Premium Episode 225: Witch Tok
There is a world that blends ancient arcane arts and algorithm-powered short form video content. That world is "Witch Tok," the community of self-described witches and other supposed wielders of magic who discuss the secrets of their craft on Tik Tok. Liv dives into Witch Tok to reveal how 21st century witches are leveraging social media to swap spells, hawk merch, and engage in occasional infighting. We also discover how christian media is reacting the popularity of online witches and continuing the centuries-old feud between protestants and those they accuse of being occultist devil worshippers.
Thanks for supporting us on patreon!
Music by Pontus Berghe. Editing by Corey Klotz.
Comments (126)
loved listening to this while polishing my rocks
That one Witchtoker seems like a big Dennis Leary fan
All my friends talk about shadow work but I cannot do anything witchy because I have OCD and it would simply become an extension of my mental illness
Turns out Jenny the ex-witch, reformed lesbian, wasn't necessarily a pathological liar... https://youtu.be/LUi11Cz4ZUg?si=M9lQJIuIBSew9gt2
I think the “red magic” existing as a discipline between white and black magic thing is actually from…fucking final fantasy games lol.
This basic witch person makes me furious
It feels like witch tok figured out how to turn witchcraft into protestantism.
Jenny is the most annoying customer that enters into my tattoo shop and tells me how much the tattoo should cost,how long it will take and that her 7 year old Christian Rapper child will look great with it, all while eating a bag of ketchup chips and licking the msg off her fingers. I’m currently putting my best fucking banishment spell on that b@✝️💰h
Jenny is the most annoying client that comes into my tattoo shop and a. tells me the tattoo will only take ten minutes b. How much it should cost c.
In response to Jake's confusion at the contrast between the Wielding of Grand Cosmic Forces and the mundanity of the results (getting your crush to notice you) being a novel phenomenon, I don't think I agree. I believe historically, what has been framed as witchcraft/magic in all cultures often concerned profoundly mundane thing, witches were midwives, they could hex or bless your crops, they even made magical viagra and stuff. It's probably a pop cultural contemporary idea of magic that it has to be about summoning hordes of zombies and casting fireballs, in most cultures, it's more concerned with edging the chaos of the world slightly in your favour, and in that, WitchTok seems to be a pretty logical continuation of this literal magical thinking. Great ep though!
I appreciate that the most powerful witch on tiktok is a fan of Twin Peaks
I grew up in a Wiccan church and this episode was really interesting to me! To me a big part of Wicca was community and worshipping with others. We had wheel-of-the-year celebrations and rituals, and full moon gatherings, but "spell casting" wasn't a big part of it, really. Love spells were basically verboten. Witch Tok seems, like so many other pastimes in our modern world, to focus on the comodification and individualization of the practice - you can have a parasocial relationship with this influencer and buy their product in place of community. Thanks Luv for this great deep dive!
How is this someone one of the most dystopian episodes... HOW?!
As both a Luddite (especially with regards to TikTok) and a loose practitioner of witchcraft (I have an altar to bast where I mostly just pray to/thank the spirits of cats I have known, plus I try to light candles or bonfires on Halloween and solstices with some vague intention of reverence for nature etc), this episode was very enjoyable for me. I’m glad jake got offended by the flippancy and marketization of these TikTok practices, i felt seen in these moments lol
How do these people square their spellcasting with the notion of free will? Do they not believe in free will?
Do YOU believe in free will? Much of the scientific community does not, though there is plenty of argument re: the extent to which determinism is true.
Oh no, Supernatural and it's hunky main characters has birthed an entire generation of good witch wannabes, aahhh
Where are the spells that make rich people suddenly want to use all their wealth to truly end poverty and hunger?
FWIW, the song (“I kissed a girl”) that Jenny Weaver referenced as turning her gay was the 1995 song by Jill Sobule, not the later Katy Perry song. Which means her timeline holds up and her story must be true.
