49ers Electrical Substation Conspiracy Theory feat. Arif Hasan (Premium E322)
As Super Bowl LX rolls into Santa Clara’s Levi’s Stadium, Jake Rockatansky and Travis View are joined by sports writer Arif Hasan (Wide Left newsletter) to dig into one of the NFL’s strangest modern fan obsessions: the idea that the San Francisco 49ers are cursed by an electrical substation.
Over the last decade the Niners have become infamous for suffering from brutal, momentum-killing injuries. This has fueled endless theories about potential reasons for the medical incidents that are causing heartburn among football fans in the Bay Area. Is it turf, training, recruiting strategy, bad luck, or something else?
One rumor has dominated the online discourse: the idea that the Northern Receiving Station, right next to where the pro athletes train and play, is bathing players in “EMF” and making them more injury-prone. We trace how the theory travelled from locker room chatter, to online content creators, to a “board-certified quantum biology practitioner” until it finally had to be addressed by the 49ers administration and NFL’s chief medical officer. This is despite the fact that the idea doesn’t have any empirical support and it doesn’t even make sense upon examination of the timeline of the substation.
Wide Left: A newsletter about the NFL and its intersection with politics and culture
https://www.wideleft.football/
Arif Hasan
Thank you for being a patron of QAA
Check out our new podcast series network Cursed Media and binge the entirety of our exclusive shows Science in Transition by Liv Agar and Truly, Tradly, Deely by Annie Kelly
Produced by Corey Klotz. Theme by Nick Sena. Additional music by Pontus Berghe. Theme Vocals by THEY/LIVE (instagram.com/theyylivve / sptfy.com/QrDm). Cover Art by Pedro Correa: (pedrocorrea.com)
QAA was known as the QAnon Anonymous podcast.
Comments (85)
jake still talking about uncrustables between his thighs
Kept skipping ahead to get to the conspiracy bit
Has anyone mentioned Gmelch's "baseball magic"? Not to be the academic here, but he uses malinkowski's work on superstition to hypothesize that probaseball players turn to superstition to mitigate feeling a lack of control over the outcomes of their game. In short all humans rely on magic to relieve the anxiety of uncertain outcomes. It seems to fit here!
the 49ers keep getting injured because i, specifically, cursed them with my brain bc fuck bay area teams. sorry :/
i dont even follow football, my hate for the giants is just so strong it extends to all their neighboring teams (except the oakland As, u guys are too cute to hate)
My first comment as a subscriber because I had to move the total comments to 89.
Please don't do football. This episode is boring af, I couldn't finish
The Chiefs have a substation ~1500 ft. from their training field. The high voltage wires go right over their parking lot and have for decades
I hear joe Rogan, i fast forward
It always catches me off guard when I realize travis and I went to the same community college
the alkaline water (and bottled water in general) scam drives me crazy. you can look on the back its literally just water with baking soda in it. a coworker of mine was like “i mean i just like it, and then i saw if you’re balanced it prevents cancer so like why not?” because its not proven and all bottled water is a scam to privatize a public service and health scams are to scapegoat the blame of getting sick onto us, like “why do u need health insurance, you should have been taking care of your body”
im 31, and i didn’t have parents who were super into music, so i didnt get into it until i was in middle school, but a lot of the first stuff i heard was in 7th grade playing the guitar hero games. i had never heard any of those bands until guitar hero, like i remember listening to heart shaped box and it sounded sooo dark. i would buy all the songs in my ipod and listen to them.
