The Slenderman Stabbing [Ad-Free]

All the comments complaining about this, i really hope they just ignore the screeching. I liked the episode and those people dont speak for everyone.

I blame the parents of the little girl that seen the signs and did nothing

The way you say our Wisconsin town names is horrifying

honestly i dont want true crime just cause it feels too repetitive of the red thread

Revisiting this episode on Patreon. Have to say, never been diagnosed with schizophrenia, just Schizo-personality mumbo jumbo at one point in my life. There were times at my lowest where I was genuinely terrified and would cry when it came time to go back to my apartment, because there were 3 different *insert the creature meme here* that lived there too. In my mind, I KNEW it was all inside my head, couldn't harm me, weren't real, etc., but it still held so much power over me. Looking back, it's still terrifying to know just a little of what our mind can to to itself. Okay, Nick trauma dump over with. Stay creeped

It really rubs me the wrong way how the article or whatever is being read calls the girls monsters. Especially after showing multiple times the mental illness that was present and how at least one of them believed, that they had to do that to save their families. The girl that got attacked is of course the main victime here, but a story can be tragic in more ways then one

I know this is old, but gonna give my two cents that no one asked for: while I like true crime, I like when it is done respectfully, and this ain't it chief. Please think before having Hunter voice act real people going through real traumatic and horrible events. What the fuck was that. I think you both have done true crime in respectful ways on your own channels, so idk why this was done in such an awful way. I get covering this story because Slenderman is so prevalent in the community and it could be good to acknowledge and cover, but you would need to cover it in a very different manner, it can't just read in the same way you cover fictional stories.

Holy shit, for people who are paying for their patreon, y’all are complaining an awful lot. Seeing alot of personal requests and gripes. They can’t make all of you happy lol. Stop depending on them to do exactly what you want them to do. You joined the patreon for extra content, not for them to dance like a circus monkey for you. (get outside more)

I avoided this episode for a while because I’ve heard the slenderman stabbing story many times, but they’re take on it was really unique. I haven’t heard a story that more focuses on Morgan’s point of view. I didn’t know the extent of her mental issues before coming across slenderman.

I’m hella late on this, but as a person who lived in the town where this happened, it was the equivalent of them mentioning Voldemort in Harry Potter and I wanted to comment it’s pronounced “Waaa- Kesha”

Woah, Isiah was 15 when this happened, meanwhile papa meat was 31, whata old head.

Could be the world’s most sensitive fan base?

I’m only at the start but I am curious if they go into the abuse the two perpetrators faced by medical staff while incarcerated. It’s horrible to think that this crime originally only had one victim who luckily survived only for doctors and in one of the girls cases her own parents; turned them into a new set of victims via withholding medications or overdosing or underdosing them. This was to be able to plead insanity but all it did was make their mental issues worse. Like yes what they did was horrible, but to torture children, even children who are capable of evil acts, takes another degree of evil to do.

Was not a fan of having a true crime episode, tbh. I'd be okay with this being the only one. Also, requesting the rest of Stolen Tongues.

This comment section makes me hate this fan base 😂

My Dad was the one who found the two girls on the side of the road and I have to say it is very strange hearing Wendigoon say my last name.

You guys are reading a scary story but this time it isn’t fictitious. It’s something that really happened and I think that’s cool and a nice break so I appreciate it. It’s more interesting than reading dumb slop.

Nobody's gonna read this cause it came out 2 months ago but scrolling through the comments I think people acting a little performative on how "distasteful" this is. I stopped listening to this one because, I mean I already heard it. It wasn't that long ago it happened, Hunter already covered it, this was just information I already knew but told way slower so I didn't care. Disregarding the fake pearl clutchers in the comments, I think there IS a way to creepypasta-ify true crime and have it not be just the same info but slower. Legit just go into it like it's a regular creepypasta, change names, create characters and write from hypothetical perspectives and then at the end reveal it's based on a real thing that happened. Like you could do a fictionalized version of Mary Vincent or Amber Tuccaro's story and they would sound completely unrealistic, so at the end when it's revealed not only is it something that really happened there was a MASSIVE miscarriage of justice in both cases and that in of itself is horrifying. Again, ain't nobody reading this, but I feel like doing a fully fictionalized retelling of the events gives enough leeway for the regular jokes so nobody has to act offended by it and at the same time it makes the real details that more horrifying.

Great episode. I like you guys throwing in one of these real life stories every once in awhile.

Y’all are so annoying💀if the girl actually died I’d understand but she was badass enough to escape. Until I see her complaining than I don’t wanna hear it😂

Too respectful for my tastes, be worse next time guys

We complain when they read stories we don't want, we complain when they read stories we do want, we complain when they try something new other than a story, there truly is no winning for them. Love you boys and appreciate all the hard work that goes into the show

Day 805 of requesting- Would be cool to watch you guys read through a collection of classics from the Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark books. There's three volumes so lots of good ones to pick from. They're also banned in a lot of schools now, thankfully not until after I graduated because I loved them and they scared the hell out of me, especially Harold the Scarecrow. It would be an awesome grab bag episode, not to mention the artwork by Stephen Gammell is excellent nightmare fuel. Plus: since it was a compilation of stories and folk tales, Alvin Schwartz, the author, did footnotes at the end of the books detailing some of the origins and variations of the stories, etc.

Wa-ke-shaw

Walk-uh-shaw

I liked this. I really did. For me, it just worked as a fairly serious reading of a tragedy, with some humour thrown in here and there which felt generally tasteful to me. They showed a lot of respect for Payton, and took care to highlight the details that deserve attention and consideration. To me, the episode felt a lot more about what actually happened, and how devastating it was, than about putting on a show. I guess I see the criticism, since Hunter and Isaiah themselves didn’t feel much different as personalities, but it just seemed more like humans reading about a crime case, and having natural reactions, than hosts making a spectacle out of it. As for the concerns about this becoming a regular thing, I don’t think that’s the plan - I think they chose this case because it was related to Slenderman, and the anniversary was coming up, so why not remind people about it, you know?

-, x,,

For various reasons i just listened to this episode almost a month after release so i don’t know if in future episodes they mention any of the comments here. But i didn’t see anything wrong with this episode, like hunter said they were just injecting some brevity breaks into this horrible story. I understand the comments saying they come here for goofy stories and jokes but I appreciate the guys wanting to branch out and try something new. I enjoyed the episode 👍

Heyo party people. I'm quite a bit behind and I'm binging now to catch up. I see a lot of really upset people in the comments sometimes. I'm just happy to listen to them read and chat so I feel like people are overreacting or becoming entitled about this sort of thing like begging for them to read your suggestions. I was under the impression this was a donation subscription with ad free posts and some occasional complementary exclusive content.. It's kind of disheartening to see so often people ripping on them for not doing their podcast the way other people want them to. Idk if anyone else is lagging behind like me but I hope the comments don't poison the experience for those of us not in the moment

Yeah I love the pod but idk it just feels weird when youre talking about a little girl stabbed 19 times with side tangents of "yeah this must've happened with V-bucks aswell" any other fake store it'd be funny but idk about this

Just rewatched the Jeff the Killer video on papa meats channel. I'd be down to see the occasional episode where they deep dive into crime stories that had been connected to stories or something. Creeps in the Crime? Creep Crime? Throwing out ideas lol

i lived in a county not too far from where this happened, and as a kid the same age as the girls who was also into creepypasta, everyone looked at me like i was gonna be the next in a news headline. i even remember my parents sitting me down and making sure that i knew the difference between fiction and reality. scary times. also more of isaiah trying to pronounce wisconsin city names lmao say Oconomowoc

Can’t tell y’all how much I enjoy the podcast, and I think it’s fun when you change the pace every now and again. Whether the stories are fictional or based on real-life events, they all possess an element of horror. Your observations, experiences, and banter make it all the better. That’s what I come here to see, and you always deliver. Inspiring work, truly.

I really dislike this type of content for creepcast. This is coming from a fan of both their channels. I feel like you should just keep the scary stories/videos.

I don't know who this comment is for but whatever. I think what pisses me off the most about this episode is the absolute terrible comprehension coming from the comments. This ENTIRE episode I was horrified because they were able to paint such a clear picture of the events that no documentary or article could ever have achieved and it's so obvious from the start that Isaiah and Hunter both talk about this tragedy with a heaviness and understanding of what they're talking about. They never once made fun of Peyton, any of the parents, or of the event itself. The only jokes they ever made was about their younger selves and making overexaggerating examples. Im dumbfounded to be reading comments on Patreon, YouTube, and Reddit that say they stopped 15 minutes into the episode because that's exactly where the story starts with no jokes ever being made. They could've done a way worse true crime story to cover but this one is one of the rare stories that has a happy ending. Hearing about Peyton and her indominabtle human spirit was inspiring and makes you realize how powerful the will to live really is. If you don't feel comfortable with true crime or just don't want to hear anymore then that's fine but to not even give it a chance and bash on the both of them for not reading another shitty story from 15 years ago is stupid and childish. The story also paints an important lesson for any parent whether new or experienced and that is to always check in on your kid and their mental health because sometimes you can stop what happened here.

Im glad the first detaled documentary was narrated by them, for me.

This was a great change of pace. I thought covering this was very interesting and entirely in the realm of what should be covered. I think this was very important to cover, especially near the anniversary. I appreciate this small step!

I can see why people are complaining about treating this with seriousness, but at the same time I don’t want the boys to think they can’t cover stuff like this. This episode is a breath of fresh air to me. I like that they took a detour to something real life, and I hope they do it again some time.

I somehow missed this episode, so I'm a little late. But if you haven't watched the interrogation of these two girls it is sureal. I believe EWU has it on youtube. And it's not to gawk at, but to observe the absolute confusion of the detectives as these two small kids describe Slenderman. Overall I think EWU does a good job persenting that kind of content with respect and expert opinions.

Me looking through the comments to see people make fun of them for mispronouncing Wisconsin town names but it’s just people complaining about the episode.. 🫪

I’m not disliking this SPECIFICALLY because it ties to a creepy pasta. If they did a true crime episode on like Ted Bundy I would be extremely disappointed; it wouldn’t have any relevance to what the podcast has built up.

