💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
July 23, 2026

Phantom Of The Neighborhood - Acme, Washington

This week, in Acme, Washington, a young woman vanishes while on a jog, on her very rural road. When she's found, brutalized & very dead, it's clear that there's a very sick person in the area, even prompting the police to look into the Green River Killer. Despite several suspects, detectives have nothing to go on, except hunches, and some DNA that they can't seem to match to anyone. Then, two women having a seemingly casual conversation at a waterpark, cracks the whole case, and reveals a murderer, that is as ordinary a man as there could be!!

Along the way, we find out that the diner seems to be the center of social interaction in some small towns, that you should consider it very good service, when you call to file a missing person report, and the police send a "human tracker" right out, and that "murder stay murder"!!

New episodes, every Wednesday & Friday nights!!

Check us out on VIDEO Wednesday and Friday evenings on Netflix! www.netflix.com/smalltownmurder

Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions!

Follow us on...

instagram.com/smalltownmurder

facebook.com/smalltownpod

Also, check out James & Jimmie's other shows, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!

Comments (69)

E
Elizabeth Boucher · August 8, 2026

In the northeast, it goes brook, stream, creek, river

J
Jessica A · August 7, 2026

Women have a lifetime of experience dealing with innocent flirtation, sexual harassment, lecherous behavior, the entire spectrum of sexual overtures and it starts EARLY. This is pattern recognition. Running across a dangerous predator feels like ice water running through your veins and electricity up your spine. It's different.

A
Amy Rodriguez · August 6, 2026

Kim Wagner is a damn hero!!! Can you imagine how scared she must have been?!

C
Chad Litzinger · August 4, 2026

How sad that their Mom had 2 children get murdered, and 1 went cold and the other took 30 years. How would you handle that?

S
Seanbob Kelly · August 3, 2026

. . . But what happened to Yoko?!

L
Lori Ditchfield · July 29, 2026

Friend's big brothers can be problematic, in general. Back in Jr high, we had a friend who would try to get me and my sister to stay over. This girl, i believe, pretended to be asleep and my sister and I were then visited by this girl's older brother. Oddly, we ended up playing Monopoly with this weird boy, but still... Friggin creepy of him. We found out after the fact, we weren't the only ones.

S
Smalls (smallenoughtofit) · July 27, 2026

Important note about men who "get broken up with and suddenly hate women": they ALWAYS hated women. They just feel like they have a reason to be open about it now

V
Victoria Sterling · July 27, 2026

I read the Blooding. It a very interesting story

M
M. Kultra · July 27, 2026

But did you wear Big Johnson shirts?

D
Danielle · July 26, 2026

This Kim woman is my hero

T
Trevor Fletcher · July 25, 2026

Wednesday Before thanksgiving where I grew up is called blackout Wednesday Lmaooo 🥂

L
Laura Larson · July 25, 2026

I wish they would do an episode of all the missing people Patty, Michaela, Lanae, and all the other missing people from Skagit/up river. There is a 4 hour episode - include the body found in the suitcase 2-3 years ago up in Ross Lake .

O
OMAR GOBBY · July 25, 2026

I used to be all in regarding sex offender registries...but, like death penalty, there are times that it might not be good I recommend the movie "Untouchable". It comes at this from all angles.

O
OMAR GOBBY · July 25, 2026

Am I the only one who is disappointed that Yoko just disappeared from this story?

L
Laura Errera · July 25, 2026

You are right about the wine coolers

S
Shay Howsmon · July 25, 2026

I live in the PNW. This is the whitest place on Earth 😬

G
Ginger Thomas · July 25, 2026

Given the curse that seems to be on this family, I’m really glad she didn’t fly commercial airliners.

C
Crashtestwoman · July 24, 2026

But what happened to Yoko…..???

M
MaryBeth Southwell · July 24, 2026

So the funniest thing about this was all of the things you were like well hell I don’t know let him know the evergreen boughs. It was just funny and I think that it just helps me relate to you as being just real guys.

A
Amanda Clay · July 24, 2026

Omg Jimmie, Cintas! I’ve worked there for 25 years, that made my day!!!

P
Punkie · July 24, 2026

When I hear “Running in the woods” it always makes me think of the “Pine Barrens” episode of The Sopranos.

