Something's Really Weird About My Sexy New Neighbor [Ad-Free]

im so sad it took an hour and a half to get to phenomenal cat

Every time Sunday rolls around, I always get my hopes up that we'll get another Jared Roberts episode.... I still think The Arkansas Sleep Experiment should be featured in a classic creepypasta grab bag!

Did the gooner react to this episode on a Patreon post? Or am I tripping?

When life gets tough, I come back to Creepcast. Thanks for best content guys (commenting this on the first video I watch after I come back from my internet break)

Hunter’s not bad at reading, he just reads too fast. Take your time buddy, you got this 😃

Jared Robert making hay as usual

I was hoping to see Isaiah react to this episode.

Obese man with a pre K reading level trying to read schizophrenic, rambling.

This guy could do opera. Fuck man his voice shocks me every time.

This story kind of reminds me of "Weapons". Definitely agree the ending fell really flat, but Hunter did a great job by himself. This was fun all things considered.

Papa meat rawdogging it solo, yes and thank you daddy 💕

If Isaiah was here this would've been twice the length

Tbh I keep coming back to this story, I actually love it all the way through. It's just so ridiculous by the end that I'm totally enveloped in trying to understand it. Of course it has objective flaws like the snake not coming back I assumed it was the transformed bodies of his victims, or some symbolism with shed skin and how he's keeping himself or her corpse alive, but it really goes nowhere. "Frog day" made it all worth it though.

this goes from scary to incoherent so fast

I thought we were getting a wendigoon reaction to this video?

We love momma meat

I’m sorry but is no one talking about about the authors username?

The Tulsa hate is real (my hometown is dog water)

Holy shit 1:39:02 this writing made me think I smelled burnt toast wtf

This had SO many little parts that I loved and were creepy, but the majority of this story was so disjointed or had parts in it that literally didn't make any sense. I think a lot of it was AI generated, which is why it sucks. We wanna read something that was made with heart, and had actual effort put into it!

Congratulations Isaiah and welcome to the world baby Tonka 😂

God damn Hunter got some fucking pipes in that voice well done sir!

Why did Hunter's camera mirror then unmirror when his mom came in, and then mirror again?

Hunters grandma is kind of hot 🥵

The little jabs were pretty potent, but this dude could not do the connective tissue. I was so sure the snake would play into the sexual aspect of the story. Forbidden fruit, and how a snake mouth can look when opened wide. Really expected the MC to get putting his schmeat in the snakussy. Big squandered potential all around.

The bussy has claimed many a young man.

👏👏👏👏🐱🐈🐈‍⬛

"The bussy is a dangerous and powerful drug my friends."

Isiah should react on Wendigang

He's reading English but I don't think I understood anything at any point in this story at all. I do think it had some good blurbs but man poor Hunter, props to him for powering through.

I believe the story revolves around the idea of the U-Haul truck I won’t elaborate

Best episode yet

Make sure to give Isaiah another episode off in a couple months. The sleep deprivation stacks and makes you go crazy. The first bit is helpful, but in a couple months giving him the ability to take a nap will feel like heroin to a new parent 😂 I think this was a great episode for the record. Keep it creepy.

35:49 I’m working while listening to this and hearing him say “Michelle” just gave me the biggest whiplash lmaoo

Convinced the author was having a stroke whilst writing this. As a result, poor Hunter had a stroke reading this 😔

Loved it and I loved your analysis and your reading, awesome

I know people didn’t care for this one but I think this is pretty cool. I think Jared Roberts is just really good at these batshit stories

Btw. I think we can just let Hunter do this from now on

I can't tell if I loved this or if I am confused

Can we get Hunter's rendition of "Phenomenal Cat" clipped & downloadable? I need a new ringtone!! 🤧🤧

Hey, uh, anyone know where I can get some uh "street" Cast? It's been 2 weeks and I'm pretty strung out and.. not sure... I... can make it... to Sunday...

Started off so interesting with great moments but went on for too long

Omfg imagine if he did an episode with Nik the next time Isaiah takes a week off. Shit would be 5 hours for a 30 minute story with all the Nik stories we'd get

If there's one thing I've learned from listening to creepcast it's sometimes you just need to end the fucking story you're writing cuz a lot of them just draaaaaaag

Someone needs to make this into a movie.

hunter is rot maxxing

One of my favorite episodes ever, wish Isaiah were here too🥰

Hunter pulled an Isaiah “Oh my God.” when his mom brought up seeing boys pp. 😆

I really liked this story. One of my favorite stories on the podcast tbh.

Phenomenal Cat was so good, wish it would've been as long as Fairy Queen!

I need Hunter Hancock's Phonomenal Cat on Spotify and Apple music yesterday!

Definitely should've ended when the dad went in the house. Kill the dad off, made the little brother as well. MC is traumatized and so is the mother. Then the story is vague Monster Descriptions that read like a metaphor, underage naughtiness, and an ending that equally confusing as it is unhappy. That's a award winning Stephen King Novella right there

I love when Hunter starts reading a sentence and turns into Simple Jack. Lol

I guess the lesson to be learned here is to never, ever trust a pair of big ol’ ghoul titties

There were so many really neat leads that just never paid off. Shame. The ending was enough to make me regret the story entirely. It also sounded at points like Chat GPT wrote it, like random excerpts were just language model babble.