I have no idea why people are hating so much on this? I actually loved this and we forget that this is THEIR podcast. They can release an episode of them farting into a paper towel tube and I would watch it. I really liked this and I hope we get more material like this in the future 🖤

Walk-eh-Shaw

Any content from the boys i lap up! So lucky to have Meatcanyon, Papa Meat, Meaty Magic, Wendigoon and Creepcast. I never have to wait long to see something new from the fellas. People complaining in the comments really saddens me as we are lucky to have these people in any capacity. Glad that the whiners dont influence them at all. Keep on putting out great stuff guys. Changing things up takes guts and I personally loved something different. Lots of love ❤️

I'm just here for the wonderful banter and chemistry of the hosts in an effective audio format. Found the pacing of events covered to be a bit awkward or sluggish at times, but the bit about the inept K9 unit killed me. Glad you guys happened to pick a story with a happy-ish ending to test waters with. Wouldn't mind more of this to be honest. Maybe sticking to conspiracies, unexplained mysteries, or occult folklore instead attempted murder cases and missing person cases would be the play if you guys revisit the format? Keep things a bit silly given the spontaneous backlash over subject matter.

i get why this episode was made because it was a real tragedy surrounding a creepypasta i hope they dont make it a regular thing and if they wanted to just make it a seperate podcast i just dont see how this can go forward that being said this was a great episode for what it was

Y'all will literally whine about ANYTHING. This episode was great.

Excellent episode 👍 I'd like to suggest a few stories. My property isn't normal, Cerber: Uber for the paranormal, and Dirty Work Inc.

was this as poorly received on youtube or are the patrons just being babies? i don’t see how this was any more tasteless or disrespectful than any other true crime podcast. i don’t even like true crime and i would call this a solid episode

What a comment section. 30% mild criticism directed more at the general concept of true crime than the hosts themselves, 70% dickriders crashing out. My dad could totally beat up your dad, he has a motorcycle 🏍

Glad I'm not the only one that thought this was in poor taste. I'm mostly confused on what it is theyre actually reading?? Like why is a real life tragedy being written and read like a creepypasta with creepy music in the bg and voice acting? Where did you guys get this "story" version of it? Still love you guys and i hope that if you want to do something like this again in the future you approach it with more sensitivity and carefulness.

For those that "LOVE" this episode, you'll have fun with RottenMangos

I love this format! I’m excited for more Creep Crime!

Pearl clutching taking place in the comments !!!! People taking their slop too seriously alert !!!!

I guess unpopular opinion, but I enjoyed this. It's probably because I enjoy true crime, but I think since this crime in particular related to CreepyPasta/Online horror, that it fits! There is a lot of real crimes and incidents that are born from online horror mixed with mental illness. Idk just one person's perspective, didnt comment to argue.

Unpopular opinion clearly, but I really enjoyed this episode. I appreciate the change up and listening to the boys takes. Truthfully I’ll listen to these guys talk about anything, which is why I pay for the patron. Just happy to have any type of content from them. Thanks guys!

If you don’t like it don’t watch it. I’ve skipped several episodes like happy appy because I knew it was gonna be a shitshow

Appreciate you guys mixing it up. I'm here for whatever you guys do

Awh geez guys. Doing something different? Why? Just do the same thing forever and never add anything! Appease the people who complain incessantly and are never satisfied! Please?!

That was awesome. Would be a big fan of CreepCrime.

The survivor of this just came up on my TIktok feed.

I personally really enjoyed this format, everything is bleak in this world, sometimes it's important to learn to laugh at the atrocities to cope, otherwise it's tears. I think they did a good job covering the details of the story without being disrespectful and making it too silly there is joking moments but again it's to lift the mood, bad things happen all the time and pretending it doesn't doesn't help anyone.

i think i would feel a lot better about these kinds of stories if more things were sourced. had a lot of moments mid episode where i was asking myself "how is this known?" / "where does this anecdote come from ?" hearing sfx like the monitors beeping for her in the hospital was also very jarring for a real life episode. all of this has been said in better ways already im sure. i just wanna add my voice to the amount of people saying that this is okay as a one of f thing. but as a reoccurring thing? not a fan. there's not even much to even get into about the "story". just mostly >" here's what happened" > "yeah that's fucked up" -- this format feels limited.

Okay so I am not schizophrenic but I have brain damage from my time in the military which is left me with auditory hallucinations so uniquely different from someone with schizophrenia I do not have any confusion I have the constant frame of mind to be able to identify what is there and what isn't there the knowledge that I can do that I think is the only thing that keeps me sane. Granted the hallucinations are best described as radio static stuck in between two stations I also couldn't imagine what it would be like if it was something more substantial some tangible phrase or word that I could cling to because I hear it all the time non-stop it never ends. Very manageable as it is but the thought of it getting worse or me not being able to recognize it is a constant terror in the back of my mind I can't imagine how people with severe hallucinations can a deal with the day today.

If I wanted to subscribe to a true crime podcast I wouldn't have came here, if that type of content becomes a regular occurence I will sadly pull my subcription.

Please give “How to survive hell” by ratrotted a shot. It’s about 9 years old and despite listening to countless creepypastas it’s always stuck out to me. I think webdi would enjoy the biblical references and Hunter would enjoy the brutality of it .

I think sometimes reading a story about a real life event could be fun.

I feel like these are totally fine as additional Patreon content, I don’t get the complaints other than that this show is primarily about horror stories. People complaining about the ethics of true crime would have a fucking stroke if they saw Isaiah’s channel. I will say I don’t think this should ever replace the weekly story upload, but I wouldn’t have an issue with one of these going up maybe like once a month or so as a Patreon bonus.

Need to to abandoned by Disney and the follow-ups…

I love this as a concept, hopefully they do another episode about the Jeff the Killer murder next! Hunter already did a Papa Meat video about it but I think it could be interesting to get Isaiah's reading on it. Plus it could open up the door to covering true crimes related to other folklore creatures or beings. Not saying they need to turn the podcast into a True Creep one but I think this would especially be a fun Patreon-exclusive series. 👀

I like this as long as it stays funny with the jokes n such

Lifetime Waukesha adjacent resident, knew the girls by proxy through a classmate but didn’t talk to them directly outside of a couple coincidental community events. We had a whole conversation in class a while after it happened about if any of us had visited the website. Me being the class goth of course I was all over that shit but made it very clear to our teacher that normal people don’t believe anything sketchy on the internet, especially badly written horror style fanfiction. We made cards for her after she was out of intensive care, no idea if she ever actually received them or cared but I still genuinely hope that she never has to interact with that level of mental illness ever again. Also Isaiah: Walk-ih-shaw You’re welcome ;)

Great episode, comments are acting wayyyy too self righteous lol. Also you guys should cover “my dad finally told me what happened that day”

Well, I liked this episode, as I do all of them. Joined this podcast for you guys, and honestly, on some episodes the stories become secondary to the personalities and banter. I enjoyed you covering this, it felt relevant to the Creepypasta content that's normally covered, and you were both respectful about it. None of the humor made light of the situation, just in my opinion.

Please drip milk off your toes into my mouth

It kinda blows me away how much hate the boys get here on patron. Everyone is either mad they read a "shitty" story or upset they try something different and reading through comments there's some pretty venomous comments. Maybe im a simp but even if the story they read isnt that great, I enjoy their commentary, I enjoy listening to the tangents an them going off cuz I enjoy the dynamics of their personalities. Also im really confused on why people think this is a creepy pasta only podcast when they cover other writers an actual books an other things outside of just online creepy pastas... regardless to the boys if you see this, you guys are amazing an I look forward to sundays because of you, keep up the good work👍

While I definitely don’t think this episode is in great taste, *especially* with them pointing out the sensationalization of the Sallie house, it’s kind of wild how most of the comments are completely missing the point of why it’s in bad taste. Instead of pointing out the uneasiness of making jokes around a brutal attempted murder case of a child everyone’s saying things along the lines of “this is terrible, how could you read about a real case instead of the story *I* recommended. I don’t want to hear about a real little girl I want to hear ‘Im a teacher and the Tunky man is looking at me, here are the rules’, im so disappointed.” However I feel like something discussing real life horror could be done effectively, just not starting with the incredibly tragic attempted murder of a very real human child

Great stuff enjoyed this creep crime alot. Very respectful. Good bits. Yall should do another role play thing like the early Patreon exclusives ?

Say “wa-kesha” again. I dare you. I double dog dare you.

Being from Milwaukee hearing Isiah’s pronouncement of Waukesha is hilarious😭

i liked this new kind of story, ive always wanted a more in depth analysis of this true crime story and got it from the boys! especially with how much they’ve talked about slenderman in the past

I enjoyed the episode. I am glad they are still willing to experiment with new video genres

Can y'all please do "PROJECT MONSTER" by Lost Utopia films for a creep TV. It's some extremely good Godzilla horror.

I for one enjoyed this because it’s tangentially related to the pod subject and I find the psychology behind crimes, especially “weird” ones, to be fascinating. Human brains, man. Nobody’s immune to them going haywire on em

Such a fan of this

10/10 episode! I got in a car wreck while listening to it and nearly died, when the EMT came to get me he said ‘oh sick this guys listening to creepcast’ and proceeded to talk to me about it throughout the ambulance ride.

“I realized I’m married to a horse girl” *incredibly well thought out point about how children who felt ostracized in the early days of the internet found community in online circles to fill that necessary human connection* “I think my father hated me as a child” Please never change Hunter lmao

Hi all. I'm fairly new to patron but not new to the creepcast. Listened to all the available episodes and now caught up to all bonus ones as well and I'm sad that now I have to patiently wait for new ones I'm a gardener and I listen to stuff while at work, that means a lot of hours of streaming. Any recommendations to fill the emptiness of waiting for new episodes?

TRUE CRIME, GROSS!

The worst part of this story is how Isaiah pronounced Waukesha. It's not WauKe$ha

I enjoyed this. Thanks for making my workdays bearable. Much love ❤️

Appreciate trying something new, Creepypasta adjacent, but I definitely had a hard time getting into the story knowing it was a real event.

Personally I’m here for creepypastas not true crime type content

"erm guys... the name is CreepCast as in doing creepypastas.... why is this a true crime thing..."

Patreon is a place to support your favorite creators. Not a place to get special treatment.

Love you guys but I think this podcast is so special and great because you cover fictional stories, and true crime really brings a different vibe that doesn’t feel right

I did not like this. Please stick to fictional stories

Casting creep in my Amazon van on my 15 minute break

Yall should definitely do the burned photo series!

no this was so funny and a very palatable way to understand this

This was a great video I honestly really like the diversity with this subject and it still being creepy pasta adjacent and honestly enjoyed the episode! Please keep doing stuff like this and switching it up!! Still love the creepy pasta and horror stories but I really appreciate the diversity!!!! Thank you papas. 🖤🖤🖤

Please react to llama arts old creepy pasta animations it’s my fav drunk videos to watch

Would love for you guys to revisit The Black Farm series!

another common creepcast W, love the true crime aspect !

I think the "problem" is making a real world crime in story-form. Trying to fit it into your normal creepypasta narration then it becomes kind of problematic. It would be different if you would just be discussing the case.

The HBO max doc on this is genuinely horrible. They didn’t get permission from Peyton or her family (which I guess isn’t required) but they also really lean heavily into sympathizing with Morgan and Anissa’s family.