J
Jae Melton · July 24, 2026

Pretty much every Evil Dead movie lol

C
Ché and Seph · July 24, 2026

Just because I was curious, at 1:22:00ish, after they talk about her funeral they mention some other murder/missing people in the local area Diane Leslie Reeves - ‘Endangered Missing’ Jay Cook and Tanya Van Cuylensborg - Their case was solved in 2019 after a suspect was arrested in 2018. He was caught using familial dna. The guy was a trucker, there’s no way these are his only 2 victims. Rita Disanjh - on October 2nd 2007 Henry Keeler Redlighting confessed to the crime. He became angry with her whilst giving her a lift home from the mentioned beach party. Wendy Aughe - Darren Dee O’Neall was on the FBI 10 most wanted list for a different murder for which he was caught and sentenced to 27 years and 9 months (plea deal), he was extradited to to Oregon for a kidnapping and rape case, for which he got 135 years. He was charged with Aughe’s murder in October 2022.

A
Amber Nicole · July 24, 2026

I’m pretty sure No Fear is sold at Hollister now 🫣

L
Liz Scoops · July 24, 2026

JIMMIE are you good my man

K
Krista Lelie · July 24, 2026

They used to use Yoko Ono songs as a method of torture in the military

M
Melissa Dickinson · July 24, 2026

I know it didn't make sense to the guys that Mandy might have run into the river to escape, but I get it. Women are told to run into anywhere to escape an attacker, including into the street to the median. When I've been on trails alone, running into the river has actually been one of my mental escape plans for any kind of attack. A guy could probably outrun me, but swimming is a more even score, and he's not going to be able to r*pe me in the water.

S
SilverHairedMiddleAgedTuxedoMask · July 24, 2026

My guess though is if he had a gun if you're in the water you're incredibly vulnerable as its a clear shot for the entire time.

L
Laura Larson · July 24, 2026

The first time I drove through....I was really pissed that there wasn't anvils everywhere. 🤦🏻‍♀️🤣

T
TJ McCollum · July 24, 2026

This one hits close to home. My mom knew Mandy. Was part of the reason she got into law enforcement. Really great job as always.

S
Samuel Katz · July 24, 2026

Why do so many criminals have the name Wayne in their names? It’s usually a middle name too

M
Mary · July 23, 2026

I’m telling you, gotta trust the female creep meter

J
Jane · July 23, 2026

Me listening to this while working in airway heights 😳

J
Jessica Schafer · July 23, 2026

The song is on YouTube BTW for anyone curious. Not the worst thing ever. And super sad cause its a slideshow of her pictures. That poor girl 😔

C
Clifford Walraven · July 23, 2026

There is gangs in Seattle and it's suburbs they came down for California the gang that over ran the area is MS 13

C
Cosmo's ma · July 23, 2026

So weird... Yoko means "Side" in Japanese... why would they name the kid Yoko?

T
Trina · July 23, 2026

My sisters and I were standing in line at the Atlanta Airport to board an international flight. There was a little girl in line ahead of us holding onto her passport and she was around the same age as my niece. I said to my sister, mom of said niece, "Aww, she has her own passport." The girl's dad heard me and pulled his kid in closer to him. I felt so bad!! He didn't know I was a harmless old woman, my comment definitely could've been creepy if I were anyone else! 😄

H
Hot Dog Racing YouTube · July 23, 2026

I worked on a research project on the Nooksack River in grad school between 2017 and 2019 and I assure you guys, I CONSTANTLY made nutsack jokes 💀

P
Paul · July 23, 2026

Any woman who would not leave her abusive homicidal husband "because of my kids" should not have kids to begin with.

G
Ginger Thomas · July 23, 2026

I know James doesn’t think it’s creepy that he touched that girl with a pen or that his actions made them think he was capable of murder—but women get it. Our instincts are finely tuned. We can feel murderous rage even when they are being nice. Always choosing The Bear.

M
Makayla · July 24, 2026

What I got from him was that YES the whole interaction was creepy, pen included, but saying "this guy was pervy to me one time" and jumping to "so he must be a murderer" is a stretch in general. James (and Jimmie) always stick up for women so I think they get it (as much as a man can).

