HP:BTHBP — Chapter 5 - 6: It's a Niffler's Instinct, Isn't It
"Twenty Galleons." The wizard narrowed his eyes dangerously. "Mr. Graham already has something he wants to buy?"
Faced with the full weight of Snape's presence, Lucas was perfectly calm. "That ugly sculpture at Gringotts — it glows too." Brief. To the point.
Snape paused to recall, then leaned forward in a way that felt like a threat. "You mean that wizard selling sculptures — that sculpture has a problem as well?"
Lucas nodded.
"How bright?" Snape followed up immediately, then repeated himself with open impatience: "How bright was the sculpture you saw?"
In truth, that sculpture hadn't glowed at all. Lucas had made a deliberate judgment call based on experience alone.
He had spent the entire morning following Snape, and what he'd seen matched everything buried in those old written records: Snape had noticed early on that the misshapen leather shoes didn't fit, yet said nothing and did nothing, which meant his moral compass wasn't entirely absent; he'd kept a close eye on Lucas's movements throughout the used bookshop, and while slipping a student's gifted book into his own pocket would have been trivially easy, he still asked for a reason first.
Among all the roles that made up Severus Snape, the title of youngest Potions Master was the most lamentable. He had never made proper use of his own talent.
That hadn't mattered before, because this man had died in the past. But now, with everything beginning again, Lucas understood he had been handed an opportunity. Many people in this era were still alive. And he himself was no longer the child of a Death Eater family, watched with careful suspicion in the post-war years.
He would be entering school again, and this year would be Snape's very first as a professor. Which meant Snape didn't yet know that collecting new students by Floo was wrong, that Muggle transportation was the right call. He didn't yet know that leaving a child at an ice cream shop was perfectly workable, that the staff there would look after young wizards while the adults split up to finish the shopping.
And most importantly, this man had not yet fully built his framework for judging students. Lucas could slot himself in as the finest one. He could learn things under this master that no classroom syllabus would ever offer.
Perhaps by graduation, he could walk away with an advanced Potions Master certification.
All of that depended on becoming an excellent and valuable student. Right now, he was making the case for his own worth.
"Much brighter than the books."
Snape studied Lucas's expression carefully, making sure this small wizard wasn't bluffing on the back of one lucky guess.
He was skeptical, the idea of Lucas having spotted a hidden gem among goblin inventory stretched belief, but he was already on his feet, settling the bill, striding toward the restaurant door, words thrown back over his shoulder: "Keep up."
He was going to look into whether Lucas Graham had some kind of Niffler instinct. The sort that could pick the one metal object out of a pile of worthless junk.
By the time they made it back to Gringotts, both the wizard and the Gnome sculpture were gone. A goblin was polishing the newly acquired piece, preparing to catalog and shelve it.
Snape walked to the counter and asked whether the sculpture was for sale. Most things at Gringotts had a price. What followed was a round of haggling between Snape and the goblin.
Lucas found a spot in the main hall waiting area and settled in. He still had the large illustrated volume, Snape hadn't taken it. Some of the spells inside were genuinely interesting: how to confuse a dragon and steal a portion of it from under its nose, a piece of dark magic for pilfering dragon bones that was strikingly bold and elegant, one that came with a built-in pain-numbing effect so the victim couldn't immediately realize they were short a bone.
Used on a person, the results would surely be something.
None of the spells in the book specified they applied only to particular creatures.
"Can you actually read that?" Snape levitated the Gnome sculpture over and walked up behind Lucas, he'd caught sight of the page showing the dragon's suffering, and drawn the same conclusion: dark magic.
"The illustrations are nice." Lucas pointed at the dragon beating its wings. "You should keep it." He performed the role of someone very eager to give the book away.
This time, Snape took it. Which left them with the Gnome.
"Well then, Mr. Graham — so gifted at finding treasure. Please tell your future professor where the dimmest point of light on this Gnome is."
Lucas shook his head. He watched Snape's expression shift in that particular way again: that deliberate, performed display of feeling.
