D&D Court: Bonus Cases - The Piss Cleric
Dungeon Court is STILL in session! Join Justices Murphy, Tanner and Hurwitz, along with the Benevolent Bailiff, as they continue to pass judgement on your trials at the table!
CREDITS:
Sound Mixing and Editing by Trevor Lyon
Dungeon Court Theme Song by Sam Weiller
Comments (108)
“Social climb your way to Scrooge - This show sucks” Counterpoint. This show in fact rules
Is it me or is the goose thing 100% because of Zac Oyama on Dropout being a goose killing knight? Anyone else think that.
For the whole Goose thing, why not just make all (or most) geese in your world monsterous beasts and just make the character arch being that the part tracks down to course of what's turning the geese into monsters, they fight some geese, lift the curse or whatever, and then BOOM you never have to think about geese ever again
When I run my middle school DND club, we have a discussion beforehand, 'Come on guys, we're at school. Keep it appropriate." Then encourage the heck out of their creativity. I've never had a problem
I'm dead certain they covered one of these cases before
The fact that Murph roles on the table is such a city pigeon move
Murph used metal dice for star struck odyssey and complained about it
I know the paladin didn't "roleplay" his character but when someone at the table finally engages who hadn't, i would never want another player to take that away from them. They Will never engage again and I've seen dms do that. Bad call judges
I didn’t know about the Fabio incident so I looked it up. In a People magazine Fabio said that the goose hit the camera and the camera shattered. A metal piece broke off and that’s what sliced his nose. “Fabio says the goose ordeal marked "the beginning of 'fake news,' because everyone said I was hit by a goose”
My friend is a middle school teacher who runs the D&D club at their school. Their strategy for war crimes is to have in-game consequences: the party gets a bad reputation and people refuse to help them, the clerics and paladins temporarily lose spell slots, etc.
GUYS I'm eating a steak with shrimp and potatoes. Is it a Murph and Surf and Turf or a Surf and Turf and Murph???
It’s a surf and Murph and turf
Caldwell, duckburg linked in guy is just Mark Beaks
DM Hunter here! My thought process for using the Wizard, a gnome named Simon, was in fact for him to be freed at the end of the battle! He did get freed earlier than I expected, so mixing that in as well as some great rolls by me and bad rolls by my players, I panicked. Knowing that Simon, as a character, is a true wild card and goes over the top with a lot of things; I asked as Simon if one of the players wanted him to “take care of the problem” and when the player said yes, I used Simon’s upcoming turn to cast Meteor Swarm, an over the top spell from a silly little guy, ending everything within the area and reviving the players right after “taking care of the problem.” At the time, I thought it was a funny and silly moment for a campaign that was meant to be funny and silly. But now I know that it had the opposite outcome. With that, I accept my punishment with the strive to write better encounters, not panic when things go south and to not fumble my chance to meet Scrooge McDuck. Thank you very much, Members of the Crit and special guest Jim.
Love that the wizard was a Gnome, pure gold right there👌🏻
Certainly the paladin overreacted but it’s fucking insane to put a goose in front of a player that opened the campaign with wanting to exterminate all geese and just be flabbergasted when they attack the goose they’ve been waiting all campaign to kill
This entire episode feels like I took acid and your ago and didn't realize it
In this episode, Emily fully believes Murph is a big metal die fan. This was a bit I'm pretty sure SHE STARTED somewhere else during Starstruck, where they joke about Murph loving big metal dice in relation to his big heavy balls. The Queen of commitment, everyone.
Raising Gunkizona?! Caldwell! I love it.
Campaign Idea: it starts as an escort mission. Take this kid, bring them to a point. On the way, for some reason, a bunch of religious zealots keep on trying to kill them. If the kid gets downed, an elder god that was trapped in this child escapes and now they're the big bad.
When I worked at Disney World, I worked by the pool, and specifically at Grand Floridian, there were always ducks on the pool deck or swimming around. My number one bit when a guest would point them out to me was “Oh that’s just Donald and Daisy. They’re doing a staycation. Celebrities need days off too”
I love asking the squirrels at Epcot if they were craving Mexican food that night
For the shattered D12 it should be put inside a new resin set and be born anew
Can we get some more TWILIGHT? pretty please we will be super good
I like this new version of Justice Hurwitz, he's much less wishy-washy now that's he's DMed. Didn't abstain once, decisive and slightly grouchy rulings.