Granpussy is simultaneously so offensive and so diabolically funny, my lips ache with laughter.

The funniest thing about this story (far funnier than any of the intended comedy) is that the only scary part of it was the feet licking scene, and that was just straight up plagiarized from a much older (and much better) horror story. And I’m pretty sure it was only included because it was the author’s fetish.

Hunter, you are an epicenter of an artist and we love you ❤️ hello mother meat, and lady....

If Mr. Goon is going to be gone for a few more episodes I'd love to see Papa and little Nik to do a story together

What an awful ending to a great story

I’ve missed hearing Hunter narrate! I’ve been enjoying the live streams where he reads more

PAPA YOURE THE BEST, MY WIFE AND I HAVE WATCHED YOU FOR YEARS ACROSS ALL PLATFORMS, WE WISH WE COULD SUPPORT YOU MORE BUT LIFE IS ROUGH FOR A YOUNG COUPLE. YOU HAVE 2 DIE HARDS RIGHT HERE!

I was so confused through most of this story, I can’t tell if I was missing things or if it’s just nonsensical. This whole thing read like Who Was Phone to me, like I was being punked

This story is like a train wreck, I cannot look away.

Wild story

Jared Robert’s gotta be my favorite creepypasta/no sleep author everything is so whacked out in his stories i love em. Ordered his books cause of this episode

Annoying ass ending

1:32:20 best part

Holy the Rick Sanchez bear trap was INSANE

I really checked out after Dad went missing

What the fuck

Did anyone else view the story as a metaphor for online predators, TCAP, and how systems are designed (and bent) to lack efficacy for their stated purpose? It reads more like an abstract of differently affected individuals’ experiences, perceptions, and actions while experiencing stages of CSA. I think the semi-stream of consciousness style is a great vessel for these individually distinct experiences that can’t help but bleed into everyone else’s.

I get the distinct impression that this story was written by a stupid person.

This was for sure written by Hunter

Someone explain that ending to me I got so lost

I for one, have no problem if Isiah needs to breastfeed Tonka during future episodes.

The real creep cast story should be craigslist missed encounters

What am i

You can tell this is the same author as hidden webpage. The story goes on forever and no interesting payoff. Hunter is doing what he can though to make it bearable

I thought the story was pretty great but I am a little betrayed by the sudden unexplained ending.

If you need another episode for paternity leave, play a game where Nic gives Hunter the names and thumbnails from episodes and we see how many he remembers

This story would’ve been great if it just ended after the dad disappeared

The story was mid but... That song!! That was pretty impressive 🤣

I think I like the “I write from hell” story more than this lowkey

Aunt Thea communing with the spirit of Michael Jackson was definitely not something I would've predicted

It’s nice to have a mid one every once in a while. Thanks for keeping us going Hunter!

This episode was soooo good. Hope Isaiah watches it and goes wtf.

WHAAAAAT?!?!?!? “WHO IS THIS MAN” is an all time shocker twist

Doing great on your own but while Isaiah is off feeding his worm or whatever Dad's do, It would be cool to get a show with Tom and Don doing Creep cast. I know it won't happen but getting the old cream crew back together for a creep cast episode would warm my heart

anyone else go back and replay phenomenal cat like 20 times

I would love a guest star while Wendigoon is out. Like a Noel Miller or a PsychicPebbles riffing with Hunter over bad stories would be amazing

Need to get Hunter‘s Phenomenal cat on vinyl holy shit

WENDIPUSSY?

American Pie if it was a Horror Movie

I liked the story until the Department of Energy thing. Then it got me back in with Aunt Thea… then it ended. I think the author didn’t know what to do with all the setpieces, like the kid’s Mom, and then just kinda got tired of the story and ended it. C’est la vie with internet horror stories, I guess. Still been loving the Hunter-only episodes though!

Man this story hurt to go through I checked out halfway through, but meat singing brought me back in near the end

CreepCast nostalgia grab bag suggestions (in no particular order just what I can remember) 1.) Happy Appy 2.) I Purchased my Childhood Home 3.) Bubby The Clown 4.) Mr Mix 5.) My Family Has Been Stalked For the Last Four Years 6.) The Cell Phone Game 7.) What I've Done As Your Secret Admirer 8.) Teddy 9.) Abandoned By Disney 10.) Rap Rat 11.) Antran 12.) Ronald MacDonald House

CreepCast nostalgia grab bag suggestions (in no particular order just what I can remember) 1.) Happy Appy 2.) I Purchased my Childhood Home 3.) Bubby The Clown 4.) Mr Mix 5.) My Family Has Been Stalked For the Last Four Years 6.) The Cell Phone Game 7.) What I've Done As Your Secret Admirer 8.) Teddy 9.) Abandoned By Disney 10.) Rap Rat 11.) Antran 12.) Ronald MacDonald House

Some of this story is so well written in terms of suspense and reveals that I'm convinced this is a normal writer who was challenged to see how many jokes/horny he could put into a story.