Why had no one ever mentioned that Snape made unusually pointed use of his body language and expressions when dealing with young wizards? The long, winding sentences. The intentional pauses designed to let the imagination do the work.
Lucas put on his best look of difficulty. He was a wizard with a modest talent, not a prophet. The Gnome was already in hand. Snape could do his own exploring.
"In that case, I should take you home, Mr. Graham." Snape walked him out of Gringotts, shrinking the ugly Gnome sculpture and pocketing it. "Take my hand."
Lucas did. He felt a raindrop hit his face, it had started raining over Diagon Alley.
Then it was as though he'd been stuffed into a pipe, twisted and spun, before landing in front of a small house on the outskirts of London.
His home.
The brief journey through the magical world had come to a close. Now it was the Muggle world.
Lucas took in the overgrown garden: wild grass, withered vines, dead leaves piled on the roof, and several panes of glass that had been magically repaired, clean and bright, jarringly out of place against the rest of the house. All of it exactly as his fragmented memories held it.
He took a deep breath and knocked on the door.
"I can let myself in."
Lucas was handed a train ticket. Snape didn't even bother issuing a warning. A single nod, and he vanished.
Lucas stood there a while longer, then knocked again. This time, something stirred inside.
A man in slippers, slouched, rumpled, opened the door, didn't look to see who was there, and turned straight back inside.
This was Lucas Graham's Muggle father. Mr. John Graham.
Lucas walked in. The wreckage from the accidental magic outburst had been cleared, the Ministry of Magic had restored things to their prior state, which meant the tear in the armchair was still there, and the chipped paint on the table leg was still there too. The Ministry had simply put the mess back the way it was before the mess.
A gecko, startled by the door, shot into a crack in the wall.
Lucas sat down in the armchair, pulled off his secondhand shoes, and let out a long breath.
Adult irresponsibility always follows a pattern. The shape of it differs; the fact of it doesn't.
In his memories, this Muggle father had never once struck the child. He had simply collapsed after his partner died. In the beginning, Lucas had been taken in by Mr. Graham's older sister, everyone assumed it was temporary. But John Graham happened to be that rare, terrible kind: the sort who cannot survive the loss of the person they loved most, who shuts the door and stops answering it. Day after day, year after year.
His sister raised Lucas for three years. She had her own career, her own life to maintain. Eventually, she brought Lucas back to her brother.
Before his wife's death, John had held a respectable position as a university lecturer. There was a typewriter in the house. Under his wife's encouragement, he had been preparing to write his first novel.
Then the wizarding world's disaster reached into his small family and took everything.
His wife had gone to purchase supplies in the wizarding world and never came home. He never got to see her one last time. He received a written notice informing him she had died at the hands of Lord Voldemort's followers, and that the Ministry of Magic had already coordinated her death certificate with the Muggle government.
John could not bear it. When he looked at the infant, he could not summon any feeling a father should have. He only knew he would never be happy again.
After Lucas turned 5, he was sent to nursery and then primary school. He never cried or made a fuss. His responses to the world around him were slow.
Many teachers advised Mr. Graham to have the boy assessed for intellectual development. The child was always getting himself dirty. But Mr. Graham was barely keeping himself upright, still sunken inside his own world.
And so Lucas, his soul incomplete at the time, his mind genuinely underdeveloped, was raised along by Britain's patient educational system.
No magical incidents had ever occurred around him.
John assumed Lucas had inherited his side of things. As time passed, Lucas grew to look like neither him nor his mother. He was smaller than other children, always grimy, and John couldn't find a single thing in the boy that reminded him of his late wife. The child's existence only confirmed what John already suspected about himself: that he was not an adequate father.
The neglect snowballed. Layer after layer.
Until not long ago, when Lucas had his accidental magic outburst.
He had always been bullied at school. This time, the other children had put a caterpillar down his collar.
