💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
May 21, 2026

Meaningless Mutilation Murders - Farmington, New Mexico

This week, in Farmington, New Mexico, finding a tow truck driver's phone near a murder victim, out in the desert, leads to a trove of evidence. This all helps in solving of many more murders, over the previous couple of years. The serial killer turns out to be local, who is obsessed with knives & swords. But the even crazier part is that he has two different accomplices! A horrifying tale of serial murder, and downright stupidity!!

Along the way, we find out that someone thinks that ALL Native Americans LOVE metal music, that just because someone's phone is near a murder victim, doeasn't always mean that it's the killer's phone, and that when you have three different kinds of tires on your car, you may not want to drive to murder scenes!!

New episodes, every Wednesday & Friday nights!!

Check us out on VIDEO Wednesday and Friday evenings on Netflix! www.netflix.com/smalltownmurder

Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions!

Follow us on...

instagram.com/smalltownmurder

facebook.com/smalltownpod

Also, check out James & Jimmie's other shows, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!

Comments (104)

J
Jeremy Doran · September 23, 2026

vivisection, people collection! 😂

J
Jodi Bright · August 1, 2026

Y

F
Full of BS · July 2, 2026

holy crap 💩 my initials are BP AND i was born on June 29. i think this may be my favorite episode ✌🏼&🫶🏼

j
jwhutch · June 21, 2026

I write in all caps now (28) because I don’t like the letters touching on the row underneath🥲

E
Eddie LeBoeuf Jr · June 19, 2026

You have to, but don't have to

J
Joe Jacobbi · June 9, 2026

If Bobby found god in jail why would he want to leave? God is there! And I got a chuckle every time he went looking for prostitutes in his Ford Aspire- the Aspire basically took over for the Ford Escort. He was looking for Escorts in an Escort

B
Braylen · June 3, 2026

For being such a god-forsaken town, 3 MLB players coming from there is impressive.

J
Jackie Tague · June 1, 2026

Holy crap, the trench coat kids had me rolling! I am from a small (and I mean very, very small) town and we had one trench coat kid. He was totally into swords and he brought the Secret Service to our school. He made a threat again the president from one of our school computers. After that we had no trench coat kids left in my school... What a fucking moron!

M
Mana · May 31, 2026

Vampire: The Masquerade. In November 1996, it became associated with the real-life double murder of a Florida couple committed by teenager Roderick "Rod" Ferrell and his cult.

G
Gail 10-A · May 28, 2026

James: “Jimmie isn’t a dumb person - he just plays one on TV” … I KNEW IT!!! That is Jimmie’s brilliance and it plays so well against James’ storytelling abilities. You two are so good together. Love your pods and the two of you

D
Dennis Scott · May 28, 2026

Attempted sexual penetration is one of the worst charges I have ever heard!!

S
Sherry McArthur · May 27, 2026

All I wanna say is, “Justin Verlander is my Tiger”. I’ve been a Detroit Tiger fan for at least 30 years.

J
Joe B · May 27, 2026

Yet another episode where a psycho killer drove a legendary POS car (e.g. Chevette, Pinto, Gremlin, etc.). I used to feel sorry for someone driving a Ford Aspire or similar shit box. Now I know to immediately pepper spray them and run away if I want to survive.

M
MJ O'keeffe · May 26, 2026

Awww man I love you both so much. Pronunciation Schumuncuation!!!

C
Chelsea Neeley · May 26, 2026

My Papa’s name was Harold, and he was in fact an old bald man 😂

D
David AndMelina · May 26, 2026

I think you guys should have one of those heat sensitive mugs that says "We are not ok" when cold and then says "I'm good now" when hot liquids are poured in it. I would definitely buy that.

B
Bethany Lynn · May 25, 2026

I hope Betty Lee’s friends stub their toe every day for the rest of their lives.

A
AnnaRaeLou · May 25, 2026

This was such a great episode! I live in Durango and commuted for 2 years to Farmington for nursing school. Definitely cool to know the area. (Ps Farmington totally does suck as much as they say it does)

J
J Iller · May 25, 2026

Ford Assfire

G
Grace Luterek · May 24, 2026

I still print in all caps.

A
Abracadabra Steven Miller’s Whorewife Rachel Uppengrabya · May 24, 2026

0’ mall mi know know bo jo oh b my hi ty

A
Ashley W. · May 24, 2026

"Vivisection People Collection" would be a sick-ass name for a metal band.

J
Jim Dolen · May 23, 2026

Every week I think that we'll never hear a story highlighting the idiocy of criminals worse than this one and yet here we are!

