Manclan Episode 10: Womanclan (Just Pearly Things)
Raised by the youtube manosphere, a new female generation of anti-feminist influencers are rising to internet prominence, exemplified by Hannah Pearl Davis AKA JustPearlyThings.
This series was brought to you by the QAA podcast. Thanks for supporting us on patreon!
Cover art by Jess Johnson (http://instagram.com/flesh_dozer)
Theme & music by Nick Sena (http://nicksenamusic.com). Editing by Corey Clotz.
Comments (138)
I can fix her
WTF happened to Pearl? I agree with Julian. She's one of 10 children. She's fucking nuts.
Money!
Wow Pearl is stark raving bonkers. She doesnt sound like she even believes what she is saying 😵
This is the most maddening and sad episode of man clan. That pearl woman has the worst case of internalized misogyny I’ve ever seen. Not to mention she’s the definition of my ignorance is as good as your knowledge. Truly sad and infuriating.
I binged the whole of Manclan (was a bit much for one go, even for a hardened peeker into the dark side like me) and still wasn't prepared for this episode. Great series!
Why on earth is Pearl so obsessed with purity and virginity? She herself is neither. The self loathing is unparalleled and she really should just find a cave to live with the rest of the troglodytes.
In America almost all Catholics I’ve met don’t consider themselves Christians, and most Christians don’t consider Catholics to be Christians either. And it doesn’t seem to vary by ethnicity either. Idk the root of this
Theory: Protestantism has ascended to moral and legal authority in the USA. Now they get to be the default. Christian = Protestant = shouting about jesus, guns & babies, and winning exemption from the rule of law via the supreme court. Also, claiming the name of "Christians" also attaches to them a long-ass persecution narrative; they are simultaneously claiming their rightful dominance over morality, culture, and politics whilst crying endlessly about not being allowed to discriminate against the Homosexuals... Catholics are now "other", with historical ties to the Irish and other migrant groups. It now seems convenient to Protestants and many Catholics alike to let the foaming cultists have the title of Christian. Altho it seems now that Catholicism has caught on to the need for religions to evangelize aka actively go out and burn books and beat people over the head with bibles, so. 🤷♀️
Pearl is not only terrible because of... well, all of the reasons. But she's also weirdly uncanny to me because she both looks like and kind of sounds like a horrible Donna from that 70s Show.
Pearl rots my brain because women *make other people*. You wanna do a dumb analysis on gendered contributions to society?? Talk about giving birth. Society wouldn’t exist if not for women, and neither would Pearl ☠️
The low self esteem thing explains so much. Her cheerful nihilism at her own prospects for love or marriage (I know I'm garbage, why bother worrying about it); her abyssal standards for making any sense or actually knowing anything the fuck about which she is talking (ha ha guess I'm shit at logic because woman, anyway I suck shit so who cares if I look dumb on Piers Morgan); her lack of attachment to her own previous viewpoints (welp, comments say I'm a dipshit and I happen to agree, guess I'll just say something safer next time); her need for attention and validation (oh look people click the thing when I talk about how shit women are, that's convenient because I'm a woman and I'm very shit!) It seems like she's found a way to get social approval while talking about how stupid, dumb, useless and slutty she is, by proxy of claiming that all women are those things. To me it indicates more sincerity than I'd ascribed to her previously, which is disturbing. It was easier to think of her as just another grifter. I kind of feel bad for her. Men pay her to talk about what a worthless slut she is, and she doesn't even get to come while doing that.
Yeah, it’s a humiliation kink crossed with deep stupidity.
I've seen and heard clips of her in the past, but this was actually pretty difficult to listen to because of so much of her aggressive stupidity.
I would love to hear some thoughts about the role of the Westboro Baptist Church in establishing the platform for someone like Pearl. I don’t mean ideologically, I mean rhetorically.
I saw someone refer to her as a pick me who doesn't actually want to be picked. Pretty much sums it up.
This makes a lot of sense actually. Even in her earlier content she'd say "I want to be married" rather than "I want to find a husband" or whatever. It's like she wants to "be married" as part of her commitment to her conservatism rather than out of any actual hopes or dreams about her future.
She sooo badly wants to be a Serena Joy but just comes across as a lame edgy teenager. I get more of that vibe from Casey DeSantis than from her.
