HP:BTHBP — Chapter 99 - 100: Radical Demonstration
"Do I look like someone who goes investigating on impulse?" Snape looked at Cartwright. "Your mentor did research on soul powder — what else? What more is there?"
When Snape mentioned 'death,' the box in Cartwright's hands suddenly lurched, something inside slamming against the walls. Cartwright rapped his knuckles against the lid a few times. The box went still.
The Potions Master noticed the small gesture. A wicked smile spread across his face.
"What's the story with this screaming box? It reacts when death is mentioned? Is it alive or dead? Is it a Dark Arts creation?"
Snape worked several uses of 'dead' and 'death' into a single breath, watching with satisfaction as the box gave a little jolt every time he said it.
Cartwright rapped a warning on the lid, sharp and rapid. The box stopped moving.
"Is it dead?" Snape asked, feigning surprise.
The box made no further sound.
Cartwright regarded Snape with an entirely new look in his eyes.
"What?" Snape put away his smile. "You still haven't answered my question."
Cartwright pressed his lips together for a moment, then said with a trace of exasperation, "I nearly forgot what you were even asking about."
But they had already gotten onto the subject of the old alchemical master, so a little more wouldn't hurt. "Every alchemical scholar studies the Philosopher's Stone — that goes without saying. This German master was particularly skilled in dark rituals. Animating corpses, summoning the dead, Mind Magic, that sort of thing."
"Summoning the dead?" Snape noticed the box in Cartwright's hands had stopped reacting to their conversation.
He looked away with faint disappointment.
"Research requires a great deal of funding. This alchemist had a particular ritual that could summon the dead back to the living world. Would you give every last Galleon you had to speak once more with someone already gone?"
Arguments left unfinished. Secrets never spoken aloud. Love never declared.
"Like a medium?" Snape sounded slightly let down.
"Actually, it's closer to the Resurrection Stone — that legendary ritual said to call the dead back to the world of the living." Cartwright corrected him.
Snape was unconvinced. "I fail to see the difference."
Cartwright was quite serious. "A medium can pull up any old portrait to deceive you. The spirit summoned by this ritual can continue walking the path it walked in life."
Snape turned serious as well. "Then what distinguishes that from true resurrection? There are quite a few Dark Arts capable of shaping a physical body."
"But someone who has died once is different." Cartwright asked with a meaningful look, "In the fairy tale, the one who became obsessed with the Resurrection Stone was eventually claimed by Death. If there were no side effects, would you have someone you'd want to bring back?"
Snape looked at him and answered quickly. "I would not."
Cartwright gave a small smile. He shook the object in his hands. "Do you know why this box is perfectly fine when I touch it, but screams the moment you lay a hand on it?"
He answered his own question with complete seriousness. "Because it's a lie-detector box. I tell the truth. You don't."
"Cartwright!" Snape said through gritted teeth. "Do you think I can't tell the difference between a lie-detection artifact and a Dark Arts object? You must have some specific way to control that box!"
Snape moved past the topic of resurrection.
To press further might lead somewhere he didn't want to go, to what Cartwright, who had died and returned, had lost.
And whether, in the end, he would lead those close to him toward death as well.
"I'm different." Cartwright said suddenly. "If I were going to leave, I would tell you."
He said it without preamble, then lowered his head and opened the latch on the box. "The study, of course, contains only books. This one is the most dangerous in the second-floor study. It contains a number of medieval alchemical and potion formulas."
A thick surge of black mist poured out of the box, rolling down onto the carpet and spreading outward, forming seven or eight formless shadows. They wore shackles and were in the midst of conducting some kind of experiment.
Snape covered his nose and stepped back.
That intense, oppressive malice hit him again.
Cartwright was completely unaffected. He reached bare-handed into the box and withdrew the heavy hardcover volume. The book was in excellent condition, gilt-pressed on leather of unidentifiable origin, the page edges trimmed in silver, the round spine engraved with an intricate pattern of bones.
Snape made certain his gaze didn't linger on any single part of it for too long.
"Shh." Cartwright stroked the spine with practiced ease, then held the book in one hand and extended the other toward Snape by way of demonstration. "All illusions. This book cannot kill directly."
He added quickly: "Twisted wizards create these books hoping that someone worthy of inheriting their knowledge will one day come along. Most books are not made to kill directly."
