Outer Masks - Chapter 23: I See What You Truly Are
Guinevere Beck never expected that she would ever find herself in a situation like this. Now she was sitting across from her ex-boyfriend’s ex, having just been told the worst news she could have ever imagined hearing.
Candace sat next to Beck on her couch, patiently waiting for any kind of response from the other woman.
But Beck could not speak; her hands rested in her lap, her fingers curling so tightly into the fabric of her jeans that they ached, and yet she barely noticed the pain. Her entire body felt distant, like she was watching herself from somewhere outside of it, trapped in this moment.
It was already hard enough to take in everything that Peach had told her earlier about Joe, to accept that he would be capable of being so cruel, so heartless, and so brazen.
But now she was supposed to believe that Joe had attempted to murder a person and bury what he had thought to be their dead body in a shallow grave? All because he found out that Candace had cheated on him and tried to break up with him.
After a while, Candace sighed, rubbing the back of her neck with one hand. “I know everything I just told you sound insane-”
“It sounds more than insane!” Beck screeched, her eyes wide and manic. “I thought Peach must have been wrong when she mentioned the possibility of Joe... of Joe...”
“That Joe would try to kill me?” Candace asked, staring deeply into Beck’s eyes. “I’m not the first person he’s attacked, I’m just the only one who’s survived. Well, me and your friend, Peach, are the only ones to survive.”
Beck let out a shuddering breath, gripping her jeans again. “W-What are you talking about?”
“The guy I had cheated on Joe with, Elijah Thornton, his death was labeled an accident, but I know that he didn't just accidentally fall off the balcony of his hotel. I know Joe is responsible for it, just as I know that he’s responsible for the death of Michael Lawrence. Do you remember him?”
Beck’s brow furrowed as she tried to place the name, it sounded vaguely familiar to her, but she could not for the life of her figure out who the other woman was referring to.
“He’s the guy you made out with at Max Rockefeller's beach house when you thought no one was watching,” Candace said, smiling not at the fact that Joe had killed a man, but because Beck’s actions had such a profound impact on Joe that she had reveled in seeing him sulking and pitiful for weeks after he discovered Beck’s betrayal.
Beck’s eyes widened, the hazy memory crashing back into the forefront of her mind, and her voice became shaky as she spoke. “I… That was-it was nothing, it didn’t mean anything. I was drunk, and we barely even-”
“And then he turned up dead,” Candace finished for her, her tone flat. “Convenient, right? If you don't believe me just search up his name along with deaths in the area.”
“How do you even you know about that?”
“I told you, I’ve been watching Joe ever since that bastard tried to kill me. I’ve been keeping track of almost every fucked up thing he does.”
“And you have proof?”
Candace hesitated for a moment. “I have some.”
Beck scoffed. “Some? You’re telling me that my ex-boyfriend is a serial killer and all you have is some proof?”
“I can’t watch him at all times of the day!” Candace snapped before forcing her to relax, her jaw tightening. “Look, haven’t you thought that it’s strange that all these things have been happening around you ever since you met Joe? Peach being attacked, your friend Benji disappearing on a bender despite him having never been gone for this long, a guy you hooked up with turning up dead shortly afterwards, even me being here right now is only happening because of him. You were, you are always at the center of it.”
“Yeah, but-”
Candace pulled out her phone, swiping through it for a moment before handing it to Beck. “I care about what happens to you; I don’t want there to be more victims of Joseph Goldberg, and because he deserves to pay for his crimes. I wanted to warn you of just what he’s capable of, I’m sure he’s going to try and contact you and convince you that everything Peach told you was a lie or exaggerated, but you can’t trust him, or be alone with him, or even talk to him.”
Beck took the woman’s phone and saw that Candace had opened a video; the footage was dark, grainy, and clearly filmed from a distance given how zoomed in the picture was. It was only because of some light from neon signs that she could see what was going on and could see her ex-boyfriend dressed in all black and standing over the body of Michael Lawrence, and with a bloody rock in his hand.
In the video, Joe looked around a few times before placing his hand on Michael’s chest, he then shoved a bloody rock into his jacket pocket and bent down to drag Michael’s body behind a dumpster. Beck let out a gasp, putting a hand over her mouth as she watched Joe reach into Michael’s pockets, pulling out his phone and wallet before leaving the alley, not once glancing back at his victim.
Beck dropped Candace’s phone as her breathing became heavy, and her body folded in on itself as she started to gag.
