to post the full reaction *with the movie itself* on both Patreon and YouTube! (The musical score is copyrighted, so they might need to mute the sound for parts of the film.)
Bad Santa
Either watch the original theatrical cut or the unrated "Badder Santa" cut. Do not waste your time with the Director's Cut, as it removes IMO one of the funniest scenes in the movie (the boxing ring).
Maybe "A Christmas Carol" from 1999. Where our most british frenchman of Starfleet alias Jean Luc Picard will "engage" your hearts in his version of "A Christmas Story". :-)
Although it's slightly more of an Easter movie than a Christmas movie and you've probably already seen it: Ben Hur (1959)
“Silent Night, Deadly Night”..the original.. And I’m sure you’ve seen “A Christmas Story”, but watching it while keeping in mind that the dad was married to “queen Deela” from Wink of an Eye gives it a whole new experience ha.
I would also add Love Actually as a suggestion. I also like Scrooge, a Christmas musical starring Albert Finney.
Great film. Wasn’t crazy about the musical aspect. But the George C. Scott version in 1984 is a more serious dramatic tone. Scott is amazing. My personal fav.
2 movies that are fantastic if Alex and Josh haven’t seen them are 1-A Christmas Carol, the George C. Scott version, and 2- The ORIGINAL Miracle on 34th street with Natalie Wood!
Love Actually. A Christmas-themed "Chick Flick" with a ridiculously loaded all-star British cast, and where--strangely for a chick flick--the vast majority of main characters are men.
The Ref. It's from the late 90's - early 00's with Dennis Leary
I made that suggestion also. Great movie.
If all else fails, there are several thousand to choose from on the Hallmark Channel and Lifetime, all with roughly the same plot.
They only have four stories, they just keep retelling them over and over and over again!
A Tree Grows in Brooklyn is another that should be considered a classic
Good movie, better book, but it just sort of involves a Christmas as part of a long long narrative?
The Green Knight, Placido, A Muppet Christmas Carol, Tangerine, And The Ship Sailed on are all excellent Christmas movies
Christmas is a Die Hard movie.
You are correct.
Trading Places
The Long Kiss Goodnight, very underrated with a great cast (Geena Davis, Samuel L. Jackson, Brian Cox)
I have to get behind this suggestion. One of my all time favorite movies
Krampus (2015)
Kiss Kiss Bang Bang
Die Hard.
But if that's not an option, the 1999 Patrick Stewart Christmas Carol.
One that doesn’t get nearly enough attention is Rise of the Guardians (2012).
Merry Christmas Mr Lawrence (1983) - not typical Xmas fare it’s a WWII prison camp drama.
A Christmas Carol (1999) starring Sir Patrick Stewart, one of my favorites & very high production value considering it's a TNT feature presentation. It's a must see TV movie!
Love that one, the George C. Scott version and the Albert Finney musical (though I would not recommend that last one on this channel.)
Star Wars Holiday Special (1978)
Oh, come on, now... Come on! That thing is 80% boredom!
Three Days of the Condor (1975)
Die Hard (oh but its not a Christmas movie it just takes place on Christmas) don't care a very large section of people including myself have made it a christmas tradition to watch it every year on Christmas and that names it a Christmas film more than it taking place on christmas
Santa Claus Conquers the Martians
It's a Wonderful Life (1946) A Christmas Story (1983) A Charlie Brown Christmas (1965) Those are great but widely seen. So is National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation (1989). 2018 Grinch? I just know of the 2000 Jim Carrey version and 1966 version voiced by Boris Karloff. The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992)? Mickey's Christmas Carol (1983) is only 26 minutes. There are only about a 100 or 1000 versions of a Christmas Carol; just pick a new unseen version that looks interesting perhaps. A lot of television show even did a version of A Christmas Carol. Of course, there's the Star Wars Christmas special; I remember seeing that live.
Patrick Stewart's A Christmas Carol? Is there a video of that? I thought it was just an audio recording. However, I am told that he creates 30 to 40 different voices for the reading.
It was a TV movie as I recall.
Patrick Stewart's A Christmas Carol
I don't think anyone talks about Mel Gibson's "Fat Man" ridiculous premise, but definitely a hidden gem in my book
Scrooged
Die Hard and Lethal Weapon are obvious choices, but you both have probably seen them multiple times.
The Ref.
Violent Night
The Twilight Zone: Night of the Meek (episode)
You wanted obscure The Night They Saved Christmas (1984) a bit of an 80s cult classic
What an underrated gem. I like that it has an original premise instead of reusing the premise of another Christmas movie. More people need to discover this film.
Batman Returns 1993 is a Christmas movie!
Klaus, Meet Me in St Louis
Lethal Weapon. Everyone hyped of Die Hard as the action Christmas movie, but Lethal Weapon is all about that holly holly baby.
Santa Claus the Movie
My favorite It's a wonderful life.
I concur
Scrooged!