Tangentially, a much better song on that same 1995 Sobule album is Vrbana Bridge, which is about the siege of Sarajevo, of all things. Always makes for a good cry.
Omg Jake your impressions are fucking lit 🤣🤣🤣
also i literally had a witchtok-pilled coworker who had already gone deep down that rabbit hole by the time they joined the crew. they had so many different gods and demons and custom spells, and they'd talk about how they were involved in these bizarre dramas with this collection of otherwise unrelated deities. like they'd talk about how loki was asking them for dating advice or how they snubbed zeus' invitation to dream-olympus or whatever to go make out with set and it was absolutely baffling to me (i study early-modern european occultism as a hobby) and my other coworker (a practicing wiccan). it sounded like an age of mythology campaign lmao i ultimately feel kind of bad for them, because they were massively insecure and ended up immediately alienating all of us with their *constant* attempts to just tell blatantly absurd lies to make them seem more interesting. they'd monopolize conversations with (completely bullshit) stories about their own life, oftentimes while they were talking to (now obviously miserable) customers. this was a 26-year-old master of psychology lying about drinking 10 four-loko when they were 12 and "getting a really bad hangover." just really pathetic tbh. they were also the only coworker i know to have been fired due to poor performance before they could quit to escape the unapologetic sexual harassment from the owner (woooo), but that's a completely different, much more grotesque story. they actually kept their job for as long as they did because they were expertly leading him on, which, lowkey, mad respect to you chibi
That's not an Irish accent, Jake. It sounds like English West Midlands l, so Birmingham, Wolverhampton way. Not considered to be a particularly pleasant accent. I grew up doing spells, I have a lot of crystals & I will do some 'spells' because I feel it is quite cathartic in some way. For example writing a certain problem on some paper and throwing it into a river or sea. Helps you mentally let it go. I do find this witchtoc trend quite hard to stomach sometimes. Please Liv, look at ancient aliens & pseudo-archaeology.
How dare you, there's a difference between Brummie and Yammy and both are Gods Own Tongue. I think she's Yammy, slightly softer then a Birmingham accent.
The tiktok videos are soooooo fucking cringe BUT I do love me some Dean Winchester and idc ✨💅🏻🔮
Having been on the witch/wicca message boards in the early days of the internet, it is interesting to see how witchcraft is having a revival on social media and how the “fluff” is still around and stronger than ever lol. I think aesthetic witchcraft like witchtok is harmless fun and offers solutions for people who want some control over their lives in a hectic world, but it is funny to hear these clout chasers talk about spells so seriously given that they sound like they are lifted from Teen Witch by Silver RavenWolf or Hollywood (eg Practical Magic) — back to aesthetics, I guess. At best, the rituals help, and at worst, it funnels people into woo-woo scams; so the harsh criticisms here are warranted imo. And GREAT point made about how flippantly they call upon gods for petty wrongs.
Loki is from Norse mythology.. not made up for marvel movies..
That’s the joke
i love Basic Witch Shit has anyone made a movie about Tiktok witches accidently summoning Eldritch horrors yet
I kind of love the Basic Witch shit too. I loved the stuff that they were complaining about the whole time, TikTok girls talking flippantly about witch shit. Maybe it's because accusations of witchcraft have been tangled up in misogyny historically, so, in a way...it's a way of defanging it. A sign that things have changed enough that it's gone from something that could literally get us killed just for not being conformist enough to more of a basic white girl aesthetic.
"If you utilize set design properly, you can tap into the spiritual world." that's literally just feng shui, jake
Gotta be honest, the tone here reminds me of the more unpleasant side of r/atheism and it's kinda disappointing. I get y'all have been staring down the barrel of the absurd for a long time with this show, so it's easy to fall into seeing every fringe belief system with a cynical lense. But y'all might want to step back for a bit and get some perspective. Going to tiktok to get the bead on what a community is like or believes is kind of silly, because it's an inherently silly place. And while Witchcraft isn't necessarily a religious or spiritual practice, many religious groups utilize magic or ritual in their practices and theres a lot of overlap between those communities. There's a lot of different new religious movements that fall under a shared umbrella here and while y'all might not share the same views on them or think they're silly, writing off their spiritual practices or beliefs is kinda distasteful. There's plenty of genuine criticism to be made of these communities - like white people hijacking practices from cultures closed to them. But yea, this episode was kind of a bummer and I hope y'all approach these things with a little more compassion or nuance in the future, because I know you can.