We appreciate you, Hunter!! Thanks for the story and the laughs

please god check out "My Dad Finally Told Me What Happened That Day" whenever Isiah returns

the way Hunter describes childbirth is so sentimental and sweet 🥰

This is a sex pennywise. Stephen King’s “tIT”

I do love that Hunter is giving us content while Isaiah is out there fathering. Thank you Papa Meat 🙏

This story lost me with the department of energy

I just realized, even with Wendigoon gone the Creep Cast child ### abuse curse continues. lmao. I can't wait for Wendigoon's reaction.

Mom cohost next episode PLEASE

I vote Hunter's mom just co-hosts until Wendi is back.

mom is out of town and dad got us takeout

Phenomenal cat was beautiful

The music and math bits to the rituals were very interesting thanks for giving up author you can eat my poo

The story just gave up on us during the only interesting point the author can eat my poo

how was this an amazing story and a horrible story at the same time

Glad creep #1 wasn’t here to read this bs thanks number two for your service

I didn’t get the villain it was a old man demon that wanted kids in his box?

🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

I hope there will be another live they’re so fun

hunter looks like he wanted to shoot whoever that old sack of shit with his mom was in the back of the head😥

Hunter please read who was phone

Disliked the over the top horniness and scummery and how convoluted the plot was, LOVED the Phenomenal Cat song (instant hit), snake shapeshifters are a cool concept if done well (not like this)

Papa meat mispronouncing Santeria is so funny

you should do a episode with your mom

This is truly the castiest creep to have been casted

As someone who’s in calculus rn when she said speaking of limits I felt like a Vietnam war veteran

Yeah this one got really confusing and disjointed

I mean I already know Hunter can sing but he absolutely crushed phenomenal cat

This is like if hereditary was written by a 16 year old boy

The fact that his mom just walks in 😂

Hour and a half in and we've lost the plot about 12 times

Bro really enjoyed that Gussy (Grandpaussy)

Tommy taffy but good?

Papa meat doesnt tolerate double standards when it comes to females SAing males, and as a SA survivor i rock with that

reminds me of the scene from South Park where Ned and Jimbo are in the bushes and like 20 people go running out of the bushes when they think they're caught

PLEASE let nick cohost while Isaiah is away on maternity leave

Unfortunate the first half was Great then it just devolved into what the fuck.

Is there a way to get chat replay on this video?

Hunter's mom is an absolute BADDIE 😩 (this is a joke hunter please don't ban me 🗿)

It was good, until it got the the aunt part. It should have just ended when the dad disappeared. Say he gives himself up for the kids and the lady is never seen again.

Man, wasn’t expecting a new worst CreepCast story this weekend

This story is like constantly flipping from genuine to complete meme territory and it’s giving me horrible whiplash

This story feels like the unholy love child of The Hidden Webpage and Tales From The Gas Station, written by a horny high school freshman

I don't even understand wtf happened

The power of them titties

Where's Nicholas?

This story has some of the best little creepy moments, a horrifying otherworldly old man snake monster that doubles as a sexy lady. Its hard to tell what was real and what wasnt. the abrupt end was a huge bummer. Certain moments with the humor was definitely weird, like the main character gets SA'd and the dad makes jokes and the story goes on. In different ways it feels like the author either didnt want to continue or it was like a poorly executed purposefully unsatisfying ending.

Hi guys I was working outside and it’s 80° on February 9th bruh. Ac feels nice in the truck 🤣

This story had so many strong points and concepts but then would switch up as if there were 2 people writing it and the 2nd person was 12 and it makes no sense.

Grandbussy.

You should have nick or Harry or Alison read with you

We love you hunter 😘

Please do more Jared Robert’s stories! “My dad finally told me what happened that day” is really good. And his short stories are great as well

I liked it at least. Thanks, Hunter and Congrats to Isaiah.

What the actual fuck was this? It was pretty funny at first and then just completely faceplanted after an hour. Props on Hunter for powering through

This story did not make me want to creep my cast 💔 Much love to Hunter and his newly-mothered co-host regardless

Santeria and a Kung Fu Grip reference

Peak cast without the giant lips to help is still peak cast. Thank you Hunter for still holding down the channel and providing content while the lips is on break. Keep your head up king.

This comment section needs a napalm airstrike. Do yall even like the show?

It took 1 hour and 44 minutes for him to fully lose his mind with the reading

Congrats to Isaiah on becoming a father!

