Extremely Overdetermined Adventure Game Tier List: Viewer's Manual

I love this system to bits, cant wait till there's more. Is it cool if I just yoink this for myself (making some changes that suit my purposes) and post my version on some forum?

Full Throttle deserves so much more attention. I’ll admit my “sugar” badge on that game is bordering on type 2 diabetic, but I can firmly say every frame of that Mac OS9 point and click has earned it’s permanent tax on my brain

I'm not much of an adventure game guy anymore, but what about Sam and Max Hit the Road? It's almost as good as Day of the Tentacle and much better (IMHO) than Full Throttle or Grim Fandango (or maybe I'm just biased towards more open world feeling games :)

The overall rating system which accounts for the unexpected delight that a game can give is a really nice touch.

Overdetermined bordering on fussy, but I like it!

Parsing the math of this is almost as interesting as the actual review.

i love this and i am *totally* applying this system to albums on rateyourmusic.

Oh my