HP:BTHBP — Chapter 97 - 98: Old Threads
Lucas let out a sigh. The memories he had erased from Karkaroff covered the German alchemical master — so where had Snape gotten the information?
Lucas ran quickly through everyone who had known, pulling from Karkaroff's memories.
Ah!
There was one person he had missed!
"It was Jimmy Macmillan."
Macmillan's memories should have been erased too.
Snape's provocative smile confirmed Cartwright had guessed correctly.
Snape was waiting for an explanation.
Cartwright raised both hands in surrender. "With analytical ability like that, you could succeed at anything." A sigh. "But the reason I didn't tell you about this is precisely because I don't want you investigating any further."
"Didn't you ask me to bear witness?"
"You can bear witness to the Ministry of Magic's part." Cartwright said quickly.
Snape narrowed his eyes and pressed. "Is there some kind of taboo surrounding this wizard from Germany?"
"Isn't it obvious? The man is dangerous." Cartwright's assessment only made Snape more curious about the mysterious alchemical master.
"So you know him well. Is he prominent in the field of alchemy? What is the purpose of infiltrating Britain?"
Cartwright held the cup and said nothing for a long time. Then, taking the questions in order: "He used to be my mentor."
"Yes, well known in the field. People know him as a master of ritual magic, but most don't understand him well enough to see the darkness behind his reputation."
"His reason for being in Britain is... the legacy of the Dark Lord."
It was only through investigating Karkaroff that Lucas had learned the mentor had once come to Britain in pursuit of Lord Voldemort's legacy.
The mentor believed the Dark Lord had inherited the Chamber of Secrets, and that the Chamber held a wealth of research notes from the era of Salazar Slytherin.
Beyond that, the mentor had coveted the Inferius army the Dark Lord had deployed during the war, a force that had brought considerable renown to the dark side, only to vanish without a trace alongside the Dark Lord's disappearance.
Most importantly, the mentor wanted the Dark Lord's records on immortality experiments.
Lucas had turned that question over before: what exactly was the Dark Lord's secret to immortality?
In chasing the Dark Lord's secrets, Lucas had traveled further down that road than most people of this era.
At the time, Lucas had been teaching at Hogwarts, clean record, good reputation among the students.
On one occasion, while stepping in to help a Hufflepuff student out of a difficult situation, Lucas happened to cross paths with Harry Potter, the Savior, returning to the school on a visit.
If Lucas chose to, Lucas could become friends with anyone.
The Savior soon treated Lucas's office as a mandatory stop whenever visiting Hogwarts.
Harry enjoyed listening to Lucas talk about the castle's restoration progress, or about expeditions into secret and dangerous places. In exchange, Harry began sharing stories in return.
On one of those visits, the conversation turned to the Chamber of Secrets.
Inside Slytherin's Chamber of Secrets lived a Basilisk.
The Savior had once used a Basilisk fang to kill Tom Riddle.
"I want everyone to be able to say the name — Tom Riddle. Not Voldemort. Not the Dark Lord." The grown Savior had a pair of very striking green eyes.
Lucas sat in the armchair and listened to the clearly edited account, playing along without resistance. "Tom Riddle. Saying that name doesn't seem particularly difficult. People's fear probably comes, in most cases, from the unknown."
Lucas rather enjoyed those days of taking tea with the Savior.
The Gryffindor's stories were obviously trimmed and concealed in places. Sometimes a story would reach an exciting moment, and Harry would realize it couldn't be shared with the outside world, and would forcibly explain away the crucial detail as "Dark magic."
Even so, listening to the Savior tell stories still felt like cracking open a page of modern wizarding history.
The name Harry Potter was destined to become legend.
Lord Voldemort had possessed the Defence Against the Dark Arts professor and infiltrated the school during the Savior's first year. In the second, had ensnared a Gryffindor student and brought the poor girl into the Chamber of Secrets.
Through the scattered fragments of Harry Potter's stories, there were accounts of multiple escapes from the Dark Lord's hands.
Even then, Lucas had been turning one question over: how had Harry killed Riddle?
Of all the stories, only that once, in the Chamber of Secrets, had Harry used the word "killed."
Lucas had noted that particular choice of wording at the time. But what Lucas had actually asked then was: "The first-year you rescued — that was Ginny Weasley, and she became your wife?"
Harry went a little red at the sense of fate Lucas had conjured, as though the whole visit had been a deliberate trip to discuss the origins of a love story with a scholar.