Maybe in these solo reads you could bring in nick to help lol

1:12:00 Kratos “There are consequences to falling for the bussy, Atreus.” Atreus “How do you know?!?!? How do YOU know!?!?!?”

that was a rough one

Your review was fucking harsh bro. It was better than a lot of other shit you said was fine xD. A noticed a lot of moments and themes seemed to go over hunters head so perhaps that is why. Missing those moments can make a big difference.

hard listen would’ve been 10x better if i didn’t hear every sentence 6 times

Hey hunter I love the story I just wish you would reread certain parts. Im really confused at what's going on and even after relistening im still confused

That story sways between cool reveals and really confusing dialogue

ill take more solo hunter if we get some more phenomenal cat

Really needed Isaiah at the end to break down what happened.. I think this story ending would have really hit with better delivery

I love that I tell my partner that this episode is only Hunter, and their response is "I hope Isaiah realizes what he has done by allowing this man to do this by himself. He truly is a hobgoblin. Not a goblin-a super goblin" 🤣

Also, I love your mom and grandma so much.

Been boofing too much galaxy gas and had no idea there was even a stream.. heartbroken I missed lil red forty :c

I watched part of this live but ended up having to do something and didn't get to finish it. But how dare you put down Oklahoma when you live in Kansas/Missouri 🤣🤣

bro really just started slammin his fists on the keyboard to write the last 1/4 of this story. made no damn sense.

Mr floppy is life

Next time you’re solo do a creepTV gang 😭😭✌🏻

Wtf is that ending is that some kind of creepcast mini series

Knowing it's by Jared Robert's and the mention of the dept of energy makes me think it's connected to The Hidden Webpage or "the machine stories" that they mentioned in that episode, because that one similarly had that unreality, dreamlike pace to the writing and then had an immediate drop in a sudden end. I personally liked it. I wish he knew the author before hand now cause it's kind of cool if it's a connected thing and could relate back to the Hole from the other story. Being in the box is the same as being in the whole or something and similarly things stop making sense once inside.

the story seems to be an analogue of how sexual abuse in young men is handled in the black community, notice how jb brags and jokes about “becoming a man” for his first time with a woman (who is clearly older) and never once thinks to process that he was actually molested by an old man

Hunter you are truly and genuinely a beautiful singer 🙏💚🖤

Yo who was that milf that showed up? Give me her info H dawg 😏

You're telling me that our main character and his family, and Darnell aren't black?? I thought they all were the whole time but if they were why would the narrator mention a black man 💔😭

This read like a David Lynch production, I bet it would make a killer film if done in his style

This male fantasy is crazy work.

The story is about a black family. It didn't hit me until the aunt came into the picture. If race isn't mentioned readers usually visualize white characters. I can see how the story feels confusing and oversexualized if the main characters were white, but if they're black there are several themes of black masculenity and the sexual adultification of black boys. Society sexualizes black men in general and tends to see black teen boys as sexual deviants. The story is good, you could have a lot of discussions on the themes and how the author shows the race and culture of characters without saying it (I just don't feel like typing it up). If you're up for it you should re-listen to the story or read it by yourself with the image of a black family being haunted by a white 40 year old woman / white old man. Themes of white women sexualizing black teen boys because white men push oversexualization on both of them. There's a history of white men first sexualizing women then sexualizing black men (the 40 year old woman's story). The school kids mentioned later in the story are also black which adds the discussion of the SA of black teen boys by older white women and being seen as an adult in the situation (Darnell's story). Happy for Isaiah (Wendigoon) but wish he was here to dig deeper into the themes of this story. I wonder if he would have caught it. (Also the box that's mentioned is the stereotypes that white men put on minorities. We're tempted to "go in" (fit the stereotype) but once we do we're never the same. The box (stereotypes) change people and it gets bigger as the old white guy (white men) put more people in it. We all have a chance to escape (break free of the stereotype), but sometimes escaping has consequences and we think staying (accepting the stereotype as truth) is better.) As the mother of the story said, "Dad would have been so proud of you. Too bad we're in that box." Happy Black History Month ya'll!

….mr floppy………

Holy hell what is this

(Rabbit season voice )God Damm this episode is good

I can’t wait until someone compiles the random clips in the last few seconds of these last few episodes

Wtf I thought they were introducing these ideas and they would all come to a climax, but it just throws it all away for nothing at the end

need to get hunters mom to cohost with him when Isiah’s away 🗣️🔥

Lots of thanking

Missy really needs to be the substitute co host from now on.

"Get me away from vampire stuff. We've done a lot of vampire stuff" Hunter that was one episode lol.

The aunt is named "Aunt Aunt"

15 minutes in, so far the best part has been hunter's mom being real af.

In Tulsa?

“Jean Baptist who is that man” is gonna be in my rotation of creep cast quotes

It felt like the last half was written within a smaller timeframe. First part was very intriguing, could do less with the gooner talk fr.

I have seven minutes left, and this story has genuinely been a fever dream. What the actual fuck. Edit: finished it now. As someone who used to do m*th, I feel like the person who wrote this wrote 70% of it while on m*th. Genuinely.