Please read “I’m a janitor in the backrooms there are 6 strange rules”

I personally like this. I think this is a good topic because it is *related* to creepy pastas. A lot of comments on here are acting like y'all plucked a random true crime story while this directly correlates to something y'all have covered in the past. Plus, this sort of content isn't much different from content you would both do on your own channels. Have any of the people complaining paid an iota of attention to your individual work in the past? The only real reason that I could see this being an issue is if some of the side tangents were too mocking or mean, and I didn't really see that here. To the haters: don't like it? Don't watch it. Not everything is going to be cherry-picked for your exact tastes. The team both on camera and off bust their asses to make cool shit. Put your big boy pants on and take a hike.

Would love an episode on the satanic panic if they're doing true crime

true crime in this format feels really strange, especially making a true crime episode read similarly to a creepypasta

Don't know if anyone is in here anymore but creepcast patreon needs a chat section not just under the videos ..anyways looking for a story they read about a man in the desert riding a horse the horse dies as they come upon some giant monoliths but it turns out to be a creature that eats him. Is this real or my imagination?

Finally got around to listening to this one and I'm just kinda put off. If you want to have a true crime episode that's fine cover the crime, but it feels kinda gross to turn it into a dramatized story reading for viewer entertainment.

I love trying new things with the channel but real life crime is not it. The channel has a certain style that doesn’t suit this.

Idk if it’s possible to do a published book but the short story Sour Candy by Kealan Patrick Burke is so creepcast coded 🙏🏻🙏🏻

I have to say, seeing a reading of a real crime was a bit off-putting at first but after listening to it I don't think there's really anything wrong with it. I understand why some people aren't interested in this kind of thing but I think it's more just a difference of preference to a certain type of story rather than any actual issue of quality. These are the same guys that read both Penpal and Happy Appy. I think you guys should keep doing whatever you want to do and as long as you're reading something and bantering many of us will be happy to listen.

Respectfully, I hope we don't get more true crime stories. There is an overabundance of true crime podcasts out there that cover exactly that, and creepcast offers a breath of fresh air with the silly banter and back and fourth stories while being able to get back on track with something I've never heard before. I understand the want to try something new, but what you guys have been doing has, in my opinion, been great (except for the absolute ass stories but that isn't either of your fault lol). Preferably this will just be a one off and we will get back to scary stories and banter next week

Good Lord the entitled people in the comments are INSANE. I really enjoyed this. Let them do what they want. If you don’t like it, don’t watch. You don’t dictate what they do.

Black mouth is a great book inspired by the Slenderman killing. Would recommend

I love this style of video

Y'all handled this with a lot more respect than a lot of actual true crime channels, & your coverage offered some insight & details that I never even thought of. This was cool & I'm down for a side series for true crime

good lord if you don’t like the content just go somewhere else

I think this is a misstep. Not a fan

i don’t know where to suggest stories but, here goes! i also love to see you guys branch out but was hoping to hear this one ‘the man in my basement takes one step closer every week’, thank you for being so consistent these past couple years! i used to have trouble sleeping since being sober but ever since this show came out, it’s really helped so much. it’s been a scarily effective rock in my night routine haha

suprised people are shocked about this episode when they talked about covering this story in the past

I liked the coverage and you did a good job with such a serious real world topic. However for some constructive criticism I’d say it would be a good idea to change some of the sound effects if possible but definitely the background music. It’s a little weird to hear about such a disturbing real world crime while the music that serenaded the birth of FaMbUgEr and Wendiblum plays on in the background. Keep it up though! Interesting to hear the story in this level of detail.

i love how many people are now paying to complain about the podcast now, the episode is entertaining and respectful calm down lmao

I need to see hunter’s reaction to the Mandela catalogue

I’d love to see more scp stuff shy guy or 682 would be fun

creepcast backrooms ever? series in one video, movie in other video? or somethin?

All the complaining on here is wild. Let the boys try something new.

Got angry every time I hear it pronounced wok-keesh-a lol

Given the subject matter I'm impressed with how funny you were able to make this. I will say creepcast hasn't made my stomach turn like this since the early episodes. I don't want this to become a true crime podcast but I always welcome experimentation and applaud you for trying to keep things fresh

I unironically would love to hear about the v-buck violence on wendi’s channel lol

I thought this episode was great. Im a fan of true crime once in a while

Adding my voice into the void here. I definitely prefer the fictional stories, but I'm not opposed to straying from them every so often for a true story like this, especially if they're creepypasta adjacent. I appreciate the effort put into making the script feel like a normal episode, too.

I haven't see Hunter this uncomfortable reading a story, since Tommy Taffy

there are more idiots whining about the backlash than there are people actually being critical. actual children that can’t assess that there may have been a misstep in the process.

It’s bizarre to me that so many comments are about this community being whiny, when writing a comment like that is being even more so. Criticism of a podcast isn’t an indictment against one’s character, you don’t need to die on the front lines defending a bad decision. The point of a patreon is priority access, and a more direct line for feedback should they ever need it. Letting them know that something might be in poor taste is exactly the kind of thing this is here for. If you don’t see anything wrong with it, that’s up to your discretion, but it would be exceedingly stupid to die on the hill of trying to convince others that how they feel/interpret things is wrong

yeah this felt gross. i appreciate the attempt at branching out, but it feels like a bad fit for the “reading crappy old internet horror stories” podcast. CreepCast is at it’s best when it’s just these two goofing off, and this isn’t a style that lends itself well to that

Wawk-a-shaw

true crime? no…true CREEP

I loved it! Y’all did great covering this

I love u guys and your content. . . 🌝

The 7 sisters are gonna love the true crime drama of this episode

People are a bunch of whiny children who say this podcast is lighthearted and this episode doesn't belong definitely haven't listened to the third parent or like borassca nothing lighthearted about that shit. Also its still their podcast they can do what they want with it. Not like this is a paid patreon exclusive. Also bring back creeptv!!

I don't this will find you hunter, but. I was waching your episode on wubbys podcast. I think you wold love the afl( Australia football league) nothing like your foot ball its a completely different sport. Its like basketball poker football and hockey all in one and its realy fun to wach. 😁

😭 bunch of people upset that they are taking about true crime acting like this story doesn't have everything to do with what they read and talk about on this podcast but I do agree I don't want this read on here this story is so over read it's so boring to hear over and over again

They’ve been reading creepypastas for over three years. I still prefer the normal episodes but I’m all for them switching it up every now and then!

Hey. If if hunter and wendi get bored of doing internet scary stories a good alternative that isn't as extreme as true crime but has real world precedent I'd recommend they do hoaxes. Stuff like the painting you stair at for 20 seconds, sighting of killer clowns, elevator games. Rituals etc. they could even do the rituals and film them.

Imma be real with you chief, this one is not it. Those girls wanted the attention from the attempted murder they did, and the internet is giving them just that. The creep will not be casted for this one 😭💧🚫

So many comments always whine and its unfortunate because they dont seem to realize that fresh content is also for the creators and it keeps these longer running channels going. Keep it up boys

I’m being incredibly nitpicky, but Waukesha is pronounced “wah-kuh-shaa”. Still a great video as always 🫡

Recovering horse girl here. Can confirmed I also duped my husband.

It's just a whiplash to go from laughing about a silly cop checking off boxes and then going into the horrors that poor girl had to face in the hospital or hearing about the real child that didnt feel any remorse after stabbing her real friend 19 times. Just a little bit more heavy than what I've come to expect from Creepcast

i swear to christ when i’m breaded im buying that deadstorm pirates game along with every other arcade rail shooter

Honestly, I knew people (like my older sister) who believed that Slenderman was either a demonic presence on the internet infecting young girl's minds to murder, or a demon using the influence of Slenderman, something like that. I grew up in a pretty religious family.

I don't know why so many people hate this, it's a nice little treat. Like Isaiah's juicy lips. 👄

The victim Payton is now a therapist, the incident inspired her to move in this direction and its great that she survived. Its a shame that the two girls essentially ruined their lives, generally psychotic mental disorders never get taken seriously until the person does something seriously dangerous to themselves or others and its a shame the first thing she did to be taken seriously was attempted murder. She could have been saved. It was definitely a different style of story, and while i prefer the fictional stories i think this story was great and done in good taste. Considering payton survived I dont think it is really offensive to anyone, this incident is a massive mark on the history of creepypastas, i remember the severe impact it had on media and creepypasta at the time. I was 12 when it all happened and i remember how much scarier and real it made creepypastas. Good video.

Yall can just not watch if you're not interested. I understand being disappointed but these comments sound so entitled. I get all perspectives and i respect that but the attitude feels unnecessary.

Reading the levels of toxicity in the comments is EXHAUSTING.

It feels wrong to incorporate real crime into a podcast that focuses on scary stories. I personally find true crime exploitative, even though I thought the episode was fine. It's harder to riff and go on tangents, or even laugh, when you're talking about the actual mutilation of a real child.

i was too busy on sunday watching backsessions so i didnt get to comment but its pretty wacky to have may 31 as my bday (and lucky bc i get creeps as a present <3)

Creep cast and red thread had a baby congrats papa goon and mama meat

This will be unpopular, but I have no remorse for the killers. I don’t care what’s wrong with them, they should be locked up forever. The parents should be too.

Just putting in my vote that I would rather they stick to fiction as that’s what I was expecting when I began paying for this. Do not be offended if you don’t share opinion, I’m not telling them what they can and can’t do and I’m fully aware that I can unsubscribe. I will if I’m no longer enjoying the show after a bit of time but having a negative opinion of a single episode that is vastly different from the usual creepcast does not mean I’m obligated to immediately right off my support for some of my favourite creators. Settle down and let people share they’re opinions and let meat mom and goon dad make they’re own decision based that feedback and their own feelings.

I BEG you guys to read "The Beach", it's a narrative SCP story that I'm sure would do some numbers

I quite enjoyed this episode, great step away from the norm.

Really loved Creep Crime, hope there’s more of this in the future. Maybe you could cover the crime of the guys who were obsessed with the movie Scream.

More of this would be cool

i think this is totally fine it’s true crime about a creepypasta it’s not off-topic at all 😭

Really enjoyed this video. The new idea of covering crime is great!