I feel really torn. On one hand it's like she's deliberately trying to be as hateable as possible and it's working! But on thd other hand she's also kind of tragic and i also feel sorry for her. Her views on relationships reveal she's never experienced romantic love. And her desperate need for attention, even negative, seems to indicate she's never experienced parental love either. She needs like a best friend or a dog or something.
The same can be said for most Manosphere activists or right-wing reactionaries. Like, you know what's better than spewing hatred for money? LITERALLY ANYTHING ELSE.
Pearl sounds amazing honestly. We need to go back to an era where trolls embraced trolling as a way of life rather than just using it as a tool.
This is, this is a sex thing, right? She gets off on this, right?
This was infuriating. This child is the poster child for purely contrarian content creators. (I also listened the the Knowledge Fight episode where she interviewed Alex Jones)
This was not good for my blood pressure, but great work as usual.
Great work- would you be able to add tags so i can find all of the other man clans eps?
I don’t even know if I can listen to this entire episode because this woman is so enraging.
Listening to this really feels like being fascinated with punching yourself in the best way possible
I loved this episode, great work
Ive been pretty resilient to being triggered, but this one broke me. It bent be over and triggered the hell out of me. Which is what they want…damn good episode, love this series
Dang, guess you'll need some triggernometry to measure all that!
So good. So depressing
Guys, I realize that this series will never get the hits that something like “Pearly Things” gets, but it is without a doubt, the best series I have ever listened to. It turned me on to Klaus Theweleit, for one thing, and so many other authors! I cite it to my students all the time and, if y’all can get me the transcripts, I’d be happy to translate it into Portuguese. This is number one, top notch, quality programming. Please consider doing it again. Meanwhile, I am buying Annie’s thesis as soon as she gets it published!
One of the best podcast series I've listened to - and one of the most important. While most podcasts/media wouldn't be able to get past their initial outrage at the people you've studied in Manclan, you both have an incredible ability to withstand insanely high levels of toxic content to examine it through a proper anayltical lense - while still being able to acknowledge and make fun of how fucked it all is. This better not be the end of Manclan!
I don't think I've seen Annie so passively dunking on someone before. Take my money.
had a sudden realization while listening to this as a cooking accompaniment: she’s a weeb, but for men; same pseudo-nostalgic apologia, same secret desire to Be
Or even worse! She’s a “twelve year old commenting on classic rock youtube videos to talk about how this is Real Music and their own generation’s music is all trash”… but for men
Felt I learned everything I needed to know about Davis when you mentioned she's from a very large wealthy family. She's one of those English artistocrats that became a fascist in the 30s basically because they were bored.
the worst, dumbest mitford
Agreed a masterful series. Annie Kelly is a genius. Unfortunately I got way too triggered and sensitive-girl to get through these last 2! But I’m so glad for the series being out there. I got really sad though after seeing some of the subtle and not-so-subtle misogynist comments of (what appears to be mostly male?) patreon listener comments to this episode alone - I don’t normally read them and am now glad I haven’t! Perhaps the underlying misogyny and psychology of this (actually quite common) demographic of men who consider themselves progressive, pro-liberal, intellectual, w/e, listeners-of-QAA (and, much less, specifically Manclan!) types who find no dissonance in displaying aggression towards women they deem the “other” - from sex workers to figures like Melania Trump to random off-the-wall anti-feminist female YouTubers they disagree with - can be the topic of episode 1 of next season. Way more subtle and nuanced; unfortunately still very real. 😊
We do love an acceptable target, and there's a very nasty tendency in a depressingly-large tranche of nominal progressives to find excuses and rationalizations (e.g., "I'm just using an insult that resonates with them!", "it's to show they're hypocrites!", etc.) to bring out normally-veiled bigotry (with very little off-limits) when we're targeting one.
The epistemological catastrophe that is Just Pearly Things is proof beyond metaphysical certitude that the project of human civilization is doomed. Also: Annie & Julian are international treasures.
Annie, this is a masterpiece both in research and presentation, Julian said it well: this woman is a golem born of social media algorithms. An incredible case study in how a fairly normal person's insecurities are weaponized by the internet into a mouthpiece propagating reactionary ideology to millions of people. Excellent last chapter to the Manclan series, thank you.
PS yes the internet is a weapon, please read Surveillance Valley: The Secret Military History of The Internet, by Yasha Levine.
