Mixed Bag of Holding: M&M Taste Test

Strawberried peanut butter is the best M&M. They were part of the transformers movies promotions and tasted like heaven

Team mini years later forever

I went in listening knowing what my favorites were, funny that toward the end they were between pretzel and pb. Agree on the snackability of the pb too, delicious but rich and a little nauseating after a bunch

Would love to hear yall do this with crazy oreos flavors

Ima let you finish, but peanut butter mini M&Ms are THE BEST SNACK OF ALL TIME.

Emily really channeled Nyak this episode, saying the peanut butter M&M was "heavy" is almost word for word something he would say.

This is an all-time Emily episode. A hall of famer. Lemon M&M. Calling Jake “Jack” when he defends her. The mom teaching aerobics of it all.

Thank you. I’ve been listening through lots while sick the past week+, it destroyed my holiday plan and it’s teetering on chest infection territory so not a lot has raised a smile. Em’s EmM&M&ms - and more specifically the razzing of Murph - made me full belly laugh (and then cough a lot - but so worth it!) Blessings on your house(s) 😉😁

CLADWELL MISTBORN MENTIONED 🔥🔥🔥🦅🦅🦅🦅

I love hoe Caldwell is literally on board for any bullshit that comes his way. M&M psychic, yes you can! He will gas you all the way up!

Emily and Murph are literally the blueprint for love. Murph is so indignant the entire episode but the second Jake tries to give Emily an M&M she can't eat he's ready to protect her from it

I am glad Murph defended milk chocolate from Caldwell's slander. What an absolute joy of an episode.

Caldwell “I really like almonds that’s why I like mounds” you mean almond joys rejected step-brother that notoriously doesn’t have the almonds

Caldwell is a Sanderson fan

“It’s not a journey, it’s a commute” -Jake, tasting an m&m

I've never heard of MnMs in a tube, but as a kid I got mini MnMs in a little cardboard box, like the ones lunchbox sultanas (rasins) come in. Those were kinda fun.

I've only tried classic, mini and peanut, had no idea there were so many flavours

I loved Murph making sure Em wasn't going to eat the (I believe) brownie one. When I was dating someone with a peanut allergy I swear I was more attentive to checking things were nut free than they were.

Caldwell: "Don't worry folks we're not psycho nobody is going to rate anything under a 5." Jake immediately after that statement: "yeah I'm gonna have to go with a 4 on this one" absolute chaotic energy love these episodes so much

Why couldn’t Em have so many?

I really relate to the way Emily rates things. My friends hate it 😂

Murph - "real ass nut in here" "no nut cloning going on here" classic

Welcome to mixed bag aka Murph freaking out for over an hour

props to murph for always playing the role of angry sane person

Jake: "What's the mean?" Caldwell: "There is no mean all M&M's are friends"

Given a loose idea like “M&M Taste Test” and the gang hits the classics: gaslight Murph, chastise Jake, Caldwell makes some weird strong opinions, and Emily just makes up her own game.

Pretzel M&M's are great. I love 'em. They are my faves. I love when you get a really salty one. Peanut is my second. Glad they liked the pretzel ones!

Gotta get Emily some Nestle Smarties, they do have different flavor shells!

What types to they taste? I want to join along and find the same ones!

Crispy M&Ms we’re the very best. Love that crunch

Whoa emily is literally psychic

Emily - I got a bag of mini m&ms today because of your hot take and I have to agree - they are pretty awesome

I love these kind of mixed bags because it's like Murph is a real person being tormented by Muppets.

Go Syracuse! Emily was definitely right about the Orange and Blue and I would like to award her an honorary Som&melier certificate from Syracuse University!

Eminemily

I love you guys and I powered through for the banter, but listening to you guys chew in this episode was an absolute nightmare.

NADDPOD content is always enjoyable, but this was a miss for me. Obviously, the band of boobs’ content is goofy and that’s why we love them, but this felt a little… off? Maybe too far outside of the realm of their normal content?

also - I pitch valentimes day strawberry (jam) chocolate m&ms into the ether

1. Peanut 2. Mini

I had a friend who refused to eat the orange and yellow m&ms because they tasted different and then we finally did a blind taste test and she didn’t guess any of the colors right. Still refused to eat the orange and yellow ones.

First off, this pod has proven that I will listen to anything these three goofballs record and post. Second! Proposition : millshake with mini mms at the bottom like a boba tea

Hard disagree, Mr. Dude Sky

The mini m and m hate is unacceptable

disappointing that jalapeño m&ms werent featured (imagine my surprise when i picked up a bag of m&ms in a hurry to get into a movie and crunched into a spicy chocolate candy)

Weird feeling to be excited to listen to people eat M&Ms and then talk about it

Maybe a bit doesn’t need to go for 40 mins

There's something about the way Murph says chocolate. I need to go to Walgreens.

I would have given up my entire dice collection for this to have been a video mixed bag.

These are my absolute favorite Mix bags!

Bro never again with the mouth noises please

Trolling and gaslighting Murph should be it's own podcast. So fucking funny listening to Murph lose his damn mind lmao.

