BIGGEST WEEK EVER! We Need Your Ideas!

“Games night” so Star Trek themed roleplaying would be good if anyone can run an adventure for you both to play as characters, maybe an interactive element where we could run alongside the GM about optional paths the adventure could take them it’s all down to how you guys interpret and dice roll 😂

I’ve noticed that you have a few Star Trek board games. I remember having that VHS TNG game when I was a kid. That one is literally an hour I think. That might be a fun thing to watch when you hit 2000 and I don’t remember the rules overhead being to bad. Filming will probably be the hardest part.

More of process suggestion, I think it’s entertaining when Josh or Alex look up the IMDB rating immediately after finishing the episode to open the discussion because your reaction to the score is always entertaining whether you agree or disagree.. Another thing to consider (even if just offscreen) if you want to get the full 1995 first run viewer experience is to check out Jammer’s reviews who is the og GOAT or episode reviews. Every week myself and a ton of others would check out his take on the DS9 and Voyager episodes we just watched. Like you guys he doesn’t pull punches. . https://www.jammersreviews.com/st-ds9/

I don't mean to dick ride but I think you guys deserve far more than 2k paid Patrons because of the frequency of videos and quality of discussions. Even just as a YouTube subscriber your release schedule is competative.

How about a series of short “get-to-know” videos with members allowing them to tell their Trek story.

How about watch the original V Mini Series as a week long event?

Finish up Garth Marenghi, it's only 3 more 30 minute episodes and the one supposed to come out last month never appeared.

RESIDENT ALIEN!!!

From time to time, maybe react to an episode of Kolchak: The Night Stalker (1974).

One other idea I thought of. Put out the Patron Tier List post before you record the episode, and then you could include that result in the episode discussion.

I don't comment a lot, but I just wanted to tell you both that you guys are great. Love your takes and reactions to things. I used to watch on my lunch breaks at work, but now I do the full length reactions with you guys on my phone, my videos on a tablet, and me playing a video game of some kind. Great way to relax.

Josh, the movies you watch here, any chance these will go on Youtube? Dirty Harry might get some views, lol.

What's up guys. Cashflowhustles here. Hey I got 4 suggestions: (1) Watch spoiler free TOS or TNG documentaries. There are hundreds of great ones or at least scores of them. 😅 I was addicted to BTS Behind The Scenes docs in general on my favorite TV shows, movies or stars or actor interviews. For example there are some AMAZING BTS docs on the movie The Abyss as well as James Cameron interviews (2) Patron guest interviews or live stream panel shows with Patrons as guest panelists. This could be episode reviews or various topics and subjects. Would be more interactive and entertaining and introduce more personalities, stories, characters, viewpoints and opinions (3) ComicCon or convention episodes if you dudes don't mind traveling occasionally or waiting for a convention near your local area or region or maybe a state or 2 over. (4) A contest or competition giving something cool away and a show focusing on that and possibly interviewing the winner. (5) You guys are pretty huge in the Trek fan base so why not try to book interviews with Trek actors or major crew members like writers, directors, producers and what have you. There's a professional process to book interviews through booking agencies so that would be nice. I know you have had a few celebrity guests so I'm sure many of them wouldn't mind an interview. PS Be warned 😅 I've heard Colm Meaney wants to distance himself from Trek and actor Avery Brooks has had a difficult relationship and experience with Trek producers according to what I have heard and read. 😅 Welcome to Hollywood guys. You are officially part of Trek media now. Just some suggestions to liven and spice things up. Okay 5 suggestions. 😅 I lied

I think you guys would enjoy Resident Alien. It's a sci-fi mystery series full of absurd comedy. If you ever need a one-off it's also rare in that it has a great pilot.

I want a gold star for 500 comments of reinforcing “no actually the Jem Da’har IS mid”

I joined in the DS9 spike. I need to go back and watch all your TNG stuff though.

I joined just a couple of weeks ago and hope to start becoming active. Happy to be here.

