Manclan Episode 5: Iron John & the Mythopoetic Men’s Movement feat Matt Christman
Have you stolen the key from beneath your mother’s pillow? We explore the mythopoetic men’s movement of the 1990s including a deep dive into Robert Bly’s ‘Iron John: A Book About Men’ which became a bestseller and was part of a movement whose thinking can still be found in today’s online masculinity influencers. Our guest is Matt Christman of Chapo Trap House and the upcoming history podcast Hell On Earth.
This series was brought to you by the QAA podcast. Thanks for supporting us on patreon!
Guest is Matt Christman: https://twitter.com/cushbomb / http://patreon.com/chapotraphouse
Cover art by Jess Johnson (http://instagram.com/flesh_dozer)
Theme & music by Nick Sena (http://nicksenamusic.com) & Pontus Berghe. Editing by Corey Clotz.
Comments (49)
i ❤️ christman
Also in Kimmel’s book, he details how manhood in America was focused on things like guilds and professional communities in the 1800s, and this was destroyed with the rise of factory work. The definition of manhood went from “have these physical attributes” to “be upwardly mobile” to “you can’t change any of these things but you can change your personality,” so that’s why self help books were huge at the ends of the 1800s going into the 1900s.
This all comes from the turn of the 20th century actually! In Michael Kimmel’s book Manhood in America, he details how “neuroasthenia” a condition of the “neuroses” caused by industrialization and modern life meant that men needed to return to something physical and have a connection to nature again so they recommended The West Cure as a “treatment” for the mental illness caused by modern life.
i’m doing an exercise for class and reading translations of an antonio machado poem. reading one and the translator has made some choices i disagree with… it was robert bly! oh brother this guy stinks
Wait, is UniLad just British for college bro?
So there is this really interesting idea that young men (around 13) make their own risk taking and initiation behaviours because we dont have anything as a culture anymore but this is meant to be done with supportive family and community not just to 'make you a man'
I was really surprised when I learned about this idea from the academy, because it was something I always believed from my time in the punk/hardcore/noise/rave scenes as a young man but in a kind of inchoate way, I watched a lot of the other guys embrace nihilism and reactionary ideas, mysogyny, self-destruction and etc. even if they started from an explicitly 'lefty' radical position and it seemed to me at the time that it was precisely because we had to figure it out on our own and the only kind of older role models were guys that were too stunted to have grown out of the scene, or guys with toxic ideology consciously preying on waywars and vulnerable youth.
I had forgotten how homoerotic this movement was. All the daddies initiating the younger men? It's like a Pornhub category. Sorta hot but also creepy.
I don't think Bly the copywriter and Bly the poet are the same Bly.
There was a English Civil War Q! There was a conspiracy theory that the dog of the Royalist Prince Rupert was actually a demon/woman who he had sex with. It started as a joke from a royalist making fun of how superstitious the Parliamentarians were which seemed to have been believed by some people.
I live in Japan and that passage isn't even internally consistent. Is duty the responsibility of the employee or the bosses? He says that American corporations lack a sense of duty and require unions to fill the gap because the employees have no leaders to look to, but how does that relate to the concept of the shogun? In medieval Japan (and by extension, modern Japanese companies), it is the peasant (salaried employee) who is duty bound to serve the lord, not the other way around. This is also related to Buddhist concepts of caste and the idea that a person's station is life is determined by the behavior of their ancestors or past lives. It's true that in its ideal form, the feudal lord should be wise enough to balance the need for all his people to have enough rice to eat with the need to store some rice in order to survive the coming winter, or provide the people with necessary infrastructure, etc.. But there is never any point where the leader has to *earn* trust. He is born with it. Even if we're talking about the samurai class, an honorable samurai was one who would die for their lord whether or not their lord was deserving or not, because the abstract concept of duty outweighs the material reality. The samurai proves himself better than his master by successfully subjugating his will in a way the master could not. This is the reason that Japanese work culture has the bad reputation you discussed. Because the burden of sacrifice is placed entirely on the bottom, rather than the top.
I was involved in the Men's movement in my early 20's and when Jordan Peterson started popping off I instantly thought this just sounds like Robert Bly but for dark manchildren.
I love Julian and everyone on the show. I want to listen to Mark’s history podcast. Are there free ways to listen? I’m not ready to throw down a monthly subscription.
The huntsman obviously thought the king was a dick and didn't want to come back. Maybe they became Iron John's posse
I was given a copy of Iron John at my Bar Mitzvah in the mid nineties. I never finished it and gave it to a friend, maybe I’m one of the hunters.
I had to write this line down: Julian says that Bly is “a horny old professor inseminating the culture with his esoteric navel-gazing.” It’s an apt description not just of Bly, but of a whole anthology’s worth of mid-20th century literary types.
