PREDICTION POLL - Voyager Characters
Based on ONLY the PREMIERE episode Caretaker, who do you think will be Alex and/or Josh’s favorite character?
(Listed in order of IMDb credit)
Comments (110)
Okay so the correct answer was Janeway, Torres, Kim? Maybe Paris and Tuvok?
I am more excited than expected. I watched the first few seasons and then life took over. But do love many of these characters. Can't wait to see the reaction.
I am just so excited, I have that morning (please be early morning) planned
Janeway, since she is the focus of the pilot and has to make some tough decisions.
B'Elanna. Because she's the least Starfleet-like...unless they pick Neelix for that very same reason.
Based ONLY on a single episode a few of these characters haven't gotten the screen time to really earn these votes, even if they deserve them.
Based only on the pilot? I voted The Doctor along with a lot of other people, but I think Neelix had a very strong start in the pilot.
Let's go Chakotay, daddy needs a new pair of shoes
Exsqueeze me, but meesa thinks Neelix is bombad! No lovey for twosa-cousin to Jar Jar Binks! 😆
I think they will like Paris and chackotey
Just based on the pilot, i know you'll love Janeway, and you have a Vulcan as you asked for. I also know you love Klingons, but the Doctor gets my vote.
The Characters I liked the least became, in my view, integral to the show, I stand by my Janeway\Tuvok assumption, but any of the characters would make sense. I hate everything about the Kazon though
Mulgrew really owns the Janeway roll from Day 1 of the show, matching Shatner's season 1 Kirk. I expect confusion and possible annoyance about Tom Paris not being Nick Locarno.
In my headcanon, I just assume Nick changed his name, and delete any contradictory canon info from my brain. I heartily recommend this surgical procedure to others.
Everyone a spoiler is ANYTHING that would not have been known when Voyager premiered
I am going to say guessing is a bad habit, best not to practice it. I will say as soon as it drops I will make a pizza to watch it with you guys. However based on the trailer made Janeway and Tom are top choices then Belanna and Harry
There's nothing wrong with guessing. It's a fun thing to do and totally harmless, as long as we're talking of trivial things like we are here.
My guess for your favorites for the first episode: Tuvok and B'Elanna.
The question is based on one episode the 1st one, it's named for him and he's not on the list nor is he played by Steve Martin which would have been appropriate. That said Tom, Harry, or the Captain herself and I think they will like the ship design.
tough choice for sure - for me Tom Paris is always a favorite and i hope they enjoy him too - the Doctor is big fun but based on the Caretaker episodes we don't see him enough - B'Elanna is awesome but again, in these episodes she is not quite great yet - Janeway of course, love the woman in the big chair - but for me, always, Tuvok is the one i love to watch
Definitely Tom Paris. The Doctor is a little weird before the actor figures him out.
I think its gonna be Tom Paris and sticking my neck out here I dont think it will be The Doctor as I dont remember him getting either much screen time or do anything of interest in the pilot. In a way I'm surprised to see him so far in front in the poll. Off the top of my head I can only recall 1 scene The Doctor is in while I can think of the several interesting conversations Tom has with various members of the crew Btw amazing we almost have 1000 votes!
I think the Doctor is in the lead because people are voting for who will be their favorite character in general, and it's hard to put yourself back into the shoes of someone who's only seen the premiere, I can't blame them too much. I also think they'll love the Doctor. It's just that the premiere doesn't give him very much,
Yeah, there's one character who for me is the GOAT for the series, but for the premiere isn't given much time. For this one episode I think the standout is Tom
I mean, they'll get the hots for B'Elanna. So Alex will have to add both spots AND forehead ridges to his list of kinks.
Can’t blame them, who doesn’t?
I think based only on the premier episode, they'll appreciate Janeway, but later will gravitate to Paris, Tuvok or the Doctor. (and by season 4....)
Yup, no spoilers…but season 4 😂
The continuity of Nick Locarno will be too much to resist, but the machismo of '3 packs a day' Mulgrew will be admittedly hard for them to pass up.