I
It Ain't Easy Being Eldritch · May 23, 2026

Absolutely cackling at James' joke about the NM Supreme Court.... 😅🤣😅🤣 Bless you assholes! 💖

M
Mike McClure · May 23, 2026

Leslie Engh=baby chicken= murder bird! Check the website. 😂

H
H-man · May 23, 2026

I KNEW JAMES AND JIMMIE WERE SMART! Seriously, I was going to post that recently when I heard Jimmie say “all the alleles” a couple of weeks ago. How many of us (who aren’t geneticists/biomedical scientists) remember what alleles are?!? I KNEW IT! 🤣🤣🤣❤️❤️

D
Dennis James Mcintosh · May 23, 2026

Jimmie, did you ever get to fish the San Juan? I fished it back in 1994. Catch and release, but I caught the largest trout of my life there! Fantastic fun!

I
It Ain't Easy Being Eldritch · May 23, 2026

Holy shit you guys!!! "Vampire The Masquerade: Bloodlines" is a freaking awesome game!!! I think the one they were talking about is the first one, whereas the one I mentioned is the second in the franchise. But either way, I highly recommend those games despite their clunky controls. 💖🎮

D
Dennis James Mcintosh · May 23, 2026

Jimmie, what kind of work did you do for APS?

N
Natalie Bland · May 23, 2026

I’ve never heard anyone pronounce larynx that way, is that like a southwest or north east thing?

N
Natalie Bland · May 23, 2026

lol I came to this episode directly from watching this week’s episode of Dimension 20, where they are playing Vampire: The Masquerade for the first time

C
CL Perez · May 23, 2026

Lol the part where "putting 3 year old in the closet as a prank", I can confirm is a thing and actually is my earliest memory. I asked my mom "did you guys put me in a closet as a baby." And she said "they thought it was prank you weren't in there long..." long enough to last as a memory into my mid 30s. Now, don't know if it's a better prank, but when my brother was 4 o 5 convinced everyone to ignore him and pretend he wasn't there. Then I sad "I miss him so much. I'm so sad he died. What's that? I can almost hear him stilll..." meanwhile he was crying "I'm here I'm a ghost". He's 21 now, doesn't remember it.

S
Shelly · May 22, 2026

Lived in Farmington for a year, absolute nightmare town. It’s northern New Mexico, why do you have a confederate flag??? So glad they mentioned the nuclear fracking though, that’s the most New Mexico thing ever and I love horrifying people with that.

E
Erica Teofilo · May 22, 2026

Donating plasma is how I ate during undergrad and graduate school!

K
Kevin Whitney · May 22, 2026

PLEASE PLEASE!!!! Do a bonus on operation plowshare!

H
Harold McCleskey · May 22, 2026

I’m a Harold. Love the take on the name!!! 🤣 I go by my given name with much pride

B
Becca Thomas · May 22, 2026

The Christian Power Team actually visited my elementary school several times. They would tour the country and do that. It was crazy.

C
Cathy M · May 22, 2026

Ah ha ha. My dad’s name is Harold (so was my mom’s dad but that’s another story) and he often goes by Hal. And, yeah, he’s 96! Hahahaha

O
OMAR GOBBY · May 22, 2026

...so his larynx is crushed One of the best side rants in STM history

M
Mary B · May 22, 2026

My first car was a blue Ford Aspire that didn’t even have power steering 😂

J
Jocelyn · May 22, 2026

James complaining people correct him amuses me. James comes across as someone who is always right (even when they aren't) and Jimmy comes across as someone who is always wrong (even when he's not). Ive always assumed it's part of the charm of the show and I think they sort of play their characters (which I love) but I doubt this is what they are really like around friends and family.

M
Michelle Areyzaga · May 22, 2026

I live in Farmington, New Hampshire which had a double homicide back in 2017 that you guys should check out to see if it’s worth an episode!! 🙃

R
Rainee Courtnage · May 22, 2026

Larynx, easy. Pharynx Guess what is you dumb comics

N
Natalie Meyer · May 22, 2026

Hey, for the record, I’m gonna be making 140 selling plasma this week. But yeah, I’m poor as shit.

J
Jennifer Brandt · May 22, 2026

It really is larynx as in rhymes with sphinx. I hate hearing it as layrnicks, like how?

D
Don Nelson · May 22, 2026

Exactly. It's LAIR-inks. As bad as exscape and nuculer. Grrr.