Damn she’s in Oshkosh now , same place the original back room photo was taken Prob the coolest thing about north east Wisconsin lol

I personally really enjoyed this episode. It is nice to rry new things. Do I think this should be an everyday type of thing? No. Do I think it would be appropriate if something in real life directly related to a creepy story happens? Sure! People are being so harsh. For the record I also think they were respectful to the victim and their family. Just keep doing you guys! We appreciate you!

everyone complaining about this true crime format needs to take a step back and look at hunter and Isaiah’s personal content and see that it’s literally 90% talking about real world happenings with comedy interwoven. there’s no problem with not liking this new format and no problem with some constructive criticism but i’m seeing a lot less of that and a lot more of entitled whining, strong language and rude, dramatic complaints

Grrrrr I’m an angry patron. I can’t believe you did something different and didn’t read MY suggestion “I’m a prostate doctor, and today I found something weird”

not related to the video but who else is hoping they watched obsession and will talk about it on an episode sometime soon?

While this isn’t my favorite format of creepcast, I’m here for whatever u guys want to do creatively and whatever keeps you from getting burnt out with this channel :)

It's a little in poor taste but tbh if some of yall are that affected by it, skip the episode. 100% sure some of yall love Bailey Sarian, Stephanie Soo etc. Granted they addressed and changed the way they went about cases. Creepcast has done ONE episode like this. Grow up.

Reading the comments from people who are alleged fans makes me sad. All the hate is so unnecessary. I feel that at the end of the day, this is their podcast. They choose what they want to do with it and the content they put out. Just like we choose to enter in the credit card info. If this type of content isn't for you then it might be time to move on. Some of you guys take it as a personal afront and its really not. Mind you, they also have other projects and lives of their own to live. Sometimes yall like to put these people in a fishbowl and rap on the glass when they dont entertain what you want specifically. Theyre people, not a machine. Just enjoy what you want. I am happy with what im paying for. If youre not, then I encourage you to take the initiative or perhaps change your perspective. Stay creeping your cast yall

You know this feels really weird honestly. Like using the same format from stuff like I Dared My Best Friend to Ruin my Life but this week it's about a real, actual crime that nearly killed a real young girl? True crime is another genre out there, that's fine it's whatever but this is just such a weird pick for CC to me. I wouldn't bat an eye about a video on the same topic going up on Wendigoons channel with Hunter in it. Just seems like a weird choice for the scary stories podcast.

I killed my best friend because happy appy told me to

I blame the dad 100% I mean surethe girl is insane but he was reckless with his child

If they do another episode like this the should try to get jackson on and make it a semi red thread reunion.

i don’t care for true crime either but yall are being dramatic good lord get it together

THE PIRATE GAME WAS SO GOODDDDDDD THE LOCAL ARCADE HAD IT FOREVER AND THEN IT JUST DISAPPEARED AND I MISS IT EVERY SINGLE DAY

I’ll say it, I enjoyed this, it’s a nice break from the format and would like the guys to cover more true crime 🤷🏻‍♂️

Great episode, whoever wrote this like a creepypasta did an amazing job

Thanks for the video and all the hard work guys as always. I don’t mind the topic at all and I’ve even already seen docs on this story. But I’d prefer to creep the normal casts on this format.

Whole lot of pearls being clutched in here

This shits gay

I would enjoy a creep crime section like creep tv

First

Petition to call stories like these “True Creeps” or something adjacent, like a play on True Crime

Ouuuuuuugh my crime is so cast oooooooooouuuuumppppphhhh

as someone from wisconsin, hearing you guy pronounce city names is so funny to me

You guys are really not vibing rn. This is not a random true crime story they are just throwing into the podcast. Its related to a creepy pasta and I think they are showing plenty of respect. Personally im not a fan of true crime anymore but the amount of bitching in these comments are really uncalled for. To hunter and Isaiah - i think personally true crime makes some people uncomfortable but I applaud you thinking outside the box and telling this story with a creepcast flair.

Begging for an episode featuring Nick as a guest

2:00:06 Fucking criminal to bring up the green mile and not have hunter talk about his “getting head during the green mile” story

Thought this format was super cool for a true crime deep dive. At first I thought it wasn't gonna feel right since it's true crime, but it grew on me . Hope everyone else liked it too

I liked the read. I think you guys did a good job of being respectful. The vbucks thing I think was a good way to provide comedic relief from such a tragic reality of a situation despite it possibly coming off as inappropriate, I mean we’re all human.

I held a high score with my uncle on the pirate ship game at my local Chucky cheese and it was one of my proudest achievements as a kid. As soon as you said Chuckycheese I was thinking about that game specifically

Big lips + moon face = joy

Seems like most people be cryin but I loved it. Good episode

Even tho I did learn allot more info about this case I would’ve preferred a story and not something that happened in real life. I have true crime if that something that you guys wanna do in the future that’s fine but maybe a separate channel or a pole on these kinda topics?

I loved the style of this video! I hope you guys continue this kind of video every now and then. I especially want to point out how funny yet tasteful the comedy side of this video was, it added brevity and a spotlight on the absurdity of the situation without ever being at the expense of any victims, very refreshing when so much true crime is so predatory!

I feel like there's a fine line between schizophrenia and actual demon possession and I am kinda leaning toward the latter

This feels so weird and unexpected in a bad way. This is the first ep I have not listened to.

Comments losing it over a creepypasta related true crime instead of the usual. Meanwhile I can't stop staring at the extra space in the title 🫠

Has Hunter murdered somebody for their V-Bucks? Find out next week on CreepCrime

I know the intent is to be respectful, and as an enjoyer of both of your own channels I know you didn't make this without care, but I really don't think true crime works with the CreepCast format. It's just kind of a lot of tonal whiplash. Especially when the real events are summarized and written in a way that's supposed to read as a story, even going so far as to voice act the quotes of real people. Again, I'm not appalled, and I still enjoy the coverage of real events that you both do separately, but respectfully I don't think this was the move for CreepCast.

To all the comments complaining about this story remember that at the end of the day its their channel. Also both of the them very respectfully covered this topic

You guys are tweaking I thought the video was great

“Wauke$ha” 😭😭

I really enjoyed this format

I moved to Waukesha about 10 years ago, when I read Kathleen Hale’s book about this I had no idea it happened here. You covered it really well and I recommend the book.

I recently just lost my mother and while things have been hard and feel unreal this podcast has literally made the silent nights comforting, so I just want to say thank you to both Isaiah and Hunter along with Nick and Harry and the editors for giving us this amazing podcast, I'd happily pay double just to listen to these guys describe paint drying.

Im not a fan of this personally, i really like the fiction focus of the pod and true crime media is already… the way that it is. Focusing on community creators, stories and media is such a fun part of this entire podcast and even though slenderman is connected to this story it just doesnt feel like enough to justify changing the content and keeping the format, it doesn’t exactly feel respectful

crazy that I was 11 when all this was going down and remember how hard it shook the creepypasta fandom

I do feel kind of weird with this being on Creep Cast, but I think the hate is unwarranted. This is their first time trying something new, and while it might not be a horror story and instead a true crime made into a story format, and people are acting like this is a common problem they have. They're trying something new, I'm sure they want the feedback saying people don't like it, but I think people saying that they're rebranding or shifting their focus completely is uncalled for. They just wanted to try something new, and since people don't like it, I'm sure it won't happen again. Why do we have to be so mean to them for experimenting?

I 🫶🏽 u guys, u can talk about whatever you want!

All the comments complaining about the fact it’s a true crime thing and I expected to open it and see people talking about wendis pronunciation of Waukesha

I love this show, but this is a very unfortunate miss. I imagine most fans of the show are expecting fictional stories that can be inspiring and/or comically reviewed. True crime is much more serious, and requires a necessary amount of respect.

Better tip that editor lip boy

I guess I get why it was done. It's surrounding a creepy pasta story and it feels a bit disingenuous to avoid the topic totally. When this happened I had just given birth to my first child, and I after seeing it and feeling awful for the girl injured, and the other kids mental state and knowing the mental illness history etc, I immediately thought I hope they don't condemn creepy pasta cause I enjoyed them so much as a teen/young adult. I don't mean to sound disrespectful to the individuals involved either I just remember enjoying them, and thinking it would be awful for others that came after me to not get the same experience and pleasure of reading these. I get the point of all of us coming here, we laugh and take the most unserious opinions, and understandings to things. But in my opinion before borrasca got close to real at the end there was so many times where many laughs happened. I can understand the want to escape real life, but no matter what we do real life is in there somewhere. Borrasca with trafficking and baby farming, left right game, has a lot to do with a father who made a heinous mistake based off an obsession only to find his future was already set in stone, pen pal and the absolute horrifying realness of childhood predators and the sickness of a mind. Not to mention the trauma. 1999- again with predators, and witnessing a person find out the reality about a childhood show that they couldn't fathom when they were six to eight years old. Think of nickoledeon and Disney and all the things that have came out about them, surrounding so many shows we loved as children. I feel like the nuances are always there and just because we choose not to see them in the other stories doesn't mean they aren't real. It's just my take. Don't come for me. lol. I enjoyed this episode and felt like it was a respect paid to the real thing that happened and how a creepy pasta story was tied into the real realities of mental illness, sickness, and learning disabilities that make us all as parents realize that sometimes we should pay attention a bit more because it might not just be a phase.

Doing something different like true crime is like oh well whatever, yall wanna switch it up but why is it formatted like a creepypasta?

Hey siri, play many men by 50 cent

For their conversation on schizophrenia, my wife has schizophrenia. Audible and visual hallucinations. When we first got together they were REALLY bad, to the point she would describe them hurting her physically by like digging into her and biting her and shit. Some super scary stuff. She's a lot better now, very rarely has episodes and when she does it's primarily just hearing voices screaming. She's a way stronger person than me I can tell ya that.

Biting the “true crime” bullet a bit early aren’t we? Can’t have read ALL the good creepy stories yet!?

Close enough, welcome back Red Thread

Loving the butchered Wisconsin town names

Also, I actually really liked this video :)

Don’t RedThread my CreepCast !!!

I fuck with this, idk why ppl pissed ab it lol. I think it should be every now and then do this format where its a crime connected to a creepypasta (if there is that many)

I wish so badly the guys would look up how to pronounce places and names BEFORE recording or even just look it up quick if they aren't sure. Hearing Waukesha pronounced like that hurt my soul (its supposed to be wah-keh-shaw)

I understand the logic behind choosing to cover this for creepcast but as many others have said the reason we like creepcast is for the stories they read with the dynamic between the the boys. Oh also side tangent as a wisconsin native it’s painful hearing Isiah pronounce town names. But at least they’re consistent with pronouncing shit wrong lol

@47:52 it's not Waa-ke$ha, it's walk-key-shaw. I almost spit my coffee out when he said that 🤣🤣🤣

Love the show. I genuinely respect and appreciate that they’re still trying new things to keep the podcast fresh. That said, this ain’t it son. Would rather see them explore other genres of fiction than this.

I’m disappointed to see all the negativity. I really liked this episode and thought they handled the subject material appropriately. Miles better than some other true crime content creators I’ve heard before.

