November 5, 2025

BONUS: The Insane Story of Jonathan Idema

Comments (65)

K
Kurgaah · March 6, 2026

Had to come back here just to say “everyone leans left in the end” has been in my head everyday since this was posted

B
Brandon P · January 28, 2026

"Short guy" - "5"9" Maybe to you, Joe. No way Idema was that tall.

J
Jeffrey Garcia · November 24, 2025

Took psychic damage from “PooKeepSee”

M
McGinter · January 29, 2026

I so feel you 😂

J
Jalil Henry · November 24, 2025

Joe, how were you an emt but didn't pay attention in your stem classes? lol

N
Nicholas Matson · November 18, 2025

There is a red hook in downstate ny near poughkeepsie. He did not have a training camp in brooklyn

A
Alive Or Trees · November 13, 2025

Partway through, I realized I knew this story. Oki's weird story made a youtube documentary in 2022. It was wild and this podcast was a much more pleasant experience. Oki does great interviews but lacks the Unc energy that tom contributes

E
Erin and Gilford Murphy · November 11, 2025

The name Poughkeepsie is of Native American origin, so I’d avoid calling it dumb. We have a lot of places on the East Coast that use the Native American names for certain places.

M
Marc Bosse · November 10, 2025

“In Prussia they proceed from the principle that no kind of occupation can demean a soldier, as long as it brings in money” Guibert, 1773. CiC says bustin for the camera is honest work boys.

L
Loquin Britton-Herndon · November 10, 2025

Lol my dad supplies pot (and probably cocaine) to his brother who was in the army at about the same time - he was out himself but he was everyone's best friend because of that.

K
Kentucky Fried Commie · November 10, 2025

Pu-kip-see Not Poooo-keeep-seeee

N
Noblese Oblahaj · November 14, 2025

Often heard that first sound made like 'dough' with a p. Pough.

E
Edward Bartlett · November 9, 2025

I had no idea that's how Lux Interior died. I thought he just died from some heart condition.

1
19ZXB Donkey brains · November 9, 2025

Asserting that robbing a bank without shooting someone is a victimless crime, is wildly ignorant and immature. I have a friend who deals with brutal post traumatic stress from one such situation.

B
Brandon P · January 28, 2026

It's fine if you're a gentleman about it.

J
James Cézanne-Taipale · November 8, 2025

Died hated so much nobody claimed the body. Me: Just like my grandpa!

R
Robbie The Space Raccoon · November 8, 2025

This guy was a first ballot hofer dudes rock guy until all the DV and torture.

B
Brian Azevedo · November 6, 2025

When LLBD promises an “insane story,” you can take it to the bank (or private torture prison).

J
JM · November 6, 2025

Waiting for the next straight to streaming true crime Jeffrey Dahmer series to include Nate’s Dad. Who would be the best actor?

N
Noblese Oblahaj · November 6, 2025

You spend time in Islip in the 90s, Nate? Go to that big ass beige mall with the fake stone facade, with the sky bridge that led to the arcade?

A
Anthonyk · November 6, 2025

It will forever be called Pookkipsey from now on.

J
Jake · November 6, 2025

Grew up in Fayetteville, Nate’s assessment of “it wouldn’t exist if Ft. Bragg wasn’t there” is entirely correct.

S
Sam Blackman · November 6, 2025

so, what have we learned? Nate has 2 degrees of separation from both J. Cole and Jeffrey Dahmer… Apparently you can do basically whatever the fuck you want with zero consequences for decades as long as you’re a white American guy who knows how to talk like a special forces soldier… damn…

S
Sam Blackman · November 6, 2025

The wall locker is based asf, but throwing it out the 3rd story window with the narc in it?!? did anyone get courtmartialed for that??

S
Sam Blackman · November 6, 2025

NOT BOOFMAN!!

S
Sam Blackman · November 6, 2025

…no shit… wow, Nate, dude… that’s a HELL of a realization

S
Sam Blackman · November 6, 2025

“just sit tight we’re gonna get you to Jeff the medic” “absolutely not” “dude you just broke a fucking rib you’re going to the medic” “ABSOLUTELY. FUCKING. NOT!SIR.”

S
Sam Blackman · November 6, 2025

“The ballad of the –WORST FUCKING SONG IN HISTORY GOD DAMN!!!

A
Alex · November 6, 2025

The ABC would have no doubtedly done something dodgy like that. Then of course they did have a moment of doing something decent when uncovering a bunch of war crimes in Afghanistan from leaks about the Australian SAS.

