THIS WEEK IN VIOLENCE: Zombie Liberalism
2026, Week 7
This weekend saw the return of the annual Munich Security Conference, which began on Friday and is continuing as this newsletter goes out. On the first day, Pelosi gave a talk at something called the POLITICO Pub, billed by the publication for insiders and policy wonks as “an immersive experience inspired by the atmosphere of a Westminster pub.”
On the conference's opening day, former Speaker of the House and Democratic Party grandee Nancy Pelosi participated in an interview in which she provided a number of incoherent, meandering remarks on numerous US foreign policy issues of the day. Unfortunately, it wasn't the type of senile incoherence we've become acclimated to in US politics which at least has the benefit of being funny to watch. In fact, it was pretty terrifying.
This week, we're going to take a look at Pelosi's response to one question, on the topic of Iran, and examine what that answer (or non-answer) can tell us about the state of establishment liberalism as we enter the second quarter of the twenty-first century, and whether these obstinate, self-ordained standard-bearers of the liberal international order are sufficiently equipped to bring the fight to an ascendant Fascist International drawing the knives out on nearly every continent. (Bad news. Sorry.)
Rep. Nancy Pelosi talks Iran, potential Newsom presidency and more
Politico, Friday, February 13, 2026
Interviewed by Jonathan Martin
What do you want to see happen in regards to our posture toward Iran? And what is the best course there, do you think, going forward?
Well, we did it under President Obama, when we had the agreement—nuclear agreement. And then this president comes in and casts that aside. And so the Iranians were moving forward, and that was unfortunate, now that, now he wants…
I hope the president—I really hope when every time I read it, and i read all the papers coming here, he's sending another ship and all that—please don't take us into—
He calls them armadas, which… bit of an old word, but yeah go ahead,
Yeah it's, well, please don't be thinking about war, yeah, please, you know, the—let's see if we can… Let me just talk about President Obama for a moment. What he did was so masterful. What Kerry did as Secretary of State was genius. To get all those countries, including China and Russia, to be on board. And then to bring them in, so members could hear them say, we're on board, this is it, we're all the way.
To have Moniz, who's here, Secretary of Energy, be so respected by the Iranians because they know that he knew what he was talking about and all the rest. Every piece of it was so remarkable, and to have them, to stop the enrichment of uranium was a very big deal.
And then he comes in and overturns it and now… putting ships in the region. The regime is horrible. All the things about human rights and the rest of that are very important.
What's the best outcome there? What's the best outcome there? You don't want to see President Trump use force, but you obviously have concerns about the regime. So what's the best outcome?
Wait a minute, wait a minute, let's separate some things out. First of all, we all agree: Iran cannot have a nuclear weapon.
Right.
What he did made it more possible for Iran to have a nuclear weapon. And if Iran has a nuclear weapon, there'll be a proliferation of more countries in the region who want to have a nuclear weapon. So we all agree that they shouldn't have a nuclear weapon.
The fact that they have been so disrespectful of their own people is something that we hopefully can deal with diplomatically, but he's not going to go in there and, and, and, uh… we should we should give encouragement all the rest of that and we have been all of us for years—we've been worrying about the women in iran for a very long time but they're… we’ve got that; you've got a genocide in China; you've got what's going on in so many countries that is so wrong, and—any reporters here? I brought my newspapers here in a ‘Save Jimmy Lai’ bag, a ‘Free Jimmy Lai’ bag because...
He got sentenced, obviously, in Hong Kong recently.
20 years, yeah, the other day.
Do you think that the regime in Tehran could fall this year, though?
I don't know. I'm not on the ground there. I don't make any things about saying that. But they have one article of someone who said, I was in jail from his father...
He was born in jail, he saw—
He was born in jail, and now I'm for... His mom was imprisoned by the Shah. He was born in an Iran prison. And he says, I'm for the Shah's son to come back to power now, even though the Shah put my mom in prison where she gave birth to me. It was quite a... It was quite a statement. But it's... Well, it's one person, but it's indicative of some... I don't know if the Shah is... I don't think the Shah is necessarily... The answer maybe is... But… Again, if people... You know, everybody says never again for certain things that have happened. But they really… you know, you wonder if they really do care.
Is there a way to sort of bring about the regime following without using American force, I guess, is the question there.
