Review: The Rings of Power: Marnûkh/The Gift of Men
The second season of Amazon’s The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power saw the program broach narrative competence. This probably had a lot to do with showrunners McKay and Payne not writing any episodes until the finale and relying on their writers’ room of Better Call Saul and Game of Thrones veterans to tell their story, but even those two J. J. Abrams acolytes from Washington D.C.’s most invidious suburb held their own in the finale. So who knows? Maybe the season written exclusively by Payne and McKay and a chap who wrote four episodes of Stranger Things was in with a shot. The Rings of Power may be nothing more than an extremely expensive item in Jeff Bezos’ portfolio, but it’s had fleeting moments of quality before.
And to be sure, “Marnûkh” isn’t an improvement on nothing. It more or less communicates the stakes of the season — the war between Sauron and the Elves is in its fifth year (something communicated via an intertitle and then seconds later by voice-over). The episode dutifully rolls out the season’s major players and shows us exactly what the show is going to deal with over the next eight or so hours. The scenes in which Sauron R&Ds the Nine Rings grant a pleasing macabre tangibility to moments in the Legendarium which Tolkien generally left to the imagination. Sauron’s haunting by Celebrimbor is a pleasant bit of Macbethism sensibly anchored in the Dark Lord’s fear of losing his power and the knowledge he has sabotaged his own quest to forge more rings. Eddie Marsan’s casting as Thrain is nothing short of inspired, and his dynamic with Durin makes for both a convincing fraternal relationship and a solid bit of foreshadowing for Annatar’s machiavellian turn in Númenor. This may be McKay and Payne’s best script to date, assuming their draft of Jungle Cruise isn’t secretly a lost masterpiece.
But with that, we have exhausted the good qualities of “Marnûkh”, which is mostly as insipid and inert as their other scripts. McKay and Payne’s still appear to believe that the height of drama is making the audience ask “which legacy character will this person turn out to be?”, as if we didn’t spend last season waiting around to learn when they’ll finally start calling Ciáran Hinds’ character Saruman (spoiler: he’s “the Dark Wizard” now). This show has absolutely no idea how to give original characters like Theo and Arondir a personality, and it only fares slightly better with legacy characters who have established personalities. Charlie Vickers is still hopelessly miscast as Sauron, commanding all the screen presence of a washed up celebrity cameo in a StateFarm commercial, and hardly anybody outside of the dwarves feeling like they belong in a show about Middle-earth. The Nazgûl lumber around like discarded prototypes for The Terminator. The Rings of Power continues its ruthless assassination of Galadriel’s character, reducing Tolkien’s tragic penitent mystic into an enervated Jeanne d’Arc who only waves swords against faceless masses of orcs or waxes rueful about the fate of Middle-earth.
But we’ve already discussed this program’s assassination of Galadriel’s character at length across two seasons’ worth of reviews, so let’s cover new ground: The Rings of Power’s assassination of Celeborn’s character. Ignoring that Jamie Campbell Bower’s Celeborn evinces not a symptom of personality, it’s hard to imagine even Bower’s predecessor in the role Marton Csokas extracting any pathos out of the character as scripted. The program discards Tolkien’s story of Galadriel and Celeborn falling in love and healing each other in a world broken by the wars of gods and elves in favor of a scene where two people with chemistry too scant to be observed by a microscope get the hots for each other in a laughably bad round of swordplay. The sequence is a perfect showcase of The Rings of Power’s visual failings: color grading that’s afraid to distinguish between characters and backgrounds, action blocking which fails to match the excitement of a playground sword fight, lighting that’s not so much soft as flaccid. It is hard to imagine anyone being moved or exhilarated by this sequence, which seems to posit that the basis of Galadriel and Celeborn’s love is banging swords together. The Rings of Power’s improvements are so scant as to be pointless; you cannot infuse a fundamentally soulless project with a soul.
Perhaps that makes the success of Season Three’s second episode “The Gift of Men” all the more frustrating. Unlike “Marnûkh” (why is it named after an orc with a couple minutes of screen time and almost no bearing on the episode’s plot?), “The Gift of Men” is a focused and thematically coherent piece of TV drama. While the season premiere hops across space and time, “The Gift of Men” focuses primarily on power and politics in Númenor as the underground resistance of the Faithful works to overthrow Ar-Pharazôn’s regime. Writer Justin Doble (of course Payne and McKay didn’t write this one) comes across like he’s actually read Tolkien, engaging with the legendarium’s themes of power rotting souls and destroying kingdoms. Isildur’s failed attempt to assassinate Ar-Pharazôn makes for compelling television, while Ëarien’s struggle to overthrow the regime from inside is the most interesting part of the show since Celebrimbor, culminating in a truly effective tragic ending. Watching this show written by somebody who understands drama and suspense is a pleasant reprieve, and I dread to think of how Payne and McKay will follow this up.
“The Gift of Men” has a handful of interesting moments outside of the Númenor plot. Sauron luring in Theo with talk of his bloodline is an interesting example of the program actually cutting against some of Tolkien’s racial ideas, albeit one undermined by the impossibility for a casual viewer of remembering who Theo is. Thrain’s role as Moria’s Maeglin continues to be fun. And Charlotte Brändström’s directing improves drastically when she’s given actual writing to work with. The orc’s fear of being enslaved by Sauron is also an interesting take on the source material (although given the racialized nature of The Lord of the Rings, this seems like a fundamentally doomed idea). But as a sophomore effort, “The Gift of Men” is respectable, aiming to be an effective episode of television drama rather than a slog through Payne and McKay’s most important resumé bullet point. I cannot fathom why Amazon dropped four of these shows at once (there’s a reason I’m doing these four episodes as two essays rather than one), but hey, it means I didn’t only have Payne and McKay’s storytelling to talk about today. I’ll take these small mercies from one of my least favorite television shows of all time.
Comments (2)
I find myself wondering why you’re spending your time on this Earth reviewing one of your least favorite television shows of all time.
Says the writer of the Chibnall Eruditorum essays.