D
Don Nelson · May 22, 2026

😂😂 Jimmie thinks having different tires on your car is against the law! 😂

C
Catwoman79 · May 22, 2026

I laughed so fucking hard when James was saying he gets shit for not pronouncing things right but if Jimmy says it wrong we’re like aww he’s trying. 🤣🤣🤣 my boyfriend and I lost it and laughed for at least a good 20 minutes. God I love you guys

R
Rainee Courtnage · May 22, 2026

Jimmie is comedically brilliant. He makes STM work. James and Jimmie, a perfect team

R
RandomDeathMetaller · May 22, 2026

I'm pushing 50 and have been listening to metal/hardcore my whole life... never heard of a single one of those shit bands.

M
Mary (a Catholic in the South) · May 22, 2026

A guy I once stated, pointed out a Ford Aspire in traffic and told me it was called that because it was “aspiring to be a car”… that was 2003 and we’ve been married almost 21 years. Sucker for dumb jokes. 🤣

R
Rainee Courtnage · May 22, 2026

Ship Rock is nowhere near Farminngton!

A
Amanda Bauerschmidt · May 22, 2026

Pollock is a little bitch

T
True Crime Stoner Girl in Phoenix · May 22, 2026

Listening and Jimmie makes a comment about ranch and pizza being a favorite of white girls. When I worked in restaurants, we used to call it “fat girl ketchup “. I’m dead right now

S
Sonix2016 · May 22, 2026

Married to a Navajo. Yes they love metal and ICP

J
Jenu Kertesz · May 22, 2026

This totally brought back memories- I knew a short pudgy kid in HS who got a brand new car for his 16th bday… a white Ford Aspire with a neon pink racing stripe down the side! It was the gayest car in the HS lot. I felt so bad for the guy.

S
Scottmichael Farrey · May 21, 2026

If I were the sole prostitute in a small town, my street name would have to be “Highlander”.

K
Kramer and his Cougar MILF · May 21, 2026

James! - I can say Larynx, but I suuuuuper can't say Exsanguination.... You breezed right through that 🤩 You're also right, though; Jimmie DOES have it too good lol

M
Morgan Mclain · May 21, 2026

Santa Fe prison riot would be a WILD Patreon episode. Some incredibly fucked up shit during.

7
70Boss302 · May 21, 2026

As a New Mexican listener and huge fan, I'm truly conflicted about J&J's feelings about NM. I kinda get it, but if only they could see the gorgeous places up north. Still a huge fan and an Albuquerque Turkey! 😍btw-Jimmie is 100% correct-many many Native Americans love metal 🤘they pack the place!

T
Tony Legg · May 21, 2026

Epic and memorable episode guys. Well done.

7
70Boss302 · May 21, 2026

How were his parents not charged?? At the very least with obstructing justice for taking their blood-soaked son home to clean up. They assisted with tampering with a crime scene and helped him and his blood-soaked buddy. WTF?

K
Kellee Green · May 21, 2026

The conversation about Jimmie landing the best job, and other comedians wanting that job -- Jimmie's job (listening to James and reacting) may seem easy, but I think it is deceptively easy. Jimmie is really excellent at knowing where to interject, make a joke, add personal experience, etc. I doubt other comedians could equal him.

T
Tony Legg · May 21, 2026

You could never replicate the chemistry the boys have. It’s perfect

A
Anónimo · May 21, 2026

Jimmy was kind of right. I live in a small town where voluntary firefighting is essential in the fact that if you don’t sign up for so many hours to help/volunteer, then if your place is ever on fire, you have to pay $500 for them to even come to your place if it is on fire. This is when you first buy property you sign up and if you’re older, you can help with cleanup efforts, or providing food, working in the office doing paperwork for after a fire. Etc.

K
Kristen Merek · May 21, 2026

Love y’all but it is WILD to claim that everyone pronounces larynx wrong. 🤣 The convo about it was hysterical!

E
Erika Fultz · May 22, 2026

I've heard it on tv and in podcasts and it makes me cringe because lair-inks is phonetic.

C
Cara Butcher · May 21, 2026

Can’t wait to see you guys in Buffalo next week! Driving home from a Philly to treat my bestie for her birthday 💁🏼‍♀️

M
Makayla · May 21, 2026

I had to pause and turn on Netflix when I heard James talk shit about Jimmie's old job 💀 I needed to see his reaction

D
Dennis James Mcintosh · May 21, 2026

We sold plasma back in the 1970s. Used the money for a keg and had a “blood bash.” Jackson Mississippi, 1973—77.