Difficult choice between the Doctor and Tuvok
I was never a huge fan of this show, but anyone who chooses someone other than The Doctor as their favorite is simply wrong and needs to work out their issues
This isn't supposed to be YOUR favorite. Or a series favorite. Can you name even one scene that the doctor is in during this premiere?
Dumbass First Officer.
You could be glad he is different from other first officers, being spiritual and all.
People are definitely voting on who they think their favorite character is, but that’s fine.
Yep, if you follow the rules of the poll it should come down to Janeway or Tom. Other characters will get a chance to shine and maybe Josh and Alex will change their choice in the future but just the episode "Caretaker" in a vacuum really is Janeway and Tom's episode.
Poor Kes...
J) Quark
Given the affinity Josh and Alex had for Locarno in “The First Duty”, I’d wager they’ll gravitate to Tom Paris at the outset. They’ll also find the idea of a hologram Doctor as a character interesting, as well as Tuvok the Vulcan. 🖖
I'm torn between the doctor and tuvok...
Stadi.
Poor Kes
Kes deserves more respect and votes than Chakotay at the very least
Voyager doesn't have as many great characters as DS9, but they're all distinct and most get good development. I think their favorite will vary from season to season, as I imagine it does for many viewers.
As far as recurring guest characters go, I would agree with you that DS9 has better characters, but if we're talking main cast, I would rank the Voyager crew right up there with the DS9 crew, and in a lot of ways I think the Voyager crew is stronger.
I like how Harry Kim has less votes than Neelix and hardly anyone has brought him up in the comments.
I named my last car Harry Kim. Why? Because it was a boring little Korean.
I chose Tuvok as a curveball. His dialogue with Janeway hints at an established partnership built on respect. It's interesting to have such a tight relationship between security/tactical and the captain. Worf and Picard respect each other, but it feels like more of a one-way street, chain of command. But Tuvok/Janeway feels more like a two-way street, a trusted advisor. And I think his actor plays Vulcan really well.
Tuvok from the pilot, but The Doctor for the series, is my prediction.
Tuvok is a good guess. They were just talking about how they wanted a new Vulcan character.
We know the fellas are gonna bond with Neelix. They probably already have his action figure in the background. By the gods, I'm joking - please don't bond with that freakin' weirdo.
Did someone say The Bonding?
Only 4 contenders I think - Janeway, Paris, Tuvok or the Doctor, though the Doc doesn't have much screen time at all in the pilot.
Looking back with hindsight "Caretaker" is the best Trek pilot but misses the S-Tier spot due to lack of screen time for The Doc
I can tell you who I hope to god it's not: Neelix. Nobody likes neelix.
i DIDN'T like Neelix as a young man in college when it came out. I like him better on re-watch as the show goes along
I think they'll like Tom Paris because he's an everyman, and I think they'll be intrigued about Tuvac being a full Vulcan character.
I am voting for Paris but I do think the guys will find the EMH an intriguing concept.
That's a tough one. Going just by Caretaker, Paris and Janeway are by far the most fleshed out characters. So one of them, or Tuvok because they'll be excited for a new vulcan and he plays it well. None of those three would surprise me, but if I have to pick one, I'm going with Tom Paris. He has more of an arc than anyone else in this first episode. I think they'll like the Doctor as well, but he just doesn't have much screentime in the pilot. I expect they'll be curious to see more of him, but that there's just not enough of him here to be the immediate favorite.
Jar Jar Neelix
Darth Neelix
Based solely on "Caretaker," I bet the favorite will be Tom Paris or Neelix. I do not think this opinion will be held for long though.
Based on season 1 only! It will change.
Based on Caretaker alone, Im guessing Tom will stand out with his backstory.
It's a backstory so good, you'd insist you'd seen it before... with the same actor, no less!
Josh- The Doctor and Alex- Tom Paris
Yeah, seams like most other assume Josh and Alex will pick the same character. I bet some Quatloos that won't be the case.
i actually have zero clue.