Yeah I don't get why this bothered them more than the actual harmful stuff Christian communities are doing all the time. I've yet to see anyone into witchcraft trying to legislate my rights away as a black person and a woman but I see plenty of white Christian men advocating for that daily. Also that witchtok debunker was such a worthless PoS. Why isn't he debunking the miracles if the mega churches that are scamming people out of millions everyday? At least when a witch sells you crystal you get the fucking crystal.
When Jake tries to relate to Liv through very American holidays like Fourth of July 🥲
Oh man, kinda sad about this one. I think you would find a similar distaste for the aesthetic-driven WitchTok crowd if you look at other Witch groups (Facebook, Instagram, podcasts, etc). Idk where I fall but there are so many folks who believe hardcore in "use what you have" over the aesthetics. This is such a narrow group within Witchcraft. Everyone is a little different but my belief is that there is a lot of benefit that comes from focusing yourself on a goal through creating a ritual/spell. When it comes to cards I think there is a lot of benefit for pulling a "random" perspective to contemplate on a given situation. Guess this is my pilled thing.
I'm a pretty classically anti-woo-woo guy as a result of growing up in one of the woo-iest towns in north america, but i've always run in alternative/radical/experimental circles and was always pretty dismissive of spells and divination and what not despite being constantly surrounded by friends and acquaintances who were into it, I viewed it as harmless but corny consumerist self-help at best and potentially a dangerous rabbit hole at worst. Then last year I accidentally took 10-15 hits of acid and spent 8 hours staring at a tarot deck and finally 'got' tarot and magical practices as exactly what you describe. They can be very helpful tools, for focusing intention and promoting clarity through rituals/spells, and also pulling cards is something I straight up do with my co-op business consultancy clients now because, like, no, I don't believe that the cards are a conduit for unlocking my psychic capacity to see the future, but THEY are a very helpful to get a semi-random 'outside perspective' on a specific question or problem in order to break through blockages or get some distance and objectivity.
NEXT TIME ON QAA: Jake discovers that all this time aliens had engineered witchcraft to be real just to "see what happens." Meanwhile Julian threatens to cut out and mail a conspiracist postal worker his own heart, Liv stumbles on a new form of hentai the right claims is turning people Mexican, and Travis has to scramble after accidentally scheduling two dates on the same night. [TV-M, Pizza]
Liv's sojourns into TikTok leave me both befuddled and bemused, amused and amazed. More please.
Why would I sign up for tikt*k when I can just go to the library and talk to the lesbian with too much eyeshadow and a fancy hat to learn about witchcraft? (Any maybe get some free wine)
I shared Jake’s discomfort. I have zero belief in the occult and a lot of cynicism about New Age movements but … if you’re going to invoke the gods show a little bit of respect and reverence or what’s the point. Everyone of these “witches” is the opening scene of a straight to streaming horror movie. A fun episode. Liv’s Loki joke made me laugh out loud on the train.
Classicly beautifully episode of liv bringing us in tune to the reality and jake hurting himself to understand. I get it Jake. I choose to disbelieve.
Jake get at me I want to be friends so bad I’m so lonely
I think that ex witch lady was probably talking about the 1995 Jill Sobule song…
I thought the same thing. I keep forgetting I'm old, but I thought Travis would know it.
