Reacting to 'Watch the Throne' by Jay Z and Kanye West
Direct Play Link: https://iframe.mediadelivery.net/play/27377/1323c1fd-1df9-4aaf-a8d8-2e267ee743b6
I think I had the music audio a tad too low, but oh well. Life goes on.
Comments (92)
This album would be perfect if it was only the first 6 tracks
If you loved this Collab, you have to listen to Cruel Summer 100%
You should absolutely do “cruel summer” by GOOD music. It’s a collab album but another one of Kanyes masterpieces. Im almost positive you’ll love it
You mentioned loving Frank Oceans work. I really enjoyed your reaction to Blonde, wondering if Channel Orange was on your radar.
btw MBDTF was recieved with instant commercial and critical acclaim
How dare you act like you don’t know the viral sensation Eli Porter from 14 years ago?!? https://youtu.be/tKKxPtP6XjQ Don’t worry this is not something you would ever react to on an album.
Lex Luger is one of my favorite producers. He helped in defining that Trap Music sound. What he did on HAM is amazing. Great Reaction!!
I expect Bob will do Flockaveki one day. If you want loud and agressive. There it is.
Great stuff Bob! You are really good at this. I like your balance of music and lyric appreciation, and your curiosity to understand what is happening for the artist. This phenomenon of watching someone else experience an artist's work, particularly when it is something that has already lodged a special place in my psyche, is so f-ing satisfying! Maybe its partly validating my own appreciation. Kanye's body of work is special, to alot of people, and going deeper into it with someone like you (or into an in-depth analysis like the Dissect podcast) is like manna from heaven. Keep going Bob! I am happy to be along for the ride. There is so much more goodness coming...
Regarding Jay reactions i'd skip to Blueprint if doing it in order as albums between RD and Blueprint are pretty mid and dated. Don't get me wrong, i'd definitely recommend listening to them in your free time or coming back around but minus a few good songs on each, you're not missing much. Also if you want to hear more Jay-Z and No ID (Kanye's original mentor btw), then a perfect record would be Jay-Z 4:44. I think you'd really enjoy it as entirely produced by No ID, a much more personal record from Jay and even a cheeky Nina Simone sample for a bonus point
He plans to listen to Blueprint, The Black Album, and 4:44, in that order.
Another good reaction, only thing I'll add is like another comment said it might be worth listening to Cruel Summer, a collaborative album released the year after this (and year before Yeezus) it may not be necessary to give it a video since many don't consider it a "core" part of Kanye's discography, but the album is an important milestone in Kanye's sound and there are a few hits I think you'll really enjoy, if you don't want to dedicate a Kanye month to it like his other albums it might be worth it to just make May a double Kanye month (Cruel Summer + The Life of Pablo, one of my favorites btw)
I would love to see you react to Kanye’s single Only One, it’s often missed by people. It came out between Yeezus and The Life of Pablo, so makes sense for where you’re at in his discography. Kanye did a few songs with Paul McCartney and this is one of them. It’s sung from the perspective of Donda looking down on Kanye from heaven
I would love to see a reaction to Only One. It will probably get a lot of views too. Because of how beautiful it is. One of my favourite songs.
You should make a video telling people to join patreon if they want to see Jay Z.
Man you should do his song “Only one” it’s a single but I’d love to see you reacting to it 🙏🏾
Me too. so touching. I think it would be a popular video too.
Gave me a whole new appreciation for this album, I never really liked it before tbh. But it was really just a victory lap. I think some of the production aged kinda poorly. That said, you def need to do Blueprint by Jay-Z ASAP! No rapper has ever had the confidence, cleverness, charisma of Jay-Z during the blueprint era. While Jay's rapping on watch the throne was pretty good, he was definitely a few years out of his prime. If you want prime Jay-Z over some of kanye's best beats, Blueprint is a must.