“Oh my God…” Beck whispered. “No… no, this... this can’t-”
Her gaze then found the phone where it had fallen to the floor and saw that the video had restarted, showing her everything again.
Beck was sure that she was going to vomit as she now had undeniable proof that Peach and Candace were right, and could now see with her own eyes just how far Joe was willing to go.
Candace stared at Beck, leaning over to place a hand on top of Beck’s, squeezing it gently. “I really am sorry that you had to learn the truth this way, but I just…”
I just want to do for you that no cared enough to do for me. Candace finished in her mind.
Beck started to tear up, and she hated how she was now crying when she felt like what Joe had done to her, paled in comparison to everything Candace experienced.
“It’s not your fault,” Candace said, wrongly assuming that Beck was crying because she believed that she had somehow brought this on herself. “Joe is good at what he does, and he’s the one who is choosing to be like this.”
Beck let out a broken laugh, dragging her sleeve across her face. “I thought I knew him. And I thought, I thought I might be in love with him.”
Candace’s expression softened even further. “I thought the same, but the longer I was with him the more of him that I saw, and the more I began to realize just how obsessive, possessive, and narcissistic he was. I just realized the truth too late, and I ended up getting buried alive because of it, but I won’t let the same happen to you.”
Beck nodded her head, her chest tightening painfully, still overwhelmed by everything she was feeling and by everything she had learned.
Candace checked the time on her phone and stood up before handing Beck a piece of paper with her phone number on it. “I have to go.”
“Go?” Beck looked up and for a moment, Candace thought that she looked like a lost puppy. “Go where? I... I... You can’t just drop all of this and leave.”
The thought of being alone now terrified her, and she did not know what she would do once Candace walked out the door.
The other woman hesitated, putting a hand on Beck’s shoulder. “You asked about what proof I have of Joe’s crimes, but that video? That’s just the beginning; Joe is already facing criminal charges, but it's not enough. He’s out walking about free, and even when a trial does come, he could get like what? Seven to ten years in prison. I’m going to bury him, and to do that, I need to find everything he’s hiding so he can’t weasel his way out of justice.”
Beck watched as Cadance pick her phone off the floor and move toward the door, her stomach still twisting in knots.
Candace hesitated again when she reached for the doorknob, turning back to look at the other woman. “If he reaches out to you, and I know he will, I need you to tell me, Beck. Don’t meet him alone and don’t believe a word he says.”
“O-Okay,” Beck said, keeping everything that she wanted to say to herself.
“Good,” Candace said, giving Beck a reassuring smile as she stepped outside, the door closing softly behind her.
Once Candace was gone, Beck laid down on the couch, grabbing one of the throw pillows and holding it against her chest, and staring blankly at the ceiling.
I... I don’t even know what’s going on anymore. Beck thought, starting to cry again.
She felt a strange mix of anger and gratitude toward Candace and even Peach for cursing her with this information, but most of all she struggled with the love, hate, disbelief, and fear that the thought of Joe now inspired within her.
Within a few hours, her entire world had just been thrown of its axis, and she has never felt so helpless and useless in her entire life. And she despised how this same feeling reminded her of how she felt when she found her father in the middle of an overdose, which in turn made her feel worse as she remembered that Joe was the first person who she told the truth about Edward.
She was not lying when she told Cadance that she thought that she loved Joe, but now she wished that she had been, that she had never come to fall for him in the first place.
The woman cried harder, rolling over to bury her face in the couch cushions, trying to muffle the sound despite no one else being around to hear her.
~X~
Paco had been spending every moment he could looking out for any sign of Joe, spending hours sitting on the top of the building’s staircase.
But after two days of the same behavior, Claudia had grown tired of her son’s behavior and had told him to stop, forcing him to stay inside their apartment.
The nurse had grown skittish over the last few days, agonizing over Joe’s arrest. Weeks earlier, her boyfriend, Ron Baker, had disappeared and no knew where he had gone, and now, with everything coming out about Joe, she hated the increased scrutiny that was now falling upon herself and her son.
She could not say that she was upset about her boyfriend being missing and possibly dead, Ron had been an abusive, cruel, drunk who had threatened to report her addiction to CPS when she tried to leave him, and who constantly hit her. And she was not sure if she believed that Joe could be capable of stalking, harassing, and assaulting someone, but then she remembered how little she knew of the man and her worrying increased.
