D&D Court: Snitching Ponies, Wingman DMs, and Surf & Murph
AD-FREE EPISODE FOR $5+ PATRONS!
Dungeon Court is back in session! Join Justices Murphy, Tanner and Also Hurwitz I Guess, as well as the Flawless Bailiff Axford as they convene to pass judgement on your trials at the table!
CREDITS:
Sound Mixing and Editing by Trevor Lyon
Dungeon Court Theme Song by Sam Weiller
Comments (166)
is the baked potato flight PRE Spudfuckers???
murph and turf is just steak and potatoes... i want that please hahaha
The first time I met my husband was through a pseudo set-up at a game night, and I was NOT into him at all. Repeat exposure over time is the way to go to see if a spark could be there. Also, I would never waste an escape room on a first date. I'm in it to win it, and if they didn't pull their weight, the room would be ruined!!
I think the biggest issue with the boy who cried wolf’s dm is that instead of bringing up an interpersonal issue they had with their long-time friend, they took it out on them in-game, and then mislead them by saying “it’s just what my villain would do”
So ordered? More like spud ordered 🤣
Is Carl hot?
YES
Just wanted to note that circle of shepherd druids are widely considered one of the strongest and most problematic subclasses u can play. A lot of games ban them due to their strength + the tendency they have for slowing games down with extra turns in initiative. I don’t see how rogue combining with this would be especially strong - but definitely shepherd Druid by itself is powerful.
Horses don't draw with their hooves, they draw with their mouths. Paint is easier, and some can get pretty good at abstract art.
The fact that they have this conversation last week and now red lobster is having a revival right now is so funny to me
Murph saying Circle of the Shepherd isn’t known for being powerful made me give a full “HUH?” out loud 😭
Yeah i couldnt help but come here to point out how wrong he is. That druid making themself worse with levels of rogue is a mercy
A D&D campaign is way more important than a nine month relationship :P
I think pathfinder gives natural stat bonus to races but you can still make a strong halfling they just start at 8 before point buy.
You could remove all mention of D&D from the first two cases and it wouldn't change anything.
GUYS I'm eating a steak with shrimp and potatoes. Is it a Murph and Surf and Turf or a Surf and Turf and Murph???
Murph 'n' Surf 'n' Turf
The dating story from 11:00 was very easy to understand. I was laughing at how terribly murph was understanding it.
Pathetic and sadly common dog owners. No one wants to put foot down against their pet
A horse could definately ID a person, i mean they can count for crits sake.
definitely*
Caldwell gave me an idea for a session villain - one of those corporate facilitators whose whole thing is team building synergy nothing is worse than corporate icebreakers
Oh man this is too good
Murphs big natural Murphies have all the eyes on them.
Murph being unable to understand the dating question and assuming no one else understood was the highlight of this episode
Right? I didn't even think it was that badly worded.
How do they keep saying Carl without regressing to CarRol?!
eating the horses? damn, doesn't matter if he's playing hardone or not. jake really has a dislike for horses!
kugrash mention 🔥🐀🪳🦄
It is absolutely wild to expect Carl to figure out he was supposed to be flirting with Ingrid if nobody told him he was being set up. Most men are simply too dumb for machinations to work on us. Lol
That was part of the puzzle that he didn't solve
The bard and the barbarian don't need to talk about the girlfriend, Chris and David need to talk about the girlfriend. This is so far from being a D&D problem
Some of the most toxic submissions to date, dating your friends ex and bringing biting dogs to sessions??? Wake up or grow up people
This is off topic but I still think about how about a year ago Murph got everyone to stop saying Sweet Blue Hole by suggesting we save it for 2025 and then sighed a huge sigh of relief knowing everyone would forget
Thank you for bringing attention to this Dr. Eggman
Went to a restaurant today and there was an app called "Lobster Potato Boat". I think the Justices were on to something.
My "confession" being read on the pod is the highlight of my week. Probably month! Can confirm my ass was raw 😂
Sorry you’re going to hell, but it was a good story, filled me with dread
An escape room as a first date is brilliant. However, you can take it to the next level by running it solo beforehand. If you know all the solutions ahead of the date, you are fully set up to display so many admirable traits, “intelligence, reliability, patience”. You’re basically wing manning yourself.
