Replacing a rear-view mirror with a screen isn't recommended
I also made a review of a rear-view mirror dash-cam this week.
In the video I explain why you probably shouldn’t buy a rear-view mirror dash-cam.
So that’ll generate lots of affiliated sales revenue.
On reflection, rear-view mirror LCD screen Dash-cams probably aren't worth looking into (YouTube)
Comments (40)
It probably will generate affiliated revenue but for the Viofo. Come next pension day (Saturday - woohoo ;-) I'll buy one from your link, just on your say-so and the brief sample you posted from that camera. Looks excellent.
I’ve just updated the firmware on my A129 to V 1.8 - it was only on 1.3. I also added the CPL filter and Bluetooth remote. I’d definitely recommend getting the remote - very handy.
For whatever it's worth, I bought a Ghost X helmet cam from your affiliate link and I've been very happy with it.
I’m still happy with mine too.
Good video once again. I love these mini reviews. You seem to have made an error in calculating the space required for 1 minute of recording for both cameras. The two numbers don't add up to what is stated in the video. It should be 142, not 146?
Yep - can’t change it now though and no point crying over spilt milk. What’s past is past - it’s the future we can change.
DEAR SIR, I WAS DISGUSTED AT YOR USE OF THE PHRASE 'LCD DISPLAY'. FOR A MOMENT I THOUGHT I WAS WATCHING THE THIRD CHANNEL AND NOT THAT ESTEEMED ORGAN OF RESPECTABILITY MSSRS. TECHMOAN. IN FUTURE I HOPE WE CAN LOOK FORWARD TO THE CORRECT PHRASIOLOGY OR WE ALL MIGHT AS WELL NOT BOTHER WITH ANYTHING EVER. THIS COUNTRY ETC... YOURS ETC... MRS TRELLIS, THE GLEBE, ORPINGTON.
Get stuffed. I hope that’s sarcasm
Now I imagine driving with that camera running and having that wasp (or any other bug) crawl on the rear lens and scare the crap out of you...lol
Thanks for the great video, Matt. We bought a similar unit, but the rear camera is just a little inset window on the right 1/4 of the mirror. The big complaint we have is that the touch-screen starts selecting random functions within a few minutes of a trip. We figure it might be due to drastic temperature changes of getting in a hot/cold car and starting the A/C or heat. The manufacturer sent a replacement and it does the same thing. For the other car, we were considering the aukey, but the fact you've been using the A129 for a year is a huge endorsement. Your reviews are some of the best on YouTube, and you'll never seen a nitpicky comment from me. Thanks for all your hard work!
I'm guessing the auto manufacturers won't be including full dashcams in their cars mostly because of different laws in each country. Where I live (Greece) the legality of even having a dashcam is very much in the gray. I'm guessing it's the same in other countries (most notably Germany with its very strict privacy laws).
I’m not looking for it to be standard fit - just an option like a heated steering wheel or sat nav.
I kind of want to like devices like that, because they seem like a neat idea. But they just seem to fail on the "actually being practical" level.
Great video! And it was a bit disappointing as well; I have hoped for better results from the unit you tested. But of course I'm thankful that you gave us the facts without unnecessary praise. Let us stick to the facts, as you do! After seeing this video, I would be interested in learning more about the factory installed camera-driven mirrors that some new cars have today. Are they better than the one you tested? Surely they must be! Let us know! :-) /Greetings from Sven in Sweden
I’m interested in the electronic side mirrors on the upcoming Honda e - I think they’re a great idea as that car would fit though my garage door while most new ones wouldn’t (even with the mirrors folded) - I’ve got to imagine Honda have done it right.
Interesting to compare this with the recent Fully Charged video which shows a new Honda that has small cameras instead of door mirrors. The screens are positioned on either side of the driver, but inside the car. One benefit is reducing the drag caused by external mirrors. Honda's implementation shows that the idea could be a sound one. Anyway I'd hate for this or my earlier remark to be perceived as negative. This is a good example of a successful video even if the object itself isn't an unmitigated success.