Honk honk. (*Disappointed)

This feels insanely insensitive

Why so much hate towards this? Let them do their thing if you don’t like it don’t listen to it simple as that. Same thing happened with creep TV that to me was awesome. Again don’t like it just skip it. Keep doing what you’re doing boys.

"the childness of it" -wendigoon

Which ninja turtle do you think it was?

Ahhhhh, reminds me of highschool watching Marble Hornets in 2010.

Like the episode. Kinda feels out of place but since they both cover real life topics, it felt understandable. Just out of place for creepcast imo

This one was pretty interesting. I'm not sure about all the hate I'm seeing for this episode, but I liked it.

This ain't it boys

As a Wisconsinite I have to say its pronounced "WA ('a' sounds like 'aw') - keh - SHAW"

Yeah after listening to the episode I actually think it’s pretty good and they treat the topic with respect. Obviously yeah they joke but i genuinely felt sick to my stomach hearing about how brutal the stabbing was.

These comments are crazy negative…. I’ll level, I don’t love true crime either cuz it always feels at least a little exploitative, but jesus christ- it’s a podcast not a nuclear control panel. They’re allowed to try new things and make mistakes. Bear in mind that this podcast is only like 2 years old, they’re still finding their feet. Quit throwing your toys out and just wait for the next ep 🫩

Ignore the comments

I already knew before looking at the comments it’d be filled with people complaining

I think that there is an audience for comedy, true crime, and riffing off of that. Plenty of popular podcasts out there use this format. I think this true crime event is relevant to the subject matter. I agree that the story format with the music and background was the wrong choice. That being said, I would want this in a different and more thoughtful format, or something similar, before I would want more CreepTV.

Wendigoon should of went back to red thread for an episode with this script lol

comments full of haters

I was expecting some horrifically dark jokes the way the comments were reacting but this was handled very respectfully, was a really good look into this case and a great episode.

Whatever adumb said but with mustard instead of milk 😩🙏🏻🤲

Take it from someone who lives near the area, this was a huge deal, and this episode handled it so very well. I even have a connection to one of the people featured in the documentary Hunter mentioned, and boy do i have stories about that person. When the Slenderman movie came out in theaters, it was really difficult to find a theater in the area that would show it. Loved the episode and would love more content like this in the future! Very relevant to the theme of the podcast. HMU if you want more creepy info on this story or anywhere in Wisconsin lol.

true crime on creepcast ?! i’m obsessed 🫡

Bro, every time I watch a creepcast video, I am always amazed by how empathetic Hunter is, it’s freaking awesome.

So many people are being very negative about this video. I am not against this type of format, but I’m not entirely sure how much there is to expand on with this concept? I’m not really aware of any other cases similar to this one, so would they all be this true crime route or some other route that is related to the stories?

I like the idea of doing something different appreciate the variety

If turns to a true crime podcast i'm gonna end it all

Bro! Let’s go Jungle was my shit dude!

Hey cast creeps loved the video!

The fact that the kids spoke in code tells me they got in trouble at school with someone for talking about it before

Y'all need to calm the fuck down. They're doing a story directly influenced by where they get their bread and butter. They have every right to do this. And it was actually good. They're not turning it into a true crime podcast. They don't want to do that. You all need to chill the fuck out.

Clearly an unpopular opinion according to these comments, but any slop these two do together is quality enough for me to Creep my Cast too 🤷🏽‍♀️

I don't like this ):

Not really liking this one, would rather it stick to the fictional stories

Please read the Masterson chronicles! I need a cowboy story

I’m unsure if the guys here read a bunch of these messages, but there’s a writer on TalesFromTheCreeps that supposedly has gotten wrongfully perma-banned for someone mass reporting her for “using AI”. I don’t know the truth, but I think it’s worth it to check out the validity of her work. She made a TikTok video about it with the name of @britatochip411

This episode was a change of pace for sure, but tbh I welcome a bit of a mixup here and there. This was still a fun episode, especially with all the tangents they got in to with each other

Legitimately tho; Every single adult and system in these childrens lives failed them every step of the way and your takeaway is "Man schizophrenia be crrraaaaaazy" You'll pivot out of left field to something deadly serious and you can't actually say anything more profound or take a stance aside from "What a badass stabbing victim. Do you think the little schizo freak ate her scabs or painted with them?"

It’s pronounced “walk-uh-shaw.” I hate to be one of those but it’s bothering me so badly.

As a fellow wisconsinite, I dread how they are pronouncing Waukesha. Walk-uh-shaw is the proper way to pronounce. Jebus cripes

I like true crime, but turning this into a "story" was a bit weird. It disconnects the actions from the real people effected by this. I think this could work but not in this format. I also wish it was just a creepypasta instead of true crime. This would fit better on a collab vid or sumn on one of their main channels

The hardest thing about this story is that I knew kids that would do all the exact things that should have tipped adults off. There was a kid that would carry a screwdriver in their waistband to school, or kids that would draw all the slenderman drawings or other “scary” sketchings, and even kids who talked about seeing ghosts constantly. None of those people led to any stabbing, and you never knew quite exactly how you were supposed to deal with these problems either.

I really enjoyed this format and I would love to see more

This one is a bit too real ngl, got me stomach in knots.

I enjoyed this. All you people complaining guess what? It’s their channel

The combination of my favourite podcasters and true crime stories had me casting all over my creep. Pretty please, don’t be afraid to pepper in some true stories if you guys find something you want to talk about.

Thank you, guys!

You’d be surprised how well your body handles trauma. I was stabbed 5 times in college (one stabbing). I was able to finish getting dressed, walk down 4 flights of stairs and meet the ambulance in the lobby. The police said the room looked like a Jackson pollock painting.

This was good, people are way too overly sensitive and crying in the comments (women)

Okay I liked this episode I think some kinks can still be worked and it’s always good to try new things. I really like true crime and I’m happy they want to try new things I feel like not everyone will be pleased. I feel like on every thread people are always unhappy whether the episode isn’t long enough, they talk too much about the stories, or the stories aren’t good etc. I liked it and maybe could be more serious and just special episodes. Sometimes people just need a change of pace and there’s nothing wrong with that.

Tbh all the people complaining can eat a big one. I don't like this format for the boys, but dear God the entitlement in the community here is just gross.

To maybe offset all the negative, I enjoyed this one. Knowing that the events actually happened as read was more jarring and upsetting than any creepy pasta has ever been. Didn’t detract from the tragedy at all for me, in fact it shed some light on mental health, parenting, friendships, and overcoming trauma. And the humor they used is exactly the kind I would use when talking about something like this. They didn’t make fun of the victim and didn’t make fun of the perpetrators in such a way to dehumanize them. Papa and Wendi, ya done good on this one.

Alison blind sighting hunter with her drawing furry art, probably hits too close to home for my wife.

Honestly I don't have a problem with them covering real things as long as they're showing respect to the victims. It could be a fun way for them to branch out and maybe consider other stuff too

For the people complaining about this: this is in respect to a real life event. It’s the anniversary of it and was read with respect to the victim. There are thousands of stories they could read every week but I think shedding light on this event was a good thing they did. Not sure of what the issue is

Very parasocial in this comment section lol. This is not your channel, just because you pay a small subscription to get bonus content and added benefits does not mean you’re part of the crew or generally have any say in what they do, especially for weekly episodes that are not Patreon exclusive. After 3 years strong of creepcast growing into what it is we should be happy they aren’t super burnt out of this, especially the fact they have ungrateful whiners as a fanbase who will turn and complain and call episodes “yucky” (super millennial coded and childish to call things “yucky” btw) when it isn’t the exact story or content they want. We get weekly episodes plus bonus content frequently on top of their respective solo content, be a little more appreciative of how much we already get and that they are trying to venture into other topics and formats to keep the show fresh instead of whining and complaining that you didn’t get the exact episode you wanted this week. Anywhoodle Happy Monday my cast has been creeped as always

Oof, looks like you guys may have get back to the creepypastas. The audience has spoken and they are upset.

Found this really interesting, I had just watched the EWU video about this case and still learned some new things here. I didn't know the dad was also schizophrenic

Horrible event. But great coverage of it , I didn't know the full details, it's all around a terrible thing but you both handled it with respect, also nice to have an episode where you aren't crashing out, thanks boys, got some good drawing in while I watched

Love the show guys, but I have to say this episode is in very poor taste. This is a real event with a real victim, and I think sensationalizing it by voice acting characters and reading it as a narrative misses the mark. The amount of lighthearted jokes in this episode is shocking, I wish you guys tackled this episode with the weight it deserved.

2:35 - did Hunter just leak the new creeptv episode????

Milwaukee mention🙂‍↕️

Well that’s the first and last true crime episode cuz the community likes to cry like entitled babies hahaha

I miss cream crew when Hunter would trauma dump his father's stories lmao

Oh lord, I got flashbanged by a repressed memory of me and my friends pretending to be horses at school when we ere 7-8 years old

God, the larger the fan base, the more utterly insufferable the comments become. Its so sad. I come here to enjoy stories read by Wendigoon and Meatcanyon, and even though I get that every week, when I go into the comments, there's ALWAYS some divide or disconnect. People rarely make jokes anymore, they just want to complain and act insulted by a product that they don't 100% agree with. If these guys upload a story or two or three that I don't like, I simply tune out for a few weeks and eventually come back. Why can't we all do that? If you don't like it, nobody is making you tune in.

Please don’t let this become a true crime podcast 🙏

This was good.. I like the change of pace.. relating to creepypasta and they made it digestible.. enjoyable listen this week... people are weird..

Another episode of "I loved this episode, let me see what the comments say!" Followed by a "oh..."

I'm not the biggest fan of True Crime personally so this might just be my bias here, but I also think that CreepCast might not be the best place to cover things like this as a main talking point. Maybe it's just because everyone involved are still alive and have tried to move on from what happened to them/the heinous actions they committed but it just feels like it's bad taste. And this is nothing against Isaiah or Hunter, I think they did their best to make light while still keeping on track here but it just feels off to me personally with the voices Hunter does or the tangents, etc. Even Isaiah mentions that this is skirting the line a bit. We have people like the Lore Lodge (who sometimes makes off-hand remarks but stays tasteful) and MissingEnigma (who is very serious about what they cover), both covering true crime - and sometimes helping solve them - the tone is always a lot more serious, sometimes documentary level which I appreciate. Maybe if it were an older case this wouldn't have given me the weird vibes but at the same time with the anniversary and recently finishing Marble Hornets and how the duo's dynamic played into recent events I totally get why this would be a story to talk about. Just my opinion that no one asked for lol.