Fuck. Now I’m gonna have Witchy Woman by The Eagles stuck in my head for days…
Hmmm… not seeing how this is related to conspiracy. Feeling like you’re just taking a shit on my religion. And don’t get me wrong. I know it’s kooky. I am actually very into science and I don’t expect people to believe the things that I believe. I’m also sure that there’s a lot of vapid, empty promises within the realm of witchcraft on TikTok, (there’s a lot of health and wealth doctrine!) but I don’t think that that sums up all of witchcraft or even all of witchtok. I am a skeptical, reasonable, logical person who has been practicing witchcraft for 20 years. I love this podcast, I have been listening for three years now, every now and then I hear an episode where I just have to quit y’all for a while and eventually I’ll come back to hear about more qanon stuff.
yeah. it's giving like "i'm smarter than you atheist" which is my least fave lefty vibe. i'm not a witch/pagan/etc, but there's very little recognition of how history, race, culture, etc intersect with witchtok. idk. i couldn't finish it
These sweet summer children should watch the deeply profound BOB'S BURGERS episode where Tina thinks she became a witch by wanting it.
It's easier to imagine demons destroying your life than capitalism destroying your life
Supernatural rocks!
This takes me back to being a teen obsessed with The Mists of Avalon.
I can’t even reread Mists of Avalon now that I know how fucked up the author was. 😩
I was not prepared for the emotions I felt when hearing TikTok witches scold people for believing in lies on the internet
I love these kinds of episodes
So what I've learnt is we should ban TikTok. Just get rid of it.
Pretty sure Mystic Manson's accent is English, probably from the Midlands, not Irish.
Yeah she has a Birmingham accent.
Don’t think I didn’t notice you released this on a Pisces Full Moon 🧙🏽♀️🪄
All of this seems like just another thread of young people inventing worlds of pure fiction and investing themselves entirely within them, because the real world is too bleak and alienating to contemplate doing that with. Who's hyped for Starfield, anyway?
Ugh, the way the hosts were talking about the film The VVitch is such a male perspective!
This was so good! I am such a Liv fan!
Liv points out, it’s anyone who claims to be an expert. Doesn’t that sum up where we are in America right now? 😂
I’ll gladly let Liv know that my witch friend collects her ingredients from the woods. Also, it’s fun to hear everyone turn into those studies that say younger left wing media is propaganda and it just happens to be the ones that say naughty words.
Also, the Horned God in Neopagan tradition is based at least somewhat on Cernunnos, an antlered deity depicted in actual pre-Christian Celtic iconography. I dont buy the whole "survival not revival" bit, but it's not just backformed from the Christian devil.
That may be true, but it doesn't mean that claims about worship of a Horned God during historical witch panics had any basis in real mythology or religious practices. They were almost certainly just attempts to portray the accused as Satanists.
Jake has clearly never been a teenage girl, lol.
Liv! Jake! I will subscribe to a new spooky show talk Patreon if I can listen to you two review every episode of Supernatural! I know y’all are busy but damn it would be great! 🖤🐐🖤
Your Black Phillip emojis made me chuckle 😂
Dear WitchTok: I've vomited eels every Thursday ever since I swindled a wizened crone. Please help!
I knew the Katy Perry thing was dubious because that "kid" would not have remebered the Ellen thing.
These are all Christians. I think they find their own religion boring so they created Christianity with witchy stuff.
Jake slowly losing his mind as the episode went further and further along was just the best
You guys should look into this shadow wizard money gang I have been hearing about. They love casting spells
Oooh, I love that closing song. My girlfriend is pretty into stuff in the same vein as witch tok, but I'm pretty sure it's mostly the aesthetic, and we spend a ton of time out in the woods lol. She's a totally normal person though. ..UNLESS she's just so powerful that she's been able to convince me that she's normal 😳 😂
I'm fairly familiar with Witch Tok and other stupid stuff like this on TikTok. It's just amazing how people try to fill the holes in their lives.
Curious if anyone agrees The Witch would've been so much better if the identity of the witch would've been left ambiguous until the end. Felt like I couldn't sympathize with the family's paranoia because I knew none of them were it.
I don't think the film's intention was to make the family sympathetic at all. There's an underlying metaphor of coming-of-age female liberation it appears to be working from.