I feel like the writer used the TV mini series adaptation of "The outsider" as an influence and doubled down on the santaria aspect that the series briefly touched on to wrap things up and then kind of realized he was explaining too much or didn't know how to wrap it up so he made a knot with every thread possible to get to that ending pretty solid tho if it ended with them just moving away. We need a full karaoke track of hunter singing about that cat

Isaiah would not have anything good to say about this story

The story was so unique and refreshing (at first) with the mixture of creepiness and silliness. Genuinely had me HOOKED up until the Dad disappeared, then it just fell flat. I REALLY hope we can read another story with a writing style like this one day D:

I enjoyed this up until the ending. And a lot of it made no sense but it could’ve been so much better

Came here to be scared, left with a boner

This has got to be one of the most disappointing stories they’ve ever read

I would kill to have my mom be like hunters mom

I don't want to explain the title to my coworkers I swear this is a horror story DONT JUDGE

It’s a good concept of a story, but I really feel like it drags? I think it would have had more of a punch if it stopped after the dad revealed that his son is now “imprinted”, it would be a good cliffhanger

SOMEONE IS WALKING TOWARDS ME AND LAUGHING

Same author as The Hidden Webpage, that explains the gut punches and the overall fever dream style

Gonna need Hunter to sing more, that was genuinely fantastic lol

More papa meat mama features!!!

Jesus that really fell apart at the end there huh?

Certified Hood Classic

It would be cool to see Nick, your mom or whoever guest host during Isaiah is away. You handle the show perfectly, and think that would be a great foil here. Thanks for babysitting, us Dad ❤️‍🔥

I feel like I don't know what the missing piece of this story is. The Santeria rituals suggest that there is something going on with a cultural divide that I have no context for, but a better writer could have given context and maintained the mystery. Like imagine if Stolen Tongues never had Tiwe and Nathan explaining the American Indian folklore going on. But with even more disjointed yet loosely connected elements going on. Overall I didn't dislike it and was legit spooked at times.

This story was such an insane fever dream lmao, I had no idea what the hell was happening

LET THE OLD GOAT CO-HOST. While Isaiah is away

First 3/4 for me was good minus some jokes if u cut the amount of jokes in half it'd be alot better that last 1/4 was interesting with voodoo to dispell? The box. The caprie sun thing was weird and the whole Micheal Jackson thing was unneeded and then the ending felt very rushed I agree with that but I think overall you make the ending the dad is missing and cut out half the jokes and it'd make a great story

Bro this shit started out great as hell then shit the bed real quick lolol some of those reveals got me real good though

I can’t be the only one begging for a full version of “Phenomenal Cat”

You guys should read tails from the grid square

Day 39 of asking for "The Supermarket Monster".

I have to say, Hunter, you genuinely are such a fun person to listen to. Like, it shows that we could listen to this whole thing and not vomit through our eyes nearly as significantly during the second half exclusively because you were helping us through it.

The reveal of the mom seeing the man... I was looking like a man in the trenches

Is this not the same Jared Roberts that wrote The Hidden Webpage?

All the horror of the story is drowned out by just how much "teenage boy fantasy" there is. Could be better if there was actual discussion on female perpetrated predation on children, but nah. The author is a child themselves.

Yeah, this story read like someone who has lots of neat ideas, just couldn't execute a story that actually used them and tied them all together. Enjoyed the writing though, feel like t his author could make something great with little more practice.

14 minutes in....unhinged and I see why we do not leave Hunter unsupervised.

I really liked this story. Then the dad went missing. I liked the energy guys don’t get me wrong it’s like the bee guys from the hole and I really liked how they were saying things that made him think of her boobs and how he felt ashamed about thinking of them. Sometimes the humor about the sexual stuff was too much but I liked how his mindset started to evolve through the story. From a kid first really diving into sexual things and into someone who has sexual trauma a now feel ashamed for his rashness to get into that world. A better version of this story without the sexual stuff is My Dad Finally Told Me What Happened That Day. Please please please please please please please please read it. Please.

Isaiah better start sweating bullets because if you keep posting these solo bangers Hunter, we might not need him anymore. Bro needs to get his priorities straight and focus on what’s more important than being a “father” or having “baby” or whatever lame ass excuse

Overall really enjoyed this story. Interesting concept much more unique story than anything I’ve heard in awhile .

Truthfully i liked the ending! It could’ve been better but i didn’t think it was bad at all!

im pretty sure this story is connected to another story of Jared Robert's called the farmhouse

Damn, that cat really was phenomenal 😻

TULSA OKLAHOMA MENTIONED LETS GOOOO!!!!

This story is remarkably similar to the Hidden Webpage: our protags were sucked into "the box" which is essentially "the hole" the moment they opened it in that backyard. You could even say that hole is the same hole as the one they dug up, transmuted into reality instead of the digital world. The sexual themes were extremely pronounced but similar, the idea of being taken advantage of by an ambiguous entity that feels like a stalker/predator, a callback to potential buried childhood trauma. The reoccurring appearance of "the snake" is essentially the "bee men" and whether following it may have freed them is left ambiguous as every time it appears, our protags avoid it instead of having that endgame pursuit that the Hidden Webpage protag had, though you could say the end sequence with the jar of blood and the snake on the table was the equivalent of that HWP sequence. It has the same theme of an unknowable evil entity that transcends time and place, that traps people within its realm by throwing non- sequitur distractions and threats at the protag. The escalating ridiculousness of the story is nearly identical to the HWP, but where it seems to hit a brick wall is that the writer decided to end with our characters getting stuck in the "box/hole" instead of being freed like the HWP protag, which leaves no time or room to explore the idea outside the crescendo. It is interesting that the box might not have had anything to do with their situation, but that the father had gotten them stuck in the box before any of this started by interacting with the woman as a teen. If that's true, these protags were born into the box, not reality as we know it, which might overlap with the themes of the HWP and the uncertain reality that he might never have left the Hole, that there's no way out for someone that never existed in reality to begin with. Edit: looking into the release dates between this story and HWP, this story was posted about one year before it, so I think that this story served as kind of a first draft to what would become The Hidden Webpage, where they resolve the abrupt ending, they treat the abuse themes with a lot more subtlety, the buildup and cool off are a lot smoother, and the humor doesn't kill the pacing the way this story does. It seems like this was the progenitor of what became The Hidden Web Page, a much more refined idea, and a much better end product.

