HP:BTHBP — Chapter 129 - 130: The Truth of the World
In Horace Slughorn's fifth-year Potions class, a small explosion occurred.
A Gryffindor boy's cauldron began to smoke. Following the next step in the textbook, the student kept stirring. Moments later, the cauldron started splashing half-finished potion, and a few stray drops landed in the cauldrons nearby.
Slughorn rose from the chair beside the lectern — accidents in Potions were perfectly normal.
From a safe distance, Slughorn waved a wand and emptied the problem cauldron.
"Mr. Dewitt, adding too much bluebell is what causes this. If you're willing to sacrifice a little of your lunch break, I think you still have time to brew another batch and hand it in at my office."
The Gryffindor student looked grateful.
But a few minutes later, the cauldrons belonging to two students sitting beside him began the same splashing reaction, and the affected area spread further.
One Gryffindor student was trying to increase the stir count to salvage the potion.
Different cauldrons were at different stages of brewing. Splashed impurities entered the mixture, and an explosion followed.
Several students were hit by scalding potion. They clutched their burns and cried out in pain.
"Stay calm, don't panic! Lupin, take them to the Hospital Wing!" Slughorn's wand kept moving. With each motion, four or five nearby Gryffindor cauldrons were emptied.
Over on the Slytherin side, most students were watching the spectacle with open amusement.
Seeing Gryffindor's misfortune, the Slytherins gloated — while carefully shielding their own cauldrons to make sure the disaster stayed on the other side of the room.
Snape extinguished his cauldron.
His seat for this class fell in the border zone between the Gryffindor and Slytherin sections.
In all the chaos, nobody noticed a sheet of parchment fall to the floor.
And nobody noticed what happened next: as the Gryffindor desks were shoved about and students checked on one another, the kicked-aside parchment drifted in a direction that made no physical sense, carried along by the movement of feet, sliding between them, until it came to rest beneath Snape's desk.
Snape bent down and picked it up quickly.
Eddie, floating high above, had witnessed all of it.
Dried bluebell looked very much like lily of the valley. With just one or two stems mixed in, it could easily be blamed on a careless supplier sorting ingredients.
The raw material was simple to obtain, and it left no trace afterward.
The potion being brewed in this class, combined with the incorrect ingredient slipped into it, had produced an unexpectedly good result.
Lupin anxiously led the injured students toward the Hospital Wing, not noticing at all that a folded sheet of parchment was missing.
After class, Snape found a quiet empty classroom and spread the parchment flat on a desk.
Snape tried Appare Vestigium and Finite Incantatem, working at it for a considerable time. Finally, the parchment grudgingly revealed a single line: "Stealing another's possessions is morally reprehensible — Snivellus, kindly return this where it belongs. Fifty points from Slytherin!"
Snape was thoroughly infuriated.
But since he already knew what the map was capable of, he was not about to abandon it over one sentence.
Snape noticed the ghost had been keeping quiet.
Ever since Slughorn had turned Eddie down, Eddie had gone silent, wearing the look of someone who had taken a serious blow.
"This would be an excellent moment for you to suddenly remember some useful magic."
Snape had not initially wanted to deal with Eddie's low spirits. Eddie was the one who had been rejected. Eddie was the one who would not be making any money. It was not a ghost's place to sit there moping on his behalf.
"I think I have a method that could break this enchantment," Eddie said slowly. "But you have to answer one question for me first."
Good, the ghost was not feeling sorry for him. Simply wanted to negotiate. Snape looked at Eddie with barely contained vexation.
They had never established clear rules covering every situation between them.
But the past few weeks of companionship had gradually formed a strange kind of unspoken understanding, to the point that Snape had never thought to examine whether any of it was even reasonable.
Going by the pattern of exchange they had settled into, the Slughorn matter had been Eddie's proposal. After the negotiation failed, Eddie was the one who owed him. On what grounds was Eddie making new demands?
"Are you still after the moongrass?" Snape frowned. "Then give me a reason why it absolutely has to be done this way."
"Have you noticed that someone is missing from the castle?" Eddie asked abruptly. Ordinary school life ran on too rigid a schedule, once the rhythm of daily routine became habit, it became easy to overlook certain things.
