Episode 214: Rewriting Cambridge Analytica (P2) feat Anthony Mansuy
This week we bring you part 2 of our exploration of the Cambridge Analytica Scandal — cast in a very different light. In part 1 we took a look at Christopher Wylie’s origin story and the sketchy science behind the supposed “psychological warfare mindfuck tool” Steve Bannon employed within Cambridge Analytica on behalf of Robert Mercer, which, the story goes, won the election for Donald Trump by manipulating the masses. In part 2, we’re gonna be taking a look at Wylie’s attempt to create his own Cambridge Analytica, how he turned into the supposed do-gooder whistleblower in the first place, and what it means for the accepted narrative about the scandal.
We are joined again by guest writer Anthony Mansuy, a French reporter for Society Magazine. For this two-parter, Anthony conducted months of research and forty exclusive interviews. You’ll be hearing from Cambridge Analytica employees, data scientists, former Obama, Trump and Cruz campaign staffers, as well as friends and associates of Chris Wylie.
The evidence lays out how Wylie spread numerous fabrications and exaggerations to minimize his contribution to the development of Cambridge Analytica's tools and conceal the true causes of his departure from the organization. More importantly, Wylie capitalized on the deepest fears held by the liberal media about the far-right, social media, and Russia; allowing him to craft the perfect narrative to fit the political moment — one that persists to this day.
Subscribe for $5 a month to get an extra episode of QAA every week + access to ongoing series like 'Manclan' and 'Trickle Down': http://www.patreon.com/QAnonAnonymous
Anthony Mansuy: https://twitter.com/AnthonyMansuy
Les Dissidents (Anthony's book): https://bit.ly/3jgCFfK
Merch: http://merch.qanonanonymous.com
Music by Pontus Berghe, Nick Sena, DJ Death. Editing by Corey Klotz.
Comments (33)
I am going to have to relisten to both episodes because I can't even say I really resonated with the Cambridge Analytic narrative to begin with, so a lot of this went over my head. Like all the technology "scandals" of our day: Hillary's Emails, Hunter's Laptop, and Twitter Files I hear them (and its never even a coherent narrative) and my eyes glaze over. I guess the narrative of social media being weaponized with data/marketing knowhow, seems true though even if the specific wizardry of CA's personality test data was overblown. As the world goes to hell, it seems like we are in a crisis of right-wing populism which is seemingly attracting people often through social media. I do believe the right is good at "marketing" with disinformation/outrage/fake news on social media just like they succeeded with AM radio and cable news. I'll grant you a lot of the attraction to these rightwing/conspiracy narratives is because of the failures/collapse of the liberal world order, but the right is still DOING something and has agency. If there wasn't something going on, conspiracies and hate becoming rampant online and with real violent offline consequences, I probably wouldn't be listening to your wonderful podcast. I just felt like you almost dismissed the danger of disinformation at the end, "it's just economic anxiety guys", which seemed an odd conclusion for a podcast about the dangers of disinformation.
You are absolutely right that right wing actors (including and especially the state) proactively propogandize, and that new information technologies have facilitated this and changed how theu deliver their message, I do think it is worth challenging the narrative that tech geniuses have unlocked dark secrets of social engineering on a massive scale and not just expanded their market channels in a politixal economic environment which structurally reproduces right wing propoganda. I find myself making the same point about 'cointelpro' and 'psyops' in my lefty circles where people imagine that the CIA unlocked the secrets of mind control and have essentially magical power to shape social forces when really they just tortured and drugged a lot of people. We can acknowledge the reality and danger of these projecta without imputing to them an almost mystical level of power. (Not saying YOU are doing this, person i'm responding too, just feel compelled to articulate the point.)
DAYUM some hard hitting reporting that will surely have ramifications... I hope this gets you guys some notoriety. Brilliant!
Ok I confess, I fell for the Cambridge analytica mind fuck idea, because it really WAS hard to understand how people believed a criminal reality TV idiot should be president. People in NY knew his character, actually it was everywhere if anyone cared to look. So forget Facebook....it always seemed to me that it was the Apprentice version of Trump that people bought into. "Reality TV" was its own Pill. Anyhoo, great info on all of it....it feels good to be de-pilled about Bannon being a super genius 😂
Brett, calm down buddy, take a breath. It's just dipshits from california doing what they do. #onlypodcastipayfor
They are kinda representative of people everywhere....it's just that in California they do it better 😉
This is why you guys should try and do traditional journalism... It's because you never get around to any actual journalism. This is just a story about a guy who might be a liar, but there's no way to tell. You simply introduced a woman whom you claim is credible, and parrot her claim. You haven't even given us a reason to distrust the liar, because you haven't proven he's lying. "Dude said a thing, we found someone else who says differently, you don't get any context, believe us". You do what the right does and simply rattle off a few negative things about a person, and that's why they drink adrenochrome. It's hard to be a real journalist, so maybe leave it to them. Speaking of, I guess I'm supposed to know who this French guy is. You're platforming him like I'm supposed to know who he is, or something. No solid reasons given why I should trust him, so I don't. The worst part is that I agree with you, and still think you're shit at proving anything. This is just a bad movie script that's just, "and this happened, and then this happens, and then this other thing happens...". That's fine, but don't expect me to care if you're not putting a narrative together. I'm not putting any more work into a piece of media than the creator. You don't tell me why I should trust this journalist, so I don't. You don't tell me why Wylie's claims don't hold up versus his detractors, so I assume he's right as a default position because he's the protagonist. Journalism is like translation - it's not enough to simply regurgitate machine translation. A good translator has to put the translation into a context the target audience culture will understand. A good journalist has to lay out facts in a way that lets the audience have context and understanding... Neither of which you ever provide. It's like Liv's episode that was just dry regurgitation of esoteric political theory that assumed I was willing to do homework to listen to a comedy podcast. Stick to what you do well and stop trying to be what you're not. We don't even get a Jake Story as a reward for sitting through this stupidity. Granted, the one from the last time Julian tried to play journalist is one of the worst he's done, it's still better than the episode it's attached to... And that episode was leaps and bounds better than this one.