My group solved the birthday problem, by have a group birthday in April and doing a secret Santa style gifting. Everyone gets a gift and cake, and no one feels left out. This year we even turned it into a sleepover, which was very fun
one big bed!
It’s very rare that Murph of all people derails the podcast. 🤔 Was anyone else slamming their head against their desk when they were explaining the Barbarian and Bard dating situation? 🙂↕️
I 1000% agree, my head hurts from all the desk slamming
Huge missed opportunity to order these people have their difficult conversations at a little place called mangia’s
The lovely lovely lovely lovely lovely baliff Axford
This dog story is crazy. A dog biting a person is not caused by other dogs. Maybe they hype it up but a dog that will bite a person, especially a friend, has a mindset that is way more dangerous than it seems and is absolutely the biggest issue.
Look up the breed. Malinois are notoriously very hard to train and extremely territorial and bitey. Not trying to justify, more the opposite. Regular ass people should not have these kind of dogs.
I WILL DO ANYTHING FOR NADDPOD LIVE AT RAINFOREST CAFE PLEASE 😭😭😭
All but one of these cases would have been solved by an adult conversation. No hints. No, hoping they intuit. And the "but one" case was the one in which the targeted player talked openly about their issue with the DM. Be honest about your feelings and intentions, things stand a better chance of working out
I absolutely wanted them to sentence the question asked for being frustrated the other dog owner wasn't "taking the hint". JUST TALK TO YOUR FRIENDS!
The dog one is crazy. Having an untrained Belgian malinois is irresponsible already, but then someone is just bringing their dogs without asking? And why are they 'hinting that dogs aren't welcome? You just say 'hey you can't bring your dogs to my place'. If they got a problem then they're also irresponsible. Wild.
0l p 0
Ugh the dog one is so stressful. Both owners are being so dumb. A poorly trained malinois is unreasonably dangerous to be around. Then adding TWO more dogs to that environment. Thats asking for a tragedy.
I do wonder if the pony thing is a bit of a cheeky shoutout to Skyrim in which horses absolutely can and do report you to the authorities for any crimes they witness you commit
i dont know if many other people know this but if u add "-ai" at the end of your google searches, it searches like it used to!
Oh word, I hadn’t even considered using Boolean search tools- I was just scrolling down- this is smart!
Potato murphado...
real👆🏻👆🏻🙂↕️
Obviously not the most important part of the episode, but as an escape room employee we can always tell who the first dates are. They tend to be significantly worse at talking to each other than most groups, which means that most first dates don't get out.
BLADES IN THE DARK REFERENCE?!!
The crew should totally play that!
“Your butt must be raw from all the ass pulls” 😂😂😂
The Barbarian/Bard situation might have been easier to understand with another way to refer to the people involved - perhaps fruits? Eg if apple was dating pear …
As long as Blueberry doesn’t show up, I hate her.
All I know is, after the first 10 minutes of this episode I am definitely making some baked potatoes for dinner tonight.
The song playing at Red Lobster will be “These Are My Crustaceans” by Oysher
Pull that Murphcord, baby!
Surfin’ Murph is my favorite 60s garage rock song!
We need a Murphs big naturals with two potatoes on it merch drop
How are we not having the person bringing unwanted dogs swimming in a suit of armor? Stop avoiding the conflict and tell them to leave their dogs at home or they're out of the game. This is a recipe for disaster for everyone involved and the Malinois is going to be the one blamed for people's stupidity.
The DM needs to stop hinting, he needs to outright be like "hey please dont bring your dogs anymore". it's the DM's house, what he says goes. Also someone was bit! Like come on
also does anyone know emily's substack? i'm following an eaxford but not sure if that's her ...
great ep!! i always enjoy y'all's silly commentary and insight on these silly situations. as a fellow introvert, i fully hear the anxiety about flirting in a group social setting. we had some friends where one of them thought the other was cute and we played some dnd together and they would help each other out with rules, but nothing ever came of it. you can't force anyone to hit it off, but you offered a great space for that sort of thing to happen in the first place!
Still waiting on pins and needles for the Trinyvale triplets in Barovia
Come on Murph. This relationship question is not hard at all... get it together man.