S
Sam Blackman · November 6, 2025

pretty sure at age 12 I still wanted to be an ornithologist and/or an astronaut(Star Trek or Dr. Who character lol)

S
Sam Blackman · November 6, 2025

AW FUCK OFF ITS NOT A STUPID TOWN NAME, YOURE A STUPID TOWN NAME🙄

S
Sam Blackman · November 6, 2025

Pā–Kip(like the last name)-çi cmon yall…🤦 😆☠️

S
Sam Blackman · November 6, 2025

ah yes, the “pls don’t die” cords/buttons in nursing home and some hospital bathrooms. It’s like what you pull to get the bus or train to stop, but way more high stakes

S
Sam Blackman · November 6, 2025

I dodged a fair amount of Mtn. Dew growing up… only ever had a few, though Mtn. Dew still became a nickname of mine for a while jsut because I said it weird in my slightly different hillbilly accent than the other hillbillies

S
Sam Blackman · November 6, 2025

and yeah… code red was a bit of a thing there…

S
Sam Blackman · November 6, 2025

juggalo make the best American medical care providers, why? they’re down with slashes, budget or otherwise

S
Sam Blackman · November 6, 2025

holy shit I wrote this before I even heard the end of the joke, pre-cog’d that shit lmao

E
Elsie Hupp · November 6, 2025

This episode provides an important PSA: Yes, “Be Gay Do Crime” …just not *war* crimes.

S
Sam Blackman · November 6, 2025

very true…

C
CEA · November 6, 2025

Nate I’m gonna need you to run that by us again because WHAT

M
Matt Watterson · November 5, 2025

When my dad was a kid my grandfather was stationed at Fort Bragg/Liberty/Bragg/? and he and his friends stumbled across a mock Vietnamese village the Berets were using to train and they got the hell out of there as soon as they realized what it was.

A
AppliedJest · November 5, 2025

Nate, please sell your Boofman OC to Marvel. If RDJ can return to the franchise in a different role for $80mil so can Stellan Skarsgaard. Or a reanimated Robert Redford.

A
AppliedJest · November 5, 2025

Wait, 5’9” is Short King territory now? All kings no mayors then. I agree 5’9” is not tall but that’s because the literal *average* height of US males. I get that special forces have a sexual- I mean, operational preference for above-average-height people, but are the two genders really Green Beret and Short King?

F
Final Bond Girl · November 5, 2025

Someone tell Tom about Fayettenam. Speaking as a community college professor, it deserves it

S
Sam Blackman · November 6, 2025

what’s Fayettenam?

A
Ander Pierce · November 5, 2025

So many crimes and HIV infections could have been prevented by just locking the clown up

S
Sam Blackman · November 6, 2025

Also true of bill Clinton!!!

A
Ajusco Huerta · November 5, 2025

Gotta love Nate's dad lore. He's been close to Dahmer and in Korea during the dmz axe murder.

N
Nomber · November 6, 2025

He sounds like some kind of bizarro Forest Gump of fucked up historical events

M
Marc Bosse · November 5, 2025

An acquaintance of mine was approached post-high school about doing some solo videos of the sort discussed. His mistake was telling us about the $2,000 offer (in 1998). We did not let him forget that for the rest of the year. Buying a burger? Dude, you should save your $2,000 for the future, and it got worse from there.

N
NowhereMan661 · November 5, 2025

Jesus Christ, this guy is genuinely sociopathic.

S
SouthpawFL · November 5, 2025

Tom and Nate just chose violence this morning

N
NowhereMan661 · November 5, 2025

INSANE Nate lore reveal.

H
Hey mind your business, name's not important · November 5, 2025

I've been to Fayetteville several times for SCA reasons. The entire SCA group at the time was guys from the 82nd Airborne, Air force members from the base adjacent to Bragg and a few very frightening guys who were operators with non regulation mustaches.

O
Ol Purdy Bastard · November 5, 2025

No Poughkeepsie slander will be tolerated. Home of Bill Duke, Mindforce and a whole bunch of heroin. Also, it’s pronounced “puh-kip-see”.

A
AppliedJest · November 5, 2025

Thank you! I’m not American but I was sure it isn’t pronounced pur-keep-sea, but they kept saying it... I mean, Joe and place names is a crapshoot, but Nate too? I mean, I have *no idea* why I would care either way, but the vindication is real. Go [insert favored Poughkeepsie sports team]!

N
NowhereMan661 · November 5, 2025

Only America would create a for-profit freelance torture prison.

K
Kaiju and Chill · November 5, 2025

My fiancees ex-husband. His dad died from auto erotic affiliation. He sounded like a piece o f shit much like his son. Rest in piss.

L
Liz · November 5, 2025

As someone from the Poughkeepsie area, it’s killing me hearing yall talk about it. Red Hook is a tiny town near Poughkeepsie, not the neighborhood in Brooklyn Nate is talking about.

B
B-Reezy · November 5, 2025

Came here just to say this lmao

n
nughh · November 5, 2025

HOLY SHIT. That is some crazy lore your dad dropped, Nate

M
Matt · November 5, 2025

I thought they did this guy, I can’t remember where I actually heard of him. Maybe Behind the Bastards.

H
Hey mind your business, name's not important · November 5, 2025

A live show episode.

A
Al · November 5, 2025

I love when Tom makes both Nate and Joe groan while he cackles.

L
Luke Baumgartner · November 5, 2025

Been waiting for this one forever.