Back to the real question, then: how exactly had the Dark Lord "transcended death"?
What was the secret the Savior was unwilling to share?
The only lead Lucas held was that one word, "killed", the word Harry had used for Riddle.
Harry Potter had gently declined when Lucas proposed looking at Slytherin's Chamber of Secrets. But as long as Lucas knew such a Chamber existed somewhere in the school, Lucas could find it.
Time passed. The dead Basilisk became bleached bone.
The serpentine fountain inside the Chamber no longer flowed.
Lucas explored every deep branching passage and found some ancient runes and wards, but those inscriptions had been permanently sealed with the extinction of Slytherin's bloodline.
Slytherin may well have left a treasure behind. It was possible even the heirs had never found it.
And while exploring the Chamber, Lucas had naturally used the Revelio Retroactus, a spell commonly employed by wizards searching ruins to look back at traces of the past.
The magic showed that Ron Weasley and Hermione Granger had once come here to retrieve Basilisk fangs.
Any traces further back than that had been thoroughly erased.
The story of Harry Potter's battle with Tom Riddle inside the Chamber was, in the end, nothing more than a story.
And that gave Lucas the final answer.
Dark magic that disfigured and enraged. The power to halt the aging of youth. To be killed in part, and yet still survive.
The Dark Lord's secret to immortality was a Horcrux.
From there the reasoning grew more interesting: why had Lord Voldemort been unable to kill Harry Potter?
The explanation widely known to the outside world was that the Savior's mother had used an ancient protective magic.
The Savior had lived with Muggle relatives every year, right up until coming of age at eighteen. Harry had only meant to convey that the childhood had not been as glittering as most people imagined.
But that was enough to establish that what Mrs. Potter had left behind was blood magic.
Blood magic had caused Lord Voldemort's physical form to collapse on the day of the attempt to murder Harry Potter. Yet what was the force that had allowed Harry Potter to survive the Avada Kedavra?
Lucas actually held one thread. Whenever the choice was made, it would be possible to perceive the nature of certain events that had not yet come to pass, earlier than most people could.
But this line of reasoning was extremely dangerous. To probe the survival essence of a Dark Lord was the kind of thing that could very easily get a person killed.
➤ Next: Back to the Conversation
Chapter 98 - Back to the Conversation
Snape noticed that Cartwright had drifted back into that contemplative state the moment the words "the Dark Lord's legacy" left his mouth.
If he used Legilimency on Cartwright right now, Snape pressed the urge down. He was still inside Cartwright's house. Caution, he reminded himself.
But that was no reason to sit here and let Cartwright wander off.
Two clues had surfaced in what Cartwright said.
Cartwright had been a student of that alchemical master during his lifetime, which meant Cartwright had to be younger than the master. The range collapsed from zero-to-six-hundred years old down to zero-to-sixty.
The second clue concerned the Dark Lord. Snape hadn't expected to hear that name come up in connection with Tooth Fairy Powder.
"Crack."
Snape clapped sharply beside Cartwright's ear. The sound yanked Cartwright back to his senses.
"Explain what 'the Dark Lord's legacy' actually is." Snape pressed the key question.
"Then you have to call me Eddie."
"What?" Snape thought he'd misheard.
"Call me Eddie and I'll tell you." Cartwright patiently repeated himself.
They held their ground for a moment.
Lucas thought Snape looked rather like a student who'd been told: get an O on the Potions final and you'll get your pocket money. The pocket money was very appealing. Sitting the exam was not.
They held each other's gaze.
Snape looked away first.
"Don't push your luck!" Snape said, voice strained.
"The Dark Lord's legacy." Cartwright drew the words out with exaggerated relish. "Don't you want to know?"
Snape drew a slow breath and kept his face composed, refusing to be pulled into this flippant atmosphere. "Eddie Cartwright, your pitiful Potions Master has serious doubts about your credibility. One given name in exchange for the Dark Lord's secrets? You should count yourself lucky you came back to life after the Dark Lord disappeared—"
"But I think it's a perfectly fair trade." Cartwright rested a chin in hand, completely unswayed by Snape's stern expression. "I think it matters," he said, with an infuriating calm, "that you call me by my given name."
"You're toying with me." Snape's voice was flat with certainty. His wand pressed against Cartwright's throat.
Cartwright was forced to tilt his head back. The tension coiled through Snape's entire body was palpable. As a precaution, in case the wand misfired, Cartwright quietly shifted the rug beneath his feet to give himself a clear escape route.