But most of all, she was afraid that with the investigations into both her ex and her neighbor, that her drug use may come to light and she may lose Paco and her job.
But her attempts to pretend everything was fine for his sake did not work as Paco knew more than his mother was aware of.
He knew about his mother’s addiction, about Ron's abuse, and more important, he knew that Joe had killed Ron having seen the man do it to protect him from the parole officer when the man tried to attack him.
It’s why he did not believe Claudia's warnings that Joe may be dangerous. How can he believe those lies when Joe had only ever acted to keep him safe?
Paco laid on his bed, staring up at the ceiling; his small hands clenched tightly. In Paco's eyes, Joe would never hurt another person without good reason, so whoever had him arrested had to be lying.
Nobody understands him like I do, Joe is a good person, and he only hurts people who deserve it, like Ron. Paco thought, the idea of joe rotting in a jail cell unfairly, boiling his blood.
His gaze shifted toward the door, listening carefully for any sign of his mother moving around the apartment, faintly hearing the television from the living room. Paco slid off the bed quietly, his bare feet barely making a sound against the floor as he crept toward his door.
He hesitated for a moment before reaching out and turning the doorknob, slowly opening the door and peering out into the living room, seeing Claudia fast asleep on the couch.
The young boy swallowed hard, tightening his grip on the doorframe before slipping out of the room. He moved quickly toward the front door, grabbing his sneakers and shoving them on without bothering to tie them as he stepped out into the empty hallway.
The moment that he closed his front door; Paco heard something hitting the floor from nearby. At first, he thought it was his mother, having woken up and realized he was gone, but as he heard another thud, Paco realized that the sound was coming from Joe’s apartment.
“Joe,” Paco whispered, a wide grin all but running toward the adjacent apartment door.
He did not even bother to knock, nor did he question why Joe’s front door was unlocked in his excitement.
“Joe?” Paco said softly as he pushed the door open, looking around the apartment.
When he did not see Joe in the living room or kitchen, Paco immediately went to check the man’s bedroom, but before he could, he noticed a shadow moving underneath the bathroom door.
Again, Paco did not hesitate and opened the door in front of him, but when he did, he did not see Joe Goldberg, but a small auburn-haired woman, standing on a chair with one hand braced against the wall and the other inside ceiling, above the toilet.
The ceiling tile that was supposed to be there was lying on the floor, partially broken and dust scattered across the bathroom floor.
Candace froze; her fingers still curled around the edge of the shoebox Joe had hidden in the ceiling. Paco froze too, his hand still on the doorknob as the two stared at each other in stunned silence.
“You’re… not Joe,” Paco said quietly, staring at Candace with confusion and suspicion. “What are you doing here?”
“I’m... I’m a friend of Joe,” Candace said, forcing a small smile as she slowly lowered her hand from the ceiling.
Paco’s eyes flicked to the open panel above her, then to the shoebox in her grip and glared at her. “Joe doesn’t let people in here, and he doesn’t let anyone touch that box.”
“Hey,” Candace said softly, her smile faltering as she slowly stepped down from the chair, trying to salvage the situation. “It’s okay, I’m not here to hurt him. I’m just-”
“You’re lying!” Paco shouted; his hands clenched at his sides.
Candace sighed. “Look kid, I need to-”
Paco ran forward, shoving Candace’s side with all the force he could muster, knocking the woman in the bathroom sink.
Candace let out a gasp, ignoring the pain as she tightened her grip on the shoebox and tried to steady herself as Paco continued to push her back.
“Stop it!” Candace snapped, using her shoulder to push Paco back. “What are you doing?!”
“Put it back!” Paco yelled, his voice cracking as he grabbed at her arm, trying to make her drop the box. “That’s Joe’s! You can’t take it!”
Candace did not want to hurt the boy; he was just a child who had no idea what kind of man he was trying to protect truly was. And it was this thinking that kept her from
“Listen to me,” she said, catching Paco’s wrists, and holding them both with one hand. “Joe is not who you think he is.”
“You don’t know him!” Paco yelled, tears springing to his eyes as he struggled against her grip. “He saved me! He saved my mom! He’s a good person!”
“You don’t know-Ow!” Candace hissed as Paco leaned forwards and sank his teeth into her wrist, hard enough to make her flinch and loosen her grip.