Ideas for 2k you say? Well a one off react would be interesting. Don't start a show or anything. But there is a special Doctor Who thing you could watch. In the 90s Dr Who had been cancelled and there was an attempt to bring it back as an American show with a soft reboot TV movie. One of the two stars was a certain Melora actor favourite of yours....

Hey I'm new here having been regular commenter on YouTube a while. But thought I should pony up at last.

Hello all. My name is Ryan and bran new to here and first time ever on Patreon. I joined bc I have enjoyed watching your YouTube channel TNG, DS9 and now Voyager. This is the golden age of trek and I enjoy your discussions and through your journey I discover new things and perspectives on the episodes. I also love the X files videos keep those coming. Happy upcoming birthdays to you both!

First I've heard that Alex has graduated into full-time territory for this. That's fucking awesome. Congrats to both of you, seriously.

Since you loved TOS, which is from the 60s, perhaps the time has come for James Bond, another iconic franchise that launched in the 60s.

Congrats guys.

Finish watching the rest of Star Trek Continues. They are all great and you’ll really appreciate the ending of the last episode.

I forgot to come up with an idea! A fun activity would be to tierlist a bunch of standout Space Fashion from all the shows/eps you've seen so far. Ranging from "straight up fire, I'd wear it" through "why'd they make it in that fabric though", "not for me but they're kind of rocking it", "what is happening", all the way to "kill it with fire" XD

There are extended/director cuts of the movies to react to. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND the "longer version" of TMP which is included in the TMP box set on Blu-ray. It is probably the one most people are familiar with because it was released on TV for the original broadcast release, then became a popular VHS version for rental. When a DVD was released 20 years later there was suddenly a director cut... and it was missing a ton of the footage in the "longer version". I hated it because it removed great dialog. The Blu-ray release is the reason I purchased the box set.

congrats - hope your success continues to grow - love your work

A word to the new folks: Sometimes the boys don't like what you think they'll like. Sometimes you need to just embrace it. Case in point: I found TA when they posted their Wrath of Khan discussion where they doubled down on why they didn't think it was great. I immediately signed up for their patreon cause I appreciated the balls it takes to call Star Trek II overrated.

Also, would lurve to see you guys react to wrestling shiet. Even better if it's old skool/New Era/Attitude stuff. Not just matches, but promos and interviews and whatnot as well.

I know you guys have a life outside, but I always look forward to your Star Trek reactions and discussions so much.. I wish you could do more, quicker! This is particularly true of DS9, which I believe is the best of all the series. It’s a bummer it will take you to 2028 to finish at your current rate. Your commentary is very interesting and has helped me see many episodes in a different light..frequently causing me to change or modify my previous opinion..almost seeing the episode in a more favorable light. As a suggestion, might consider a chat poll for each episode..asking the audience to rate each episode. The results would likely be interesting.

Congrats! Hope you guys play through the 3 Star Trek Super Nintendo video games sometime, and the 2 point-&-click PC adventure games, voiced by the original crew.

Though it would appear unlikely you guys would ever watch it, NYPD Blue is a show that premiered the same year as DS9 (1993). Its first season is probably amongst the best of any show. I don’t watch procedurals, by this show is different . I think it would really cater to lot of your guys’ tastes in terms of character and relationships. I think the first episode old work well just to get a taste of the show. Denis Franz is amazing! The show was quite controversial when it premiered. Come on, Patrons — any other fans of the show who can back me up?

Congrats guys! It's still likely an unusual request for most, but I'd love a tier listing / eatalong to your favorite fast-food places. I do watch a lot of Good Mythical Morning for all that food content lol.