Pearl is obviously out of her mind, but Piers Morgan says a lot of logical (as well as illogical) things on his show. I’m a little disappointed in this finale. I didn’t hear any push back on her point about how the country would basically shut down if all men stopped working. 94% of construction workers are men, 99% of plumbers, 94% of steel workers, 73% of military, 84% of long haul truck drivers, 84% commercial airline pilots…all male. So I get that Pearl deserves to the sh*t being thrown her way, (and lots of it), but it’s obvious men, especially white, heterosexual, “cis” men are the last people you can talk about without having to watch what you say without having the Woke P.C. Police attack you, physically, mentally or emotionally.
that's too bad, a Gallup poll recently projected that by the year 2054 we're all gonna be gay! sorry about your town's economy, that's the first i've heard of a dick sucking factory, it would have been like the next gold rush over there if they had just held out a little longer.
Favorite opening music of any podcast.
Haha it’s my least fav
Thought this was will menaker's girlfriend
God I was with Julian on this one, I can’t stand the way she can’t complete a sentence without interspersing laugh noises…
Has anyone pointed out that Pearl is single...and she is 26 years old. So, by her own logic, she can never be a traditional woman and is going to die an old, shrill crone.
I can't remember who did, but her response was pretty much: Yes, that proves my point about modern society being bad for families. You unfortunately can't use logic against grift/dumbness, it is unflappable.
I'd love to see her debate Matt Dillahunty.
Great episode! Also if anyone is interested Knowledge Fight did an in depth examination of that interview Hannah Pearl Davis did with Alex Jones that was played during the outro: https://knowledgefight.libsyn.com/841-like-a-pearl-before-a-swine
She is smashing the glass ceiling by taking the role of internet troll from the boys. But seriously I hope her brand crashes and burns.
Really wish I could find the clip of her saying “the only reason I can stand to listen to all these people tell me I have no value is because I hate myself” (paraphrasing)
Started this ep sad to be at ep 10 but after listening I need at least a year off from Manclan
Men ARE, notoriously, logical people
Lol! The complaint about how her antisemitic song being misread reminded me of the early “social experiment” assholes like that dumb fuck Sam Pepper. He did a “social experiment” where he grabbed women’s asses in public then tried to say he was making a point about how women are treated in public. These are empty shells who’s ideologies are entirely shaped by AB testing against youtube’s engagement algorithm. 💯 radicalized by the internet.
Everything I see online now is doused in misogyny, if only in the comments. Every video or tiktok of a woman doing anything, every tweet by a woman, the comments will have seething hatred in them. My only hope is that similar to the rampant transphobia, it is the dying rage of those pushing back against social progress.
This is so depressingly true. I recently discovered I have a pituitary condition which causes many symptoms including weight gain. So I have been watching patient stories on youtube. And I can't believe how many times a women makes a video for educational purposes to talk about her medical condition. And some man still feels let to enter the comment section to add some misogynistic fat shaming shit under a medical story!!!!! Of course this never happens on the videos by men with the same condition.
also fucking HATE the bs evopsych. it is literally Not True that men (or anyone else) are biologically predisposed to dislike women who have had sex lol. the concern about paternity developed WAYYYYYY late into human existence with the advent of class society.
"I blew up on TikTok bc my dad bought a giant waterslide" is a very roundabout way to say "I blew up bc I'm rich"
Goddammit I went to her Twitter feed. Just from the last 24 hours - I don’t think they could make a female Elon Musk if they tried !! Our brains aren’t as smart Let's start a gender war!!! Is your house the way your husband likes it or the way you like it?
Good Lord!
The "conversion" thing is important. I noticed this awhile back when listening to podcasts about "Christians" who left their churches. I grew up Catholic and was taught that other Christians were still Christian. I get the impression that many Christofascists view Catholics as "other" and discuss them as such. No one discusses this, but I see it as key to understanding what's happening.
I think this may be why so many Catholics (like Alito, Kavanaugh, etc) throw their lot in with the religious right. They think it’s a broadly Christian movement; but, to the protestant evangelicals who lead it, they’re just useful idiots. Once the revolution’s complete and there are no non-Christians left, papists are going to be the next up against the wall.
Tell me you’ve never had a serious relationship or a job without telling me you’ve never had a serious relationship or a job.
Omg right? 🤣 …I think she surprised even the host with that gem smh
I think the easier answer with her is that she's a fascist who hasn't come out of the closet yet. She says whatever because language is just a way of clowning on the people who try to engage with her nonsense ideas. You don't hang out with Nick Fuentes and write an antisemitic song if you're just among the average pilled idiots. She's on some stronger shit.
