February 9, 2025

EARLY EPISODE: The Modoc War

Once upon a time, the US went to war against a small tribe in the pacific northwest, and, despite winning due to the massive power imbalance, they managed to get their asses kicked the entire time.

Sources:

Arthur Quinn. Hell With the Fire Out: A History of the Modoc War

Terry Johnston. Devil's Backbone: The Modoc War, 1872–3

Robert McNally. The Modoc War: A Little Indian War Goes Big https://www.historynet.com/the-modoc-war-a-little-indian-war-goes-big/

Kurt Nelson. The Modoc War of 1872.

https://warfarehistorynetwork.com/article/the-modoc-war-of-1872/

https://www.militarymuseum.org/Modoc1.html

https://www.csuchico.edu/alva/projects/2012/the-beginning-of-the-end.shtml

https://www.nps.gov/parkhistory/online_books/labe/intro.htm

Comments (35)

N
NowhereMan661 · July 31, 2025

Forcing people into open air concentration camps and then slowly stealing their land piecemeal. Where have I heard that before? It's almost as if this is a time honored tradition of settlers.

N
Noblese Oblahaj · April 7, 2025

I can't help but notice the parallels of doctrine and the failures thereof between this and American efforts in Vietnam. The concentration camps/reservations/strategic hamlets, the blind attacking into difficult terrain, the assembling a perimeter and enemy slips through, etx

B
Brendan Bonner · February 13, 2025

I was so proud of my students yesterday. I taught the long walk of the Navajo a few months back. I’m now teaching the Armenian genocide and they made a direct comparison of what happened.

L
Lee Duce · February 11, 2025

What wàs the "anal glands of a deer" comment about?? How did native Americans use them against the enemy? Pls halp 🙏🏻

B
Boils · February 11, 2025

There is no way the Donner Party tasted good. They were starving so you know that meat had to be stringy as hell.

T
Tom · February 11, 2025

That's the first time I've heard the phrase, "Tubal-cain" outside of "Newsradio".

C
ChipotleAway · February 11, 2025

This is Free State of Jefferson territory lol

J
Jsuman · February 11, 2025

Worked a register for a bike shop awhile ago. Lady came in rambling about nuclear reactors at the Denver Int'l Airport, the UN cutting the world population in half, chemtrails, etc etc until my boss kinda shooed her away. Only later did I realize that boss regularly indulged those kinda nuts and I was just in the line of fire for the nonsense.

O
Olafo Waffle · February 10, 2025

The lady asking for the fudge is grim like watching a slow sepaku

r
ruin · February 12, 2025

My first kitchen job involved a regular who wanted a BLT with a bowl of ranch to dip it in. Like, roughly equal proportions ranch and sandwhich.

J
Jordan Foster · February 10, 2025

As someone born in Humboldt county, CA and who has spent the vast majority of my life in that area, I am ashamed to admit I have never even heard of the Modoc War. I spent a ton of time around a few of the smaller tribes in the area, and am familiar with the Mendocino "War" and others, but our education on this is truly terrible, which is saying something considering I went to a highschool that was almost 50% native. Also, hearing Hoopa mentioned by Nate almost made me fall out of my chair!

B
Ben Schwabe · February 10, 2025

"Always Coming Home" mentioned! Great book.

M
MaidenlessBrewer · February 10, 2025

The only Tubal Cain mine I've heard of is here in the Olympic Mountains in Washington. You can visit it and a crashed B17 on the same day hike if you're ever in the area.

T
The Best Sean · February 10, 2025

Never knew the US military fought that guy with the huge head

i
iDoTechOK · February 10, 2025

Thanks very much guys. Great history here and always great humor. I don't know the answer either. I would've thought that teaching and talking about the holocaust very hot. Various holocaust would make things better but I think in some ways it's making it all worse. I don't know.

S
Star maker 75 · February 10, 2025

Since they are doing west coast history. I hope you guys do pig war. It quite something

b
big meg · February 10, 2025

My experience with the Colorado education system was similar to Nates in New Mexico. A very sanitized version of US history but the school had much more freedom in regards to state history were we lurned about the sand creek and Ludlow massicures and the various miner strikes that happened during the gold rush era.

W
Wolf0nKrack · February 10, 2025

As an external add of a New York American on to the end of the episodes monologue. I'd have to say this show and we'll there's your problem have taught me more about the world and other countries than anything my government has ever taught me, but my high school did have a decent Native American studies program interesting enough.

A
Alive Or Trees · February 10, 2025

It is not true that all landlords become bustards, I knew someone who inherited some apartments, he lived in one of the units that was empty. Tried to be a nice guy, ended up running out of money, and had to sell them to bastards who jacked up rent. You either become a bastard or find a real job.

h
have you heard the word of Maidens of the Fall? · February 9, 2025

Imagine somehow Trump flubs the whole new American fascism thing and JD Vance gets into office and is immediately ordered to present America's sepuku poem to God and that's how we get landback

h
have you heard the word of Maidens of the Fall? · February 9, 2025

God who, in this case, took way, way too many Nvidia graphics cards to build

L
Loquin Britton-Herndon · February 9, 2025

Also, my hometown was the capitol of Russian America, Sitka Alaska. If you want more Native vs Colonizer history, check out the history of that town (called Novo Archangelsk by the Russians)

L
Loquin Britton-Herndon · February 9, 2025

Oh hey, I *just* started Parable of the Sower and discovered it takes place right now so I'm reading on the date things happen (unless there's a fifty year time jump or something)

A
Allen · February 9, 2025

Also, shoutout to my fellow Northern Californians (Bay Area here, obviously not as far North as where the events described in this episode took place but still).

A
Allen · February 9, 2025

Re: Nate’s bit about “Northern Californian Kurdistan”, apparently a lot of people in Turkey believe that Native Americans are Turkic in origin—a theory that doesn’t work chronologically in terms of human migration patterns out of Central Asia, but obviously that doesn’t stop people from believing it…

r
ruin · February 12, 2025

It's Turks all the way down, according to those people.

L
Lain of the Wired · February 9, 2025

so what im getting here is that jefferson davis is just the alan smithee of american military history

A
Al · February 9, 2025

If only the white man had a cold can of white Monster.

S
Salman Khatri · February 9, 2025

Learned about both Klamath and Modoc from Fallout.

R
Redmos78 · February 9, 2025

It is fun when you cover what will later be known through Marvel.

J
Jack palmer · February 9, 2025

They built my highschool where 4 Modoc POW's were assassinated by Oregon militia. Grew up on the Lost River. Been to the lava beds hundreds of times. Shit hits hard when you realize your whole community, your whole life, was built on stolen land. We also had one of the largest Japanese internment camps ever built. But never a formal education on any of it.

J
Jonathan Grafton · February 9, 2025

Prequel to the Bitch Wars, but somebody misspelled mudak.

J
James Cézanne-Taipale · February 9, 2025

*Sigh* Puts down Coffin Troopers before I finish. Picks up Always Coming Home

L
LeobaL · February 9, 2025

A formal apology was issued to the First People in Australia in 2007. It is considered incredibly powerful to have injustice, abuse and trauma formally acknowledged, particularly given the previous Prime Minister said he couldn't see that anything wrong had been done. I agree with Joe, though, that an apology means nothing if it isn't followed up with action to alleviate the wrongs. While we've made some positive steps, we too have a LONG way to go. For instance, we still have to come to grips with our version of the residential system, and we don't have any treaties. Though given the way treaties were and are routinely ignored, I'm hoping one will be negotiated that has teeth.

S
Sparky · February 9, 2025

Your impeccable release schedule is incredibly comforting Joe ❤️