I never liked Watch the Throne before. But listening to it with you made me appreciate it more. It has its moments. Fun moments and thoughtful moments. Thanks for that. It was an important moment for hip-hop so it should be appreciated for at least that much. I do think some songs might become irritating over time. I personally can’t stand Lift Off, and I’m not alone. Unlike Drunk and Hot Girls, which I think is underrated both sonically and thematically, Lift Off is paper thin. The problem is the song is so one dimensional and generic. The chorus is copy/pasted three times and it is so tiresome. The verses from Jay and Kanye are so short and worthless. This theme has been approached by both artists in much more interesting ways before and after this song and it is embarrassing that they ever released it. I have a few points that came up during the reaction. 1] Watch the Throne was released between My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy and Yeezus. My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy (2010). Watch the Throne (2011). Yeezus (2013). 2] My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy received wide-spread critical acclaim upon release. It received 10/10 from Pitchfork, Consequence, The Independent, Rolling Stone, and Entertainment Weekly. It had universal praise from both fans and critics and was viewed as Kanye’s redemption. The phoenix had risen from the ashes. https://www.metacritic.com/music/my-beautiful-dark-twisted-fantasy/kanye-west 3] The video you were thinking of is “We Were Once a Fairytale” directed by Spike Jonze in 2009. It was part of the promotion for 808s and Heartbreak. It depicts Kanye making a fool of himself at a bar, before going into the bathroom, where he rips a rodent like creature from his stomach, and watches it perform seppuku. I’ll leave the interpretation up to you. I personally think this short film is better than Runaway. 4] The Neptune’s are a production and songwriting duo composed of Pharrell Williams and Chad Hugo. Kanye greatly admires Pharrell for his production abilities and fashion sense. Pharrell has also worked with Pusha T and Malice as a producer for Clipse. Pusha T is now signed to Kanye West’s label Good Music as a solo artist. 5] H.A.M was produced by Lex Luger. He is most famous for his work on Flockaveli (2010) by Waka Flocka Flame. Waka was signed to Brick Squad, the label of trap music pioneer Gucci Mane. Lex Luger is known for his hard and aggressive production style. Flockaveli is a hugely influential and important album for trap music.
Jay Z - Blueprint has to be bumped to next Friday man lol
It would be great to see The Blueprint but it looks like Jay Z reactions just don't fly on YouTube. Watch the Throne just taken down today.
Watch the Throne (2011) Official Music Videos No Church in the Wild https://youtu.be/FJt7gNi3Nr4 Ni**as in Paris https://youtu.be/gG_dA32oH44 Otis https://youtu.be/BoEKWtgJQAU H.A.M https://youtu.be/UtoHI0JEfDg Video Essays The Most Unruly – The Making of Watch the Throne https://youtu.be/YogXo-1N1GI The Most Unruly does excellent work describing the creative process of each album. The Most Unruly – The Art of Staging https://youtu.be/Vx3oOyo7-Fs This video goes through the creative intent behind each of Kanye’s live performances from Graduation to Life of Pablo. He explains how each stage was created and how they reflect both the album and what Kanye was going through in his life at the time. Worth watching because it adds another dimension to Kanye’s art. Dead End Hip Hop – Watch the Throne https://youtu.be/utTbWZTmjxo The guys didn’t like this album so much. Which makes the conversation even funnier. Haha.
otis has a great music video, you definitely should check it out
I love this album. I feel like It does have a concept literally "watch the throne" We're kings,look how we live. We come from where you come from but look how we think look at what we've done to get here, you can get here too. We're kings and we want to see more kings just like us. "New day" i feel fits that sentiment exactly, yes they're talking about their "sons" but can't they also be speaking to the shorties that are listening to their music as well.
Yeah I loved this
Great reaction... I hadn't heard WTT in years but got a renewed appreciation for a lot of its high-mindedness about their position in thr world. I remember news about them two building a whole studio in a hotel room somewhere for a month to make this album. And they would play that "individuals in Paris" :'D song multiple times in a row at live shows with the crowds going crazier each time
No I.D. Is Kanye’s mentor. He taught Kanye how to make beats in High School. No I.D. Was a producer for Common when Common first came out. Hopefully you’ll get to some Common work soon.
Lift off is a great track, but if you want to actually listen to Beyonce you should really check out her album lemonade. It's a great introspective album about her coping with Jay-z's infidelity. And I am glad you like new day so much, I don't hear as much about that song as I do other tracks on this album and it's always been my favorite from wtt
Hey Bob. Great reaction as always. I was wondering if Jay Z ‘The Blueprint’ is on your list. It’s a great album, and very meaningful for your journey, given that it’s Kanye’s introduction to the world as a producer/beat maker.