Heads up, if you set this function as your search bar return you'll eliminate AI responses! https://www.google.com//search?udm=14&q=search
what a week for murph--Gentlemans Fister on D20 and Murphs heavy naturals on NADDPOD. Happy pride lmao
Gotta give it up for the Gotches! (I’m including Wealwell cause he’s solid)
My honest opinion on the Bard/Barbarian "case" is that it wasn't even close to a d&d thing. I also assume the "DM" was actually the "Bard" but didn't want to come across as it. Anyways, point it, it wasn't a case and I don't know why it was included >_>;;
No it wasn't, not at all. It seems to me that recently more and more non-game "questions", like this, are being showcased. Im not sure why...maybe people just aren't bringing up actual game-play things anymore. Regardless, you are right, and I hope they get back to what this was originally.
Strength is not the only thing to consider when carrying that many potatoes, 200 potatoes all in a stack is bigger than a person. Like maybe they could drag it away but they would noticeably by pulling an ENORMOUS sack of potatoes behind them
Seeing Jake pull out his "If I Were You" experience was really fun, lol
Did anyone else get Formation stuck in their heads after all the “take [x] to red lobster”s?
I completely understood the dating question immediately, Murph and Caldwell clearly never had hs dating drama
It's not even drama is wildly straightforward lol.
Any Belgian Mal that is 1. Not well-trained, 2. Not given a job that it does 10 hours a day and 3. Stressed out is a dog that is going to end up euthanized. That is God's Most Intense Dog and it's bred to bite. I don't care about the cool table, this is an actual crisis waiting to happen.
Jesus christ people control your dogs. Imagine letting your dog bite your friends and not immediately changing the situation so it never happens again
Let's go Buffalo!
DM of the Boy Who Cried Wolf case, here! I wanted to clarify some of the things about the case that were brought up in the episode, since I wanted my question to be brief for the sake of submitting it. Firstly, most of the enemies that have been in this campaign did have knowledge of the party, and knew who the big threats were. The BBEG is The Big Bad Wolf, and another difficult encounter was with The Wicked Fairy who had been the right hand to the Wolf for some time. The encounter that was discussed in this particular question was with an enemy called Stingy Jack, who at one point was possessing/hiding inside the soul of the party’s Jack of the Beanstalk. He had gained knowledge of the party in their more personal moments, and was able to observe how they act in combat and get an idea of their strategies. He eventually broke free and gained demigod level power which is what led to the difficult fight. Another player that had haste cast on Boy was the one getting his concentration broken, and was targeted by Stingy Jack because of a personal vendetta. That entire combat was pretty difficult across the board with multiple other enemies under Stingy’s control (long story) but nearing the end of the fight Stingy was throwing a lot of focus on Boy to stop him from getting a bunch of summons that could pin him down. Also mentioned it as a reply to another comment, but the snakes weren’t Boy’s only summons he used. He had apes and giant ravens for damage and mobility respectively. The summons got such high HP from the shepherd Druid’s mighty summoner feature that basically acts as the tough feat for summons, and the bear totem spirit that gives a lot of temp HP to allied creatures within the effect’s radius. This isn’t even to mention his other utility spells, almost 30 passive perception, rouge’s reliable talent meaning he can effectively never fail a check that he’s proficient at, and more. I cannot emphasize how much of a silver bullet his character can be in so many situations, which is why villains that know about him are going to need to use that knowledge strategically. It’s also lead to me trying to get more creative with how to use skill checks and out of combat scenarios that can’t just be brute forced with summons, spells, or more commonly used skills. It’s been a great exercise in adapting to not only him, but all the other shenanigans my party loves to throw out at me. It just so happens that for this case, he was the most dangerous in my eyes. I appreciate the wise decision of the judges, and am currently planning a trip to the Red Lobster for some Murph and Murph. Might go out for some Pizookie after.
just....potatoes then? No lobster shells?
Yo, an advice podcast called "if I were you" sounds like a goshdarn gold mine. Then they talk about a segments podcast???!?!? The crew is on fire with ideas right now
Would be so cool if Jake would start it with that guy who played Yugo or something. Seemed like they had really good chemistry
Murph's Big Naturals merch when?!
Sorry Murph, but size absolutely factors into carrying capacity and you could not have chosen a worse example. A halfling with 20 strength has an equal carry capacity to a Goliath with 10 strength due to their powerful build. It does not matter in this case because carrying capacity is only halved if you are tiny. Small creatures are fine.
