HP:BTHBP — Chapter 7 - 8: The Alchemist's Puzzle
It was a restaurant on the edge of the neighborhood, already fairly busy inside. Lucas found a seat toward the back under the waitress's gaze, the menu laid flat on a red-checkered tablecloth. The place was warm, and the smell of food hung in the air.
"One roast pork with vegetables and potatoes, and a pudding." Lucas read from the menu and ordered slowly. He needed to sort out his mumbling before school started, that was the kind of problem practice could fix.
"Something to drink?"
"Hot milk, please."
He asked about the price, then mentioned roughly which part of the neighborhood he lived in. The waitress accepted this without comment and went back to the counter.
"Are you the Graham boy?"
While he was waiting, an older woman recognized him. She was sitting alone, a handbag over her arm, a striking string of pearls around her neck.
"Mrs. Bryan." Lucas rose from his seat.
"Never mind that, sit down, dear. Are you eating on your own? Where is Mr. Graham?" Mrs. Bryan was Lucas's neighbor, the sort of person, in his memory, who kept close track of everything happening in the houses nearby.
But she was not the kind to simply watch a child suffer. She regularly passed along secondhand things from her house to Lucas, including the shoes he had on right now, which were also Mrs. Bryan's. There had been some secondhand winter clothes as well.
"Father went to bed early." Lucas sat down. "Would you like to join me?"
Mrs. Bryan was rather surprised by how sharp Lucas seemed today. It was genuinely out of the ordinary. Her considerable curiosity had her sitting down across from him almost immediately.
The Graham boy still had that same unremarkable face. If anything was different today, it was only that he was sitting a little straighter than before.
Ah, right, he had also started the conversation himself.
"A little while ago I fainted at home and was taken to hospital." Lucas had seen her surprise and offered an explanation.
After she expressed her sympathy, he continued: "The food at the hospital was actually quite good. I stayed a few days and felt a lot better."
A person needs sunlight, food, clean water, enough sleep, and exercise to grow.
A malnourished child eats a few days of dreadful hospital food, takes on some nourishment, and that blankness and dullness gets treated right along with everything else.
Mrs. Bryan pieced the facts together from Lucas's meandering explanation. She had always known Lucas was better off in hospital than with his father.
This kind of confession from a child stirred a deep swell of satisfaction in her. What throws one's own happiness into sharper relief better than the misfortunes of others?
Her own child had grown up perfectly well under her care, and was now traveling in Europe, she could not say that aloud and hurt the boy, though he probably did not even know where Europe was.
"How dreadful!"
"I only got out today. Dad told me to come out and eat something. I start school in a few days — a boarding school. Once I finish, I'll be able to support the family." Lucas shook his head and did not pull his hand away when Mrs. Bryan clasped it in her excitement. Her warm palm gave him a wave of goosebumps.
"Oh, dear, I think I still have some stationery my child left behind after graduating, and some of the old textbooks too — I can look them out for you."
Lucas ducked his head with a touch of embarrassment, but made it clear he was looking forward to the secondhand stationery. "Textbooks?"
"The secondary school books. My child was a very good student." By the time Lucas's food arrived, he already knew Mrs. Bryan's child's age, the university attended, and a number of details about the Bryan household.
The waitress coming back to take an order cut short the lengthy tribute.
"Actually, I've been going through Dad's bills, and there are quite a few things I don't really understand..." Once the waitress had gone, Lucas changed the subject. Financial problems always called for dealing with the most urgent thing first, and the most pressing matter right now was the car that had been put up for consignment.
"I don't understand why we can't get the money from the car that was sold..."
Mrs. Bryan spent a moment working out the transaction from Lucas's description. She gave the napkin in her hand an indignant squeeze. "Mr. Graham really is terribly inexperienced. My husband was a solicitor before retiring. A reputable company would never put forward a contract like that."
Lucas put on an expression of perfectly calibrated helplessness. "But my father..."
"Dear, would you like to come round tomorrow for a little cake? Bring your father, and he can have a word with my husband, I'm sure there's a better option than consignment..."
"But my father won't go out." Lucas offered an alternative. "Could I speak with Mr. Bryan myself? I'll bring the letters, and I'll remember everything you tell me..." His eyes went red at the rims. That trick worked twice as well on a pretty child. On him, it was better than nothing.
"Oh, I don't see why not. You can stay for supper as well, I'll ring your father." Mrs. Bryan reached over and patted Lucas's hair. Her own food arrived at that moment.
She noticed Lucas had been waiting for her the whole time and hadn't touched a thing on his plate. It prompted one more remark to herself: the boy might not be much to look at, but he really did have very good manners.
"Go on and eat — you must be starving."
Only then did Lucas pick up his knife and fork.
Muggle restaurants in this era already had televisions. Right across from Lucas's seat, a large box sat up on the counter.
He knew what a television was, it matched more or less what his Muggle Studies professor had described.
The adverts had just finished. The programme now showing was a paranormal investigation, a medium on camera describing the process of communicating with spirits, out-of-body experiences, dealings with the devil.