Cartwright stood in the center of the study, his loose robes wreathed in black mist. The way he discussed knowledge, that calm, absorbed certainty, made him look exactly like a dark wizard who had lost himself in research and crossed into extremes.
Snape didn't move. He stayed alert.
He suspected Cartwright had already been placed under some form of control. He attempted to activate the Portkey to leave the house.
Cartwright stopped abruptly, an odd expression crossing his face.
He closed the book. The black mist drew back into its pages. "I'm not under anyone's control, there's no need to rush off..." As the one who had designed the Portkey, Cartwright could feel the moment Snape triggered it.
But this had only been a demonstration.
Lucas glanced at Snape's guarded expression. The demonstration had perhaps been a touch too aggressive.
"Didn't you promise last time to help me sort out the study? That's precisely why I was introducing you to this book, once you earn its recognition, you won't have to worry about any of these books attacking you." Even that didn't quite sound like the words of someone free from the book's influence.
Cartwright saw that Snape had already moved to the doorway.
No choice but to keep going. "I genuinely am not under any control. There is a technique to reading Dark Arts books."
Snape watched Cartwright with wary eyes.
"Bookmaking is a complex craft in its own right. Take this one, wild dragonhide cover, human-skin inner pages, human bone where a spine would ordinarily be reinforced with a strip of wood, and silver gilding because silver as a material balances Dark Magic."
"I only want to show you a method of reading. You've been to the Malfoy library, the books in a normal pureblood family's collection are all selected and domesticated. Chained up, carved with runes, hand-copied limited editions, that sort of thing."
Snape began listening in earnest.
If Cartwright truly was an alchemical master with an inherited lineage, the knowledge he shared would be nearly impossible to hear anywhere else.
"This kind, call it, for lack of a better term, an original edition. Think of it as the Dark Arts equivalent of the Sorting Hat. First, the craft required to make it is extraordinarily demanding. Second, it selects its reader. You must demonstrate that you have the capacity to command it before it will allow you to read its contents."
Cartwright offered the book out again. When he spoke with that particular gravity, there was something about him that made it very easy to believe every word.
"What does one do?" Snape hesitated. He looked at the book, the ribs along its spine were still shifting, still rotating. Everything that met the eye was illusion, so Snape let his gaze settle on the hand holding it instead.
➤ Next: Dark Memories
Chapter 100 - Dark Memories
"The fastest known method for reading a Dark Arts book is murder. Most Dark Arts books will reveal their text to a killer — but those are also exactly the kind of Dark wizards we usually see dying from Dark Arts knowledge."
"Occlumency is the conservative approach. Try fabricating a dark experiment, something along those lines — as long as it feels real enough, the book will open for you. And Occlumency will help you stay lucid."
Cartwright held his position, the book still extended.
"I'll be watching over you," he assured Snape. "Nothing will go wrong."
Snape was tempted. The contents of this book were invaluable, and Cartwright was even willing to demonstrate his reading method. "What price do I have to pay?"
"You help me organize this study." Cartwright shook the book in his hand. "It records a sixteenth-century weapon-crafting process, and the smelting procedure requires a specially paired magical potion."
"Fine." Snape agreed, though not without reluctance. Cartwright always managed to produce something, some object or some reason, that he couldn't refuse at the crucial moment. Compared to chasing down an auction or squaring off against Aurors, organizing bookshelves and brewing potions were entirely acceptable.
"The potion has to be brewed inside this house, and I need to be present while it's done," Cartwright added, his tone perfectly natural.
Snape glared. "I have work during the day!"
"We can set a fixed schedule — Saturday evenings, three hours of brewing." Cartwright was unbothered. "Didn't Potions Weekly run a piece about a workstation that lets you adjust the rate of time flow? I can get you one like that."
Lucas was thinking of last year's issue. The advertisement pages had carried a sale listing for a Potions preparation station, gleaming gold, taking up an entire spread, promoted as something that could shorten the brewing time for Felix Felicis.
Lucas had just started the labor placement back then. While having Snape inspect the potions, Lucas had happened to catch the inner pages of the weekly lying open. Snape had lingered on that page for a noticeably long time.
When Cartwright finished speaking, he noticed Snape had gone somewhere else entirely. He waved a hand in front of Snape's eyes. "What's wrong? Is there a particular feature you want?"