J
Jane Blackbird · May 24, 2026

It was a great way to get beer money! 🍺 San Diego late 70’s-early 80’s 🩸

D
Dean Burns · May 21, 2026

anything happens to either of you... shows over. RIP COMICSTORIAN

S
Smalls (smallenoughtofit) · May 21, 2026

James: how did you work it so everyone thinks you know nothing and I know everything? Jimmie "Puhmella" Whisman: I have no idea

J
Jenna Augustine Atwater · May 21, 2026

I started an all New Mexico relisten yesterday. Jimmie's rage hatred of that state feeds my soul 😆 🤣

S
Samuel Katz · May 21, 2026

I’m only 40 minutes in, but I feel like I’ve heard this story before about some loser who tells fibs all the time hahaha. They’ve definitely had another murderer who did this. I predict he’s going to kill someone later in the episode.

E
Em · May 21, 2026

Looking for a particular pole?! Come on! The jokes write themselves 🤣😂 Love you guys ❤️

J
JB · May 21, 2026

Jimmie thinks there's a draft for firefighters

J
Jenna Augustine Atwater · May 21, 2026

😆 🤣 😂

E
Em · May 21, 2026

I've got some twin mounds for ya! Hey yo!!!

J
Jessica Bohn · May 21, 2026

I could've sworn they covered the Vampire: The Masquerade murders 😅 but I guess that was LPOTL.

J
Jenna Augustine Atwater · May 21, 2026

No you're totally right! It was a creepy teenage cult leader with a molester mom in Florida or Georgia I think

K
Kramer and his Cougar MILF · May 21, 2026

Royal Oak, MI, May 30th @ 7pm. I have ONE TICKET FOR SALE - On the floor, section A Right, Row G, second seat in from the center right aisle (I'm keeping the aisle seat 😁)... WHO WANTS IT?

A
Andrew Johnson · May 21, 2026

My grandpa was part of the underground nuclear fracking test! He said the fracking part went great, just all the product was too irradiated to use...

r
regular_sized_mom · May 21, 2026

Lol. I need to send you guys a few sets of dice.

J
Jenna Augustine Atwater · May 21, 2026

TTRP represent! 😆

A
Auntie Andie · May 21, 2026

After telling a friend of mine who still works for APS (after 10 years), they also agree that APS can suck a dick. I told them to listen to the first few minutes of the show where Jimmie describes the PITA it was to work in Farmington.

F
Full of BS · May 21, 2026

oh my goodness gracious! i didn't even know that Jimmie was a lineman. holy 💩! arms like that AND a lineman?!?!?!?! 💦🪭🔥 lord help me! 😆

J
Jim L · May 21, 2026

What are you, a comedian?

P
Pepper Kepper · May 21, 2026

A navy whale 😂💀

C
Caroline Thomas · May 21, 2026

I’ve had 3 different tires on my car before. Can confirm: Definitely poor people activity. 🫣🤷🏼‍♀️

L
LaTanya · May 21, 2026

James, 20:36, I cringed and then you said something about it and it made me feel so much better

J
Jessica Schafer · May 21, 2026

Im surprised jimmie is surprised there's alot of poaching. From my experience around reservations, its a common practice. I saw it happen with my own eyes with an elk in Montana lol

D
Dorothyann · May 21, 2026

When all of your kids call you Kori and say that you should spend the rest of your life in prison, who cares what a priest says. 🤦‍♀️

D
Dorothyann · May 21, 2026

I look forward to that Patreon with the alien activity in New Mexico.

S
Steven Sanchez · May 21, 2026

I'm listening as I drive through Farmington!

S
Samuel Katz · May 21, 2026

There’s actually a trick behind ripping the phone book in half

S
Sir Chuckwagon · May 21, 2026

This is the funniest episode I remember in a while, just the guys making each other laugh, love that

R
Rachel · May 21, 2026

“This cabinet is bullshit” lol.

K
KnotStock · May 21, 2026

You missed the opportunity to do North Dakota... since this is episode 701 😹

S
Sir Chuckwagon · May 21, 2026

They got us a few weeks ago, we’re not due for another 220 episodes or so. 701 represent!

M
Mary · May 21, 2026

Now these things all sound like the hardcore band names, Still Bloody Knife and Bloody Sledgehammer

M
Meg C. · May 21, 2026

I cannot stop laughing about Jimmie thinking firefighting was compulsory in small towns 😭

S
Sir Chuckwagon · May 21, 2026

I thought they were trying to reboot Abbot and Costello’s “Who’s on first” because James didn’t want to accept what Jimmie was trying to ask

L
Laurel Fay · May 21, 2026

YAAAAAAAAYYYY!