Snape initially assumed Eddie meant himself.
But Eddie said, "Right around the time I had just become a ghost... Slughorn told you in the corridor that something had happened at your home... You were in Flying class, I think?"
Snape had not expected Eddie to bring up something from that far back.
"Your Flying class was shared with Gryffindor. Do you remember a red-haired witch?" Eddie's voice carried a distant quality, as though drawing Snape back to several weeks before.
"I don't remember..." anyone like that.
Snape had been about to answer with confidence, there was no red-haired witch in this year's Gryffindor intake.
But even as the denial formed, a memory surfaced out of nowhere.
By the Black Lake, beneath a large tree, who had he been discussing Charms class with?
"Are you saying someone has tampered with my memories?" Snape set the map down. It was still showing no text. Eddie's silence clearly had another reason behind it.
"I've been observing the situation around us." Eddie searched for the right words. "I feel like the world is a little... blurry."
For a time, Eddie had kept up the habits of the living.
When following Snape through the castle, Eddie made an effort to avoid passing through walls. During class, Eddie would float as high as possible to avoid being walked through by students who suddenly moved.
Today, looking down at the students from above, the details of their faces seemed blurred.
Before this, Eddie's attention had always been fixed on Snape.
It was not until today's Potions class that Eddie paid careful attention to the reactions of every student when the accident occurred. But as Eddie deliberately studied their movements, the expressions on the injured Gryffindors displayed a startling uniformity.
Several of them wore identical expressions. Eddie struggled to describe it, those perfectly duplicated details of manner and look, the way the more Eddie studied them, the less they resembled real people. The discovery sent a chill through him.
Among so many details that didn't hold up to scrutiny, only Snape was real.
Eddie decided to tell Snape about this.
➤ Next: The Sun Rises, the Moon Sets
Chapter 130 - The Sun Rises, the Moon Sets
A gust of wind swept through the sealed classroom the moment Eddie spoke, every door and window shut tight.
Snape drew his wand and leveled it toward the source, and when he turned to look, Eddie was no longer standing. Back still to him, Eddie had dropped to the floor.
The fifth-year wizard wore a black Slytherin uniform. No longer translucent. A flesh-and-blood person, standing in front of him.
"Eddie Cartwright."
The instant Eddie touched the ground, the suppressed memories came back with him.
The two wizards stared at each other. Both remembered who they were.
So many years since graduation. The fifth-year memories had been nothing but a dream woven from magic.
Snape recalled the last image he had seen before his memories cut off, Cartwright coughing up blood and collapsing onto the carpet. He rubbed his temple and waited for Eddie to speak.
Lucas looked around, confirming that the room was built primarily from Snape's memories. "Do you remember when we were sorting the study and I had you try a linking spell? The time I entered your fabricated memory and played the werewolf, the link that spell created was extremely weak. I assumed it was a one-time thing."
But in reality the magical link had held with unexpected stability. When Lucas was struck by the dream curse cast by his mentor, Snape, who had been nearby, was pulled in alongside him, and Snape ended up sharing the burden of the curse.
"Is the matter with the Tooth Fairy Powder resolved?" Snape asked, suspicion plain in his voice.
"The Aurors have already caught most of the masterminds, so yes, it should be resolved very soon." Lucas answered quickly. There was some relief in that: when Lucas had entered the dream, the name Eddie Cartwright had still been in play, which meant the face inside the dream was Cartwright's face.
"I'm very sorry. I didn't expect that linking spell to hold so stubbornly. The next time I use something like it, I'll reassess first." Lucas could tell Snape was deeply displeased. The apology was sincere.
Snape sat cross-armed in one of the empty classroom's chairs, the fifth-year Slytherin face now wearing the grave expression of a Snape in his mid-twenties. Without the Potions professor's robes to frame him, that forbidding aura had dimmed somewhat.
"How do we end the dream?"
"We can't end it yet." Eddie glanced at Snape uneasily before continuing. "There's a reason this dream is built on a foundation of your fifth-year memories. It draws people back through their darkest recollections. The only way out is to shatter it completely."
