Retrospective: The Tragedy of Macbeth (2021)
Anybody who has seen his Big Lebowski, No Country for Old Men, A Serious Man or True Grit knows that Joel Coen — in collaboration with his brother Ethan — is capable of miracles. But I'm not sure we knew Joel Coen could split from his brother and make a Peter Brook film for the 21st Century. When I watched The Tragedy of Macbeth last night, I kept thinking "didn't Peter Brook do this with King Lear? Did Elijah Moshinsky of BBC Television Shakespeare work on this? Which Weird Sister did Coen personally consult before shooting this?" I was flummoxed. I didn't know the kind of Shakespeare productions I loved still got made, or that Coen had any juice left in him after True Grit. But they do, and he does, and it's nothing short of miraculous.
Aside from being the single most entertaining play ever written, Macbeth is full of elements a Coen brother would love: criminal upstarts, pitch black comedy, devastating irony, ill-conceived murder plots, a doomed protagonist. When Corey Hawkins' Macduff enters the film, he seems like a detective out of a noir come to solve Macbeth's crimes. Like Shakespeare and Jan Kott, Coen understands that history's Grand Mechanism is operated with blood, a fact that makes him and Ethan the Kafka of our time.
Coen approaches the material like a Fritz Lang or F. W. Murnau film, shooting in black-and-white and the Academy ratio, juxtaposing the stark modernism of Macbeth's castle with the crooked eldritch weirdness of the heaths. Like Orson Welles and Trevor Nunn, Coen understands that Macbeth works best with a stark color palette. He makes a Macbeth that could have been shot shortly after World War I, with a Macbeth who looks like he has just slaughtered entire legions. Crucially, he casts Black men as Macbeth and Macduff, always mirror images of each other, and sends white men to kill Macduff's young Black children, adding a layer of uniquely American horror to the story.
Denzel Washington takes a role that's been played onscreen by Orson Welles and Ian McKellen and makes it hard to imagine that anybody else ever played the role. Frances Mcdormand operates similarly as Lady Macbeth. Coen has created one of the three definitive screen versions of Macbeth — a miracle of our time.