Snape took a slow breath. "Is a workstation completely worthless in your line of work? Time magic doesn't quite align with your mentor's research direction, does it?"
"It's not that difficult. I study everything on my own time." Cartwright shrugged it off. "Since you're not an Alchemy Master, the authority to define what's easy and what's hard rests with me."
"Time-flow adjustment, ingredient preservation, flame temperature control, you can do all of that?" Snape pressed, feeling his way forward.
He was beginning to suspect he'd already fallen under some hallucination from the book in Cartwright's hands. How else could he find himself in a situation where an Alchemy Master was telling him to name any demand he liked and a custom laboratory could be arranged?
"All of it," Cartwright said, agreeable as ever.
"How soon can I start using a laboratory like that?" Snape's words came faster.
Cartwright considered this. "I'm glad you're so eager to start experimenting. But you need to help me organize the bookshelves first, then we move on to the experimental phase."
Lucas could hear the gap in Snape's understanding. The Potions Master seemed to think they would each be completing their respective research separately: potions on one side, alchemy on the other.
But in this house, Cartwright held final interpretive authority.
What Cartwright had heard was: Snape agreeing to complete the potion portion of the experiment together with him.
"Why are you so fixated on organizing this place?" Snape couldn't make sense of it.
Cartwright shook his head. "The study is one of the places in this house where magical fluctuations run strongest. Changing the layout accelerates the house's renewal, it becomes more comfortable. But if you're going to organize the study, you'll need to earn the recognition of this book first."
"Who was the owner of this book?"
"The owner of this house. He deciphered and refined a medieval forging technique from a fragmentary text. That happens to be my research direction as well."
Snape understood. Cartwright's research direction was apparently to study a bit of everything.
He drew his wand, cautious.
"Don't use your wand, that will amplify the book's power." Cartwright gestured toward the two single armchairs he'd brought in. A tap of his short silver wand, and the two chairs merged into one long sofa.
"It's better to try this while seated." When Cartwright was being serious, things were generally quite grave. Snape decided to follow his advice.
He walked over and sat down on one end. Almost immediately, he felt the cushion beside him dip, Cartwright settling in next to him.
"You can fabricate something, a Dark Arts experiment, something wicked. It helps if you can approach it with a bit of academic spirit." Cartwright shared the technique with the ease of experience. "Place your hand on the spine. No need to be too tense."
Snape nearly pulled back. Touching a Dark Arts book with bare hands in a house like this,
What if this was the secret behind Cartwright's resurrection? First taking over the body of an Auror, and then moving on to take over his...
"Don't let the book affect you," Cartwright said.
Snape steadied himself and reached out to touch the spine.
Boom, A piercing shriek tore through him, fragments of experiments slamming into his brain. It was like taking a violent Legilimency probe head-on, roughly what it felt like when the Dark Lord searched his memories at the height of his fury.
But this book's probing was stranger. It was not the thought of a living person. It crashed into his mind in a state that had no name.
Snape brought the book into a memory: conducting potion research under the Dark Lord's command. He had once been ordered to develop a berserking potion for werewolves. The ultimate goal was to make a werewolf who drank it go so berserk that it would ignore the Cruciatus Curse and keep charging.
Snape's memory settled on a meeting.
"Let me see which of my servants is willing to help me test the effects of this potion." The Dark Lord paced the length of the Death Eaters' long table. Seven or eight powerfully built werewolves stood beside it.
"My Lord, why not have the person who invented this potion test it personally?" Fenrir Greyback, the werewolf leader, suggested, unable to keep the resentment from his voice.
The Dark Lord gave him a cold glance. "Tell them why, Severus."
"This potion was designed specifically for werewolves. An ordinary wizard cannot demonstrate its effects, and furthermore," It is an unfinished product.
Snape answered respectfully. By that point he had already begged Dumbledore to protect Lily Evans; he could not allow such a berserking potion to truly see the light of day.
"Yes, I know this is only a half-finished product, Severus. Let us first observe the berserking portion." The Dark Lord knew the potion would only drive werewolves into a battle frenzy, and that after the fighting, only death awaited them.
He had dispatched a great many Death Eaters to search for the child of the prophecy. Some internal unrest was unavoidable.
Death had always been one of the Dark Lord's key instruments of control.
"Severus." The Dark Lord's gaze settled on him. "Choose a test subject."
➤ Next: Altering the Memory