This podcast is the 3rd source in the same amount of days to bring up the cadmium and lead thing just as I bought a big bag of dark chocolate coins

This is a master class on how to gaslightm Murph😂

Okay so this is totally my fault but if you have misophonia do not listen to this episode! Those chewing sounds of the almond m&Ms are going to haunt my nightmares!

No caramel M&Ms?

I love episodes where everyone just decides let's gaslight murph!

But which one should I fuck???

The fact that the tan m&m wasn’t even included in this conversation is a DISGRACE!!

Grab some Crispy m&m's while you are in Australia. 🐐 flavour.

Peanut butter M&M is the PB Beebee

My favorite are caramel! Also I wonder what you guys would think about the m&ms candy bar lol

The superior flavor is to take a sharing bag of peanut butter and a sharing bag of pretzel and mix them.

Jake. How can you forget the PEANUT ONES. All jokes aside, just saw you guys at the Melb show sat and had an absolute blast with my mates there. Was also lovely to meet you guys in person too :)

My wife and I are a split house on the blind m&m tasting. I’m with murph, but my wife is on Emily’s side. She said that the tests are inconclusive due to the colors mixed together in the bag causing cross contamination of the other shells.

Missed opportunity on a new “Tang v. Bang” scale

I hate to take such a hard stance but the objective best “pack” of Mnm is the peanut white/dark/milk mixture pack

Murph hasnt been gaslit like this since the dnd movies

Who else couldn’t hear them talk about “shooting the tube,” without thinking of the reddit cylinder guy

What is Emily allergic to?

Peanut butter M&Ms in a fruit and nut mix is... *chef kiss*...do it.

I don’t understand why Brian was so upset…

Mini M&Ms are the true GOAT 🐐

i liked this episode but it didn't smell very much like my mom was teaching aerobics 😔 6/10

Congrats Caldwell!

I know it would be hard to schedule, but I desperately need one of these taste test mixed bags to be done with Brennan.

Mini M&Msthe caviar of M&Ms! Emily in Caldwel are correct

Can’t wait to hear about where the fondant dick filled with mini m&m’s ranks!

Hey 2-Crew and all the sultry MnM mascots. Thanks for a perfect and definitely not flawed tier list.

I absolutely adore that Caldwell just doesn't like M&Ms

Blue M&ms are the yummiest

I pay mixed bag money to listen to murph knowingly lose his mind

Everyone gaslighting murph will never not be my favorite

9 minutes in and Murph is already yelling. This Ep is already a banger

The mixed bags are a monthly chance to listen to Murph get driven to insanity by the rest of the crew

The moment I read the title I knew we were in for multiple Murph freak-outs. I was not disappointed.

Made me laugh out loud during church oops. M&M/10

I love the bit of them gaslighting Murph that M&Emily got it right everytime no matter how off the mark it was hahaha

The m&ms should've been rated A-J

I live for the tiny Cosmere references that they drop

I used to work for Hershey selling chocolate so I sadly find this whole thing to be blasphemy😂

Toffee are the best. Need a retest so we can get the peanut in there too. An unforgivable oversight, Jake

No Crispy M&Ms?? Those are so good

This did make me buy some m&m’s and I forgot how good they were.

For next months mixed bag, if you guys wanted to continue the food flavor phad you could always order a bunch of variety flavors of Kit Kat from Japan or where ever you may find them locally. They have some bangin flavors, even green tea matcha I believe.

I am very excited for this. I hope there is justice for my pretzel ones!

Manga’s callback!!!!!

What? No palette cleanser?

Goddammit, I pay $10 a month, specifically for the mixed-bag and I DON’T get peanut m&m’s? Just kidding…did you find coconut?

Dude Threedom did this already

Every time they do something like this, it always goes off the rails and its usually emily that is the derailer. And yet murph is still suprised by it every time. Love these dorks

listening this after i got a haircut on saturday… is this what m&m’s is?

emily eating a peanut butter m&m like it’s a butterfinger bb

The rabbit trails that Emily’s senses go on are so fascinating it almost makes me forget that Jake neglected to get peanut m&m’s

My misophonia is going crazy, but the show is absolutely amazing

M&Mily is truly psychic. I can't believe she got every color right.

I can't wait for the Short Rest of this.

Mini m&ms are the caviar of candy

Emily being an absolute agent of chaos

Pretzel M&M’s seek vengeance

Wow. Disappointed in everyone except Em&Em! As a pretzel purist, this is heresy! And isn’t there a freakin caramel M&M? Hurwitz?

Thank you for this 💯

All the peanut m&m were taken by Lou Wilson you know he’s gotta have that funny little guy

Buying M&Ms on Jake time.

Hey Jake I was as the dollar store, want me to get you some peanut M&MS?

Upon hearing the selection (and not listening to the whole episode) I can’t believe you don’t have the insanely underrated Crispy M&Ms.

When I read this I thought they were just going to be ranking the different color M&Ms in the basic bag

This is the only podcast that can ever get me excited about m&M's

Agree with Caldwell - dark chocolate is the superior flavor

How do you "not find" the yellow bag jake?

Assuming Em didn’t need a spit cup for this one

Dice Christ forgive me, but I would have at most done a piss poor job at pretending to taste the peanut m&m.

Perfect thing to listen to on the way to the Sydney show!

Time to roast Jake in the comments

Oh I've been WAITING for this one

Peanut m&ms are OP