I Want to Hear Your Thoughts About the Future of the MMD World!
Warning: This will be a very long post. I'll be talking about the different options I'm considering for bringing the MMD world back, my vision for the project, my thoughts on internet censorship, and a few other topics. So get comfortable.
Possible Options for Bringing the World Back
Option 1: Keep the World Public, but Add Extra Steps to Enter
The first option I'm considering is keeping the world public, but requiring users to go through some sort of verification process before accessing the main area.
This could be something similar to Japanese worlds, where you enter a separate room first and complete a questionnaire, accept terms and conditions, enter a password, or perform some other hidden step before being allowed into the actual world.
Option 2: Make the World Private
Another option would be making the world private and only allowing access through direct links or specific groups that maintain active instances.
Option 3: Reopen It Mostly As-Is, but Hide Rule-Violating Content ?
I could try to keep the world largely the same while hiding elements that might violate the rules, such as low-angle cameras, NPCs, certain songs, and other sensitive content.
These features could potentially only appear after entering the R18 password.
However, I'm not sure this would actually be enough. My guess is that the issue may be that new visitors can still immediately see all the dances on the main stage.
Option 4: Start an Entirely New Project
This one is a bit more radical.
Perhaps I could create a completely new world from scratch. This would give me the opportunity to improve many things that honestly need improvement and create something visually better and more polished.
That said, I would prefer this to be a separate project rather than a replacement for the current MMD world, so I'm mostly ruling this option out for now.
Option 5: Patreon Verification Access
Some other MMD worlds use systems that verify whether someone is a Patreon supporter and automatically grant access.
Honestly, this is one of the options that sounds the most appealing.
The problem is that my world creation skills are pretty limited, and I have absolutely no idea how to implement something like that.
On top of that, a Patreon-only world would naturally have fewer visitors, and one of the things I've always loved about the MMD world is that both free users and supporters can enjoy it together.
I'm only partially ruling out this option because of the technical difficulties. If I found a way to implement it without excluding free users, it would definitely become one of the most interesting possibilities.
Option 6: Remove All NSFW Content
I could remove all NSFW content, turn the club into a censorship-support group, and invite audiences of all ages to enjoy a completely family-friendly experience! ...
Just kidding.
That will never happen HAHAHA
Extra: Tell Me Your Ideas
I'm sure there are possibilities I haven't considered.
Please leave your thoughts, suggestions, improvements, or completely different ideas in the comments. I'd genuinely love to hear what all of you think.
Accessibility Matters to Me
One thing I want to make clear is that I strongly prefer solutions that keep the world easy to access.
After all, what is a VRChat world without people?
Honestly, nothing.
The MMD world has stayed alive because of all of you.
I know it would be easier to make everything private, but private solutions create barriers. Sometimes people are tired and just want to relax while watching MMD dances. They don't want to spend time searching for active groups, finding invite links, or creating empty instances themselves.
Likewise, if you're a Patreon supporter and want to bring a friend with you, it would be frustrating if they couldn't join simply because they aren't subscribed.
This is also one of the reasons I originally maintained the password system.
My thinking was that if you wanted to occasionally share the password with a CLOSE FRIEND who didn't normally play in the MMD world, that wasn't necessarily a bad thing.
I never openly encouraged it because that would inevitably lead to password leaks and unfairness toward supporters. Instead, I treated it as a sort of gray area and looked the other way.
In my mind, it was similar to sharing a Netflix account with a friend or family member.
Unfortunately, the password eventually became widely leaked and publicly shared, which created problems and wasn't fair to the people who support the project.
I'll likely look for a different solution in the future, but that's a discussion for another day.
I've always believed that the more people there are in the MMD world, the more enjoyable it becomes.
That's why accessibility remains one of my highest priorities, and why I don't tolerate any kind of discrimination during the events I organize.
Everyone deserves the opportunity to have fun.
My Thoughts on Censorship
(Feel free to skip this section if you'd like.)
This section is more personal.
Honestly, I'm tired.
I've watched websites that once allowed NSFW content gradually become pressured into censorship and forced to follow increasingly restrictive "family-friendly" standards.
Often, this seems to happen because of a very vocal minority that doesn't even consume the content in question.
If someone is legally consuming NSFW content and not harming anyone, why is there such an intense push to censor it?
Most of the content involved is fictional rather than real.
Meanwhile, there are many real problems happening in the world that receive far less attention.
I've never understood that contradiction.
NSFW themes have existed throughout human history.
They appear in literature, paintings, sculptures, music, photography, cinema, and countless forms of art from many different cultures and eras.
Human sexuality and reproduction are natural parts of life.
So why is there suddenly such a strong effort to erase or suppress these subjects worldwide?
What fundamentally separates a classical Roman nude sculpture from an anime figure?
Why are stories involving organized crime, graphic violence, revenge killings, and psychopaths often treated more leniently, even though those are behaviors that can actually be imitated?
Yet the human body itself becomes controversial.
I genuinely don't understand it.
My Vision for the MMD World
After getting that off my chest, I want to make something clear:
I am not giving up on "gentlemen's content."
But beyond that, I never viewed my MMD world as simply a collection of adult content.
For me, it has always been about appreciating the art of dance.
That's why I chose a stage design where dancers are placed at the center and visitors can appreciate performances from multiple angles.
I didn't just add whatever dances and camera motions happened to be popular.
I worked hard to provide variety.
I included both classic and newer songs.
I tried to represent different cultures rather than focusing exclusively on Japanese content.