Forgot to mention the guy that helped her escape looked just like ticci Toby

Wouldn't this have fit better on the main channel. Thought this was for reading creepypasta, not true crime docs. 2/6☆

I love you guys, and I want to be clear that I'm not trying to ascribe any malice or ill-intent here, but as someone who lives and works in this area, it didn't feel great that you were repeatedly pronouncing things (specifically Waukesha) wrong, and that you kept a lot of your production choices very similar to your fictional videos. I know this seems like a crazy story that happened a long time ago for a lot of people, but Waukesha has been the site of two awful events that have become catnip for the true crime community (this and the Waukesha Parade Tragedy). Both are still very much affecting the community and the people related to the cases who still live here. Similarly, Milwaukee still deals with people who salivate over Dahmer, and many of his victims' families still live in Milwaukee and the surrounding burbs and struggle with the way the case is treated, so SE Wisconsin has a rough history with our tragedies being relayed as spooky stories on the internet. I just think it would have gone a long way to make sure you were pronouncing things correctly. You can check the Wikipedia article for "Waukesha" for a clip of someone saying it, or you could have even watched some news clips about the case to ensure you were doing so. As someone who lives in the area, I also think the usual creepy background music you guys use felt off, as well as the way you essentially wrote it as a story. While I appreciate that you guys were trying something new, and you were WAY more respectful than most people who discuss this case, I think making the writing/production so similar to your usual creepypasta videos felt jarring.

Wow I didn’t know so many people were against this video. It seems like they wanted a break from the mediocre horror and boring gag stories and wanted to cover something CREEPY for once. They don’t want to cover your dumb stories, they want to deliver scary stories. Thats the whole point of this channel. The gag stories and stories you guys think are scary are BORING. The proof is in the many videos before this one, mostly fan suggested.

Stories like this always remind me that wendi and I are the same age because I had a similar experience when this attack happened my parents sitting me down and asking me about the stories I read concerned lmao

oh Lord the way he said Waukesha

loved this :) please make a million more

I’m glad the boys are trying something new

this women is blessed with such amazing compassion, and the strength and perseverance it must have taken to survive that attack is inspiring. i truly hope she has found happiness and peace

Welcome back Red Thread

I honestly really enjoyed this episode, it was good to get more information about this case I forgot about but remember seeing on the news and love listening to the back and forth from eachother

I personally liked this video. They told us in the beginning of starting this, that Patreon would be a place for branching out and doing things that are not just creepypastas. They do short stories constantly and will undoubtedly give another one soon, I’m not worried. Besides, the boys deserve to have some liberty with their content. It’s not all about us, I would rather them make videos they are interested in so they get to enjoy as well. They can easily get burned out and bored of repetitive content and need a break now and then. Instead of discouraging them, thank them for changing it up to keep themselves happy and be happy they are still making content at all.

Man these comments are dummyyyyyyy lol the kid survived. We love 9/11 and Nazi jokes but God forbid people joke about a survival case and its a bad thing lol stfu bush did 9/11

I don't get some of the criticism here. I enjoyed it but I guess I'm just one against 1000 who didn't. It shouldn't matter if this was a real life event. A lot of creepypastas out there have the potential to be real life events and you wouldn't know if they were. The fact that it actually happened makes it even scarier. I found the format to be creative. Instead of just reading off boring walls of information it was changed to fit more in line with creepypastas.

Man I love you guys but I don’t think the Creepypasta podcast should be used to discuss real world crimes. It feels distasteful IMO.

Aside from this episode, for this month alone, we have gotten about 10 hours of stories. For the price of less than one hour of work for the average minimum wage worker. And people still whine and complain. It's related to the CreepyPasta. I've seen other people cover this topic but the story type of telling of it was a new take. Enjoyed that. And this does not seem like it'll be a regular occurance. Not many famous Creepypastas that are linked to IRL crimes. That girl is an actual angel on Earth. I don't think I'd ever be able to forgive someone that did that to me and have that positive of a spin on the entire situation.

The amount of people dogging on this video knowing full well they both constantly talk about true crime on their solo channels.. It’s also their channel they can do wtv they want, you’re the one paying money to sit on patreon and complain.

I doubt this becomes regular yall, there are only 2 creepypasta related crimes. The other tragedy they already covered on their channels. I think this is just their overlapping interests becoming one episode in a long list of many.

Uh oh I made a stinky

The most I ever did was believe in Herobrine and blamed him when our computer got viruses from 9 year old me clicking download on everything.

I'm not saying they should continue doing true crime stories if other fans don't like it, but I think it's important to display real life horror to expound on why the tropes in fiction are actually scary. If they did another episode like this, I think a topic of interest could be the Case of the Manson family. Or, another thing that can display real horror is survivor stories, like people stranded or lost in the wild, something like 127 Hours, based on real events.

I get why they covered this and the content was good, but I already know about this story from red thread. It just kinda feels like recycled content. Yall made it fun but I fell like this story was out of place on this podcast. Not dogging you at all, but this came out of left field. Still a classic episode for jokes.

I appreciate trying new things but I agree that this was not the venue for this story. Also the “creepypastafication” of a real life event felt very icky imo. Not against the boys doing true crime, but I feel like maybe Isaiah’s channel is a better venue and format for this sort of thing.

Goddammit. Every time I love a YouTube channel and get into the fan base, the fan base becomes fuckin intolerable. They wanted to do one true crime episode based on a CREEPYPASTA and you chuds absolutely lose your fuckin minds. Holy shit find something real to complain about

with all due respect as a long time watcher, i really don't want to hear true crime here. i go elsewhere, or i even listen to isaiah's main channel for real stories. i got 10 minutes in, and i just can't really shake that this is a real story being made into a...piece? idk how to explain it. i love you guys so damn much and i'm not trying to spread hate or be disrespectful at all. i feel like other "true stories" turned into movies and what not are more digestible because it's not true crime, just ghost stories that no one has 100% proof of. this is a deeply saddening story, even if the ending is truly motivating and heroic. if you guys continue to do these, i'll most likely just skip these episodes...not that my 1 view really matters, but yeah. AGAIN, this is no hate or disrespect. you two are my favorite creators of all time and creepcast is near and dear to me! i will always support you guys. i just love to come here on monday mornings to laugh and listen to creative story telling. there's a reason i stopped consuming so much true crime content. :(

I mean, I get the idea because it’s tied to creepy pasta, but I think this is a rare hiccup, it’s alright to try new things I guess. Also just watched the Buckingham video, and you could tell Hunter was not fucking with lil bro 😭

the episode wasn't bad, but there's so many fuckin' true crime podcasts out there man, don't replace the thing you're ACTUALLY best at with being like everyone else

Despite the dislike of this subject in the comments, this does actually seem like a video that you two should have just dual posted on the papa meat and wendigang channel, it seems more fitting. I do enjoy this though, a harsh subject made comedy is great. Idk why people have a problem with this

Everyone complaining is lowkey wrong tbh. Obviously what happened wasn't funny but so are some of the other topics the two have covered on their other channels (some of them being more serious, yet they make more jokes than they do in this episode). "Then they should make this video on those channels then!" The whole point of this is that it's a story related to SLENDERMAN the CREEPYPASTA on CREEPCAST. Like everything the guys do on here other than what they do every week is hated on and booed. This is going to grow stale and they are going to gain resentment for us if yall continue this trend. Let them experiment and run THEIR CHANNEL the way they want to. Overall good episode, I thought the idea of covering the slender man case was very interesting and you guys told the story pretty well.

So Wendy’s doing red thread again, but with hunter. hell yea

I appreciate the team trying something new, but personally I'd prefer fictional stories only

Not a fan of a true crime reading at all.

Isaiah's story about playing Jeff the killer at a sleepover gave me flashbacks to the time I played unravel by tk lingure at a bonfire (the intro song for season one of the anime Tokyo Ghoul). For context I was a bit more of an "emo" kid I guess, and these were a group of my more regular friends and everyone just kind of looked at me and someone asked me something like "what the fuck is this?" And at the time I thought i was so cold being brooding and playing this song on some "people just don't understand me". And now I just about kill myself out of cringe everytime I remember. Just had to get this out there. God what the fuck was high school man.

Reading creepypastas all the time can get really boring, most of them seem to try and copy each other and it gets so boring

Yes! Love this idea!!

We getting Creep Thread now

Gonna be honest, this episode ain't it. I get that they wanna try something new but the fact that this happened is just weird on a podcast about made up stories.

Did people even listen to the beginning of the video? The only reason they are covering this is because of it such an infamous case attached to a creepypasta. So far through listening to this, I haven't heard them say one thing about covering other true crime. On another note, I can 100% see Allison as a horse girl.

I can understand the interest in covering a case directly relating to online horror media. While I still enjoyed this episode, I believe the only aspect keeping this from falling off the "guardrail" as Lips put it, is that the victim survived and is doing well. There were funny moments in the episode, but it felt wrong to enjoy them. Ultimately I think the problems I have are with the true crime genre, not with the host. While the concept of creepypasta crimes is intriguing I don't know if the often comedy spattered 'CreepCast' is the right setting. If true crimes became a mainstay it might be necessary to brand it clearly as a separate series, whether on or off the primary channel.

I’m begging Isaiah to learn how to properly say “Waukesha”

Yo who's idea was this? Fire them

Given the overwhelming negative comments I feel I should voice that I did enjoy this, although I get why people don't want this as a regular episode perhaps having this as patron exclusive type content would be better

I really liked this episode!!! I hope we get more fun content like Creep Crime!!

I wasn’t sure on this like lots of people here but after listening, I really enjoyed it. (I had heard about this before but a more in-depth take on it was interesting). I do see what people say about true crime being an over-saturated and exploitative genre, and while I wouldn’t want creepcast to become a true crime podcast, I feel this episode is close enough to the original ethos and theme (they’ve talked about marble hornets and creepy pastas in the early days of the internet, it’s what started the podcast). Long comment but I enjoyed the ep, thought it fitted creepcast and also felt unlike a lot of true crime it wasn’t exploitative or pure sensationalism! It might pay to have creep crime episodes focus on the theme of creepy pastas and their real-world impact.

I had a friend for a long time who was one of these girls cousins. I haven't listened yet but the comments don't give me much hope for liking this recording

Watching this at my job, which is working at a facility with individuals with schizo active disorders. There's a good parallel between morgan and one of our residents, who has stabbed two people because they believed them to be zombies. Schizophrenia really Is a reality altering condition and sometimes you can only wonder just how they come up with their delusions.

Good lord that was fucking depressing.

i liked this episode i disagree with these haters it was a really interesting watch/listen!

Thank you for the content guys. I literally just come to these for the vibes you create. Love the side tangents, off the rail comments, etc. The tommy taffy wrestling bit was honestly funny as fuck. I don't really care about where or what the content you guys are reading is about, I just like watching you guys have fun and shoot the shit. Cheers and post whatever want.