New to the Patreon here for Voyager, but have been watching on YouTube since I found you guys at the start of TNG. TOS, TNG and Voyager have always been my go to Star Trek shows. I'm just trying to finally finish up DS9 that I had started back when it was airing in season one and just couldn't get into it. DS9 still not my favorite as an overall show, but have grown to appreciate it much more and some amazing episodes. Keep up the amazing work. I joined because of a strong love for Voyager. Not sure if I would say it is my favorite the TOS, TNG and Voyager are all special for different reasons to me. I remember watching TOS on weekend afternoons with my dad when I was like 3 or 4 in the late 1970s when it was in reruns and Then in High School TNG came out and watched as often as I could while busy with everything else then Voyager was the first Trek show I watched from start to end making sure never to miss. I'm not nearly a big enough of a Trek fan to keep up with those who know everything about it like some people do and don't have a huge collection of memorabilia, but Trek has always been a part of my life it seems and happy to see you guys getting to experience it. I'm also a X-Files fan so that is a big plus when you guys started watching that. Lots of great shows I'd love to see you guys react to, but many aren't probably ones that would draw an audience so makes it kind of pointless. I'd go back into old school stuff that just has special place to me some you guys may have seen Smallville, Friday The 13th The Series (TV Show), Sliders, The 1990s version of The Outer Limits, Tales From The Dark Side, Tales From The Crypt, 1980s V (Original Miniseries and The Final Battle miniseries, Grimm. Some amazing old...old stuff like Gilligan's Island. The Friday the 13th The Series (TV show) could be fun for your channel maybe when X-Files wraps up way down the road, it's not a long show only 3 seasons so not super short but not super long. As far as a special for reaching 2K maybe something unique that would draw a new crowd without alienating the current fans YouTube series Space Janitors would be fun and very short.

I’m not new but you guys gotta use Rocket man for a chief ep cinematic trailer. “ I miss the earth so much I miss my wife” , “all the science I don’t understand it’s just my job 5 days a week.” 💁‍♂️

My idea: Continue Game of Thrones! (I know, I know, the videos didn't do well, but I'm convinced that if I just keep shouting this enough, somehow that'll make it happen.)

Star Trek, X-Files... Doctor Who: The Movie (1996). You need a third leg :)

Seeing as you just appeared on The Inglorious Treksperts podcast, you should watch Mark Altman’s movie ,“Free Enterprise”, which has William Shatner in it.

My feedback: don’t hate my favorite episode! Jk, so glad you guys are killing it.

Welcome to all the new folks!! I joined back when they started Battlestar Galactica, but stayed for the Star Treks. I hope one day the guys will finish Battlestar, but I have been having a blast ever since with everything else. Congrats guys on the success you have built. :)

Welcome aboard! Don't mind me. Just looking for Ten forward.

Congratulations guys, and happy Birthday to Alex! my suggestion would be to”Reaction Roulette” basically the patrons would suggest a movie or TV episode (any episode, not just pilots) and then you’d feed the list into a randomizer and have it select one at random for you to react to, a bit like the old movie draw. I’m not suggesting this as a regular thing, but it could be a fun one time celebration.

Buy yourselves the complete series X Files box sets and the movies before they become impossible to find. The supply has really dried up since I bought mine a couple years ago.

Welcome aboard, folks! So glad you decided to join us.

I joined for Voyager! I was so excited for y'all to start it, since so few people react to Voyager at all, much less with detailed discussion. I've loved Star Trek for at least 30 years now. My favorite forms of Trek are Voyager and the novels for TOS.

I heard through the grape vine at the start of this year of y'all doing Voyager, have seen some of your shorts on youtube talking about different movies and TNG of course. I'm a bit of an odd bug, I really love TNG and Voyager, but not so much with DS9 (although it is good)

Mass Effect Trilogy Playthrough.

Here's one you may not of heard before, why not start Battlestar Galactica again? ;

Main cast and major side cast tier ranking for everything we have seen so far, so TOS, TNG, DS9 and maybe Voyager (maybe the animated series too, didn't see those) depending on how far you guys get by then.

