Radio War Nerd EP #246 — Arab Conquests, Part I: Pre-Islamic Arabia to Muhammad

Listening to this for 3rd time ! Thanks for putting these into collections

Lp

This has got to be a contender for top 10 or even greatest episode ever. I have never read or heard such a complete and clear overview of this story, including a thorough introduction to the society, the political economics, the bigger context of the surrounding empires, the cultural factors, the sturdy camels, and the key people involved, each introduced at exactly the right point. Have you reposted this because it's so great? It is. Also, in this episode the two of you are disciplined in asking the right questions, making the right interventions, and setting up his excellent outline. What a resource of memory and ability to sort it into stories Aamer has. Thank you.

Kudos to the guest for making this so easy to follow!

Fantastic episode all, really enjoyed the content and Aamer is a great guest.

Great exposition!

I'm a new subscriber and this is the first episode I'm listening to. Already completely blown away. So thankful to be hearing you talking about the memorization and oral repetition of very long, complex, hereditary poems. On a certain pedant aside, the procedures that these "poets" use are mnemotechnics, and are widespread in Amerindian indigenous societies as well. In fact the parallels are spot on, the Marubo (a pano-speaking indigenous group on the Brazilian-Peruvian border)have the "saîti" songs, which are enormous metrical, rhyming patterns that repeat ancestry all the way back to the "people before people". Really makes you think that someone like Benveniste, when he wrote the "vocabulary of indoeuropean institutions" (which is a great book to read along with this specific episode), was really tuned in to the global distribution of certain fixed structures. Of course Lévi-Strauss does this about 30 years later, but I'd like to imagine what knowing of these parallels might have done for early structuralism. Anyway so sorry for this winding "comment", this is just to say I love the episode and couldn't be happier with the subscription!

So the uniting of the Arab tribes and the birth of Islam is based around really amazing poetry?

Aamer is a very concise communicator and already one the all time best guests.

The important C20th Spanish orientalist Asín Palacios argues in his work 'La escatología musulmana en la Divina Comedia' that the great Sufi mystic Ibn Arabi was one of the main influences on Dante. The book also has an extended discussion of the significance of the Israʾ in this respect.

This website is really slow. Does anyone know if there's some kind of a way to auto-download the mp3 when new eps come out and bypass this terrible interface?

Robert Graves was of the view that Morrocan Arabic was the purest because Morroco had never been occupied by the Turks. Also, does high Arabic differ from lower(?) arabic in the same way that High German differs from Low German? That is, depending on physical geography. Or is the distinction more like Latin where you have vulger and (I suppose) posh Latin which is a class distinction?

Good conversation. But this all appears to be based on the "traditional" history first written down by pious Muslims almost two centuries after Muhammad is supposed to have lived. Tom Holland's book "In the Shadow of the Sword" is a good, highly readable narration of what 40 + years of critical historical scholarship has done to these traditions -- which are discussed in this episode as undisputed fact. In fact, very little is known of Muhammad.

Really great episode. Arabic is such a cool language. Hearing Aamer pronouncing the names and places is such a treat. Excited for the next part!

The Táin also has a section, right before the climactic battle, with a huge long list of chieftains, and you hear about how each of them had 3,000 men blah blah blah. It goes on for ages and just destroys your will to live. Anyway, I have two theories, not mutually exclusive, about the purpose of these passages. One of them is so that no matter where in Ulster or Greece or wherever these stories are told, you can get to the bit where you namecheck the local hero and give the audience the chance to cheer at the mention of their hometown. This is a very real phenomenon in pro-wrestling, where good guys will frequently begin their speeches by saying how great it is to be in (name of city). The other theory is that there were actually stories about all of these characters, and if you were an aficionado, then you would know those stories and recognise all of the characters in these lists in the same way that comic book fans can name every X-man. We just don't know those stories because we only know the stories that people thought were worth writing down, so we don't recognise most of these characters and naturally they just seem completely pointless.

Really great episode guys, I only knew this vaguely and without context. As an academic historian, the islamic world is still uncharted. It's either orientalist research by 19th century british explorers, or postcolonial tracts complaining about eurocentrism. Nothing in-between. At least that's the way it was for me.

This episode was exceptional. I feel like I just heard some summarizing the Koran, not offering any kind of serious analysis of any aspect of Islam. A handful of other books and authors are mentioned in passing, but it doesn't look like the information here came from anywhere but this one religious text. The worst was the comment that there's a "debate" on whether or not Mohammed literally teleported to Jerusalem and Heaven. Seriously?

Good episode. For some reason my eyes glaze over as soon as I try to read up on any history that could also double as theology. This episode managed to sneak some information past this mental block. Incorrect opinions on black metal notwithstanding.

This really makes me want to see someone walk John and/or Mark through playing crusader kings 3, now that the default map includes the middle east and north Africa

This is already an all time series and I'm not even done w the episode.

Helllllllll yeah 🔥🔥🔥