I spent time selecting camera angles that would allow people to capture beautiful screenshots and share their appreciation of dance.
I searched for the highest-quality audio sources I could find and carefully adjusted volumes so that no song felt noticeably quieter or lower quality than the others.
I spent countless hours looking for music that wasn't already being used by every other MMD world because I wanted visitors to discover new songs and new experiences.
My goal was never to create something generic or repetitive.
I wanted to create something unique.
Something that represented the broader MMD culture, which is much larger and more diverse than many people realize.
I also wanted the world to be a place where friends could gather and have fun together.
That's one reason I kept everything within a single shared environment rather than separating spectators and performers into different spaces connected only through screens.
I wanted it to feel like a real place.
Looking Forward
Returning to the main topic:
I am not giving up on the MMD world.
I will continue exploring every possible option to keep this type of content alive and accessible without forcing people to jump through endless hoops.
At the same time, there is always the possibility that I've already attracted enough attention that future issues could arise regardless of what I do.
Maybe it won't be NSFW content next time.
Maybe it will be copyright concerns.
Maybe it will be something related to activities that take place inside the world.
I'd rather stay optimistic, but I also want to be prepared for any possibility.
One more thing:
If you've canceled your subscription, that's completely okay.
The only thing I'd ask is that if you're considering subscribing again, please wait for the next announcement.
I'm thinking about temporarily making all songs freely accessible as part of celebrating the world's return, and I also need time to decide whether to continue using the password system or adopt a different method entirely.
There are still many other things I'd like to discuss regarding the future of the MMD world, but honestly I can't remember all of them right now.
The next post may either cover the topics I forgot, or it may simply be a poll so that all of you can help decide which direction we should take.
Thank You
I truly cannot thank all of you enough.
The MMD world stayed alive and became popular because of you.
You are the reason it survived.
Seeing all of you continue to support the project and keep its spirit alive is exactly what convinced me not to let it disappear.
That's why I'm going to do everything I can to make sure we once again have a place where we can enjoy the things we love together.
For that, and for everything you've done for this community...
Thank you.
Comments (16)
4 seems alot of and long terms work so at this point i would suggest reupload and keep world private, or add any proctection, like patreon verify? password? whatever you think safe.
-main reason of the ban were probably the naked npcs, visible with the rotating glass, and maybe some of the songs. -it would be better if all the NSFW is kept behind whitelisting with patreon. having a code to unlock, can be easly shared, which is a risk for another ban. -uploading the world has private will also help, and groups will make the lobbies. also make sure to upload using a different account, so you dont get a second strike on your main. -making a new complete world is not necessary, but might help resolve some issues.
6. ive heard some worlds actually have acess tied to being verified with vrchat, like that theres worlds that check if you have the 18+badge that open up more stuff for people maybe a room that can only be acessed by 18+people (might need a coolider in the room to respawn people who arent verified cause chairs exist) and unfortunatly even private worlds have been getting hit for 5, you can set up a whitelist of people who suport the patreon that gives them acess to the song once they give you there username for vrchat you plug it into the world's white list and that gives them acess to the songs
Id say make a safe for work and private the +18
ive seen things done where theres 2 copies of the same world. but one is open public and mostly stripped down(sfw). and the other world is only available through a private link or something. perhaps the nsfw world link only available in patreon and also after being verified 18+ or something. i will say do miss this world a whole lot already.
Sadly with how rules are changing, a world apparently only needs a 'report' to be deemed accountable, and from there very little is directly looked into deciding if it's worthy of a ban or not. This means if just 'anyone' could even get the link, and felt like becoming a bad actor because they 'didn't get the code' or 'staff at an instance mistreated them' they could simply report it and have it taken down as we're seeing currently with so many other worlds this last month alone. As a result, you chances are do need to limit it's traffic in someway, while not making it easy accessible in the first place. Private linked, and then on top of that Patreon verified might have to be the call in a way, but even still it'll run the risk of just -1- person just tossing a report... It's really a bad spot, and I've already seen quite a few people pull out hair with far less adult oriented worlds getting either temp banned or worse over this matter. so even if you made it just SFW if someone just had a 'bad day' and a mod 'felt' like it was enough, *it wouldn't even matter*.
Met so many amazing people. People I would have never met in other worlds. It was a awesome social experience. It was my tribe. Very sad. I believe you are brilliant and can create something that can reunite us once again. Thank you.
(copied from discord) Maybe have a lobby be the spawn zone where you have to insert a code in order to get into the actual dance area And maybe they're mention of nudity is from the anime dancers since their technically completely naked under the outfit with bits visible if you walk into them, there's another MMD world that uses sfw furry avatars as dancers
Private and password
1 and 4,5
I'd sayake it private and make it link accessable only. That way, you won't have to remove any songs at all
Option 1 seems more the humane way, but I am aware people will simply click through words anyway. I would lean in much more towards having the pin pad be in a less inconspicuous area (having it be sitting right across the song selection was probably not the best of ideas, especially if they're meant to be interacted once per visit).
IMO 4+5 As for the censorship, I'm already leaving the platform, let them rot with the loud minority who spend nothing on the platform and move to the platform that knows their real customers.
Just re-upload it as private. Its the easiest and safest thing to do
I like the idea of reuploading it as a private world. The link itself could be shared here and in your discord. I would also keep the password function the same.
For me personally, as someone who very frequently uses the world, I like the option of reuploading it as a private world with the password function still in place while developing another solution. I also really like the idea of starting from scratch to improve on things you want to. So why not both of those options, and just updating the password every month until new project is done?