So much for people liking voyager least! What a spike! As far as where to go, maybe react to spoiler safe interviews with actors (that is, interviews made before the point you are watching). I also recommend rewatching galaxy quest now that you have finished TNG because it has loads of TNG references. Lots of people have great ideas in this thread.

Wow, joined on a whim (been watching the YouTube channel for a number of months now), didn't think it would be part of a wave!

A top 10 of the most attractive woman of TOS

Hi All! New member. Although I came for DS9 on YouTube, I joined in anticipation of Voyager and X-Files and eventually Enterprise. I know it’s way too early but I really want to put Fringe on your radar (spiritual successor to X-Files but with an insanely amazing cast/characters you’ll adore and awesome plot lines. For me, literally a perfect convergence of Trek and X-Files imho)

Imaginary Friend frame by frame analysis

how about reacting to all the deleted scenes from tng season 1 to 7. or react to star trek fan content in a one of video, asking subscribers for video suggestions on fan content

Or do a top 10 Trek villains

Start editing and posting the movie reactions you have done and will do. It's kinda hard to promote a reaction channel without the reactions. You're limiting yourselves to a niche group. You've got the product, use it.

Well for me, I would like you Guys to Lock In Stargate SG1 Reaction to Start around the time after Ds9 comes to an End.

Would love to see you two react to Black Sails if you've never seen it. It's an adult age oriented prequel series to the pirate book Treasure Island that aired on Starz for four seasons about a decade ago now. Very well regarded with intrigue, action and a ton of the character building and production/direction you both seem to love. It tells a complete story over 38 episodes.

When you hit your goal, you and Alex should get in the ring and have a grudge match lol

Kind of random idea, but I'd still be curious to see your reaction to a comedy series.

Not that new but first time posting something. Became a paid member for DS9 as it's my favorite Trek series. Started watching your YouTube channel when you were doing BSG (2003) reactions as it's my favorite show. Disappointed you didn't continue but understandable as I didn't like season 1 as well until the 2 part season finale. Then Season 2 hit and I could not stop watching. And on rewatches, I have a much better appreciation for Season 1 now. Still hoping you go back some day. Decided to continue watching your Star Trek content as I hadn't seen TNG, DS9, VOY, and ENT since they first aired. Glad I did as there are some episodes I had never seen before. TNG's "The Bonding", DS9's "Necessary Evil" and "Whispers". And I fucking LOVE these episodes. There are other episodes I forgot about or didn't see in full like DS9's S2 3 parter so definitely looking forward to seeing the rest. While I saw the premieres and series finales of Voyager and Enterprise, they were never my favorite shows and I only saw some episodes sporadically. Maybe I'll get a better appreciation for them on a rewatch.

Also excited for Dirty Harry!

Not a newbie, but just wanted to say been enjoying the ride so far I'll stick around as long as you guys are willing to continue lol

New Target Demographic member here. I’ve really enjoyed the TNG & DS9 reactions on YouTube, but I knew I had to watch the full Patreon reactions for Voyager. As the first Trek show I got to watch live on TV, it definitely has a special place in my heart. Hope you guys enjoy it!

Smash the Lego Enterprise D build for the 2,000 subs on stream.

Congrats! 🥳 Thinking of Star Trek, maybe doing some discussions on specific subjects could be interesting. Like, taking the Klingon episodes in TNG, what's your impression of the development of that culture over the whole TNG series? Or a review of the Borg in TNG? What did you think overall of the Romulans as antagonists? Or the foundations that TNG created eith the Cardassians? This could be a way to still discuss some TNG content, while it also serves as a refresher for the ongoing series DS9 and VOY – with B'Elanna for example there's again a connection to Klingon culture on a main crew again, and the Cardassians in DS9 are obvious of course. ... just a thought. 🤔 Also, maybe continue the teasers? 🥺

Dirty Neelix fans, the whole lot of them!

Have the guys done a reaction to Prelude to Axanar? I'd be real interested in hearing their thoughts on it, especially the production value, the concept, etc. It's only a 20 minute video on YouTube. And it doesn't mess with canon, spoil anything, etc.

