💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
October 22, 2026

The Charming Susan Strangler - Demarest, New Jersey

This week, in Demarest, New Jersey, something seems to be up, when two women disappear. Both are found brutally murdered, within days of each other, and near the same area. The crazy part is, it turns out that both of their names were Susan, and that's not the only thing that thet end up having in common. The other thing is a connection to a local man, nicknamed "The Charmer", who is supported by a rich aunt, and always in trouble for increasingly violent behavior. Will his family money keep him out of trouble??

Along the way, we find out that when the Army used to run out of space, the soldiers would just live at a racetrack, that constantly bailing a troubled person out of trouble isn't always the best solution, and that some people won't take you out of their will, even if you try to have them killed!!

New episodes, every Wednesday & Friday nights!!

Check us out on VIDEO Wednesday and Friday evenings on Netflix! www.netflix.com/smalltownmurder

Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions!

Follow us on...

instagram.com/smalltownmurder

facebook.com/smalltownpod

Also, check out James & Jimmie's other shows, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!

Comments (38)

C
Christine Brydges · October 26, 2026

C DC

M
MARTHA · October 26, 2026

My exact childhood experience: “Don’t touch that horse! It’s gonna end up costing us something. Back away!” 😂😂

M
Michael Griffith · October 26, 2026

Please come back to Michigan!

J
Judy Cronje · October 25, 2026

Kevin Mitnik's book Ghost in the Wire (James mentioned him wrt the empty birth certificates) is brilliant. He was not only the best hacker, but extremely skilled in, what Kevin called "social engineering", how to get confidential info from companies without any hacking. Great book, as is his other book, "The art of deception". Absolutely worth a listen - I also have the audiobooks.

p
pale_emo_princess · October 25, 2026

"he can't leave New Jersey, which is a sentence right there-" 😂 as a New Yorker who's been living in NJ for the past 3.5 years...I completely agree 🤣 (sorry NJ peeps - I'm happy for you if you like living here, it's just not for me. I can't wait to move next month lol)

D
Deb S. · October 25, 2026

I was so fucking happy when you guys said you’ll wait to go on the elevator if a girl is alone or you’ll lean away and go on your phone 😮‍💨 there are still good people out there. Being in an elevator alone and having a random man try to speak to you or hit on you, are some of the scariest experiences I’ve had as a woman.

N
Nunya_bsnss · October 24, 2026

2:15:30 They need to give the prison guards quarterly reminders not to lay with convicts 3:00:25 Stay cool, laugh when it's appropriate and peg willing dudes

C
Cam · October 23, 2026

What happened to the guys wife and step-kid?

K
Kyle P · October 23, 2026

The treatment director should be tried also. They hold bartenders accountable for letting a drunk drive. Why don’t judges and other people get held accountable for letting criminals out when they are obviously dangerous

A
Allen Tinker · October 23, 2026

Nagila!!!!

A
Alyssa W · October 23, 2026

I like that James can't help but repeat "hundred dollars cash". Every time 😂

M
Melissa Dickinson · October 23, 2026

I just went and looked at the real estate listings. Those are some ugly, no-personality mansions! The one homey, pretty one with lots of light had neighbors so close they could jump in the pool from their bathroom window. No thank you.

M
Margaret Ferrier · October 23, 2026

How could she have her engagement ring on her dead body after he had pawned it? Did I miss something? 🤷‍♀️

L
Louis Ludwig · October 23, 2026

1:22 “…..which is a sentence right there” 😆

M
Meg Stampke · October 23, 2026

TMI I know, but going through a miscarriage and needing something to get by. Thanks guys for providing that.

C
Coptia White · October 23, 2026

I’m so sorry to hear that. ❤️‍🩹

L
Lara Clifton · October 22, 2026

LOL Jersey native here, I just started it and you're mentioning the holy Angels dance the squad and my first thought was haha holy whores.. that's what we called them in high school that's a school where rich girls go and that was what we called the school holy whores😂

D
Dennis Kelly · October 22, 2026

The Alison name was popular with American due to Robert Clay Alison who was a huge cattle rancher and Trail Boss

C
Casey Dobel · October 22, 2026

Public defender here. Only man named Alison I’ve ever seen was a guy (not my client) who was getting charged because he [allegedly] kept calling the local cops trying to buy cocaine from them

C
Coptia White · October 23, 2026

That’s amazing. He was just calling the station? 🤣

S
Stephen Watts · October 22, 2026

Carroll is usually a surname usally with O' in front I have never in my whole life met someone here in Ireland who is a man called Carroll, like Reagan I assume it's an Irish American thing

D
Dwayne Battiata · October 22, 2026

I listen and subscribe to any and all the shit you 2 do. I fucking love you guys. Started when STM was at/around 70 episodes. I want a new episode of all your podcasts everyday (truck driver with a lot of time). That being said, I don't know how you guys have any time to do anything. I, for one appreciate all the hard work you do to bring the best entertainment to my lonely cab and make my days go by quickly. I hope I spelled and used punctuation correctly. Keep up the great work.

C
Crowded Crow · October 25, 2026

Spelling and punctuation: 4.9/5 stars (excellent, in my humble estimation)🏆🤘😁

D
Denali Hyatt · October 22, 2026

I'll be honest, if I were in jail for life, I'd never stop trying to escape. What's the worst that could happen? More forever in prison? Lmao

J
Jessica Schafer · October 22, 2026

Off topic, but can anyone remind me which episode was the guy hearing voices in the air conditioner?

S
Snarky Moomin · October 22, 2026

CIS #55 Ike Ieabuchi? ' Demons in the air conditioner '

L
Lori Ditchfield · October 22, 2026

Gloucester is pronounced Glaw-stah 🙂

M
Maritza Diaz · October 22, 2026

Is it possible that auntie got to the therapist? Money talks, rapists walks.

J
James Twomey · October 22, 2026

All I can think of is the "killing every Sarah Connor" thing from Terminator

T
Trina · October 22, 2026

James, can I pay you to record, "HEY, YO, SWEETHEART! YOU GOTTA FUCKIN' TEXT MESSAGE OVA HERE!" In your Italian guy voice? It's my favorite of all your accents/impersonations. ❤️

E
Erika Fultz · October 25, 2026

That and the drunk! Those are my faves

C
Chris Winkelman · October 22, 2026

Yayy!!!

C
Connie Hamilton · October 22, 2026

The

M
Maggie King · October 22, 2026

Ij 1975, young women of Susan's socioeconomic status often travelled abroad post graduation or summers. Trek in Nepal or work in a kibbutz. Many of us pursued Master's, some married and many took jobs in Manhattan to earn $$, figure out their next step and listen to your Dad rag on you for the billionth time that a BA in Medieval Lit! I made $200/wk as a law firm office manager, roomed w 2 college friends, and dinner was Cheetos and a bottle of wine. PS my degrees were Spanish with minors in Business and PoliSci.

J
Jennifer S. · October 22, 2026

My theory about why serial killers like VW Bugs is because the trunk is in the front. They can constantly have their eyes on their secret treasure, even when transporting their victims’s bodies. A victim is practically laying in his lap when he’s driving. It’s close, intimate, and secret even though it’s happening in everyone’s faces.

M
Maggie King · October 22, 2026

THAT gave me goosebumps. I happened to be a college student with long dark hair, parted in the middle during those rollicking Bundy days...

L
Liz Rutherford · October 22, 2026

Yaaaayyyy!!!

S
Sirc Michaels · October 22, 2026

Really needed this today. Thanks!