THE SONG
If somehow anyone here isn't also a listener of Knowledge Fight, they covered Alex Jones on Pearl's show recently.
I’m putting them on my list today 😎
Is this woman unmarried without kids? I wonder if she lived her opinion with an abusive partner, if she’d still hold this position🤔 I never listen to the man clan episodes because I get too angry. Dunno if I’m going to make it through this whole episode.
🤗 you’re not alone. Weirdly, it’s more painful because she is so completely clueless
This one just totally wrecked me.
Fellow alphas, I am not ready for my favourite podcast to end
😂
Favorite thing about Pearl is her inability to learn how to speak publicly/get an interview voice. She goes on Piers Morgan and sounds like a whiny, incomprehensible troll still lmao
You see, she was listening to Red Scare on 1.5x speed when she was struck by lightning.
This episode hits like a lobotomy.
“They try and tell me the sky is pink but I look up and the sky is still blue” ignoring that sometimes under certain conditions, the sky is indeed pink. Basically summarizes her pov.
Question for Annie & Julian: when researching YouTubers/influencers/content creators/etc, do you find it more enlightening to go back to the start of their content timeline, or work from the newer stuff backwards (to observe the change in attitudes)?
This episode has me thinking of that Norm MacDonald SNL bit where he goes “this might strike some viewers as harsh, but I think everyone involved in this story should die.”
Can any youtubers do a two minute take in one shot? Fuck me the way they cut their sentences together hurts my brain.
I suspect, whether consciously or not, it’s used as gish gallop. Of course for those who are bad making coherent points.
This is cursed. I remember seeing her song on twitter before and I thought she was trolling.
Love how she says "cancelled by the left [lower and faster] and the right"
lol it just means it was a bad idea, and everyone thinks so.
She has the loud obnoxious confidence of someone unburdened with intelligence or self respect.
Annie and Julian, excellent work and you’re both my Sheroes. Can’t wait for S2 but more than that, to sequester myself in the Enby Decompression Tank (that’s what i call my apt now)
Just started but so far I’m making noises like the ones that Julian does when he gets bleeped out :/
I still have 23 horrifying minutes to go BUT I feel a lot of answers lie in the journey from the “big Catholic family” but “converted at 22” to whatever Christian meow meow she’s on now
I was listening to the ep and thinking how this sounds like that chick who interviewed Alex Jones Knowledge Fight went over last week and what do you know…
Indeed ahah. Was a great KF ep.
Still piecing my way through it and I've developed a theory (after looking her up online). This is a girl who was on the wrong side of mean girls in high school. This whole persona is her revenge fantasy being played out on social media. Every insult she dishes out has nothing to do with anyone except maybe three or four specific bullies she's picturing in her head when she says it. And because she's from a wealthy family and has connections, everyone else is being dragged along for the ride.
Maaaan making this episode must have been HARD work. We're only exposed to an edit, but Annie had to watch hours of this hellish cringefest. I just googled Hannah Pearl Davis to look at her face, and it turns out that's something you definitely shouldn't do while on mushrooms. The self-loathing that she radiates... fuck.
Pearl’s sing-songy little girl voice! Annie earned her pay with this one.
Ohhhh I hate this one 😖😖😖 she’s the worst. One day some man she is involved with will give her a black eye and she will claim she deserved it (I hope this doesn’t happen but I wouldn’t be surprised if it does because that’s the kind of man she really wants) 😒
This is painful. She hurts. I hate the fact that I would wish a human out of existence if I could.
This is the most psychic damage I’ve taken from any QAA or Manclan episode so far. I have indeed been both triggered and owned.
I have loved and hated this series the way I love and hate going to the dentist. It's important and I think I'm better for taking care of myself, but the pain, indignity, and confusion are inescapable, no matter what flavor tooth cleaner they offer. But I will miss this series more because my dentist isn't constantly spawning warped little hate-babies and giving them ring lights and an undeserved sense of importance. Give it a year or 2 and let's have season 2! I'll just continue to lust after QAA in the meantime.
Yes, screw Piers Morgan who gives that troll a stage.
She really is just a piece of shit
And on my birthday! Thank you for this gift.
Happy Birthday ! 🥳
Pearl is utterly awful. She reminds me of an old roommate who was also a massive troll who used to get her kicks by doing raids of Jewish areas in Second Life (aging myself here !) in Nazi skins. But I have to say when Pearl started talking about her low self-esteem it made me sad :( She is escaping her own self-loathing by turning it on to other women. Just awful and sad and terrible. The Internet was a mistake.