Lucas held the stories up against certain legends from the wizarding world. A medium gazing into a crystal ball and pronouncing prophecies did look genuinely similar to a Seer.
It was a truly mysterious power. Lucas had studied Arithmancy well, but his intuitive ability to perceive the future through a crystal ball was very weak.
As for angels and demons, pure nonsense for Muggle consumption.
He knew better than anyone what lay on the other side of death. Or rather, what it was like to stand at the very edge of it.
He ate steadily through the disastrous food on his plate. For his body's sake, the dishes provided exactly the nourishment he urgently needed. For his palate's sake, he missed the House-elves.
The medium segment wrapped up. The host smiled and announced in an exaggerated tone that they had interviewed a Cambridge scholar, here to explain how these spirit-communication events really worked.
The black-and-white screen cut to a white-haired old man, thin and tall.
He looked very elderly. His movements as he found the camera were slow. But when Lucas saw him, he went completely still.
This was Nicolas Flamel.
The inventor of the Philosopher's Stone addressed the audience with perfect seriousness. His research had led him to conclude that everything could be explained by science, for instance, the medium's prophetic ability might be attributable to harmful paint used in the green house where she lived, as had happened on a number of occasions in the past.
A black-and-white television could not, of course, show the color of a house.
But the programme's crew went on to confirm that Professor Flamel's claim was entirely correct.
They asked the professor whether he would share some other paranormal events that could be debunked.
This "Cambridge scholar" addressed the viewers at home with full solemnity. "Then I'll leave the audience a puzzle. If you can solve it, you're welcome to write to me and discuss it."
"Excuse me." Lucas moved quickly to the counter and asked for paper and a pen, making it back with just enough time to write down everything appearing on the screen.
"My, you're interested in the television puzzle? But this professor didn't leave any contact details, you may need to contact the television station..."
Mrs. Bryan had her back to the television but had caught most of what was said. She swallowed a bite of smoked fish and glanced at the lopsided writing Lucas had put down on the paper. "That row at the top is decorative stationery borders, I think, that part's useless."
What rises forever and never falls?
That was the riddle.
The answer was age.
Lucas looked at the three rows of hollow and solid geometric shapes arranged across the top, forming a dividing line, and the string of jumbled letters below.
That was Nicolas Flamel's actual puzzle.
➤ Next: The Start of Term
Chapter 8 - The Start of Term
The day after the meal, Lucas visited a helpful Muggle neighbor. With their guidance, he found a legal adviser to void the car consignment agreement, then located a new buyer willing to pay cash.
He bought a few things he considered necessities and put the remaining money into the drawer where Mr. Graham kept his savings, making sure Mr. Graham wouldn't starve while Lucas was away at school.
Lucas had the gas cut off at the Graham house, cleared the overdue bills, and filled out Mr. Graham's unemployment assistance forms.
He sorted through the study. Mr. Graham's book collection ran mostly to social sciences and literature, with a small row set aside for books given by friends.
In the weeks before term, whenever Lucas wasn't going out, the study was where he spent his time. He read through Hamlet and the Homeric epics on the shelves, and worked through a great deal of British history and world history.
Why had he never read any of this in the wizarding world?
No, he had seen it, actually. He remembered passing through London in 1999, and by the time he returned to England fourteen years had gone by, the Muggle streets having swapped out their illuminated signs in the blink of an eye.
He had seen it. He simply hadn't cared.
In all those years of going from a reviled Death Eater's child to a well-known alchemical scholar, why had he never once thought about the world beyond wizards?
Awareness.
Lucas pressed a finger to a single word on the mildewed page.
A person was bounded by their own experience. Muggles had simply never existed in his former understanding of the world, that was natural enough, but it needed to change.
All the selling and buying hadn't been without purpose. Through the process, Lucas gained a clearer understanding of how the Muggle system operated, and to save on bus fare he also learned to ride the old bicycle kept in the house.
Besides reading and going out, on the rare days when the weather was genuinely fine, Lucas tended the garden.
The manual push mower he'd bought from a second-hand shop was bulky and difficult to manage. He applied a few charms to some of its parts, then dragged the machine — considerably larger than himself, through the grass each day.
He recited tongue-twisters and poems aloud, training his stiff tongue. His sallow complexion slowly grew a little clearer under the exercise and the healthy, regular routine.
Fine new growth appeared on his head. He trimmed away the dry, dead strands and kept only a clean, short crop.
In the last week before term, Lucas took out the second-hand clothes, washed them, and left them to dry in the sun.
He dug out needle and thread and redrafted the patterns, then cast a charm on a set of needles and scissors so they cut along the marked lines and sewed automatically. He replaced the yellowed plastic buttons on the shirts with buttons stripped from another set of Muggle clothes.
Finally, Lucas found a battered pigskin carry-case on the highest shelf in the study. He wiped the dust from it and packed the books and clothes inside.
Mr. Graham was an indifferent man with very little presence. The radio was all he needed.
Lucas always told Mr. Graham where he was going whenever he went out alone, but he suspected that even if he announced he was off to the moon, the man wouldn't bat an eye. Even so, he never used magic in front of him.