Well, use economic forces, use economic, use, use, there are ways that cripple their economy. And some of that has been in the works.
It does feel very tenuous, though, the regime there, you know, more than it has in a long time.
I agree with you. I agree with you. But again, it's not about a threat from war. It's hopefully, it's more about just—weaken their economy, and that weakens the support they do have. Because they do have support in the rural areas and the more conservative imams and all the rest of that. But we have to make them feel the pain as well.
If you were able to discern a single coherent point from that meandering exchange, then congratulations: You may have a future in the leadership of the Democratic Party.
With a political career that is now entering its sixth decade, Nancy Pelosi is the machine politician’s machine politician. Having served as a member of congress from California since the second Reagan term, and as the leader of the House Democratic Caucus from 2003 to 2023, Pelosi is unquestionably one of the most powerful and influential figures in the upper echelons of the Democratic Party.
Her twenty-year term leading the House Democrats, whipping votes and keeping members of congress voting along party lines, and brokering concessions, compromises and exchanges, is one of the longest in House history. All but her staunchest and most recalcitrant political detractors, be they on the right or the left, readily concede that in this role, Pelosi was an incredibly effective politician.
Even after stepping down from her leadership role in 2023, with a unanimous vote handing the reins to charisma vacuum Hakeem Jeffries (reportedly her personally preferred successor), Pelosi has continued to function as a conduit for the thoughts and perspectives of the party power brokers.
All which is to say that even today, when Nancy Pelosi speaks, she is never speaking solely for herself, and always on behalf of a much larger and more substantial political contingent.
Her half-hour discussion with POLITICO’s politics bureau chief Jonathan Martin provided some useful insights regarding the Democratic Party’s thinking on a range of topics: On the current Trump administration and their systematic violation of both constitutional and international law (all will go back to normal once the Democrats retake the House in the 2026 midterms); on her successor Hakeem’s performance (nothing negative to report); and on potential presidential candidates for 2028 (California Governor Gavin Newsom getting a positive mention).
On other topics, Pelosi’s speech was revealing in ways that were all at once concerning, alarming, infuriating and contemptible. Her serpentine response regarding events unfolding in Iran, quoted previously, was exemplary.
Pelosi’s hedging on the Trump administration’s current ramping up of hostilities against the Iranian government and its people captures the essential incoherence of establishment liberalism in the twenty-first century, particularly as concerns foreign policy.
The leadership of the Democratic Party cannot meaningfully impose the illegal, belligerent actions of the Trump administration, because they ultimately support the objectives and ends those actions pursue.
This is true for the knocking over of the Maduro government earlier this year; desired subjugation of Mexico and the western hemisphere more broadly; reorienting the US war machine toward an eventual military confrontation with China and; more immediately, the aggressive tightening of economic strangleholds on both Cuba and Iran whether as an alternative, accompaniment or precursor to military actions which, in both cases, have for decades been treated as a foregone conclusion.
And so, in Pelosi’s remarks on Trump and Hegseth’s vulture-like circling on Iran, we get a lot of tacit endorsement of the various factors necessitating yet another US military action in the Middle East. There is a vague agreement that something must be done, followed by even vaguer assertions that, even so, the thing to be done should not be the thing being done.
Aside from being intellectually vapid and ideologically hollow, this is an argument which almost inevitably bolsters the ‘Men of Action’ who populate Republican and right-wing governments more broadly, who then use this dithering to slather themselves in the glory of being He Who Dared Do What Must Be Done.
And so, in this cul-de-sac of prevarication, what does Pelosi have to offer? Naturally, she frontloads her answer with a hefty dose of nostalgia for the Obama era and the brilliance of the Democratic administration which both laid the foundation for Trump’s election in 2016, and the apparatus which then failed to account for the paradigm shift his election inaugurated over the decade that followed. At a time when regular people are looking around for some to identify Trump’s criminality and vow to put a stop to it and exact costs, nothing inspires confidence like a figurehead of the ostensible opposition saying, “Remember a decade ago?”
Pelosi’s reference to the 2015 Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) or ‘Iran Deal’ is telling in that it repeats an omission that is chronic in mainstream recollections of that process: That that agreement depended upon, and so revealed a willingness of the Iranian government to come to the negotiating table and work with both the United States and the European Union to limit its nuclear programme—the military dimensions of which had always been far more debatable than US foreign policy reporting would suggest.