I feel for Kanye when he blames himself for his mothers death on New Day. Such a good song. That line on HAM "like Eli, I did it". I feel that annotation is incorrect, it refers to a video of high school kids rapping and it went semi viral because it was so ridiculous, the reference seems so niche I like yours better. You mentioned that you didn't know Charlie Wilson, he was in All of the Lights and Bound 2. Also if you want to listen to New Slaves again, Kanye did a live rendition with Charlie Wilson (and dare I say, better than the original) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zaOIWgXepqs Also if you're interested, Kanye had an iconic interview not long after this album, so many memed moments. it might also be good to see where his headspace was around this time. Listening to him speak is just great. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DR_yTQ0SYVA
Used to go on runs after dark around the neighborhood listening to this album. Man as I walked outside and my feet hit the pavement to no church in the wild it felt like a fucking movie
It was great seeing you listen to this album. I haven’t listen to it for years, was a great trip hearing this albums again an hear your take on it. If you liked New Day so much, you really need to check out Atmosphere albums. They have a lot of tracks like that. One of the best underground groups ever with great meaningfull lyrics. https://youtu.be/6jD9sZ0PTFM
This tour was amazing. Each did 3-4 songs of their own and then met in the middle did a few from this album. Really showed how these 2 are the throne of the rap game. Not to mention at the LA show they played Paris 12x in a row and every time they would yell “AGAIN” the crowd would get louder and louder
Official music video for Paris was their live performance https://youtu.be/gG_dA32oH44
Wanted to say the following because you seemed to hesitate before sharing the story about your youth. One of my favorite things about your reactions is how you sometimes connect your own emotional experiences to the music, elucidating on the song’s theme. And I think it’s wonderful how you allow yourself to be pulled into the music on a profound, emotional level. I respect that openness immensely. Just saying this to clarify that I always love when you share stories and emotion! It helps me understand songs on a deeper level (hell, I don’t love WTT, but your reactions gave me a deeper appreciation for it).
Great reaction. Been a little heavy with the mainstream reactions recently though. I think it’s time to feed the underground again. This is my weekly By the Time I Get to Phoenix recommendation. Best hip hop album of the last 5 years.
Even though I love Jay and Kanye this album is kinda weak imo
Actually watching this reaction made the album grow on me lol
I think the song you were remembering in no church in the wild was pyramids by Frank Ocean. Probably sparked Ur brain hearing Frank over syntha
off topic but now that i think about it, there’s absolutely no evidence of bobbert here having legs. perhaps all these dirt bike stories are trying to distracts us from his true half human half alien torso nature
He stood up on stream once. Massive calves.
It’s not just the environment’s conditions and the lack of opportunity it provides. It’s what the environment does to you psychologically as well. Mental trauma that can go a lifetime never being diagnosed and dealt with.
Reminds me of Amir who was kicked out brockhampton for allegations of being abusive. He said he had to get professional help after that because growing up in an abusive household, that was all he knew. Same with xxxtentacion. Had a fucked up life since he was a little kid and when he died you had people saying he had it coming. Before he died, he would talk on IG live often of trying to change and be a better person. Even made a music video where he fights his past self. People are quick to anger and judgement but are slow to understanding. Not saying a fucked environment excuses bad behavior but I just think people gotta chill sometimes on the hating.
1. Individuals In Paris in an iconic song, it was huge at the time (definitely the biggest song from this album). Kanye and Jay actually went on a joint Watch The Throne tour after the release of this album and when they got to Paris they were so hyped that they performed the song 12 times in a row as an encore. 2. Although it is true that this album is mostly a 'victory lap', it's still a lot more thematic than people give it credit for. A lot of religious themes, allusions to ancient Greek and Rome, references to black icons/samples of legendary black musicians, etc. And yeah, you should definitely do The Blueprint and The Black Album by Jay at some point.
I think now that you’re focusing and appreciating production more, you should give Astroworld a listen. The production is insane and Travis Scott takes a slight step up lyrically from Rodeo
I put Astroworld back into the mix for fighting for a rotation spot. Hopefully that happens somewhat soon
Jayz must listens Reasonable Doubt- ✔️ Blueprint Black Album 4:44 He has other albums that are great (volume 2, American gangster, blueprint 3, roc la familia) but to me these are the highlights and are the most succinct
American Gangster should be a must listen imo it’s his best lyrical album
Despite being a huge Kanye stan I always put off listening to WTT in full bc of all the comments and tweets about how it’s a low in Kanye’s discog and that it’s all very mediocre however after hearing you’d be reacting to it soon I thought I’d give it a full run through in preparation and I love every single song (except for lift off). I really don’t see what peoples deal is with the album, I think it’s amazing
New Day is rarely brought up as one of the best songs for Jay & Kanye, although it's widely liked, it's not praised enough imo, from the production to the lyrics, just perfection.