I don't know how legal that's going to be the the UK. At the end of the day there's no real requirement for a rear view mirror- my campervan doesn't have one, for example. Wing mirrors, however, are more important and a legal requirement. I wouldn't be surprised if honda has to swap/add/alter those mirrors for the UK.
Thank you for the as always great video. Thanks for pointing out about the vibration. That alone would be a deal breaker for me. Looking at buying a 2019 Subaru Ascent. It has a similar device factory installed. It would be good to have if you had an suv full of stuff. And hopefully being factory installed it would perform better.
Just like sat-nav - manufacturer-fit might be more expensive, but is much more convenient. I’d tick the option every time.
I appreciate this because it satisfies my curiosity about the thing without wasting my own money on it. Unlucky that you haven't chanced on something that you can wholeheartedly recommend.
I always root for everything I test as when it fails it means I lose too.
Seeing you in sunglasses made me wonder if using the mirror as a screen would be a problem with polarised sunglasses. I’ve had problems seeing cars instruments with sunglasses on due to the polarisation of the LCDs in the car. I could imagine that a ‘mirror’ like this would appear black at certain angles.
They’re prescription lenses that react to UV light - when the roof is closed the UV light doesn’t penetrate the cabin and the lenses stay clear.
Nitpick: refresh rate isn't lag, it's how many frames per second it has
No it’s definitely refresh rate - I’m looking at a live feed. It would need to be 120hz to be anything other than distracting.
Just out of curiosity, In the shot where you were talking while driving through the traffic lights, why was the image in normal orientation rather than a mirror image? Is that something you did in editing? I assume that a rear-view camera will present a mirror image on the in-car display screen. (Yes and just now I looked at the reverse camera in my own car's dashboard screen and confirmed it shows a mirror image).
It records normally but displays live as a normal mirror image. - I think that might be switchable though - but it’s really not a camera worth considering.
Just add it as a second rearview mirror. Problem solved.
I recently had a run-in with a city bus, the crazy driver tried to push me off the road just before the train station. After that incident I vowed that I would get a front and back dash cam so I'd at least have evidence for the police. So I'd like to know what my options are. If you have a setup that works well, I'd like to know.
Well the A129 works well for me. The only slight issue I have is that it beeps once randomly every now and then - but they’ve probably ironed that out by now.
You don't have to do an entire video, just tell us what your top 1 or 2 or 3 favorite dashcams are as of 2019, if price is not a big concern (since even the most expensive dashcams are pretty low cost, especially if you consider the benefit of easily winning an insurance claim)
I think you buried the lead at the end there when you mention that it's time for this tech to become standard in car manufacturing. I think that is THE major reason for not going aftermarket with these products. It's a bit like when I had a cell phone AND a GPS device AND an iPod AND a digital camera! My urban adventures required a satchel of soon-to-be obsolete tech, even though the tech was in the vanguard at the time.
I have an Autovox X2 in my Smart Roadster Coupe, a very similar camera. As you'll know from experience, as soon as you put anything substantial in the back it blocks the rear view and this really does help for the kind of driving I do. It does have a case of the shakes as the mirror mounting in the Roadster isn't very solid, I need to work on this and have an idea involving R/C car dampers... For normal cars though I agree that the mirror is largely pointless but the rear camera is worth having.
Great stuff! I really like your product reviews and am sporting the Aukey dashcam you previously recommended in my MINI based on that review. Great camera system, but I'm curious what about your current one did you like better. Worth switching?
It’s not worth switching - but it is a bit sharper on the rear camera and has a Bluetooth remote and can accommodate a CPL.
Thanks Mat. I would be interested to see the current camera you use reviewed.
Me, too. If Mat's been using it for a year, it must be good.
I double Czeched, but indeed It has two Czech points.
Lol! Saw that.
With a lead-in like that, I can't wait to watch the clip! :-D