Some idle comments from a biophysicist: 1) EMF can stand for electromotive force, which essentially means the voltage generated by a battery. This has nothing to do with anything. 2) Gauss rhymes with mouse, not moss, so the guy has probably never heard a physicist (or electrician) speak. 3) The claim from the AI generated article that federal safety regulations only apply to heat is actually totally true - powerful radio antennas pump out so much energy they can burn workers from the inside (this has nothing to do with radiation burns from x-rays). 4) Cells are sort of like mini faraday cages, and electric fields can't normally penetrate the cell membrane in the first place. 5) Despite that, some cells actually are known to have special electric field detectors (e.g. the protein galvanin, discovered last year). There's some evidence that this helps e.g. immune cells travel to wounds in order to help with healing. So, you can look forwards to hearing about that in the future from other quantum biology cranks!!
this so so cool!! thank you
Obligatory go hawks, fuck the 49ers
After listening to this episode all I wanna know is where were these conspiracies 30 years ago when the Bengals were practicing in an active wasteland? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gJuz8OzOge0
This is way too much American Handegg chat for me.
I have no interest in sports let alone American so-called football, but I really enjoyed this episode.
I have and will never use an m dash
You have angered the substation and it's lashing out. 49er Keion White shot in the ankle. https://www.sfchronicle.com/sports/49ers/article/49ers-keion-white-21343888.php
Eagles mention at 1:28:22 go birds baby
really good guest on this one, i don't usually find football interesting but he was genuinely engaging.
Great episode. Love the difference in conspiracy creation and follow-up between pro and college fans. You’d never get this in college because in college: 1. Always blame your rival, 2. if that doesn’t work, doxx the coaches home address you blame for the issue (in this case the S&C coach and/or groundskeeper), 3. if that gets you nowhere FOIA the school and make things much worse than they already are.
I’m learning so much practical info about sports injuries in this episode.
Being from Cincinnati, I lack pity for the 49ers.
Same
I was in peak running form in my late twenties when suddenly I developed horrible tendinitis. My PT told me by body just wasn’t able to handle how much I was running. Basically, I’m just like the 49ers
GTA San Andreas introduced whole generation of core millennials such as my self to “It Was a Good Day” by Ice Cube and “A Horse with no Name” of course
Best ep in a long time! Loved the guest, topics, vibe.
I'm gonna be "that guy" for a second. Arif got the voltages wrong. The transformers in substations generally step voltage down from transmission (60+ kV) to distribution primary voltage (600V-59 kV). The exact voltage depends on the power utility and the connection. The step down to 120/240V for your home happens at a distribution transformer within a couple hundred feet of your house. Otherwise all the explanations were very good. Good episode guys. Kloveyoubye.
This was fun to listen to, first time hearing it.
49’ers fan here. This one hurt, no pun intended. But as much as I want an excuse, a substation is not hurting our players and if you believe it is you need your fucking head examined.
Great episode. Joe Rogan is an expert in NOTHING. What does LLM stand for?
Love Lovin' Men
Might be in the minority here, but I would love more sports conspiracy episodes.
I haven’t looked into it deeply but I can easily believe there are enough stories out there someone could do a ‘sportspiracy cast’. The weirdness you see in MMA is not new phenomenon.
Man if you put my interests into a Petri dish, it would grow this episode: nfl, physics, 2k, Ender Wiggin etc
They're blaming the injuries on EMF!? Unbelievable!
Great episode. Though I'll point out: EMF stands for both ElectroMotive Force and ElectroMagnetic Fields. They're *very* interconnected concepts. Electromagnetic fields can create electromotive force. This is how induction motors operate: fields induce magnetism which transforms the electrical energy into physical force.
Goose gang
Compromise position: the halftime show can be woke BUT it has to show female nipple. Woke nipple!
The alkaline water thing annoys the fuck out of me because there's just enough actual science in it to sound plausible but if you know anything about avid base balance in the body it's clearly nonsense. That and people who give IVs of baking soda which we do in medicine but only under very specific circumstances like severe acidosis.