There are music videos for No Church in the Wild, Otis and Neighbours in Paris.
https://www.reddit.com/r/hiphopheads/comments/4ebdkd/watch_the_throne_mini_documentary/ official WTT mini-doc, must watch also know that HAM was the first single we got. i remember that so vividly, hit everybody like ton of bricks. i listened to this song days straight and was just amazed how far they took the sound. a lot of people call it the birth of luxury rap.
HAM is a fun one to listen to. Having that as the first single is a great idea lol
I love that you enjoyed Jay-Z's verses on here because you will be blown away by The Blueprint and The Black Album when you get around to them. This album is great but Jay-Z was rapping at like half capacity. The Blueprint and The Black Album are head-to-head for his two best albums by most people and he is just on another level on those. I'm excited to see your reactions to them.
agreed, and once he's done those he should do 4:44...one of the best "late career" rap projects ever...exec produced by NO I.D. (you were asking about him Bob, he was Kanye's production mentor since his early Chicago days)...you can see the influence he had on ye's soulful sound in a song like "primetime"
New Day is such a good song, underrated asl
When Kanye and Jay went on tour for this album they played individuals in Paris 11 times in a row at the Paris show of the tour. It was around 45 minutes of them performing that one song
Loved the reaction! Such a great album. Highly recommend Lupe Fiasco's Food & Liquor if you're looking for dope concepts and great wordplay/lyrics :)
Food & Liquor is on the list, slowly moving up as well
hyped for this one. might be jumping the gun but we getting pablo or cruel summer next?
Little simz next week then Danny brown the week after that. That’s all he has said so far I think
them performing New day - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=77XUrtPFZ-M
Loved it
And by the way, I hope Mos Def's Black on Both Sides is on your list. A fantastic album.
On my list (has been for awhile) 👍
Great reaction once again! Regarding the "circus sound" I'm gonna copy paste a theory I found on reddit: "To me it sounds like circus music. Something that will play when clowns peform their acts. The first song of the album "No Church In the Wild" is powerful, insightful, and deep in meaning and towards the end we get the "clown music". I believe it signals the arrival of a dumbed down song. They sorta just tell you off the bat "Hey, this next song is pop/ignant". "New Day" another amazing song with great meaning has the clown music nearing the end and guess what song comes up.... "That's my Bitch". It sorta shows that they are aware of the music they're going to give you. My personal favorite "Illest Mothafucker Alive" has the song right in the intro just to prepare for the ignantness that you're about to listen."
Makes sense. Thanks for the write up :)
hoping you got the bonus tracks on this one they’re mandatory
I don't know if this is what you were referring to but that background noise in No Church in the wild is similar to Flashing Lights
I don't like any of the deluxe tracks. I think they bring down the quality of the album. Just my opinion lol
i think primetime is the best song on the album. and ham & illest mf alive are both top 10 songs on the album also. just my opinion tho
I knew 'New Day' would be your favorite haha, Kanyes verse gets me in the feels too and the outro is just magnificent.
lets get to it
Jay Z and Kanye perform Otis https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8W210nBHR3I&ab_channel=mittiga04
Better link https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BUObGRyYMOQ&ab_channel=WorkerBeys
Cant wait
technically you heard beyoncé first on pink + white on blonde, she had backing vocals on that song.
The album is a little dated at times, but it's a classic. Also, yes this was huge and really one of the biggest moments in hip hop, honestly ever.
NO WAY
Fun fact: Kanye made the beat for Otis in like 15 minutes before catching a flight.
Lil Wayne album before the summers over hopefully
Excited to see what you think of this one. I myself think it's kinda mid road for both of them. Few great songs and a bunch of okay ones.
Ready for all the Jay bars/lyrical quirks that will go uncaught.
Jay had a lot of great lines in this. I need to listen to more of his music
Before you do Life of Pablo I think you should react to 2 singles he dropped before the album called ”All Day” and ”Only One” they were meant for a version of the album that got canceled so they never made the final album. They’re really good and show a lil sneak peak of his progression from Yeezus. Also, people rarely react to these so you might get some good views from these
Both featuring Paul McCartney by the way
Bob reacting to luxury rap let’s gooo
Bob finally learns who was in Paris
this albums middle and third section is kinda meh but i’m excited for this album nonetheless
I agree. it’s just kinda alright to me. I don’t really return to it, other than a few tracks.
Tha carter 3 please :)
It’s his best work, trust me, the features you’ve heard are nothing compared to it