Don’t know how you feel about video games, but there are a couple I’d love to see you guys play/react to. -Mass effect -Star Trek Resurgence (play that one after Star Trek Nemesis to avoid spoilers)

Good job guys! For my own two cents, I would love to see more live hangouts. I had so much fun listening to Dark Side of the Moon and would really enjoy doing more things like that. It’d also be really cool if at some point you started the Stargate franchise. SG-1 really helped fill a void for me once Trek shows were off the air. And The Orville is like a love letter to Trek. You may have seen some of it before if I recall, but after you watch all the original Trek series pre new-Trek, it makes Orville hit WAY differently.

Currently a Free member just to help out numbers and algorithms and such but I do plan on becoming a paying member soon when I'm able; you have some of the only videos on YouTube that I actually look forward to and make time to watch, so it's only fair that I contribute to the entertainment value. Some people think $10 a month is hard, myself included sometimes, but that's the cost of one 2 hour movie in a theater with barely a snack so this is a much better deal

It's clearly all the Voyager haters, come to spend their hard earned money explaining in triplicate why it sucks and why you should hate it as much as they do. But seriously, welcome to all the new members

Hello! Joined in December as my first ever try at a "watch along with your own synced video" reaction channel, and am now locked in for the long haul. Am a 3rd Generation Trekkie, going back to my Gran who loved TOS and let us kids borrow her TNG VHS tapes in the early 90s (she always found Data a bit unsettling though...!). Alas, my daughter is not a 4th generation convert yet. Yes, she's only nine, but she must come to terms with its inevitability. DS9 is my fave, but I'm looking forward to your guys' fresh perspectives on Voyager episodes helping me find more ways to appreciate them than I might have done when they first aired.🖖

One suggestion that isn’t something we would actually see. But if you literally have more time to sit and watch because you’re both full time now, I think your Trek discussions would almost certainly be enriched if you could take 45 minutes between the watch reactions and discussions to just rewatch the episode off camera, picking up dialogue exchanges or exposition you missed while reacting, and also just being able to take in the episode without having to perform for your audience at the same time. Just an idea.

Newbie here! I’ve been watching Alex & Josh for about a year, and I’m glad to be here. I enjoy seeing their perspective on some of their divisive opinions, and for what it’s worth Past Tense (both parts) were the only episodes of Season 3 that I skipped on my rewatch about a month ago.

You know MY suggestion. I would love more horror content. 🧛 Especially more current series and movies.

I personally really enjoy polls - not just the results, but the conversation in the comments that they spark. Maybe a weekly poll question, whether about a series character or a hypothetical story arch, etc. You could solicit questions from subscribers and choose your favorites.

Hello all! Joined Josh & Alex's Patreon (my first and only paid one) about a month ago and upgraded to Bridge Crew last week (just in time for the Patreon credits to be removed from TA's content). Still.... money well spent! Absolutely loving the content, the early access and most importantly -- the community. Still getting the hang of Discord, but even my aging Gen X brain is soaking it up. Big congrats on hitting your killer milestone! The channel just gets better and better

Congratulations! That's two bus loads of new passengers for Josh and Alex's wild ride. Welcome, everyone!

Congratulations, Alex! I didn't realize that he also is doing this full time now.

Good for you, plotting now what I can suggest

This comment has self destructed

Another Star Trek Continues ep as part of it, maybe..? I'll show myself out 🤣

I beleive the quality of your teasers might have helped. Keep on trekking 🖖

I would love to see more retrospective content for TNG now that you’ve finished the show. Especially the early episodes now that you have better context for what an actually good episode of TNG looks like. 🤣

Maybe more movies? I love the TV shows, but movies, which are essentially one-and-dones, might be more doable. What do you think?

Lots of voyager fans joined lately then!

V The Mini-series

Congratulations, guys! You've earned it.