And so the day of term arrived.
Lucas shrank the respectable-enough pigskin case, said goodbye to his father, changed buses several times on his own, and arrived at King's Cross Station in the city center.
Just before he reached the platform, he enlarged the trunk again. He dragged the heavy case along and, for the first time in a long time, laid eyes on that train.
Lucas stood on the platform for a moment. Parents and children saying their farewells moved around him, and only he and the train remained still.
He had once ridden this very train, in different compartments, setting out on the road to school.
The train whistled.
Lucas came back to himself. He walked the last few steps and boarded the noisy train, and the carriage door closed behind him.
CLANG-CLANG, CLANG-CLANG, the wheels clattered over the rails as the train pulled out of the Muggle city.
Lucas walked through carriage after carriage. Most were already full.
Toward the rear he found one with only three people in it. He greeted them and sat down, and he and several other first-years exchanged introductions. The young witches and wizards were already deep in a debate about House placements. When they got to Lucas, he hesitated slightly. "Slytherin, or possibly Ravenclaw."
That had been the choice the Sorting Hat offered him the first time he attended school. Looking back now, he had chosen the harder path then, so what about this time?
"Slytherin!" The Sorting Hat dropped onto Lucas's head and gave its answer at once.
This time, there was no Ravenclaw option. Lucas walked to the far end of the Slytherin table and sat down, greeting the students nearby.
"Graham isn't a very common surname." The young wizard beside him spoke up during the pause while the next student was sorted. "Though the Sorting Hat was quick enough with you — it had barely touched your hair before it decided."
"Mr. Keynes, we may have exchanged names, but we're hardly that familiar, are we?" Lucas replied, expression flat.
The speech problem was behind him, but the protruding teeth and freckles were still conspicuous, and that combination made it easy to invite mockery. No hesitation, no showing weakness, especially not in Slytherin.
The young wizard named Keynes was brought up short. The students around them noticed the exchange, and eyes drifted between the two first-years. But it was only the first night of term, and soon enough the onlookers looked away.
Lucas waited for the headmaster to finish the opening address. He ate quietly, consuming the food that appeared before him with careful restraint, and waited for the desserts to come.
All around him sat first-years. The conversation moved to what adventures everyone had over the summer. The young wizard Keynes talked about his Quidditch experience, and predictably fixed his sights on Lucas again. "Won't Mr. Graham care to share?"
"I had an accidental magic outburst over the summer. I live in a Muggle neighborhood, and the magic knocked out the power across an entire area — roughly three Hogwartses' worth of space plunged into darkness."
Lucas paused. "Then I was admitted to St Mungo's's. The Healers there said I was a very talented young wizard. I was there for more than ten days and got to know every floor quite well. Have you ever seen a wizard bitten by a werewolf? I saw one..."
The first-years' attention swung straight to Lucas's account of his adventures at St Mungo's's.
They listened as he described the adult wizard's wounds, how they had torn open and bled, and shrieked in horror.
Lucas had genuinely seen this case. When he was admitted he hadn't lost consciousness, and he and a wizard who had been bitten had checked in one after the other.
No one's story could top Lucas's.
After a while, when the classmates had run out of questions, Keynes said, with that particular brand of deliberate irritation: "So — you're a half-blood?"
Lucas paid no attention. He ate in silence, as though no one had raised the question at all.
"Lucas Graham, you really are a half-blood!"
Lucas set down the dessert spoon. The small circle of attention swung back to him.
Keynes repeated it a third time: "Or rather, you're a filthy..."
"First-years, follow me." At that moment, all the food and crockery on the tables vanished.
The banquet was over. Time for the young witches and wizards to return to their dormitories.
Lucas stood. He hadn't responded to Keynes at any point, and that absolute refusal to hear it was pushing Keynes past the breaking point.
"You're not a Mudblood, are you!" Keynes raised his voice. Even amid the noise of every student standing up, that pre-broken voice rang out so sharp and high it carried across the entire Great Hall.
Perhaps that was exactly what Keynes intended, to humiliate Lucas in front of everyone.
Lucas cast a pitying glance at him. "No. My mother was a pure-blood witch from a minor family who also attended Hogwarts. That makes me a half-blood."
They all saw the professor striding over. He was newly appointed this year. Some of the older students recognized him as their former senior, Severus Snape, and everyone knew he was rumored to have ties to the Dark Lord yet had escaped post-war punishment. But no one knew what his teaching style would be like.
"Holding forth in the Great Hall." Snape's expression was black. His height alone exerted enormous pressure on the first-years. "One week of labor service."
"Will Keynes?" Lucas spoke up, reminding the professor of the name of the student being disciplined.
Snape fixed Lucas with a hard stare. "I did not require your reminder, Mr. Graham."
Slytherin fell completely silent. Only after the professor walked away did the remaining first-years form a line under the prefects' direction and file out.
Lucas walked the familiar path down toward the dungeons. More classmates watched him with curiosity, but no one came over to speak. The pure-blood Keynes trailed at the very back of the line, and the look aimed at Lucas was pure venom.
➤ Next: House Life