In the defense of the first player, the gm said they made the kid "a major part of the campaign" but like... did they? It took the party a full year of playing to even find him so like. Couldn't have been that important, right? Emily was spot on there.
Alt title: Number 3 Cleric
We’ve already had a Number 2 Cleric in an earlier Dungeon Court, so we’re just missing the I’m Oneing Cleric
"sir, a second bird has hit Fabio" I NEED IT ON A T SHIRT
When Emily said he was reading to a classroom of children I started crying laughing.
“Reduced to ass” literally reduced me to tears. Hardest I’ve laughed in ages.
i think its full circle that the shitting themselves player from a dnd court long ago and the pissing themselves player are both clerics
"Codfish" is what Captain Hook called Peter Pan, and Sora
Reduced to Ass is the new HtC!
“Sir, a goose has hit Fabio” I laughed until I cried at that.
I gotta disagree with the justices on the goose hating paladins: while forcing a Vengeance paladin to acknowledge nuance among their hated quarry often works, you can't start with that. They break their Oath by working with their quarry, and they don't get as much of their shit against anyone else.
With any paladin, you have to have their Oath be the right thing and good in a few situations before you can challenge it. More importantly, I think the DM is just as much at fault for allowing a goose hating vengeace paladin with no backstory as the player is for playing it. I demand justice, and that the dm also get Fabio'd
Holy fuck I'm cooking dinner and the bush ear whisper bit made me have to wash my hands and sit down cause I started tearing up laughing
I feel like the entirety of Trinyvale and the Hardwon arc of campaign 3 should have given a bit more empathy to the piss cleric. If the Jampion, DS, and beans were anything to go by, everyone loves a stupid joke in a serious world. Hell, what's his name the fire giant drank his own piss upon his defeat
As they kind of implied, they are comedians on a comedy podcast, known for that kind of humor and it works in the room. The audience enjoys it. This bit the cleric was doing obviously wasn’t playing well. As Murph said, MAYBE the first time the cleric said it, it got a chuckle but like how could that have held up. Context plays an important part here.
Anti-Climactic?
The 7 flags at Maxiapolis
This episode has reduced me to ass.
Learning that Murph doesn't take care of his dice sets is scandalous and I, for one, am shocked. Simply aghast.
Piss Cleric is a bigger issue that is solved by a thorough session 0 or just draw the line somewhere and let them walk away from the table
great episode but also I am SOOOO excited for more trinyvale
Nnnooooooo!!!! No no no. Bush reading. Second goose. Nnoooo!!!!!!
first one: 25 sessions, 6 months. Damn my campaign is at 16 sessions at 8 months... and we've split the party in game / irl 3 times. Never say yes to a 7 player table.
That’s Sir Gunk, thank you very much.
I get the distaste for goose paladin, and being sullen at the table is a bad time, but a Generous Read here: if a first time player wants to beat up geese, spends the whole campaign not seeing any geese, finally meets one goose, and then is cast on by a team member and totally barred off from the one thing they wanted to do, wouldn't that be a really bad player experience? The sentence about the table being of 'various experience' with DND is also hazy. Is this person a shit eating veteran, or a newbie who had heard you were 'allowed to do whatever' in DND games? I love the Honk character and I think character growth is ideal, but why would you expect the person with a one-track mind character to not follow that track the First Time they actually have the opportunity? Why NOT have an army at geese at some point before this? I think it's easy to forget that there are many players that are uncomfortable with roleplay, it doesn't come naturally to Be A Character. Justice for the Goose Cannon Player !!
I was thinking the same thing. Maybe he’s quiet because doesn’t really get what is going on… why throw him a goose bone and then take it away?
on a very packed train hiding my hysterical laughter from “mr. bush a second goose has hit fabio” (i don’t know who this fabio is but i looked up the picture and he has lucious hair)
As a Ryan I hate getting mistake as a Brian. It makes me sooooo angry, It’s not like I’m some nerd with glasses or something…..
Mr. President Fabio's nose has been reduced to ass
Is this the sequel to the pooping cleric court case?
i would have kicked the piss cleric out immediately because they clearly have a fetish that i would refuse to play into.
That's what I was thinking, the first part involving genitals would be one thing but doing it a second time. It's the players barely disguised fetish.