Snape was out of his seat in an instant. He grabbed Eddie by the collar and nearly lifted him off the ground, Eddie, who had only just recovered a solid body. Snape said each word like he was placing it down with deliberate force: "Relive the darkest memories?"
Lucas said nothing. There was no desire to intrude on Snape's past, but right now there was no other choice.
Pain and humiliation sometimes coexist. Lucas had already witnessed Snape's parents' deaths, the unhappy life Snape had led at school, and what was coming might be crueler still.
"You want to watch too, do you?" Snape's voice was very soft. Extremely dangerous.
He could already picture Eddie Cartwright prying through his memories. He hated the Marauders well enough, but defeating them inside a dream somehow sounded even more humiliating.
Eddie's breath was cut off by the grip at his throat. No resistance, not against Snape in that state. With careful deference, Eddie said, "I think it won't only be your memories, some of my own bad ones will surface too. I'm worried the school will turn into a purgatory. Please believe me: this isn't some exercise in self-deception. Neither of us wants to relive these things any more than we have to."
Severus Snape was an exceptionally accomplished Occlumency master. It was only when Lucas recovered full memory that it became clear, not a single girl named Lily Evans had appeared anywhere in Snape's dream.
Across every dark dream, Snape had managed to keep Lily hidden.
That kind of concealment required countless, painstaking acts of unconscious discipline to achieve.
Just as Lucas had kept certain dark memories from bleeding into this place, two masterful Occlumency practitioners had done everything possible to preserve the peace of the past few weeks.
But soon the calm would begin to bare its teeth.
Eddie spoke in fits and starts, working to prepare Snape for what was coming. They had to use every resource the dream held, arm themselves here before all logic collapsed.
"The Moonlight Grass juice you harvested can be combined with spoken incantations to draw magical runes. They'll offer protection."
"The Marauders' Map can mark the safe locations inside the castle."
"Perhaps you can give some indication of the time and place of what's about to happen?"
Snape let go of Eddie's collar, the fight going out of him. The Eddie standing before him was making every effort to find a way through this, during the Thunderbird storm, there had still been jokes, harmless quips, small moments of levity. Now there was not a single extra word.
Snape could feel how desperately Eddie wanted to leave.
With great reluctance: "The werewolf. The next full moon."
The two wizards left the empty classroom. After Eddie Cartwright's sudden materialization, the dream seemed unable to account for a student who had appeared from nowhere, and the time they occupied began to skip.
As they moved through the corridor, the portraits in their frames were behaving strangely. Eddie warned Snape: "The flow of time has changed."
The light in the corridors flickered and lurched. The sun rose and set in rapid succession.
The time left to prepare was dwindling.
They found an undisturbed corner in the Room of Requirement, a space that held some tools Eddie had wished into being.
Eddie asked Snape to sit on the sofa, then crushed the recently harvested Moonlight Grass and transferred it into the distilling apparatus in the room.
In the story as it had actually unfolded, Snape had traded this Moonlight Grass for several months' worth of living expenses.
Now the same material was revealing a use beyond Potions. A soft brush traced a drifting, faint floral scent across a wrist that bore no Dark Mark yet, the process of drawing runes onto skin with Moonlight Grass juice turned out to be nowhere near as complex as Snape had imagined.
The hand holding the brush was perfectly steady. Eddie must have used some particular technique to draw those precise geometric shapes freehand.
Snape felt a gentle magic seep into his wrist. The flow felt somehow amplified, and there was a faint cool sensation underneath it.
Snape asked directly: "What is it that you fear?"
"Certain dark magic experiments." Eddie had to give Snape some warning. Whatever Eddie feared would inevitably arrive as well, before the dream fully collapsed, forcing Snape to face those things without any preparation could damage his mindscape.
But there was no way to explain it clearly in so little time. Eddie said, vaguely: "...Failed experiments. Things like nightmares."
Abstract. Snape did not press.
Both wizards knew those things were coming. But until they actually arrived, neither of them wanted to dig through the past.
"Done." Eddie finished the last stroke. The floral juice was absorbed quickly into the skin.
Fifth-year Snape had slender wrists. Drawing on them, it felt as though the bones lay just beneath a single layer of skin.
Lucas quickly undid a cuff and applied the same markings to himself.
➤ Next: A Fine Tale