Crazy going from last episode to this
Arif talked about the freak non-contact injury Dre Greenlaw suffered while running off the field during the Super Bowl two years ago. Funny story about that game. I was there (long-time 49er fan), and the siblings, cousins, and I had a family text chain going during the game. When it went to overtime, I said something like, “At least I’m getting my money’s worth!” Jake, who everybody knows isn’t a sports fan and wasn’t watching the game, misinterpreted my text, and thought it meant that the 49ers had won. He texted the chain a congrats to his NorCal cousins on our team winning. Clearly jinxed the results. So if any QAA listeners are Chiefs fans, you can thank Jake Rockatansky for your title. 😊
Go birds
Great episode! Kyle Shanahan is the Tom Thibodeau of football, incredible regular season coach but he's incapable of managing his team for playoff success throughout the season. And fuck bill simmons 👍
This one had some issues. How did the sports guy repeatedly say “1994 was over 20 years ago” and not correct pronunciation of Kyle “Yuzzick”? But yeah I can’t believe they had Abby Martin on the other week…
It was over 20 years ago fam
It's wild that there have been multiple guests that have appeared on Defector's The Distraction podcast and QAA. I can't wait until the Rohan Nadkarni QAA episode.
Travis reminding me of Ladainian Tomlinson, didn’t expect that today
I still have a sega genesis with a working mutant league hockey cartridge. What an era- if you lacked the skills to actually play hockey, you could just kill off the other team’s players until they had to forfeit. Mighty Weenies forever.
Cupping works very well. I didn't do the heated cup method which probably does little to nothing. During physical therapy for my leg after a car wreck I was given cupping treatment with a set that uses an airpump to create that vacuum. You have to pull a LOT of your flesh up into that cup for the method to work, the slight pulling from a heated cup just cant possibly pull that much up. It bruised the shit outta my leg where the cups went and was incredibly uncomfortable. But you know what? This was 3 months into physical therapy and I had hit a wall, my therapist used this and my muscle groups basically reset themselves and I finally saw some progress in mobility and pain. Tldr: there are legit cupping treatments with proven results, the heated cup definition is lacking
Also like WHILE exercise IS very good and healthy for you, it's not that healthy to be a professional athlete. It takes a toll on your body to be THAT active. Your joints, your tendons, your bones. Even your heart sometimes. And that's not even taking into consideration that football is a contact sport. Pushing your body to its absolute limit is generally not great for it. Like with everything there IS very much such a thing as too much exercise.
Yep cyclists and I think maybe runners are the ones who tend to get enlarged heart muscles.
Jake you need to look into the conspiracy about Portland Trail Blazers big men getting hurt because of the water up there
I was unaware of this conspiracy but a) this sounds like a Portlandia sketch, and b) I only want to learn more about it through the medium of a Jake episode.
Go Hawks!!!
Arif! Heck yeah.
Didn't Jake get COVID at a Bad Bunny concert?
Football 👎 hockey 👍
Oooooooh Canada!
A snakeboard fucking lmao
Jake get an electric longboard with the big tyres
I was the Lawful Neutral Cleric who got kicked out by my Dungeon Master.
Awesome episode!
Fuck the Niners. Go Pack Go.
Same! (Shareholder)
How do I love this pod so much that I'm listening to an episode about a football team. I actually generally repel any information about football because I actively don't even want to know anything about it.
This one is somehow absolutely wonderful
EMF stands for Ecstacy Mother Fuckers
Unbelievable !
I put the sub in substation
Unbelievable oh!
It’s actually pretty fair for him to mix up “electromagnetic field” and “electromotive force.” The latter is essentially a voltage and usually discussed in the context of electronic circuits. Plus, the term “emf” is most frequently used to reference the force, not the field. In fact, I go so far as to say that I’ve never heard EM fields referred to as “emf”
Never? Never!?! So you’ve never seen ghostbusters??? I’ll have Mr. Rockatansky see you out.
SEAHAWKS
uncrustable slander!
Something tells me Joe Montana and Jerry Rice wouldn’t be bitching about EMF rays. Why? Because they are actual winners.
Assassins creed sea shanty soundtracks 🙌🙌🙌
This is the second time today I heard Arif. Got done, listening listening to Heed the call with him
He's so good!!
Just a reminder that the Patriots are evil and came from the Black Lodge.
EMF!! After living through the last few years enduring Trump etc...yeah...I'll believe anything.
No Liv Agar. Sad.
Wow, what a pull