He'd scratched at himself all through the school day and never found it. When he got home and took off his jacket, the caterpillar appeared. The sudden terror — combined with Lucas's soul drawing close to its full shape as he reached his 11th year, was enough. The outburst happened.
An absent father.
Lucas located his shoes. A Muggle neighbor had given them to him.
His father's former profession had been respectable, well-regarded, and the neighborhood was solidly middle-class. The older residents here had a habit of stepping in when things got too difficult to look away from, the odd secondhand item passed over the fence, things that weren't worth much to anyone.
The pressing matter now was to understand the Graham household's current financial situation, the potential risks, and how to guard against them.
➤ Next: Family Circumstances
Chapter 6 - Family Circumstances
The Graham house had two floors. The ground floor held the living room, dining room, and kitchen; the upper floor had two bedrooms and a study. There was also an attic, a garage, and a garden.
In the ground-floor kitchen, almost nothing worked except the pipes. Lucas could not remember his father ever turning on the gas.
The two upstairs bedrooms were where father and son each lived.
At the moment, Mr. Graham had locked himself in the downstairs bathroom.
So Lucas went back up to his room first to put his things away.
His room had originally been a nursery. The wallpaper was still a dull pastel blue, marked here and there with old crayon scribbles.
As Lucas got older, the room had never been renovated to match.
He always curled up in a one-meter crib. The side rails had been removed, so when he fell asleep he could let his legs dangle off the edge.
Lucas put his things away, then walked straight to the study.
Mr. Graham was a well-educated man. If there were any documents that showed the household's financial situation, they would be in there.
He pushed the door open. The first thing he saw was three walls of bookshelves packed with books — every one of them coated in thick dust.
The old Lucas had almost never come into this room. Mr. Graham had stopped coming here after losing his job too, spending most of his time on the single sofa in the living room watching television instead.
The room had a large writing desk. On it sat several picture frames turned face-down against the surface, and a typewriter draped in a white cloth, like Mr. Graham's love, or his career. Both long dead.
Underage wizards were not permitted to use a wand outside of school. But that rule did not apply to those who hadn't yet enrolled in first year.
Lucas used a Summoning Charm.
"Graham's bills and letters, come." Envelopes of every shape flew out from the desk and its drawers, throwing up clouds of thick dust.
Lucas gave his wand a slight turn. The envelopes settled obediently into one corner of the desk and arranged themselves in chronological order.
He cast Scourgify across the room in several passes, then followed with an insect-repelling charm and an air-purifying charm.
A swarm of cockroaches crawled out from the gaps in the bookshelves right on cue, filing out through the study door in dense columns. They would find the nearest pipe and make their way down it, then die quietly under the spell's effect.
Lucas switched on the study light. The surroundings were now barely livable. He had always been more tolerant of rooms that contained books.
He flicked his wand to pull out the stool, sat down, and began working through the documents, a record spanning from his birth to the present day.
The information fell into three categories.
The first was letters from Mr. Graham's friends and family. The earlier the year, the more letters there were, mostly urging him to move past his grief and reminding him that he had a child who needed looking after.
These letters, along with holiday greetings and invitations, dwindled year by year. The last few years had almost none at all.
The second category was correspondence from a university: letters from the administrative office and the faculty union.
At first they notified him of plans for the new term. But then what happened next was well known: Mr. Graham simply decided to stop showing up to work. The letters became absence warnings. At some point the union had apparently stepped in, and the university granted him extended medical leave.
According to these records, Mr. Graham had not been formally dismissed until Lucas was nine years old.
Before that, he had received a monthly salary.
The third category was bills.
Monthly expenses of every kind. Most had been left unpaid until someone came to the door, at which point Mr. Graham would sign and settle them. Lucas found page after page of repeated payment demands, including notices charging interest.
He had no choice but to take out a pen and work through all the miscellaneous items. He was unfamiliar with Muggle affairs like these. In his previous life he had been a pure-blood, and apart from Hogwarts's Muggle Studies courses, his contact with Muggles had always existed in a grey area.