Ok I just learned two new things I’m going to immediately look up Second Life and Natzi Skins. I swear, I love reading the comments here because people drop things like it’s common knowledge all the time and I’m like … wait, what? 🤔 lol (in a good way, since this little Comments enclave seems to be an insanity free zone 🦄)
Okay, my brains are butter dripping out of my ears now. So perfect episode. I'll try to push them back inside before Season 2.
Words can't express how much I adored this series. I know this was a lot for both of you, but I hope at some point we can see a S2. It's a gift hearing Annie in her zone
Damn skippy 🤣 …I need to listen to Knowledge Fight, I know they no longer put out content on Alex Jones but I’ve heard a lot about them
They do still do Alex Jones stuff!
I am going to miss Manclan like an addict ….I paid to listen to the guys at QAA, but …the women have yet again asserted their superiority.😶 …😁
This is exactly the amazing soul crushing, mind melting content I pay these whores for 🥰 (sorry for calling you guys that. I hated it….) I was actually pretty excited to see this pop up, especially after getting an intro to Pearl on Knowledge Fight
Okay, I am calling for a complete and total shutdown of white women with ukuleles until we can figure out what's going on
The two golden ages of the popularity of the ukulele in the continental US were the Great Depression and the ‘08 Recession. When the economy sucks, people become more interested in smaller and cheaper musical instruments. Of course, the Depression was also the golden age of the harmonica, and Millennials seem to have not latched on to that one for some reason. I would point out, though, that Pearl was playing a guitar while singing her song about the Jews, not a ukulele.
Listening to this in the gym.
Well done but ugh! Decoding the Gurus introduced me to Pearl and I wish I never had heard of this person. I don't think the internet is good for humans.
Decoding the Gurus…ok going on my notepad-of- curiosity lol
very nice outro
She talks like she's always holding back a smirk, and when you see her talk she does indeed appear to be always failing to hold back a smirk: the kinda smirk a child might do if they think they got away with stealing all the chocolate cake the night before. She and JP Sears would make a remarkable couple - (was first introduced to her through F.D Signifier / Signified B Sides: he's recommended leftie content, if that balances out being subjected to pearly things in some way, lol)
Every statement ends with a “Isn’t that wild?” and a wink like she schooled you but definitely knows she pissed you off.
She sounds like Sarah Squirm doing a bit
Oof, the song clinched it. She has no sincerely held beliefs, she just wants to be famous.
YES I have been waiting for the day that Manclan covers Just Pearly Things!
I'd literally never heard of her before last week's "Knowledge Fight" about her (appalling) interview with Alex Jones. Now seeing her in two podcasts in one week. I guess she's coming up in the world.
Per her own logic, why does she think we need to listen to a female YouTuber? Isn’t that taking work away from a male YouTuber, who (according to her) would be better at it anyway?
I love it too! Also love the cover art and Jess Johnson’s stuff! Very very talented! Seems like attracts like
Thanks so much for the series guys I certainly hope you all keep doing a round of extra shows each - you set the bar pretty fuckin high guys I was happy before but I’m certainly satisfied that I’m getting my doughs worth now. Hats off to you and I can’t say fuck yeah enuf about chas
I'm glad I don't have to take this seriously, as a separated woman with kids, but some people who are psychologically more fragile will probably go into serious mental anguish when immersed in this culture. It's amazingly sad. I was just reading about how women in Afghanistan are now committing suicide at extremely high rates because their families are forcing them to marry and stay with violent men out of "honor". That is the end result of such a harmful philosophy.
This is gonna be a frustrating episode I can just tell
What is the opening music track called?? I can't find it anywhere.
On the Dark Side by John Cafferty and the Beaver Brown Band
I hadn't heard of her until Knowledge Fight's epi last week covering her interview with Alex Jones. My god is she dumb! She says women shouldn't vote. Well, someday when she has kids, she can thank women voters when her 8-yr-old isn't sent to work in a factory and get their limbs ripped off.
15 minutes in and I had to turn it off. It's too infuriating.
Fuck yeah! After hearing that knowledge fight episode I just gotta hear more of her.
Her getting absolutely bodied live on camera by Piers Morgan (of all people) for being a raving antisemitie was funny
I am so very excited to listen to this given Knowledge Fight touched on her some because of her AJ interview!
these worlds have so much crossover and I both love and hate it at the same time