My first time dming was a game my bestie arranged as an pretext to flirt with a friend of a friend. I'm going to their wedding next week so I believe in the power of dnd based romantic machinations, but it's a marathon not a sprint
All the Carls are reminding me that we need another chapter of the Mavrus Chronicles
Big natural murphys, I’m trying to eat breakfast!!!!
For future Google’s if you put a curse word in the search it usually gets rid of the AI! So is Murph had asked “How much does a fucking potato weigh?” They wouldn’t have been any AI !
there's also free chrome plugins to remove google ai answers from the top of the results.
For your consideration- Hot Murphy, Murphy Sack, Lazier than a sack of Murphys, Couch Murphy, Small Murphys, Meat and Murphys, Mr. Murphyhead
I feel bad for the DM because either way he needs a new bard and barbarian. There goes the “save the princess” trope.
The mental image of ponies working with sketch artists to achieve detailed, perfect representations of every party member has absolutely ended me. Sitting laughing out loud, on my own, like I’ve finally lost it 🤣🤣🤣
Is Murph doing a bit as Amir during the Bard Barbarian drama case?
I feel like some how, against all the odds, these continue to get more unhinged every single time an ep drops lmao
Lobster Thermador is like a lobster twice baked potato we just save those shell and use them as bowls for the Mashed Murphies
with the boy who cried wolf case, I think dealing with the difficulty by doing AOE spells is great, but exclusively targeting that player for multiple combats is not. there are definitely combats in both d20 and naddpod where specific players were targeted more frequently than others because of their power, but it was also typically because of their relationship to the big bad (im thinking Beverly and akarot). having 5 rounds where a player just does nothing because they're "too powerful" is not cool, and I think targeting specific players tends to be more acceptable when its for one or two rounds and not the entire fight/5 rounds. like you're just making your friend not have fun cause you're trying to win dnd. its definitely fair to play to the top of your characters intelligence, but its kind of hard to believe that enemies in the world would immediately know to zero in on one player, they should know the whole party is a threat and probably that one of them is particularly difficult, but not necessarily immediately who it is or what to do about it (like murph said)
I mean, it sounds like everybody is taking it in stride, but I think it’s important to recognize that if this dog gets into the habit of thinking that biting is OK when stressed, the poor dog might bite the wrong person and get put down for it. You don’t bring animals to another person‘s house without explicit permission because the animal who lives there deserves to have their space respected. I think that is incredibly rude, and the person whose house it is gets to decide who comes over, human and canine alike.
We got a snake release case!
On the note of handling birthdays in game, my Pathfinder GM just gives each player a hero point for their birthday. Nothing crazy and we keep playing whatever the party would be doing but it's a nice gift to have for our PCs. Could just do a DM inspiration for the following session if playing 5e.
Release the big natural murphs mod for BG3 you cowards! 😂
BIG NATURAL MURPHS 🤣
I cant believe Murph kept his mic on for his piss break in this one.
I’m sure someone already told you guys but your spotify upload got messed up somehow and won’t play! Love yall, just wanted to give yall the heads up!
Hey! I think this is just a glitch on Spotify's end. If it doesn't resolve shortly, send us a Patreon message and we'll get it sorted ASAP. ~Caldwell
is Murph concussed?
as someone also afford unfortunately large naturals, sometimes the blood flow heads to the chest not to the head
“My husbands big naturals” and then a Murphy’s logo. Someone make that shirt for Emily!
Side note: Murph being unable to understand the dating scenario was insane. C’MON MURPH.
I need this. The world is burning and this is some of the only happiness left.
(hides chihuahua behind back) I wouldn't know anything about people having dogs that bite other people at all ever, but hypothetically I would think the person whose dog bit someone would want their dog to hang out in another room during dnd so they don't have to constantly keep an eye out for the next moment their dog might sink their tiny, tiny teeth into somebody's ankle. Hypothetically.
okay i know i just implied i wouldn't let my chihuahua hang out during dnd but that was before i got to the part about using the lobsters as minis, because putting him up on the table and rolling damage based on whose minis he knocks over or chews on seems like a foolproof plan for a session
In what universe do you bring two dogs with you to someone else's house?? I'm surprised the court wasn't more shocked by that.
Also the conflict avoidance in that case was so painful to listen to. My goodness.
Love me some big natural murphs 🥔🥔
Oh you know what, the circle of shepherds druid is multi classed with rogue - I wonder if they were able to summon a bunch of perfectly loyal, hard to hit and sturdy animals, have them count as allies, and position them around the battlefield to basically get perfectly reliable sneak attacks every round along with any poison damage from snake bites.