You know you don't have to give this podcast your money if you no longer like what they do right? Furthermore nothing that you said was even remotely valid. They had the journalist who reported on the topic they were discussing and the narrative they laid out was fairly straightforward. You're acting like a petulant child because a podcast you pay $5 a month for isn't doing pulitzer prize winning journalism.
I LOVE ANTHONY
Great episodes! And great job by Anthony gathering all this. The interviews with Wylie were so good but also quite painful to listen to… and that outro clip… oof.
“Girl, you’ve read some 3rd wave shit” I’m going to hurl myself into The Abyss
i feel so dumb for believing the stuff he wrote in his book 🙈
When something seems sus (and anything associated with Bannon is sus), there will be an overwhelming urge to believe the worst possible iteration of whatever that thing is and when you have so-called insiders coming out telling you that's exactly what happened, it can be hard to resist.
To the question of, "why the fuck do people fall for these conspiracy theories?" I still think, even taking all this other gaslighting and marketing fuckery into account, the answer is simply because people are stupid. I know it sounds trite, but some things become trite simply because they are factually accurate and observable all over the world. The market research, the datamining, the ads targeted at mentally vulnerable people, these are all just catalysts that amplify the root cause: stupidity. These things would never work if a large chunk of the average people weren't so insanely idiotic, so butt-fuckingly stupid, as to believe in things like QAnon in the first place. Facebook/Twitter marketing just gives direction to people's lack of intellect, which would otherwise be "squandered" on harmless things like booze, cable television, and mobile games. In other words, any success these algorithms have is a symptom, not the cause.
I would argue it’s ignorance rather than stupidity. A generation of adults who lived most of their lives without the internet feel like it’s all a magic trick. They have very little knowledge of how social media works. Combine that with huge swaths of folks who have had a lack of access to not only the internet but also media literacy education and here we are! Maybe I am a fool for thinking that more access to education would improve our circumstances but I am a librarian and the ideal keeps me going on rough Monday mornings.
Kinda disappointment by the ~economic anxiety~ turn towards the end tbh
Same. I can usually just ignore the Chappo stuff Julian veers towards every now and again, especially because I don’t always disagree with his take, but this was impossible to ignore and threatened to take something away from the whole point which is everything about the relationship between big tech and its users is incredibly messed up. No they can’t make you vote for Trump because you took a Facebook quiz and now they send you brainwashing ads… but the whole end of the episode seemed off for a group that has seen first hand and analyzed many many instances of how misinformation is dangerous. The problem with all this is not that “Libs” got freaked out by Cambridge and Steve Bannon’s claims. The problem is Facebook made as much money as they could and because they could you can tie a thread directly from them to all sorts of awful things. It’s like we had to forget all their previous reporting and work so Julian could take a shot a “Libs.” We get it. And it’s fine to have that opinion, but make sure there aren’t any mental gymnastics done to turn a story about a skeezy lying tech entrepreneur(s) into a cautionary “Look How Dumb The Libs Are!” tale. So many more interesting things going on here, that didn’t get brought up.
So basically a lot of the scandal was massive lib copium to deal with the fact that a lot of people fucking hated Hillary.
Great stuff. I hope this gets as wide audience as possible. Makes me think of the concept of Neoliberal Order Breakdown Syndrome by the boys over at Aufhebunga Bunga podcast (and their book The End of the End of History). They use it to describe how liberals lost their minds post-2016 because they couldn't understand what was going on with Trump, Brexit, etc. We need wider appreciation that liberals are just as prone to conspiracy theories. The end of history is ending and we're all losing our minds (some more than others...).
As much as I think this is an excellent episode with a ton of outstanding research, I still can't help but not believe a word Bannon is saying about any of this.
I was a little taken aback when they were like "and see even Bannon says it's all a Nothingburger!"
Conspiracy type thinking is so ingrained in humanity that I feel that pretty much everyone does it no matter their political leanings. Even you guys sometimes dip your toes in conspiratorial thought. I guess I wish that people realized that skepticism is hard and to check themselves more often.
Conspiracies, plots, and secret operations still very much exist, though. The problem is that people get sucked into obscure nonsense rather than seeing the simplicity of what occurred. This can be applied to many historical events shrouded in controversy.
Really interesting episode! Thank you.
👁️ see this shit? It's my third eye opening. Except all I see now is bullshit.
The outro clip is so infuriating
Sure but if anyone thought seriously Bannon would discuss Chanel little black dresses it's kinda funny. It really sounded fictional.
Really, massive kudos to Mansuy for this. Extremely well researched and argued case used to make a point I've felt so often when listening to and reading well-meaning friends and family getting hysterical about disinformation and the demonic influence of Russia/Bannon/whatever other beast lurks under their bed. I think perhaps liberals are not quite as used to the sensation of feeling helpless in the face of political realities and institutions failing them, and it's pretty clear Brexit/Trump/Corbyn drove a lot of them straight into the arms of conspiracy theories almost as wild and self-defeating as Qanon itself. Also, of course Dominic Cummings was somehow involved in all this lol. Wiley must have appeared so callow and guileless to him.
Russia, Bannon and Cambridge Analytica are all basically lib QAnon, seems like.
Wow. Chris Wiley sucks.
Ah-may-zing.
So fascinating
Did y'all just break Patreon a little? (•ө•)♡