I had all of breaking bad on dvr

SNIFF

1/3rd into the story i was straight jorkin it, 2/3rd into the story i was fully bought in and was loving every word. 3/3rd into the story and by the end i felt like i had had a 12 panic attacks and 18 strokes

We LOVE mama meat pop ups

i love the term Wendipussy you gotta call him that on another video

My neighborhood has an unusually high amount of elderly men who enjoy doing yard work without shirts in the summer, no big tiddy 40 year old though

This story was so fucking promising until the dad went missing. Jeeeeeeesus

When am I supposed to be creeped? I've just been strokin my shit the entire time. Alien MILF bussy? uhhh yes please!

It's like a mix of the hidden webpage and tommy taffy? The energy guys are the guys in the bee costume and the hole in the wall is well. The Hole

as i said in the live chat, this is one "long story short" kina story

I don’t know how old this story is, but honestly it has some really good parts, I’d love to see not this story in particular, but I wonder if there are any old stories that were good but kinda cringe that ever got revisited and rewritten by the author later.

at some point it felt like this was taking place in The Hidden Webpage. like they’re in the hole but poorly written

Dad?

How is this the same guy who wrote Hidden Webpage 😭

My beartrap was that i was drawing some frogs when i started listening to the episode….i can’t look at my frogs the same ngl😭 also I was convinced this was a fright night type story at first

I would really really really love to see yalls spin on reading "I'm a Guard Stationed at a secret government prison" https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/cr0lna/im_a_guard_stationed_at_a_secret_government/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb3x&utm_name=mweb3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

Being from the same author of The Hidden Webpage I can definitely see the stylistic storytelling parallels. Really intriguing set up with plenty of cool spooky twists and turns. It starts to go off the deep end becoming increasingly surreal and dreamlike, and then doesn't end as strongly as it starts. I still like The Hidden Webpage and feel it definitely didn't fall apart for me as badly as this did. This on the other hand started off really promisingly cool and scary but became a disappointing slog for me until a bizarre unsatisfying ending.

Man i was so hooked but that ending SUCKED

Kinda reminds me of The Witches book by Roald Dahl

WHAT'S IN THE BOX?

"I got a scaredy boner now, time to go to church" its like Wendigoon is still with us.

1:40:00 the torettes outburst caught me off guard

The beginning was great but the story took a nosedive

MOM IM IN A LIVE CHAT UGH

Tulsa native representing!

Spoopy story writers try not to put child molestation in there story challenge -impossible

isiah named his kid after a bean?

It does sort of read like a young guy wrote the story. Like there were some cool ideas in there but it got lost and like you said, didn't know where to go, and just ended. the base idea though is pretty cool if even a bit weird.

when isiah said hunter only reads well when he’s locked into a character super true

Honestly liked the story but like you said it felt like they didnt know what to do with it or how to end it

Spoiler, the neighbor is Jane the Killer 😳😳

Man this story was so good until it wasn't, nothing really panned out and it felt like there was so much missing. It had great potential.

OH YEAH NEW EPISODE FOR THE SHIFT

Hunter is secretly Josh Groban in a goop suit

you should read a story with nick in the future if you have any other solo videos

Turnk brownie has been birthed

In the scene where she says she needs help, before we knew what was going on, it was either a woman grooming and SAing a child or a man using a woman as a lure to do that. It’s weird how the author writes that like it’s nbd. I get that it’s like they’re hypnotized but there’s no like retrospective of how weird it’s only presented as creepy when the creature is presenting as a man.

This show definitely needs two people to bounce comments around and riff. If Isaiah can't do it, get Nick in there. He and hunter have a good energy for this type of thing. The format could be kind of like a meat canyon video. e.g. Hunter is telling Nick scary bedtime stories. The whole premise of the story was really good. I agree it felt a little improvised and there ending was a hard, unsatisfying stop. The style of writing felt haphazard too, but I think that was intentional. It was written like a 16 year old boy, especially one from where this story presumably takes place, in the American Deep South The humor got a little played out, but I think it was great, especially in the beginning.

