💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
September 22, 2026

To Punch A Predator - Kevin Mitchell - Part 3

This week, we finish this tale with attitude becoming more important than talent. Kevin continues to be a problem for any team he joins. Despite always putting up good numbers, he bickers, argues, and worst of all, gets arrested, more than the average MLB team will put up with. He even gets in fights on the golf course. He almost loses an eye & is diagnosed with a difficult disease. But there is one story here, that if true, is one of the worst, most vile things an athlete on this show has ever done!!

Have your attitude get in the way of your baseball ability, beat up a pedophile, before you even know he's a pedophile, and be accused of one of the sickest, and most heartless things that it's possible to do with Kevin Mitchell - Part 3!!

Check us out, every Tuesday!

We will continue to bring you the biggest idiots in sports history!!

Hosted by James Pietragallo & Jimmie Whisman

Donate at... patreon.com/crimeinsports or with paypal.com using our email: crimeinsports@gmail.com

Get all the CIS, STM & YSO merch at crimeinsports.threadless.com

Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things CIS, STM & YSO!!

Contact us on...

instagram.com/smalltownmurder

facebook.com/crimeinsports

crimeinsports@gmail.com

Comments (32)

K
Kristin Schmidt · October 1, 2026

As a MN Midwesterner who owns a Woodfired pizza truck. Please come here between May & October and I’ll feed you for free. Only to have your honest opinion!!!

W
Will · September 29, 2026

I was not prepared for that. WTF Kevin Mitchell? Im a huge baseball fan and big reader, Im surprised I'd never heard that story but kinda glad I didn't

E
Erika Fultz · September 25, 2026

For anyone who is curious, 400,000,000 yen is just over $2.5 million usd

N
Nunya_bsnss · September 24, 2026

1:27:00 Best story of win stupid prizes. Warning: cat murder details soon after 1:33:45 WASN'T MY BOOK, WASN'T MY WORDS

C
Crystal Christiansen · September 24, 2026

How else do you cut a tray of pizza other than into squares? Do they not sell 24 slice pizzas in the US?

N
Nunya_bsnss · September 24, 2026

I think the point is that a triangle with crusts is the best shape so you don't get sauce on your fingers. That's why Normal Pizzas are a circle as Italy intended 🍕

C
ColoRado · September 24, 2026

I couldn’t agree more about the pizza. Square cut pizza is an abomination

J
Jacqueline Rose · September 24, 2026

Judging Cincinnati’s food by LaRosa’s and Skyline chili is like judging a city by its Papa John’s and Arby’s. Idk who told you to eat those two, but don’t take their advice anymore

D
Debbie Stevens · September 23, 2026

I had to skip past the part about the cat. Fuck that dude.

R
R Monster · September 23, 2026

Lol omg I went to Rowan University in southern Jersey.

A
Alyssa W · September 23, 2026

Square pizza is for kid's sleepovers

B
Bunny · September 23, 2026

Can yall do an episode on Sheryl Swoopes???

A
Andrew Hollier · September 23, 2026

Also not a doctor but an registered nurse specialising in diabetes management I’ve never heard of getting diabetes this way

B
Brendan Ables · September 23, 2026

Not that the guys care, but Keith Mitchell played very briefly in the Majors at that time as well in a reserve role, hence why he was interviewed 😂

M
Milwaukee Nick · September 23, 2026

Yeah they mention it, listen to the entire episode.

J
Jim Dolen · September 23, 2026

Lifelong Giants fan and had never heard this crazy story. By the way I live for spurius science from you guys. Thanks for another incredible broadcast!

A
Arthur Deaton · September 23, 2026

James and Jimmie, come back and do another live show in Cincinnati. Larosa's on me. 😆

M
Maggie79 · September 22, 2026

First- it’s not lost on me that with your other obligations, either YSO or CIS is probably what would get cut in case of illness- so I really appreciate you gutsing it out James! And when you’re in Medford in November, hit either Joe’s Pizza or Amici’s- so freaking good, I miss living out there

J
Jennifer Modrall · September 22, 2026

Tbh I could have used a warning about the cat

C
Carey Turner · September 23, 2026

Same!

J
John penrod · September 22, 2026

James and Jimmy just watch out I remember when Rome made fun of Mitchell about 30 years ago and Mitchell was on the warpath with Romey and Jim sounded quite nervous on the phone when Mitchell finally did call the radio show big fan of you guys saw you in San Diego

D
Dale Oren · September 22, 2026

Listening to James breathing in snot is both hilarious and sympathetic at the same time... sorry, get better mate...

A
Andrew Betts · September 22, 2026

I eat oatmeal to keep the weight on I'm 138 so I need to carry some weight

J
Jay · September 22, 2026

Can he get a new scummy award for the biggest asshole without any felony convictions?

S
Samuel Katz · September 22, 2026

I’d say that tavern style is better than the office cutting you 1/32nd of a slice

E
Erica Magliochetti · September 22, 2026

Not a doctor but an RN 25 years and I never heard of getting diabetes that way 😂😂

S
Sean · September 22, 2026

James needs some nose spray lol. Dude is so stopped up haha

D
Donnie King · September 22, 2026

If I didn't know any better, I would say James and Jimmie hate Chad Curtis.😄

M
MYturb en is-dirty · September 22, 2026

Cincinnati chili is fucking awesome. Don’t listen to these guys lol.

M
Milwaukee Nick · September 23, 2026

You have a gutter palette

S
Snarky Moomin · September 22, 2026

To borrow one of James' favourite phrases- THAT was truly disturbing.

R
Robyn Francis · September 22, 2026

When you grow up in the Chicagoland area, square cut pizza is what you know and love. I haven’t lived there since 2021, and I still love a square cut. The middle pieces are the best!