Now, staring at these complex billing entries, he reminded himself he would need to develop a much stronger understanding of the Muggle world.
Time passed quickly at the desk. Lucas capped his pen.
The household's finances were in genuinely poor shape.
Mr. Graham never used the gas, yet over the past eleven years he had consistently paid the gas company every month. Other equally pointless charges included an inexplicable garden maintenance fee.
Mr. Graham had also forfeited certain benefits. According to several of the letters, he was entitled to claim unemployment assistance. The Muggle government would have helped him find new work, and community volunteers could have helped an inexperienced widower with childcare.
That said nothing of the car Mr. Graham had sold off half a year ago. He seemed to have simply handed it to an agent on consignment. The car still hadn't sold, and he was still paying consignment fees on it.
Lucas looked over the numbered points he had written out. An hour of exercise had steadied the hand holding the pen somewhat.
The new body lacked many ingrained habits. He slouched and rounded his shoulders without thinking, that too seemed to be a lasting effect of the wretched crib.
And it was already evening. He was hungry. No one in this house had thought to consider that a person needed to eat.
Lucas jumped down from the stool and headed downstairs. Mr. Graham was watching a commercial.
"I'm hungry." Lucas looked up at the unshaven man. His father had grey-brown eyes, and those eyes held a plain, visible blankness.
"Hm?" The man seemed to be competing with Lucas for who could look more helpless.
Lucas simply waited. He had no intention of backing down, but he neither looked away nor repeated himself. The weight of that steady gaze genuinely pressed something into Mr. Graham.
"There are still two pounds in the drawer..." Mr. Graham seemed to be hearing Lucas express a need this firmly for the first time. There was actually cold pizza in the fridge, or perhaps he was misremembering.
Lucas had seen that drawer in his memories. He went to the drawer beneath the television cabinet and found some coins. There was a fast-food place on his way to school, and the meal deals there were reasonably priced.
Mr. Graham watched in silence as the child, considerably more nimble since the accidental magic outburst, got ready to head out the door.
"Can we talk when I get back?" Lucas asked while he changed his shoes.
After their brief exchange, he had already noticed that this man was very good at convincing himself.
When their eyes met, Lucas had tried to make the man actually see his own thin, frail child. And in just that one instant, one single instant, the man was in pain. The pained frown that followed carried a kind of self-persuasion Lucas couldn't interpret but could feel.
He let himself sink into some vague, shapeless suffering. It let him ignore everyone else's.
"You don't need to bring me food... I want to sleep early." The man saw that Lucas wasn't going to leave without an answer. After a long silence, he replied, his voice weak.
"You don't have to be hungry. But we need to talk. I have school fees to pay."
Lucas paused in the act of heading out. He set aside the pages he had organized upstairs for now and put a concrete problem in front of the man instead.
"...I'm sorry. All the money in the house is in that drawer." John Graham answered quietly.
Lucas waited a moment longer. He confirmed that this was all the answer he was going to get.
Mr. Graham had simply told him the outcome. He would not offer any solution: not borrowing money, not going to the school on his behalf. Nothing.
The drawer held fifteen pounds at most, which roughly matched what Lucas had calculated upstairs. Getting by day to day always had an endpoint. That endpoint was now almost here.
"Would you like to set a time to talk? The school I'm going to is a boarding school."
Again, a long wait. The figure across from him was like an old machine, always slow to process: "Your teachers will look after you well."
"They won't. I was bullied at my last school. I'm going to a new school, and I'll be bullied there too."
Lucas turned all the way around and placed the hard truth in front of the man. This same conversation existed in his memories from when he was five — his aunt had already had it then — but he had to say it himself now.
"No, that won't happen... Lucas is a good child." Mr. Graham turned his gaze away. He found he could no longer sit in that single sofa after all. He rose from his seat and walked upstairs.
The conversation was truly over.
Lucas turned off the television, the one that always played through the night. He would only have this talk once. Mr. Graham had refused it, definitively. He would not press him again.
➤ Next: The Alchemist's Puzzle