Im 100% sure this is an AI story. The set up payoff loop is so clunky that it can only come from an algorithm

Omg. I just walked into my 12yo sons room who was streaming roblox... Hunter you were exactly the kids reaction to me walking in and shooing me out 😆 god forbid I ask him what he wants for dinner 🤦‍♀️ Thats fine my 45yo ass will just do the dishes to make more dishes 🙄

The weird whites dudes in suits thing is a reference to the Men In Black idea, including their weird way of talking and disappearing in weird ways.

Grandbussy box

lol this was a good time. story was absurd but def had some good bits. thanks hunter!!

Damn that first half was great. Wheels didn't fall off, they disintegrated.

The author just started writing a bunch of nonsense.

THATS THE ENDING???

Man this could have been an absolute all timer with the power of some of those reveals. I cannot believe where it went :(

lmao this story is insane, the mom just is so absent

special appearance by grandma meat <3

Telescope is crazy😭

You did a great job tho Hunter

Some of this story was good, it had good ideas, some funny comedy, and the typical hormonal teen boys but the ending sucked.

Just finished the video, a lot of the authors stories end like this, it’s his style for sure. I mean take the ending of Hidden Webpage for example. He leaves many questions unanswered, a lot of cool little questions to ask yourself, and a lot of loosely connected threads. I do agree with some of Hunters points however. Overall I do really like the story, and think they should read more Jarred Roberts

This is my superbowl

So what i gather is, this is just an SCP entry, the weird people who turned up are foundation, the capri suns are nestics, and the author is absolutely obsessed with his neighbour

nawww JB and lil bro got the snowbunny fever 😭

Jared Roberts is the author of hidden webpages, he has a series of stories called "The Machine Stories". The compilation all is linked/connected through technology and weird universe shifting mid story. In my opinion the best of his stories as a standalone other than hidden webpage is this one about lumberjacks, but I can't recall what it's called at the moment.

It's like a roller coaster that just kept going up. Then at the top they just have you get off and walk down the stairs.

Dude I love Jarred Roberts way of writing. This, the Hidden Webpage, and “my dad finally told me what happened that day”, are some of the best stories I’ve ever read. Twists, turns, and gut punches through and through

Hey small request, can you both raise your kids to be mortal enemies? Thanks ^~^

This story really pulls you in and out. I feel like I am swimming, and then I come up for air, and I get sunken back down. Like, there are parts I truly enjoy, but others...well, they are something. Also, congrats to Isaiah on giving birth!

The great Tonka has arrived! ALL HAIL!!

So glad to see a new story about the villages in Florida. Really feeling represented lol.

This gave me hidden webpage vibe

this story was a good 65% of the way there, some genuinely good scenes.... but there's a LOT either bad or going nowhere

Please read “My Dad Finally Told Me What Happened That Day” or “Esther” both by Jared Robert’s too. Talk about creepy reveals. I love his work

I feel like there is some super niche monster or folklore this is story is trying to be clever and not outright tell you what it is but, it all just feels so shoehorned in for that purpose and yet I still have no clue what it could be

Another great episode guys, you did great Hunter, you guys should definitely check out Vita Carnis for CreepTV.

4/5 Creeps. Loved it. The jokes enhanced the flavor for me. Papa should pick stories more often. 😆

Why does the second half make absolutely no sense

Hunters mom is so fucking funny

Great job , Hunter! Thanks for holding the podcast up! You're awesome. Also. I drink Capri Suns only pacific cooler.

congrats, mr & mrs wendigoon! and to you, uncle meat. <3

wuv you papa meat and grandma meat. congrats wendigoon with the worm!

I was wondering how many shows the mom had on dvr...it has been weeks since we have heard from her

this was a let down at the end. thought the start was really fun but really crashed at the finish line

Hunter we love you dont worry

Hey guys, I think you would really like the Novel Tender Is The Flesh by Augustina Bazterrica. It's not very long and since yall have been doing longer vids, maybe it may fit in. It's a crazy read and I think you'd like it. I read it when looking for more authors of color. I will keep commenting this everywhere until you acknowledge it!

Screaming into the void to remember Gemini Home Entertainment for creeptv

Hunter has the show completely to himself and the fucker turned creepcast into freakcast

Hunter. I love you and all but seriously sometimes it’s like listening to that one kid in popcorn reading.

How did i miss this stream?

This stream was a fever dream

Such a beautiful singer. ❤️

This was an attempt at a horror story but the author's 🐓keeps leading him down to erotica. Then he has to figure out how to crawl his way out the hole he dug himself in. Rinse and repeat.

Could you guys post links to the background music you use? Specifically the one that is featured in Drumming in the Clouds I love that almost alarm sound on the track. Please?

so is this just a recording from the previous stream?🙁

Wtf is this story lol dudes fucked old man bussy?! Dad and son just busting in old man guts Also I love Hunter losing his shit when messing up 🤣 Alright fuck this story, most retarded ass ending ever, you did great Hunter 👍

i could smell a hunter story from a mile away

So glad Meat Dad is here to take care of us while Wendi-Dad tends to his other children

This story is a lot like IT, but instead Pennywise feeds on gooners rather than fear

Happy Sunday guys :)

this story is weapons if Gladys was a pervert

He should've had nick on to read for him

Was this live-streamed on Hunter’s patreon?