Afghanistan… a snake eating itself… shouts out blowback s4
I enjoyed this ep a lot. Much like many other QAA topics, I knew nothing going in to it but I wasn’t left with existential dread after it was over. More of a “haha they’re wacky” vibe. 👌🏼
Which do you prefer, dear listener? This week you have your choice of listening to both Julian and Jake suffer psychotic breaks in real time from exposure to niche social media influencers
I really enjoyed Turning Red, it was actually quite an interesting cultural moment. Discussed overbearing parents, and the Red Panda is an allegory for female puberty, menstruation in particular. All in a Disney film, aimed at young girls. Pretty groundbreaking tbh.
Maybe don't watch it on psychedelics like I did though.
I live in Salem, ma.. I've also dated people who did.. magic. Some of my employees and people I work with are "witches". It all seems like it's people who don't feel like they have control over a lot in life and this is how they cope. It's obnoxious and stupid.
The same can, has and will be said about pretty much every religion, superstition, and ritualistic tradition.
When I was in HS through my early 20s I was all about Wicca and astrology and magic and tarot. But I didn’t turn to Christianity. I was in a place where I started questioning ALLL my beliefs, and then also how the brain works which I found so much more fascinating. But there’s not as much money being an ex-witch to skeptic/science enthusiast. But it’s kind of frustrating to see how popular it is now, especially all the accoutrements and aesthetically witchy clothes, I would have loved to have all this stuff! Little bottles and candles and magical cards and scrolls and crystals! I did have special stones and other objects that were given to me or that I created myself. Sometimes I wish I still believed in it all, to feel like there is some universal divine presence that talks to me through tarot cards and circumstantial signs. And it’s always these asshole guys trying to debunk shit. It’s not like it’s going to work, anyway. Suddenly these girls see this douche shitting all over their practices and are like “oh yeah he’s right!”
I had a similar experience but I took a sketchy detour into Christianity. I loved perusing those old witchy stores back in the day though! they had the coolest old ladies working in them.
Not Irish Jake, sounds more Midlands-y to me
Very Birmingham
Granted I had never heard of this trend until this podcast, but I personally quite enjoy the casual irreverence of these WitchTokers. There's an urban fantasy style modern mundanity to the way they talk that I find less annoying than if they were to actually LARP with costumes and use more esoteric language and imbue it with a religious god-fearing fervour. The way witch aesthetics are played with time and again across all sorts of different media is really fascinating to me, especially as a means of self-discovery for teenage girls, and I'm here for this iteration of it tbh. The Percy Jackson/Marvel movie level knowledge of mythology and obsession with Supernatural are cherries on top. I know there are probably branches and aspects to it that are more worrying, as well as it acting as a potential gateway to more harmful rhetoric, and doubtless there's a whole host of toxic interpersonal drama between all these influencers, but there are worse things in the world than people who hoard glass jars and are scared of their crushes leaving them on read.
Who do these TikTok witches think they are? Gordon Ramsey? "Take the ****ing frog and toss it in the ****ing cauldron, stir the ****ing thing and make your ****ing potion, got it? You ******!!!
I definitely read that in Gordon Ramsey's voice
According to BBC, videos with the pound sign "Witch Tok" have over 20 billion views. The astute reader may note that that is, uh, more people than exist on Earth. So 1 of 2 things is possible: either viewers are watching these videos millions of times each, or these witchcraft channels have hosts of automated accounts (bots) to artificially inflate their channels viewership. Personally, I like to think it's the former.
they are just manifesting good vibes and having spirits watch their videos
As a German, when I heard white, black and red magic, I got some realllll bad vibes
I love that one can tell is a Liv episode tu by tjhe cursedness of the title
Jill Sobule sang "I kissed a girl" a decade before
Jill Sobule's song doesn't include the "and I liked it" refrain though, which makes me think she was definitely talking about the Katie Perry song.