Paco tore himself free and immediately slammed his foot on top of Candace's, grabbing the shoebox from her hand when she shouted in pain and her hold on it loosened. He then turned on his heel and ran out of the bathroom.
“Shit,” Candace growled, shaking her wrist and running after Paco. “Get back here!”
Paco ignored her and made his way out of the apartment, running toward his own and by the time Candace had entered the hallway, Paco had already closed and locked the door in front of her face.
“Damn it!” Candace tried to twist the doorknob and fruitlessly tried to open the door. “Please, Paco! You need to open the door and give me the box.”
“No!” Paco shouted from the other side. “Go away!”
How did she know my name? Paco thought, pressing the shoebox close to his chest as he leaned against the door.
Candace grounded her teeth together; she knew that she could not stand here for long as she did not know when Joe would be coming back, but she also knew that Paco would tell Joe about this encounter.
Reluctantly, the woman stepped back and turned away from the door, and ran towards the stairs, her heartbeat pounding in her ears. “Fuck, fuck, fuck, fuck!”
By the time Candace pushed through the front door of the building and out onto the street, she could not stop herself from thinking about what Joe would do when he eventually returned.
Would he immediately think that I’m the one who broke into his home? No, why would he? He thinks he killed me, he’ll just think it was someone else that Paco saw. Candace thought, still second guessing herself.
Candace swallowed hard, forcing herself to keep moving and disappearing into the flow of pedestrians.
~X~
Inside the apartment, Paco did not know how long he had stood with his back pressed against the door, frozen in place and clutching the shoebox tightly against his chest.
His breathing came fast and uneven, and his heart racing quickly in his chest as he stared at his mother’s still sleeping form.
Inwardly he wondered if Claudia had started using again as she only slept this deeply when she was coming down from a high.
Eventually, Paco turned around and looked through the door’s peephole, holding his breath as he checked to make sure the woman was really gone.
He let out a sigh of relief when he did not see her, his shoulders dropping as the tension left his body. He then moved his head away from the peephole and pressed his forehead underneath it.
“Who was she?” Paco asked himself, glancing at the shoebox.
Paco wondered how long she had been in Joe’s apartment before he heard her, and if she knew exactly where to look for the box in his hands or if she had spent some time looking around before stumbling upon it.
It doesn’t matter; I kept her from taking it. Paco thought, a sense of pride blooming in his chest.
As long as he was able, Paco was not going to let anyone hurt his friend or try to take him away, Joe had protected and cared for him when no one else did, so he would do the same.Joe had protected and cared for him when no one else did, so he would do the same.
He did not know how long he had stood there, but eventually Paco heard someone walking up the stairs through the door.
Paco quickly lifted his head and looked through the peephole, worried that Candace had come back, or that someone else was trying to snoop through Joe’s apartment.
When he looked, Paco saw Joe standing in front of his own apartment door, looking at it confused when he saw that the door was partially open.
Paco rushed to unlock his front door, flinging it open just as Joe pushed his own door wider.
“Joe!” Paco called out, stepping into the hallway and running toward the man.
“Paco?” Joe said softly when he turned to look at the boy. “Hey, what's wrong-”
“You’re back, I was... I was worried that I would never see you again,” Paco said, his voice small as he grabbed onto the front of Joe’s shirt.
Joe’s expression softened, his hand coming up to rest on the back of Paco’s head. “Hey, hey, it’s okay, I told you, didn’t I? I’m not going anywhere.”
Joe’s smile fell when he saw the shoebox in Paco’s hands. “Paco, why do you have that?”
“There was a lady,” Paco blurted out. “She was in your apartment. I think she broke in.”
Joe went still. “What?”
“She was in your bathroom,” Paco continued, speaking quickly. “She was standing on the toilet, and she took the ceiling thing down, and she had your box in her hands, but I stopped her. I didn’t let her take it.”
Joe’s eyes flicked to the shoebox in Paco’s hands again, his stomach dropping as a feeling of dread and anger slid down his spine.
“You did good, Paco,” Joe said, his voice eerily calm as he took the box from him. “You did exactly what you were supposed to do.”
Paco straightened slightly at the praise. “When I told her to leave, she said she was your friend, but she was lying.”
Joe nodded slowly; his mind was already racing.
A woman was in my apartment? And they knew exactly where to find this? Joe thought, his grip on the box tightening. “Did you see her face?”
Paco frowned as he thought about the woman’s appearance. “Yeah, she had reddish brown hair I think and blue eyes, and she was short.”
