Black Candle Murder Party - West Liberty, Iowa - Part 2

Great as always. Love how James tells a story. I get so involved at work. I have burnt food at home. Lol. Can I write her? I’m in liberal madison WI. I can get at least 100 signatures. And again thank you for making my days at work just fly by. Oh BTW I was 19, 21 and 23 when I had my children. They all have college degrees 2 have masters in business. I was 45 when I had the first of my 9 grandchildren at 68 the first of my great grandchildren. I was M young enough to enjoy them. I finished my education and have always worked full time while I had children and we were a 2 parent family with another young gramma who was very energetic and helpful. I have never regretted having my children young. Mainly boys with a lot of energy and athletic and so were my girls.

Wait! Did I miss something? Why didn’t they do mitochondrial DNA testing on the hairs found in his hand? I know they tested the bat…

I recently watched Starship Troopers for the first time since childhood remembering it much different, and for some reason thought there were like 3 movies 💀💀

I can't fucking wait for the interrogation breakdown!!! Nobody does it like James, LETS GOOOO!!!!!

I appreciate that they take the time to tell the whole story. Give us the details and get it right. Do you want it quick or do you want it good? Because you’re not getting both

I can’t believe people are actually complaining about this part 2 of the express show. Don’t you have anything better to do with your lives? Find something else to complain about! James and Jimmie work hard to put all of these shows together. They didn’t have to do a 2nd part but they did! And I’m glad because I’ve never heard of this story! Not everyone (except maybe my sister 😄) has heard every single true crime case there is! Lolololol 😂

Here is the issue, nationwide. Prosecutors should HAVE to pick the highest charge that they THINK they can convict. Being able to charge murder 1, 2, voluntary manslaughter, involuntary manslaughter, etc, should not be legal. It ENCOURAGES compromise. I've been on a couple juries & it absolutely does. 6 guilty, 6 not guilty, let's meet in the middle and give a voluntary manslaughter. THAT is RIDICULOUS. That is not a unanimous verdict & it is insanely wrong! That is promotion of wrongful convictions, simply so the prosecution gets a W.

100s of millions in police funds every year. 2 cold case detectives. Makes sense

Neighbor who committed suicide. He had motive, access, and he was unstable.

Damn y’all complain a lot. They don’t always do everything that I want or like. But I also know I’m not the only one listening to the damn podcast. Sometimes people are gonna wanna hear things and I don’t. You’re always free to go listen to something else.

I wonder if back then she had another man in her life, and sent him to beat up Corey (or he did it on his own) and then he accidentally ended up killing him. That would explain the whole candle thing.

I can’t find part One!! Please help!

What was the title of the part 1? I didn't see it? Or what number episode?

I wish that charge nurse was a listener of the show. She would've known to MIND HER FUCKING BUSINESS. She got a grandma locked up for no fucking reason.

There is so much more to this

I have wanted you guys to do this for years !!!!!!

Well, I really hope Annette did it cos there's zero proof that she did. Huge miscarriage of justice.

WOW!!! Wild story!!

Interesting… crazy story. I don’t know what to think. I do have some extremely vivid childhood memories burned into my brain, so I do believe this nurse who heard what Annette said. It appears the baseball bat is irrelevant and not actually the murder weapon, but that doesn’t mean Annette didn’t do it. The DNA on the bat doesn’t prove anything other than the cops got the wrong murder weapon. Despite the fact her behavior was suspicious, I am not sure I could convict anyone on a case this circumstantial.

WOW!!!!! Absolutely mind-blowing story. This was so worth a two-parter, you can spring those on us anytime, guys. Thank you!!

That bat singlehandedly convinced me they got the wrong person, holy shit

Fuck people if they complain. A good story is a good story!

I don't mind multiple parts to a story. All the other podcasts sum up these cases in one hour or less. How do we get all the juice out in that short amount of time?

What episode # is Part 1?

If anyone has the audacity to complain im going to quote James' dad... 🎶 "You CANT always GET what you wannnttt" 🎶

Thank you for all the details about this case! Definitely a lot of facts left out on other platforms I’ve heard it on. I don’t mind 2 parts or 1 part. I love listening. Keep up the hard work!

I guess the moral of the story is dont have 8 relationships at once and buy and sell drugs?

Knock knock, Bob is at the door.

Are you kidding me!? You make us wait a week for a part 2 of an express episode and it ends up pretty much as a whodunit!? You guys suck!😄

"Slam Pig" !!!!! Wow.

Jacquie is short for Jacqueline. Jacque is close but no "i". I have an Aunt Jacquie (for short), who was forced to learn to spell her full name at 5 years old, I figure maybe James can relate., lol

When are these fucking criminals going to learn…. Cop- *Knock Knock* Suspect- Hello, how can I help you? Cop- I wanted to discuss a cold case that…. Suspect- LAWYER Cop- But, I just…. Suspect- LAWYER…LAWYER…LAWYER VON LAWYERSTEIN

Who's DNA is on the bat!?! There might have been a second blunt instrument murder that very same day!!

So excited for pt 2! This case is insane!

Love

I hate Multi parters. Just sayin z