As a true crime and horror fan I very much enjoyed this topic, would love to see some more with urban legends and the crimes that inspired them or vice versa.

If you’re whining about this i bet you’re the type of dumbass that eats popcorn with a spoon. This was great and them branching out of only doing creepypastas alone is a great idea. There’s plenty of creepypasta reading channels out there if that’s what you want to listen to, otherwise your constructive criticism is about as useful as a paper mache bomb shelter shut THE fuck up

I dont usually leave a comment though I hope due to this being on a paid service id be given some sort of platform or sway much like my fellow patrons. To put it simply: I don't like this. Not for the reasons that some, I'm not upset with the idea of true crime, nor do I think that its the sort of thing I may have avoided had i found this on YouTube and randomly decided to watch it. It's good content! (Though, that is sort of the crux of why so many people don't really like true crime; at the end of the day its content.) But its not the content that most viewers are looking for with *Creepcast*. I've seen many commentors point out that both of the boys make true crime content on their main channels but I feel like that gives all the more reason for this being collab content on one of their respective channels instead of on Creepcast. The format simply does not lend itself to respectful and informative coverage on true crime, and when many are looking for silly jokes and light banter just to be hit in the face with a harrowing story of survival, it makes me wonder why this was even uploaded on Crepcast to begin with. I remember once (in my nearly three years of watching this show) that there was a similar issue, Creepcast is historically given to changing up its style to the shegrin of its fans. The Ligotti episode comes to mind, but also in the middling views of CreepTV in comparison to its mainline counterparts. There is a lot to be said about how this fanbase rejects new things but I personally don't believe this is one of those cases, at least not entirely. I love the work done on this channel, and I love tuning in each and every Sunday waiting for a new episode. I will continue to do that as we go forward, but I really hope that this is either a one time experiment like the Ligotti episode, or, even better; a collaboration series between the boys on one of their channels.

Can you guys just start reading fanfic?

I want more of the true crime side of things. This episode was really good and shed alot of light on this story that I honestly didn't know before.

PLEEEEEASE bring back CreepTV

The people treating this as if it was the worst thing to ever happened that can never be talked or joked about is insane, remind me again who even died?

I did a field guide on internet horror for a technical writing class that included slenderman as an example. Found out my prof was Eric Knudson’s brother in law lol

Hi guys, long time viewer and long time patron. I love this show to death, but I can't help but feel like this episode is in poor taste. A big reason this show appeals to me and many others is because we get to appreciate good horror stories, and between those moments we get a lot of fun riffing, bits, etcetera. It's a horror/comedy podcast. The barrier of fiction is what really makes this work. We get to laugh at episodes like Tommy Taffy, Borrasca, and so on because they're all just fictional creepypastas. The Slenderman stabbing might be creepypasta adjacent, but it is not a creepypasta. It's a very real, horrible crime that nearly resulted in the death of a little girl. It doesn't sit right with a lot of us to have a lot of riffing and tangents when the subject matter doesn't have that barrier of fiction. Especially considering how the whole story was reformatted into a creepypasta-like structure. That barrier is what allows the horror and the comedy of this podcast to be simultaneously enjoyed. But the removal of the barrier makes these things grind together in a bad way. The jokes and bits take away from the subject matter, and the subject matter takes away from the jokes and bits. I totally get wanting to try something different, but I don't think this podcast is the right environment for this subject. No hate, I still love this podcast, and I'm still gonna be a supporter. Just wanted to leave some feedback, because it seems like this episode rubbed me and a lot of other viewers the wrong way.

yeaaah this is a miss. i’ll see you next week but please don’t do this. it feels wrong in a way that i’m not completely able to articulate. if wendigoon wants to make a wendigoon video he can post it on his own channel. this is too dark for a creepcast video.

Booooo

Love this direction of creep cast you guys are great

I like the real stuff and real stories don’t listen to them guys 😔 lips and the fat man this is a good idea it can be called “Creeped fr” idk but it’s a cool idea that I’m here for

YIPPEEE

i don’t know about this one chief, 10 minutes in and this just feels insensitive and gross idk if i can stomach 2 hours of true crime written and treated like a scary story, this one’s gonna be the first i’ll have to skip

Holy shit I didn't know this was a real story lmao I will delete another comment I made 💀

I'll give this episode a shot but right out the gate I do not like this. There should be a clear division between creepy/spooky/horror fiction and real life tragedy. I love you guys as a duo and seperately, and this feels a lot like it would be better on Wendigoon's channel. You have developed an atmosphere of jokes and humor, trying to branch into True Crime content is NOT it. This feels disrespectful to the victim, even if she did ultimately survive the ordeal. Adding to clarify that if this had been a fictional story inspired by real events, that'd be more in-line with what the show covers. Turning a real girl and a real series of events into a story to pick apart the same way they do works of fiction is what feels weird.

Genuinely yall in the comments piss me off so much. Unsub from the Patreon if you don’t like it. It’s always nothing but bitching and demands in here my god. Comment below with your departure and I’ll be sure to donate more monthly in your wake

people complaining about wanting them to just shut up and read the stories clearly don't realize there is dozens of other channels and podcasts that do exactly that, the boys yap and banter but that's what makes creepcast fun and different. they are allowed to experiment -- god forbid they enjoy their jobs....

Hey guys just wanted to say I loved this new format! I think it’ll be a great addition to the channel and I hope to see some more like it in the future!

I was surprised that they covered this but I actually really enjoyed it. I like when they diversify and obviously still expect pretty much consistently to have horror and creepy pasta stories for the most part but stuff like this is fun once in a while

You both are free to do whatever you want. HOWEVER in my opinion PLEASE DO NOT DO THIS AGAIN - signed one of the 7

I really like this new format and hope to see more in the future!

Please god No. Do not do true crime on creepcast. You both have your own channels for this. Please do not ruin the fun feel of the cast with real tragedies. PLEASE.

I dont think i would have a problem with this if it was just talking about the case and the actual research and everything that went into it, but this is just taking a REAL case and turning it into a story, it feels kinda icky but if they continue this format hopefully they expand on it

A lot of party shitters in this comment section

Hell yeah brothers I’m all for Crime Cast!!

Damn lots of haters on this one. I definitely prefer the fictional stories but whatever I love the guys and will listen to them talk about anything.

I don't prefer the creep cast true crime format, but I thoroughly enjoyed it anyway. Love you guys 💜💜

God is good. Forgiveness to your would be killers is a heavy thing to overcome.

Holy fuck people are mad :0 loved the video guys. Yall could post a run down of how to install a tail light and I'd still pay xD

I really liked the episode! Honestly I don’t really care what they do as long as it relates to creepy pastas. I’m here to support and watch THEM. As long as they are having fun and keeping this channel alive I’ll keep watching. I’d rather them try new things once in a while than bored or burnt out and stop doing this all together :)

This absolutely belongs here

If Hunter went to ACDCs Black Ice Tour in 7th grade, that would likely put his birth year around 1994-1995 for anyone who has been wondering…

this episode is just bad taste for a creepy pasta podcast, there are a million true crime podcasts, we dont need another and I'm hoping this wasnt part of the plan to make a new Red Thread

I remember scaring my parents when I drew a bunch of generic slenderesque schizo drawings and leaving them in my room forgetting about them, then I came back from school one day and they were sitting around looking at them thinking I’d lost my mind

Banjo kazooie💪🏼💪🏼💯💯💯

I grew up like 30 mins away from Where this happened and it was a gigantic deal with everyone knowing someone who knew someone involved in this. They even made a big announcement at school and had like an assembly

I hate the double space in the title

What in the true crime RPF is goin on here?

I hope the boys genuinely disregard people complaining. This is their channel and it's been 2.5 years of creepypastas/no sleep with a large majority of em being absolute slogs to get through. Genuinely if this episode wasn't for you, I get it, but like, don't watch it?

Loved this format! Don't get me wrong I love the creepypastas too, but this was great. Terrifying knowing it's a very true very sad story. MKE is my 🌆 so this hits close to home.

I hate this fanbase sometimes

I'm so ready for more true creep stories lol

Every time I read the comments on this fucking pateron I'm reminded you losers deserve nothing hunter and Isaiah should raise the price and upload less

Great episode guys I wouldn't mind more true crime episodes tbh

The scariest part is that they remindede this happened in 2014 I would have been 13 which means all of these girls are adults now and they have just been children in my head for a decade

Cue hunter angrily ranting about how the fans didn't like it lol

Loved it. Do more of these but don't focus on them as a replacement for the fictional creepcasta

This was an awesome episode! Knowing this was a completely true story just makes it that much creepier. I would love to watch more episodes like this

Loved the vibe of this one, the boys just kinda chatting with a story sprinkled in.

Just watched the backrooms. Why is wendigoon in a wheelchair in the movie? Who is he playing?

My god, guys, I mean, this community is really, really great. I love you all, but why do you complain nonstop, no matter what? Whenever they change the podcast in any way, it's always a problem. I hate that. Like, guys, this was a good episode. Just shut up.

I’m still mad about happy appy. Js.

Guys this is not it. We dont need another true crime channel and you both already cover stuff like this on your own channel. Also talking about real world stuff with the same voice and video tone as jeff the killer feels pretty disrespectful and messed up in general

Please do infected town case files

This is a pretty good change of pace, should be in the rotation

This is cool! I used to be very into true crime podcasts but fell off after I got tired of all the over-sensationalism and armchair investigators. ‘CreepCrime’ is kind of like a full circle moment haha. Hunter and Isaiah can bring a level of class while still being entertaining. Also would love to see more casual movie discussions! Recorded after outside the AMC in a dimly lit liminal parking lot at midnight is fine, in fact it’s a real vibe I appreciate.

no

Yep, definitely going to be a one time thing now.

These comments are a good example of why people get creatively burnt out and call it on projects like this. Making people a prisoner to their format and being overtly negative when they try to mix it up a bit will suck any enthusiasm the creators have until it becomes unenjoyable for them and therefore us. Telling people what their creation is and isn't for is whack. They have been trying new stuff a decent bit lately which shows that maybe they are just really looking for a change of pace. Let people experiment and stretch their legs or get ready for this show to be over in the near future.

Isaiah, as a Wisconsinite I feel compelled to inform you that it’s pronounced “wa-ka-shaw”

My junior year, there was a kid at my school that was passing out black and white marbles to kids to who he was and wasnt going to kill. He also drew detailed violent pictures of people suffering.....his name was Dilbert

Loved this, hope for more

Respectfully I don’t think a podcast where two people read and joke about fictional horror stories is a place for tragic real world events. I’d love it if we didn’t make this a thing

im really into the true crime hybrid. needs some tweaking when it comes to quotes/lines and the way yall read the story (maybe less storytime/narrative and more analytical and serious) but getting into how media affects real life and cases like this are VERY interesting. i dont really think theres any more cases like this though, unless yall want to get into stuff like the chris chan bodycam footage, the teen who killed his mom over the VR headset, ect, those just dont have anything to do with creepypasta or internet niche communities

Saw the title and immediately knew this wouldn’t go over well 😭 love you guys, I enjoyed the episode, but this is not the platform for true crime stuff. People are gonna be pissed for weeks to come. The subreddit will be in shambles for ages

Can yall read the pastel man creepy pasta?