Erm, according to Megadeth, it's FIVE magics. Not three. "Give me alchemy, give me wizardry Give me sorcery, thermatology Electricity, magic if you please Master all of these, bring him to his knees I master five magics (x4)" Dave Mustaine reportedly disowned this exquisite poetry when he became a Born Again Christian, because oh boy, that was some serious satanic shit. Thermatology sounds like a spa treatment. Oh wait, it kind of is!
The “OK!” Bugs me more than the fucks
This is great, I practice magic, and y’all really nailed it. Going out and getting your own stuff, or growing your own herbs, is one of the best part of putting a little spell together. And the whole thing is completely vibes based.
BTW I was waiting for Jake to realise the 'too casual tiktok playing with old gods fucking around and finding out' would be a great start to a Jake story or horror script. We missed out.
Foraging for cool stuff in the woods is great until you end up with a 8cm live worm pulled out of your brain.
When I was about 22 my then boyfriend gave me a book about modern Wicca/witchcraft. I read it, thought it was cool, decided I wanted to be a witch too and began collecting things. A book of shadows, crystals, candles, herbs and reams and reams of writing and spells. This was probably the peak of my “spiritual” discovery journey. At some point fairly soon thereafter I realised that since I didn’t believe in the Christian god, I couldn’t believe in any of the pantheon of Wiccan gods and goddesses witches were supposed to follow either, and dropped it like it was hot. I still rather enjoy the aesthetic of it, crystals are nice to look and play with, candles are cool and oils make my house smell nice, but the spiritual aspect and “manifesting” so the universe gives you stuff? Nah. Get a job and buy the things you want like everyone else has to. I’ve since dropped woo woo of any kind.
Similar journey, and same about the aesthetic and the woo. It does make me the odd one out in some friend groups, trying desperately to find something else to talk about besides mercury in frikkin retrograde
Please put “Not cursed, just a fuck up” on my tombstone
I read that wrong. I read it as, “just fuck on my tombstone.” Whoops
Wow she don't know about Deans witch-killing bullets.
God I love Liv's episodes. She scratches the itch for my internet niche communities.
At one point Jake sounded like he was so close to pulling out his fire wand and yelling "am I the only one around here who gives a shit about the magic rules?!"
I've certainly never heard of red magic being blood magic. It's either a mixed-use caster with one-handed melee weapons, or the D&D Red mages of Thay.
I love an episode where Julian loses it followed by an episode where Jake loses it well done Annie Kelly and Liv
this was so much more fun than Julian losing it :(
From the wiki entry on hoodoo: “The appropriation of hoodoo is based on ignorance about African-American cultural history and hoodoo's ties to black people”
For the utterly non-woo listener: when looking at internet trends it is important to remember how much of what you may see predates the internet and internet culture
Sabina Magliocco's book *Witching Culture* is a great resource on the culture of contemporary witchcraft.
Anyone remember the early internet days, where old school witches posted stuff how not to be a poser fluffy bunny Wiccan? How far we’ve come lol.
I remember those days oh so well! 😆
Witchtok seems like what Charles Cosimano would be like as a teenage girl.
Practitioner and chaote reporting in: witchtok sucks
The whole hexxing of the moon was the first time I became aware of this subculture. It's both fascinating and incredibly funny. No hate to any witches out there, just the mindless tiktok clout chasers.
YAY!! 🔮 I was JUST thinking about the moon hexing girlies, and how much it seems like a background detail from a 90s graphic novel set in 2020s America
“Old” GenX witch here. I purposely avoid posting anything about my practice on the TikTok because it’s honestly inviting all kinds of fuckshittery from other witches. I’m just there for the screaming dramatic huskies and Dylan Hollis to be honest.
My friend kept sending me "spell" tiktoks for money. I think I finally got through to her it's not witching at all. A day in her algorithm would destroy me 😉🌻
I'm so excited, I love hearing about wiccan infighting
Gimme gimme gimme! I'm an atheist who attends ADF Druid Grove events!
Yow!