Moreover, it once again elides the fact that, acting in good faith and sacrificing whatever nuclear aspirations it had, Iran was rewarded scarcely two years later by Trump throwing the entire process in the trash, and two years after that assassinating one of their most respected military generals in a thuggish and potentially illegal assassination.
From then, Pelosi’s response veers off into a morass of platitudes and aphorisms which convey that rudderlessness of establishment liberalism in the post-Trump era. A throwaway comment about “human rights and the rest of that.” Way to sell it, Nancy. Reference to an alleged genocide in China, a non-sequitur. What does this have to do with Iran? Another digression onto the topic of a Hong Kong political dissident who is currently in the news. Again, what does this have to do with Iran?
More revealing, then, is Pelosi’s total inability to respond to the ‘what next?’ part of the Iranian government’s ouster. To justify the toppling of the government which rose to power overthrowing the Shah Reza Pahlavi—a dictator so brutal that when he sought amnesty in 1979 he was refused it by… the United States—Pelosi makes reference to an essay by a man who was born in prison because his family had been imprisoned by… Shah Reza Pahlavi.
Now that the US and Iranian governments have collaboratively eliminated all other potential challengers, the putative inheritor of Iranian rule is, Prince Reza Pahlavi, son of the toppled Shah, who has not set foot in Iran since 1979, who currently resides in Washington D.C.
Does Pelosi, then, support his accession to the throne and the defence of liberal democratic values by… restoring a monarchy?
Again, she veers, meanders, mumbles, who knows. Something has to happen. She doesn’t know what. She doesn’t want to say. She doesn’t have any clear or concrete ideas. But the guy in the White House is moving an armada into the Persian Gulf, and so, presumably, if something does end up happening which moves the chess pieces closer to endgame, however bloody, she certainly won’t complain.
In her last remarks on the subject, Pelosi brings up the topic of sanctions, economic warfare, and perhaps inadvertently tilts her hand regarding that peaceful weapon we discussed in a recent episode. Despite the decades-long US sanctions regime against Iran having already inflicted economic devastation on the country, particularly in the years after Trump destroyed the JCPOA, Pelosi believes the vice’s grip and be tightened further still.
Her suggestion appears to be that yet further economic sanctions might succeed in spreading the immiseration beyond Iran’s urban centres, where the damage has been mostly immediately visible, and out to the rural areas, which skew more religiously and politically conservative and where a large proportion of the Iranian government’s base resides.
On this note, it is worth remembering that the current Iranian government seized power deposing the operator of one of the most brutal and murderous secret police organisations of the twentieth century, SAVAK, and where those now-romanticised images of unveiled Iranian women in western dress elided a political system in which many of the more traditionalist and religiously conservative members of Iranian society were politically, socially and economically marginalised and oppressed.
Given these facts, it should not be difficult for outside observers to understand that there is still a sizable chunk of the population who support the foundations of the Iranian Revolution, even if they oppose how it defends its government. It should also not need explaining that popular opposition to the increasingly repressive theocratic government does not then axiomatically reflect a desire to be thoroughly westernised and incorporated into the United States axis at the barrel of a gun. But again, this is the end American powerbrokers desire, even the nominally liberal ones, and so the barrel is likely what Iranians of any and all denominations will ultimately get.
And so, what Pelosi’s reference to yet further tightening sanctions reveals is a belief that, contrary to the myth that targeted sanctions only harm specific figures and organisations in a target country, their failure is that they have not yet immiserated a large enough proportion of the regular, civilian population, and who must therefore be made to suffer even more, until they make the correct political demands. The mission of American is to spread freedom and liberal democracy, and this is a process which is often better achieved with stick, rather than carrot. Go figure.
Most vile, and revealing, among Pelosi’s comments, however, was the following line, slipped in around her incoherent babble about the Shah:
You know, everybody says never again for certain things that have happened. But they really… you know, you wonder if they really do care.
For anyone unfamiliar, the ‘never again’ is a reference to protestors who have used the ‘never again’ refrain of Holocaust commemoration to challenge Israel’s ongoing genocide of the Palestinian people and the complicity of Western governments in carrying it out.
Amidst the ongoing crackdowns against protests and uprisings in Iran, alleged numbers of Iranian civilians killed or executed have abounded.