Someone said the other week that they never realized how much Isaiah talks over hunter and I can't help but notice it almost every video now lol

Appreciate the true crime crossover. Putting something like that in this format helps (some of) us to face the horror of it. 🖤

I cool with any story but I definitely miss 3-4 hour episodes. Obvi don’t need them all the time cuz that’s a lot of work for them but I do miss them

Wa-ka-shaw not Wa-kesha

God this case always leaves me feeling sick. I will say when you’re actively dying, you get some weird strength. I had a brain haemorrhage a few months ago and I managed to get help even when I kept passing out, it’s like a switch in your brain turns on and you look for survival. Also please do not go to true crime. I can sense this was a once off due to the content being directly linked to a creepypasta but I’m tired (and others) of true crime podcasts. There are a million and they’re all capitalising on the victims of horrific violence and making out like it’s a juicy spooky story (I’m looking at you Eleanor Neale) Back to original stories next week please

Honestly as someone who is a consumer of most all true crime stuff, Ive heard this case among others several times but honestly the way they set this up and the discussions they had were a nice different approach! Creeping my cast! But I do agree with other commenters on going over the several stories people have posted by different authors etc. that way both us fans have a bit of different and so does the hosts! I’m sure the same thing all the time gets a bit boring. Like tbhhh I also enjoyed the creep tv a lot too!

creep cast fans try not to be insufferable or complain about the episode (impossible difficulty)

I liked the episode and get why you guys covered this story. I do agree with some people that it's probably not a good idea to cover true crime. There are a lot of true crime channels that sensationalize tragedies and are distasteful in how they talk about it. I dont feel like you all did that but I think people want to watch you guys because it's a break from all these things. However, I'm here for whatever you guys decide to do! Always happy when Sunday comes around.

Looking through the comments and realizing people just start criticizing without actually watching first. Yall got to calm down. Its truly insufferable behavior.

I appreciate them trying something new but I would rather them read novels or something else to freshen things up. True crime already is covered by a million other channels. we’re missing actual good stories recently. I want another borrasca I-IV, stolen tounges, left right game etc. there’s no way there are not other good stories/ novels they can read to make things interesting. Appreciate the attempt but this story is so old and I don’t want true crime in this format. Also the comparisons to the red thread are way too close.

I’d kind of prefer to see you guys get into the games and offshoots of creepy pastas instead, but that’s just me lol. Like, a lot of communities online have made some really cool and creative stuff and I’d love to see the that shown here rather than true crime if you want something new or different. Idk, just a thought. But at the end of the day, it’s y’all’s podcast.

Close enough. Welcome back OG red thread

ik im beating a dead horse, but i also hope this is a one-off. couldnt really get in the goofy mindset knowing this actually happened and wasnt just a story written by a dude tripping on benadryl

Ehhhhhh

I had no idea my birthday was the same day at the slenderman stabbing neat stuff

I liked this one. A nice change of pace. Don't mind thats its true crime and would not mind if you occasionally did more in the future

Hey guys, I think you would really like the Novel Tender Is The Flesh by Augustina Bazterrica. It's not very long and since yall have been doing longer vids, maybe it may fit in. It's a crazy read and I think you'd like it. I read it when looking for more authors of color. I will keep commenting this everywhere until you acknowledge it!

Give us more creep true crime

I would love to see them do readings of what actually happened in other famous events, like the dommer family or sothing

i really hope this is a one off, this show is a comedy show at its core. i don’t listen to this to actually get sad and angry at real tragedies

love the creep crime format, it sheds great awareness on a horrible crime that shouldn't be forgotten, well done guys!

Please do not became a true crime podcast. I love you guys but I’m here for creepypastas not horrific irl tragedies

I love true crime and creepypastas, and it’s literally a crime influenced by a creepypasta. 😭 idk why people are complaining. If you don’t like it, don’t watch it.

did the editor get their tip??

The pronunciation of Waukesha just made me crash my car on my way to work

I would love to see a CreepTv about the Glendale Archives! I think the guys would absolutely love it

Good God. I moved to Sun Prairie 2 years ago from Michigan. I didn't know that crazy girl almost got placed there. Sure Flint has led in the water but there is definitely something in the water over here in Wisconsin. There has been a new crazy murderer over here like every 30 years since Ed Gein. Lol

Making this incident “digestible” (for profit) is gross. Never do this again

I remember the Charles E. Cheese…. I also remember walking in and being astonished at all the games and shit and when my dad walked up to the counter to get us in and heard the price of everything he said come on and I asked are we going to play these games?! And my dad was like: No. and it shattered my childhood dreams 🤣🤘🤦🏻

This video is well done, it's put together great, but man... I watch Creepcast for the goofs and gaffs, and this kinda felt like a gut punch.

Formatting true actual stories like a narrative is weird, I think I’m out of this one boys

Am I the only person who doesn’t hate this? It’s an event that was heavily influenced by a creepypasta. I don’t think it’s a crazy thing to talk about just for a small change of pace..?

I love the podcast and I love them just yapping but this episode just felt weird or should’ve been a bonus. Like I get that you will eventually run out of stories to read but what’s the point of creating a place for people to create such amazing stories that we barely get to hear them

This ain't it, chiefs.

I love this format

lets maybe probably not do this again, i get you guys cover true crime but this feels very distasteful, and not very creepcasty at all

Oh boy a single episode that is slightly different? Time for a bunch of fans to have an absolute blowout over a small amount of experimentation.

I think everyone forgot that the original ads for the channel described it as being a covering of all things macabre. whether that be fictional stories, movies, videos, or even irl stuff. I don't think this was disrespectful in the slightest. they maintained a general serious tone but were still respectfully playful. If we really want to get into the semantics of story contents, then by that train of logic Wendigoon and PapaMeat should've gotten in trouble for the ACTUAL murders they've covered on their channels. you can't decide something is suddenly poor taste just because the persons discussing it aren't in what you perceive to be the right room (granted, they probably could've hashed out the format a little better. but once again, at no point did it feel like it was taking from the severity of the events). I personally enjoy that they're branching out with different avenues of discussion. I thought more people would've have wanted more than just another creepypasta storytime channel. Clearly, I was wrong...

Who up creepin they crimes??!!

Please don’t do this again, this is not the show/hosts for this. I’m not trying to be disrespectful to you all but this does seem distasteful and bizarre? Not the channel for this

I don’t really think we need another true crime style show here. Like if you want to switch it up there’s creepTV to break up reading stories or like horror movie breakdowns or even vlog stuff like the mummy vid. I feel like the guys have there own channels for this kinda vibe, kinda sucks this is this weeks episode. Just my thoughts.

Mid

If i wanted to listen to true crime i would go listen to one of the million other true crime podcasts out there. I like this show because you guys can riff and review stories narratively and i value your critique. I like hearing about new or unheard of authors and giving them the spotlight. Creepcast is not a true crime podcast. Please don’t do this again or if you want to start another channel or something.

I'm such a paranoid parent already, hearing this case always makes me fearful for when my kids are old enough to ask to go to their friends for a sleep over.

After listening to the full episode i enjoyed it but i truly hope this is a one off

Wisconsinite here, it’s WAH-KUH-SHAW and NICK-UH-LAY

20:30 fuck that pirate game is so good

Huge props to the boys for trying something new that they’re excited about. But something about narrating them in this fashion like any other spooky story feels a little bit distasteful?

I liked the episode and it was respectfully done; I'm down for the occasional CreepCrimeCast. It does feel more like a Patreon than a main line episode though. Thanks for everything you guys do!

yikes…

Whole lot of over dramatic bitching this episode...

Creep cast fans trying not to argue in the comments challange: impossible

I missed red thred with the goon

i saw a lot of people not happy with this on the subreddit. i like this kind of thing! im happy if you guys decide to branch out and experiment

I love creepcast but I don’t think this was the move. I understand if you guys wanted to talk about this case because the anniversary is coming up and it’s related to a popular creepypasta, but the way it was executed wasn’t the best. Reading it like it was a story you guys got off of creepypasta doesn’t feel right. It feels the same as when true crime channels do a mukbang or their makeup while talking about actual crimes. It just feels disrespectful.

I do like a true crime episode, and this is very relevant to creepypastas and internet horror. But! I agree with other comments that I hope the show doesn’t become Creep True Crime

I'm subbed for creepcast not red thread. Thank you very much

I don’t hate this, however im not a fan of how they formatted it, wendigoon is amazing at this kinda thing & papa meat has covered true crime too, if they wouldve found a way to fuse their styles around it I think it would be a lot better

The way he pronounced Waukesha lmao

I love this episode True crime stories in my favorite podcast !! Yayyy !!

People might take this as poor taste, however I'm here for whatever they upload.

im not adamantly one side or the other but i do prefer the fiction focus just bc I love finding new awesome writers I haven't read before.

I respect the fact that they’re trying to expand the options on what can be a part of CreepCast, (maybe to avoid burnout) but at the same time, they’ve built such an awesome rhythm with their own Creep Subreddit and encouragement of creativity from us as viewers. Overall this just feels a bit out of place, and I almost felt that I couldn’t enjoy the comedic moments because of the actual tragedy that took place. I think that Hunter and Isiah respectively can have quips on their own channels that are entertaining about real life events, but together on this specific channel it just comes off wrong. I want to be able to enjoy a story and their comedic commentary without having to morally analyze what’s being talked about, at least beyond what an author is wanting us to pick up. Love Creeping my Cast but this is not the move for this channel! :)

I honestly thought this episode was fine, even if parts of it were a little unsavory. Fiction just fits this kind of content so much better. I’d much rather watch Isaiah goon over a well structured sentence than sit through the boys reading about some real life horrific tragedy and just end up feeling bummed out the whole time.

people piss and moan about everything. the episode is fine

As someone who lives next door to this story, it felt very off putting for a comedy/dramatic podcast to cover this story that hit our community so hard. Also, it's Wah-Kah-Shaw, not that hard to watch a newscast to hear them saying it right; a little petty note, but shows that not a ton of research actually went into this.

In WahKe$ha Wisconsin

Creeping this rn

I thought this was gonna be like a creepy pasta based on this I’m curious their thought process on this one — I haven’t listened but this seems odd