MamaMeat and GrandMaMeat

First episode I ever had to turn off at work just couldn’t listen to teenagers describing milfs in public, most uncomfortable shit I ever heard😂

tonka as in bean? hell yeah

Can’t wait to meet Tonka <3

...

TonkaGoone

He dint name his child Turnk? 😢

Mmm granny meat

Wait how did I miss the stream I don’t see a notification for it anywhere?

What a let down smh

"How's Darnell"i s completely messed up

😑😑😑 this is not the creepcast birthday present I was hoping for.

One hell of a start

Wasn't here for the stream so I'm so happy to get the edited version

Before watching it I know it’s a one hour story he just can’t read.

You should read a story with momma meat if wendy is not here.

Nice balls, Mr. Goon

This family interaction has explained a lot about Hunter. I'd love to see Wendi's reaction to the titty discussion.

I haven't even listened to it yet but the title is goated

3 hour flight tomorrow, gonna have to save this one for that lol

The ai rendering of hunter is still so good they figured out how to makes videos of him alone. R.i.p a legend

Not everyone made it to the livestream guys 😭😭

Hunter's mom saying she's tired of the babies she already has!! 🤣 My mother said the same thing about her grandkids

Long Live Tahnkkuh

All of you people complaining about getting the WHOLE EPISODE….LIVESTREAMED….WITH EARLY ACSESS… are going to make it so we NEVER get an early episode again and for what. Because you’re disappointed you got it early??? Oh no my steak is too rare, my lobster too buttery 😭

ty for storytime hunter, and congrats to kayla and isaiahgoon <3

Im just glad they uploaded it.

I don’t remember this being streamed on Patreon 😆

Missed opportunity for an episode where Hunter has a cardboard cutout of Isaiah and does his voice and both sides of conversations for 2 hours

Tonka Jahari?

I really like the side by side view with the story and Hunter

Respect to Hunter for keeping these going while Wendigoon if off being a father

Tonka is all of our blessed and protected child, that baby girl will be the most praised and beloved

The amount of people complaining that they’ve seen this already is wild. They’d prefer Isiah sucked Tonka back into is Wombigoon instead of celebrating his motherhood

Is this the only post for today? I caught it when it was livestreamed last week, this story becomes incomprehensible nonsense by the end.

He is a guy ..

His name is Hunter

" its weird my sexy neighbor has the biggest lips ive ever seen. And his boyfriend seems to be able to control fire"

No Appy - no Cream

pls give us another

LETS GOOOO I WAS GETTING SCARED

Your moms kinda hot hunter 😂

Oh yeah as soon as he said “livestreamed” i knew whT it was

Yea, this happened to my friend Jacobi once.

Tbh i expected happy appy

Mother Meat cameo. You can see where he gets it from lol

Oh so this is why we didnt get the livestream

When is Creepcast The Movie coming out

Where is the apple

My fellow commenters frighten me. Edit: Holy fuck my cast was totally just creeped. I had a VHS of Aladdin I fell asleep to constantly. Got them "literal chills" I keep hearing about like holy shit

Meatmom appearance

What

WE GOT TO SEE HUNTERS MAMA

LETS GO WENDIWORM

LETS GET THIS CREEP ON!!

We did hear this the other day right?

WENDIPUSSY?!?!

Nothing like some CreepCast to make me feel better. 😎

the live had to be longer than 2 hours.. how much was cut 🥹 i love hunter but idk if i can bring myself to go through this again

Yay papa got custody of us this weekend. He pulled up in the truck with the Creed CD blaring already

can someone make a creepypasta about how a man travels into his gfs smelly vagina and finds out the smell is actually the body of saddam hussein

All I did was read the title and knew, the creature is right behind me isn't he?

let's go creepers!!!

Beef

I didn’t know what they were talking about when they said my neighbor was sexy, but after seeing their rocking bod, it makes perfect sense.

Oh man, I actually get to understand the story this time. The chat was wild during the live stream 🤣

Ohhh I was waiting for the vod after the stream lol I missed meat saying it was gonna be an actual episode this time

yess happy sunday

We got this live last week

Creepin my cast so early

Love you Hunter whens Nik of love happening 😜🙏

YESSSSSS thank you!!

turned off borrasca pt 1 for this ig

Damn, I already saw this.

Beartrap: the sexy neighbor is me. 😎

Excellent perfect timing as always

do u think the neighbor fw dudes that make $62k a year

Isaiah hope you and Kayla and the baby are all doing wonderful!! 💖💖

My sexy neighbor be creeping they cast

Yes.

My favorite lesbian couple broke up going off that title😞

Me when I

HAPPY SUNDAY YALL!!!!!

S-s-sexy?!?! *GULP*

Hell yeah

Instantly hooked with that title

Oh oh here she comes watch out boy she’ll chew you up. Oh oh here she come she’s a man eater

I cant wait to creep my cast

I like the sound of that

NOOOO

more for me then

Relatable title fr

We up creeping

Uhh what?