“THATS NOT MY NAME. WTF.” “JAAKE, oh my GOahd.” Idk why but that specific voice Caldwell used itched my brain and also made me cackle
The geese paladin - https://www.tiktok.com/@makesomenoisedo/video/7492831918577306926
but enough about that
can’t wait for the triplets’ return!!
disney cm here- we once had a bird fly into the attraction i work. it refused to leave, fish & wildlife couldn’t get it, and it made it onto the second floor. birds love disney, confirmed (we were also closed down for the bird for 5 hours. blame the birds).
Saw a couple ducks hanging out in the elephant habitat at my local zoo last weekend, realized they got free admission AND a free up-close animal encounter
Murph — what do you mean all dice sets get mixed up??? Are you not meticulously separating them? Lest their luck touch??? … just me???
Also, never roll stone dice outside a padded dice tray!
Anyone else think the piss cleric is just trying to make the campaign about their kinks?
Think Hunter just gave his party too many cool magic items and built a way to get rid of them all
This was genuinely one of the funniest episodes in Naddpod history guys, I needed this! ❤️
I've had so so many dice that I've rotated through and I have one favorite dice that broke my terrible luck streak that defined my character for over 2 years. Just a bog standard slightly glossy bakalite-adjacent textured d20
Naddpod piss domain homebrew when?
In no world did I expect a 9/11 joke from Emily Axford in 2025 but here we are hahaha
Gunk 💜
minneapolis shout out !!
Absolutely wild that Jake's city pull from Maine was Bangor of all places 😂
“Dock her pay and work through July” is diabolical Jake 😭😭
Never let this man near a school, he’ll make the teachers suffer with less pay, more work, and the children will have to eat lunch at their desks
Murph was so right, the replacement die set I bought are cheap and Witcher themed and they fuckin rock
asses to asses, Disney ducks to Disney ducks
Just to play dice devil's advocate, considering the fact the rest of the table was also bummed by the lack of goose murder, could this have been a gift from the DM to the paladin? Like maybe the intent was to get more engagement out of this player by including such a specific thing from the backstory and that the attack was expected?
Our DM was very good at highlighting each of our characters, even with 7 of us, by giving each a spotlight moment. However, between you and me (and everyone else here), I really think our DM just had no idea what to do to highlight our paladin’s backstory when it was so limited
"when dice get too fancy then it becomes hard to read them" Rolled a nat 1 on the eldermourne d20 the other night. Didn't know what it was right away. <3
I think goose guy should never be invited to another campaign ever lol
He’s a good guy, I think he just likes to play a 1 dimensional bit character. This, however, while having its place at certain tables, is probably best suited for one-shots
Fabio getting hit by a goose at the opening Apollo’s Chariot at Busch Gardens mentioned
mr. president...a second bird has hit Fabio
The goose thing was just a Zac and Brennan bit from Make Some Noise https://youtube.com/shorts/v9FnPDUQSxU?si=tQ4JS1Jc8fSQq3DV
I had the exact same thought!!! But enough about that…
Hey Murph, Genuinely good advice for the middle school teacher! 🤙 That is all.
This episode was NOT reduced to ass
As a fellow middle school teacher who has run a dnd club for a few years my advice would be to take a step back. Find an older middle schooler who wants to dm, give them a module and show them how to run it, then chill at your desk and grade papers. You should still listen and step in when needed, like the story you mentioned, but they need space to do their middle schooler things.
Got the notification for this ep while in a zoom meeting with my boss and had to use every ounce of myself to not burst out laughing
Did not expect a Fabio and Twin Towers venn diagram
This is gold!!!
A second goose has hit the Fabio
EMILY. Geese FAMOUSLY migrate.
And she’s from upstate NY. Canadian Geese? Hello? Or in their case Bon Jour?
the cousin is a great dad in real life, so a deadbeat dad is his wish fulfillment character
Literally just now finishing listening to the Pooping Cleric episode from three years ago, can't wait to get all caught up and listen to this one in, like... a month.
Clerics are always the nasty ones, warlocks and bards can't compete.
not done the first court but im Extremely stoked to hear about THE PISS CLERIC
comin in hot with the piss cleric title lmfao
I was just thinking that it was a shame it wasn't out yet so that I could listen at work. Thank you for responding quickly to my prayers
Why's it always the cleric 😭
The title has concerned me
The Piss Cleric is a STRONG title, holy fuck
banger title
Let’s goooooo
Perfect thing to listen to while making protest posters!!