It's a trick question, the real answer is Quark.
not quite, Morn is refenced and that counts
That's easy,... Josh fav - Ensign Harry Kim and Alex fav - Tom Paris.
Best buds voting for best buds
I hope they like Nick Locarno I mean Tom paris
they've already watched the first few episodes.
It's going to be Neelix of course just to continue on the course of unpredictable outliers that J&A are.
Based on some of the numbers in the poll so far, I "predict" that a lot of people are ignoring the "based on only the premiere" part of the question. That said, I could be WAY off, but considering Josh's favorite DS9 characters so far have been Kira and Dax, and Alex called them both "Mommy" in a recent ep, it's really hard to imagine it being anyone other than Janeway.
Based on the Caretaker episode it will be Tom Paris especially with his tie in to TNG and Wesley. He also has a little more background development over the others.
Gee the least utterly boring character for Josh and Alex to gravitate to... lol It's PicardO hands down for me.
It’s a ship!
Honestly, I don't think they'll like anyone based on Caretaker alone. Given five episode, I'd go with the Doctor or Tom Paris (though Voyager REALLY missed an opportunity with his character, IMO, considering the actor and that this is not his first time in Star Trek).
Torres being a similar character to their favorite K'Ehleyr I think will give her the lead.
My vote is for Aunt Adah
Well she provides food.
Janeway followed by Tuvok, Paris and Torres.
Gonna be a homer with Tom Paris.
Oh, and I forgot!! Alex wants a chick that could beat him up, so maybe Torres for him? 🤣
I predicted before that Josh will like Janeway, but I think it’ll take a few episodes more for that. I predicted Tom Paris for Caretaker, jsut because I feel like he had a lot of lines and already showed so much growth in just that time. They also mentioned wanting a Vulcan back (wish granted!). They’re all wonderful characters, so I hope you like them all in time.
Chose Janeway. My prediction: 1. Janeway (She has a strong command presence). 2. Paris (Has an interesting troubled past) and 3. Tuvok (Just because he's Vulcan).
Its hard to judge. They'll probably love the Captain and Doctor the most and have a mutual crush on B'Elanna. I also have a prediction on who they won't care for. And its not Neelix.
The pilot is funny, Tom kinda feels like the main character.
Lol everyone rightly ignoring Chakotay.
Commander Cardboard Cutout.... I'm not surprised
Just a guess: Tom Paris
Just the premiere? Hmm. Who pops there? Janeway. The Doctor. Neelix I remember standing out as well.
They might enjoy a certain relationship on the show involving two characters more than just loving a particular one
I’ve gone for Josh - Tom Paris, Alex - B’ellana Torres
Knee jerk reaction, I feel the Josh will like Janeway and Alex will like Tuvok
They will love the guy that said "We ain't found shit!"
The second best Vulcan in Star Trek.🖖🏻
what a motley crew
Hmm either the flawed Nick Locarno or Jar Jar Binks
He's the unflawed Nick locarno
The Nick Lacardo of it all makes me think they might go for the Lower Deck'er going O'Brien... but the doctor is emotionally distant & funny so... uh ... to the journey, eh?
If they watched more episodes, I'd say B'Elanna or The Doctor, but as it is, I think they'll be happy to see a Vulcan in the main cast again. Tuvok.
Awww poor Harry. No votes yet for him. Neither Kes nor Chakotay either which surprises me a little.
I think Tuvok for both. (Although maybe Josh might favor Janeway)
It’s either gonna be B’Elanna or the Doctor. They’ve got a thing for the half-Klingon, half-human women, and the Doctor’s just a plain old smartass who I think they’ll gravitate to like they did with Odo.
I said Tuvok because they asked for a Vulcan on the bridge. That being said, I wouldn't be surprised if it were Janeway, Torres, Kim, Chakotay, or The Doctor. Definitely not Neelix or Kes.
Josh - Janeway, Alex - Tuvok
I feel exactly the same