But the situation still felt salvageable.
"Calm down, Severus. Why not give it a try? Ask, and I'll answer." Cartwright moved slowly and placed his hand over Snape's wrist, making every effort to appear respectful and sincere.
The wand eased back slightly.
Cartwright took the opening. Gently, hand over wrist, he guided the wand hand back and away.
Snape's hand was cold.
Lucas waved toward the hearth and coaxed the fire higher.
He looked at Snape with particular earnestness. "This concerns the Dark Lord — in principle I shouldn't be saying any of it. But if you ask the right question today, I can let slip a few details. You can try calling me Eddie."
It had started as a joke. Lucas was taking it seriously now.
"What is the Dark Lord's legacy?" Snape pressed on, then added one word at the end, reluctant: "Eddie."
"The secret of transcending death. The ability to command dark creatures. And his birth." Cartwright kept the tone deliberately light. "Some people believe the Dark Lord is dead. Others believe he isn't. Until he suddenly reappears, none of us will know."
Snape's brow furrowed hard. His awe of the Dark Lord made him miss the hint buried underneath Lucas's teasing tone.
Lucas had already said more than he should have. The warning came again. "Do not go near that alchemist. Do not investigate him. Do not mention him. Understood?"
"So you're not afraid of the Dark Lord, you're afraid of your former mentor?" Snape let out a short, mocking laugh. "Is it because you've met your mentor in person, but your experience is too shallow to grasp how truly terrifying the Dark Lord is?"
Cartwright looked at him. For one instant those blue eyes held nothing, completely blank. Then Snape placed the expression: it was the look of someone regarding a troublesome child. He had seen Sprout wear that exact look when watching the Gryffindor students.
Snape felt distinctly offended.
"There's no need to rank two killers," Cartwright said. The tone stayed easy. "You've never killed anyone. You can't imagine what those experiments were like."
"Terrible enough that you need Occlumency?" Snape pressed.
That landed like a slap.
Lucas stood up from the sofa. "Come with me. The study." He strode up the stairs. They'd originally meant to discuss Auror infighting and matters of that sort, but the Ministry's internecine squabbling would drag on for a while yet, no urgency there.
Lucas led Snape to the door of the second-floor study and lifted the wards.
"Come in." Cartwright stepped across the threshold first.
The study was quiet, on the whole. Only one or two books shrieked inside their boxes.
Snape identified a single anti-vampire ward inscription on the door frame, it flickered past, half-buried in a cluster of far more complex anti-theft sigils.
An experiment of some kind, he suspected. He stepped inside, on guard.
"Hold this." Cartwright shoved the most violently thrashing book toward Snape.
Snape didn't reach for it. He levitated the box with his wand instead. "Do you think I would handle an unknown dark object?"
Cartwright had no choice but to demonstrate himself. He placed his hand on the shrieking box. The box went silent.
He lifted his hand. The box resumed shaking and shrieking.
On. Off. On. Off.
Snape's expression went gradually, completely blank. He felt as though he were watching a farce.
"This is a protective book case that seals away dark magic," Cartwright explained. "You're welcome to run any test you like, the case itself is a perfectly safe containment measure. But if you put your own hand on it, care to guess what happens?"
"A Slytherin would never do something so incautious—" Snape began, with a cold laugh.
Before he could finish, Cartwright seized his hand and pressed it flat against the box.
The shriek that tore out seemed like it would shatter glass.
A glacial, malevolent force coiled beneath Snape's palm. The chill shot straight down his spine. He was nearly already drawing his wand to blast the thing apart.
Cartwright's warm hand covered his.
The cold, lurking force went quiet. It was as though that contact carried some protective quality of its own, the darkness beneath Snape's hand stilling and sinking away.
Snape pulled his hand back sharply and shot Cartwright a fierce glare.
"That," Lucas said, something faint and lost in the voice, "is the difference. How long has it been since you last came into contact with dark magic? Have you ever killed anyone? Do you know what it feels like to actually cast those forbidden spells?"
"That alchemical master you consider perfectly ordinary, the number of lives on his hands may exceed the number of people you've ever seen."
Lucas needed Snape to understand the danger. If the Potions Master couldn't get any leads about the person wearing the sapphire ring from Lucas directly, Snape would go looking alone.
If Lucas couldn't keep watch over Snape, the least he could do was make sure Snape knew what kind of monster he was walking toward.
➤ Next: Radical Demonstration