Many of these counts vary wildly, and are difficult to substantiate. Political factions who support Israel and their ethnic cleansing in Gaza and the West Bank have then attempted to use these body counts and supposed silence from the pro-Palestine camp to ask why they haven’t protested with equal fervour on behalf of the Iranian people.
(One quick and simple answer is that their tax revenues are not being used to supported the Iranian government the way they are to fund and arm Israel. Another might be the questionable utility of protestors picketing western governments in support of their own extant policies regarding Iran. Though conservatives and right-wingers repeatedly refuse to understand this, showing support and approval of government is neither a historical nor a logical function of protest.)
Nevertheless, Pelosi’s cynical, throwaway remark there reveals the glaring contradiction that emerged at the heart of establishment liberalism as we entered the 2020s, particularly as concerns foreign policy, and which continues to hamper their ability to meet the moment or respond meaningfully to this rapidly changing arrangement. Israel.
As regards every single issue Pelosi spun out to try and provide a suitably vague non-answering answer on Iran, her professed values smash on the rocks of the Democratic Party’s ongoing support for Israel – as is the case for every other establishment liberal party or organisation across the western world.
Hostility and lack of trust with other governments around the world to engage in diplomacy and peace deals with the US? Israel. The destabilising effect of a country in the Middle East possessing a nuclear arsenal? Israel. Concern about human rights abuses by foreign governments? Israel. Arguing for the plight of political prisoners, imprisoned for fighting for their basic political freedoms? Israel. The dismantling of the entire liberal paradigm of global governance as exemplified by the Obama presidency and its supplantment by a racist, authoritarian, militarily belligerent one which believes in the all-encompassing potential of force and violence to legitimate and determine political arrangements? Israel.
Going back much further than October 7th, 2023, the west’s ongoing, unwavering, ironclad support for the State of Israel—a structurally racist and authoritarian religious ethnostate which operates a system of open apartheid and whose political system is now tending toward outright fascism—has been a fatal contradiction at the heart of the entire liberal project. But after the events of that day, and the brutal slaughter Israel has unleashed upon the Palestinian people ever since, that contradiction has become so completely exposed as to be untenable.
A few months back, the journalist and media commentator Adam Johnson coined a term to describe this phenomenon: Zombie Liberalism. A bizarre performance of continuity liberalism in which it is perpetually 2022, where the horrors of Gaza and the liberal order’s complicity therein never happened. A world where the structural relation of liberalism to reality is inverted. Where the issue is not that liberalism has failed to adjust to the material circumstances as they now exist, but that the world has temporarily veered from the liberal norm, which is a force as universal as gravity, and so all that is required is to wait for the world to spin back onto its axis.
It is ironic that Pelosi made such an asinine speech at the Munich Security Conference where, just a year earlier, Vice President J.D. Vance shocked Europe into action when he made clear that Europe could no longer rely on the US for security. A year on from that, European leaders finally appear to be awakening to this new paradigm and making alternative arrangements. Whether these adjustments are or will be good or bad both remains to be seen and is, in this instance, irrelevant. What matters is the simple acceptance that things are now different.
This is what makes the staggering and naive denialism at the top of the Democratic Party in America right now so disturbing. It is one thing to deal with a right-wing US government pursuing violent, belligerent and destabilising actions around the world because it has ceased to care about moral authority, political multilateralism, global uplift, or any of the other convenient yarns it has spun for the past century to legitimise its actions around the world.
It is entirely another to reckon with the fact that the people who might ostensibly challenge and disempower that government still believe in those yarns against all evidence to the contrary, and so may very well stand by, acquiescing impotently to the Reality TV administration’s spiralling aggression, not because they share that government’s politics chapter and verse, but because they simply don’t have anything else to offer.
And like the FOX News logo burned into the corner of TV screens from broadcasting the same channel for so long in perpetuity, they’ll keep reciting the same exhausted, incoherent script because, burned in, not only do they not have anything else – they can’t even see what’s actually on the screen.
Comments (1)
I'm going to be voting a full democratic ticket for the foreseeable future because Trump and anyone allied with him is just the worst shit, but I had no faith in the democratic party to actually do anything to change, well, anything. It feels so bad. I can't even talk to members of my own family about the obvious horrors Israel is committing and we gleefully support. I dunno man just needed to vent. It feels bad