Have you read the Gor books? Seriously toxic masculine fantasy series.
Had to do some comparative mythology on this and, yep, it's Gilgamesh / Amleth / Hamlet. Here's my tear down based on the Wiki summary: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1cyMc-0cNtW2O7bnWAYTkGuppCIABpfHCPIve_hrzyIA/edit?usp=sharing
"elden ring style genital dungeon" go on...
Does anyone know the other book Annie recommend Julian read? Sounded much more interesting than Iron John!
The Hearts of Men - Barbara Ehrenreich
I actually enjoyed the story of Iron John, if not the analysis of it. That kind of rambley old folk tale is kind of charming; it seems like a bizarre dream. Drawing too much meaning from it is definitely a mistake; it actually strikes me as essentially modernist to want every story like that to be super meaningful.
I think the Craft remake cast David Duchovny as a leader of one of these groups.
Ngl I wish Julian would stop doing so many jokes. It really detracts from this episode.
Julian's jokes are wonderful, even if they don't hit a bullseye 100% of the time. should they just read to you in monotone?
Matt's last tirade about manclan types not even being able to conceive of standing up to *real* power is f'ing legend.
It’s a silly book, but I think Julian was too blithely dismissive from the get-go, in an annoying way, and Christman seemed kinda checked out for much of the episode if I’m being honest.
its all in the editing
this is probably my favorite ongoing pod series. keep it up yall
Sometimes I like to roll an ice king but an ice king can be weak to fire queen so you have to be careful about that. Iron John makes a good tank for an ice king.
Recently the devs listened to a small but vocal group of rogues who complained enough to get some crucial buffs to the 'Rust Never Sleeps' skill.
The picture book is far superior
Unsurprised that Annie Alpha Kelly has Conquered Covid
She is 3-0 or 2-0 at this point? Her K/D ratio vs covid is infinity.
I was in psych grad school when Iron John came out and I remember feeling like the only person not on board with the silliness, it's good to know I was right and everyone else was wrong, just like every other time I've been out of step with the people around me!
https://youtu.be/Aa9BqpLUI1Y
Listening to Bly's incoherent mythologizing about the masculine energies of the patriarchal hero or whatever, I kept thinking I was listening to Jordan Peterson, and the similarity was so striking that it kinda wigged me out lol. It's amazing how that same writing voice just carries through directly into Peterson's work.
thought exactly the same. This must be one of the few books Peterson's properly read, the similarities are uncanny.
omg this one was interesting. ive read some of robert bly's poetry but didnt know about all this! thankfully i never liked his work very much lol
Why is submissiveness to authority considered masculine? Be it a church, dear leader, king, etc. Shouldn't it be the opposite lol
my guess is it's hierarchy they crave. 'masculinity' is just an ordering mechanism for them
The whole “men being stuck in the development stage of boys” thing is reasonable, considering the extent to which American masculinity is defined by one’s ability to have the most, biggest, priciest and most destructive toys they can. That’s not women’s fault, that’s the fault of overgrown manbabies who define how much of a man you are by the amount of emissions your car generates or how many bullets you can fire.
New Manclan! I'm strapped in and ready to be sad and helpless to do anything about it like a total Beta. Seriously, thanks Julian and the rest of the team, these are great.
It's fascinating to hear someone write and write and write and say absolutely nothing
lol I kept thinking that to myself while listening on my jog. it actually felt like I was slipping into a psychosis "how can I be hearing this much text and only hear it as absolute gibberish??" I assumed I was the one going insane
@45:00 .. did we ever find out what happened to the missing soldiers? Or are we suppose to infer they all drowned after being pulled in to the lake like the dog? I'm confused.
FDR as a revolutionary. That's a new one to me. Bonkers take, but a new one nonetheless.
I mean he's second only to Lincoln insofar as being at the highest rungs of power but still recognizing the material problems facing Americans. he left office having done a net good for the American people through his socialized policies FDR also wanted to establish a solid as stone peace and cooperation treaty with the USSR which would have averted the Cold War (and 9/11) lol I wish I could say there were more than 3-4 good presidents but that wouldn't be true. FDR was one of those very few
obviously it's clear that Bly went completely bonkers in his late middle age but I really do like his short piece on FDR's initiation through uncontrolled physical pain and suffering. It seems like maybe the failure of the early masculine movement was taking a right turn when something so clear is right in front of you in the form of FDR. He was a revolutionary and a great man because he came to understand *empathy* as a "king" (via his physical vulnerability) Maybe the "king" isn't someone to be unconditionally revered but someone who has been broken down in some form and understands that suffering is real, and acts in a manner to try and protect others from it.