J
Jennifer Soukup · July 23, 2026

As a NY maple farmer.. Big leaf maple take 80 to 100 gallons of sap to make one gallon of syrup. Typically ratio for us it's 40 to 60 gallons of sap to one gallon of syrup

S
Sheila Scarington · July 23, 2026

I grew up in that area and had never heard of Acme! 🤣

S
Shinea Igielinski · July 23, 2026

When Jimmie was talking about Von getting angry at him and he said "When I through my teeth say don't you dare, Von gets angry", I thought Jimmie meant he took out dentures and threw them across the room. I was laughing so hard when I realized what he meant 😅

E
ENKC · July 23, 2026

If there is one thing we know, harsher and longer sentences in for profit prisons that dont give a fuck about rehabilitation REALLY helps deter people from commiting crime! Just like the death penalty! 🙄

C
Christine Leister · July 23, 2026

Here in the greater Philly region pronounce ACME as Ak-eh-mee 🤣🤣

A
Annika Alsterlind · July 23, 2026

God that poor mother. Two children murdered in different places

G
Ginger Thomas · July 25, 2026

And the dad—3 kids

J
Jennifer Berg · July 23, 2026

The Happy Accidents—you know ALL of those band members were told as children that “they weren’t planned. They were just happy accidents.”

R
Robin · July 23, 2026

I am a Patreon member, just want to supplement a bit 👍

R
Robin · July 23, 2026

Does anyone know the current way to send the guys money? Listening to ten year old episodes, I’m certain things have changed and I want to make sure a donation finds them. ❤️ Supporters here are THE BEST I hope you all have a wonderful non-murdery day 😊

M
Makayla · July 24, 2026

PayPal is always an option @CrimeinSports Support the Show — Shut Up And Give Me Murder https://share.google/v6PT4tqX37j6g9t9J

R
Runa Fox · July 23, 2026

I live on the NH/VT border and agree it’s all one big state. I actually wish it were - although I think people on both sides would be complaining. The scenery is the same, the people are not 🤣

R
Runa Fox · July 23, 2026

Idk why I’m only ever compelled to comment about location related things 🙄 great episode as usual!!

A
Alfonso Hughes · July 23, 2026

Jimmie had a mild Andrew Jackson moment!

T
Tiara Walker · July 23, 2026

Can confirm we call it the nutsack river

L
Laura Larson · July 24, 2026

Excellent floating - until the water gets too low and you have to carry the tube and the cooler to the next spot. 😆

K
Katy Clark · July 23, 2026

What a pig

M
Michelle Areyzaga · July 23, 2026

Son of a bitch, I knew you were gonna mention Vermont and New Hampshire being the same as soon as you mentioned Oregon and Washington being the same state 🤣 I live in NH but on the NH side, not the Vermont side hahahaha

O
Opus the penguin. · July 23, 2026

i can't stop thinking of the poor Japanese exchange student. I always feel bad for victims and family but how crazy was her perspective?

G
Ginger Thomas · July 23, 2026

I forgot about Yoko!

A
Adrian Yorgensen · July 23, 2026

What’s the “Operation Fist” bonus episode they talk about at 2:35:00?? I thought I’ve listened to all the bonus episodes but I guess not

S
Snarky Moomin · July 23, 2026

CRIME IN SPORTS BONUS - FLAGSHIP INTERNATIONAL SPORTS TELEVISION- Nov 14th 2021. Its an absolute classic

C
Crowded Crow · July 23, 2026

Ah... Man. This is a rough one for me. Mandy was just four years older than I was when she was murdered. I know her story well. She's an inspiration, made of the loveliest true grit. She deserved so much better. Wherever she is, I hope she is running free, like the goddamn wind.

L
Liz Rutherford · July 23, 2026

It would be awesome if we knew that Yoko said "automobiiiile."

B
Brooke C · July 24, 2026

💯🤣🤣🤣🤣 God Bless Long Duk Dong

A
Alyse Christensen · July 23, 2026

Looked up yoko ono and omg no couldn’t make it 30 seconds

G
Ginger Thomas · July 23, 2026

That girl must have been the hawtest. I can’t think of anything that would make me listen to that nut.

S
Steven Ferrell · July 23, 2026

That's a lot of "very"s!