On top of disengaging and getting at least one if not more opportunity attacks as the enemy moves to engage with your character
I don’t know how many people go back through the catalog and listen to old episodes but I’m currently doing that it’s pretty rad that #NADPOD is still going strong. #TwoCrew #CarnalCrew
A phrase we use is “I apologize for doubting your superior intellect” and the Murph case players need to say that to the DM
Lol google does suck now
If a friend of mine ally ooped a potential relationship for me via dnd... I'd be so appreciative and I would try so hard to make connections with the single hot girl at the table... so obvious. What a dream...
The justices are right— the bard dating the barbarian’s ex should settle this out of D&D. As we all know, “D&D ISN’T ABOUT STEALING GIRLFRIENDS”!!!!
Re: the story about the bad dogs... It's kind of annoying to me at this point when people "hint" at things. Like we are all adults here please just say what you mean. Also a dog that has bitten people is a risk, I hope it doesn't attack any more people, dog bites are not something to play around with and if your dog is so untrained it's biting people you need to either train it right or get rid of it... like my mom got attacked by dogs and her nerve ripped out if her hand by the severity of the bite from some dogs that were just "poorly trained"
ok i guess i’ll be the one to point out jake’s (that’s his name right?) “nora ephron” for a date vibe i know he meant norah jones but i cackled
Spotify version is broken
😔
My favorite part is that if you get a lobster, you're probably gonna have Murphys with it. So, whether they have Murphys and and steak or murphys and lobster sounds good but also normal to me.
“You all would be so lucky to get my husband’s big naturals” *cackling*
Person who got bit here. The DM’s setup is worth it. We all have cushioned seats, custom dice towers, and the DM makes us dinner. He made his own custom table with a screen in the middle, there are lights, music, and there has even been a fog machine. The belgian malinois is genuinely unpredictable and scary, but the setting is so sick I will get bit for it.
Please, as someone who volunteers for a city animal shelter, tell your DM that his dog biting can get reported to the city!!! I wouldn’t want to see this dog get put down because they learned that biting was the way to deal with stress.
"Do you think they need to Hamlet this thing?" Murder everyone involved?
If I Murph You has got to be one of the all timer Segments!
Is anyone else having trouble playing the ad free episode on Spotify, it stops playing each time I hit play?
It does the same for me! I even tried to turn my phone on and off again but that didn't work
I hate to correct the supreme crit… but Murph & Turf would be meat and potatoes not lobster and potatoes. That would be Surf & Murph alas
corrected later in ep!
Murph & Terf punishment should be eating at Red Lobster with JK Rowling
I've worked at a burger restaurant for over 8 years. We cut 90ct boxes at a time. It takes both hands to carry but perhaps these potatoes weren't that big in the dnd scenario.
Don’t even JOKE about naddpod at the Rainforest Cafe, that’s an ideal day
You can keep a Google search from showing you AI by adding ‘-ai’ to the end of a search! I feel like that might change the game for Murph
That Potato DM is WRONG, the problem isn't the weight, it's the VOLUME, have you ever bought a bag of potatoes? There's like 30 at most, and the DM said the goblins had stolen 2 bags total, so that's like 60 potatoes, not 200
Unless they brought their own burlap, which is pretty reasonable for goblins Edit: also they're being shipped long distance so realistically they wouldn't be in store size bags
Love the discussion of Murph's big naturals
😂😂😂 I always ponder the story when I read the title. I was not ready for surf and murph
WHOA
wait, Jake sitting in as a judge for the SECOND dungeon court in a row? This is unprecedented. Has Jake finally shirked his "lowly" status? Or is this just all to build him up so high that his fall back down to lowliness will be all the harder on him? Can't wait to see
I have to assume it is a backdoor deal between Judges Tanner and Djark, same way he got so good at DMing for Skaldova, bribery
DND court is sycophantic, embellished drivel more often than not. Bring back "When Did Things Come Out" in place of a DND Court every now and then. Thank you
Everything ok David?
Are potatoes called Murphy's because of the whole Irish thing? Only stretch I can make on it.
it was a denigration term originally bc yes irish.
Whatever Emily says, I agree with her
Yay
DUN DUN
I ain’t never missing a D&D court
Lets fucking goooooo
Slay queens