Red hair, blue eyes, and short... Now who could that be? Nobody I know has those features. Could Peach have hired someone to break into my apartment and look for evidence to use against me? “Did she say anything else to you?”
“Only that you’re not who I think you are and that I shouldn’t trust you,” Paco muttered before staring at the man wide eyed. “But I didn’t believe her! I know who you are, she was just trying to trick me.”
“Thank you,” Joe said softly, resting a hand on Paco's shoulder. “I know that things seem kind of confusing right now, but you did the right thing. Someone’s… Someone’s trying to ruin my life, and I don’t know why. First, they have me arrested for things I didn’t do and now they’re breaking into my apartment, trying to steal from me?”
Joe glanced past Paco, his eyes flicking briefly toward Claudia’s apartment door before returning to the boy.
“Listen,” he said, crouching slightly so they were eye level. “I need you to do something for me, okay?”
Paco straightened, his expression serious. “Anything.”
“If you see that woman again, or anyone else going near my apartment…” Joe paused, choosing his words carefully. “…you come get me. Or you call me right away, don’t try to handle it by yourself this time.”
Paco hesitated for a second before nodding. “Okay.”
Joe smiled faintly, reaching out to ruffle his hair. “Good.”
Joe then took the shoebox from Paco, his fingers curling tightly around the edges as he stood back up.
“Go back inside, okay?” Joe said gently. “And don’t tell your mom about this, I don’t want her to worry.”
Paco nodded. “Okay.”
Joe offered him one last reassuring smile, waiting until Paco stepped back into his apartment and shut the door before turning away.
The moment the door closed behind Paco, the softness drained from Joe’s face, his jaw tightening as he stepped back into his own apartment.
What the hell is going on? Joe set the shoebox down on the kitchen counter, dragging his hand down his face.
Of course, of fucking course this happens the moment I get out. Why should I expect some kind of reprieve after everything I've endured?
Joe looked around his apartment and saw that things were slightly out of place despite the clear attempt at trying to hide this. A normal person most likely would not have noticed how the books on the coffee table were no longer stacked in the same order he had left them in before his arrest or how one of the kitchen drawers sat slightly ajar, just barely off from where it should have been, or even the tv had been moved half an inch to the left.
Joe then went to the bathroom and saw the state that Paco and this unknown burglar had left it in, the light was still on, the broken ceiling tile still lay on the floor beside the toilet, dust scattered across the linoleum, and the chair the woman must have used to reach the ceiling was knocked over, laying sideways on the ground.
Joe crouched down slowly and picked up the broken ceiling tile, turning it over in his hands as his thoughts spiraled.
I refuse to believe this could be a coincidence, Peach had to have gotten this woman to break in, it's the only this makes sense. Especially because this happened today, after I made bail. I’m sure Peach and her lawyers were immediately told of this, and she moved to put this in motion. Wait, if Paco hadn’t stopped this woman, would Peach have given the box to the police? Or would she have given it to you, Beck?
Joe dropped the tile and stood up, his pulse thrumming violently beneath his skin as he left his bathroom. Rage and panic tangled together inside his chest as he moved through his apartment and headed toward the door, but before he could leave, Joe turned on his heel and grabbed the shoebox.
He took it with him as he went downstairs and out of the apartment building, running toward his car and driving in the direction of Mooney’s, wanting to put the box of evidence in the store’s basement.
Joe reached the bookstore, fumbling slightly with his keys before unlocking the front door and slipping inside. He locked the door behind himself and then he moved through the darkened store without turning on the lights, heading straight for the basement door.
Joe set the shoebox down on his worktable and opened it quickly, checking its contents franticly, relaxing as he found Benji’s phone, teeth, and wallet, an old necklace that belonged to Candace which he had taken from her body, and Beck’s old phone, a few pairs of her underwear, and a used tampon.
He knew that he should get rid of all of this, that he should destroy it, but he could not bring himself to, not even in this moment. Each item in the box meant something to him; they were the ultimate expression of his love; of the lengths he would go for the one.
Everything I do is for you, Beck, even now. Joe picked up Beck’s old phone, turning it over and handling it like the scared item he thought it was.
This is what people like Candace, Benji, and Peach will never understand about me; they want to paint me as some kind of monster, like a freak of nature because it’s easier than admitting how wrong they have judged me and their own insecurities. Love requires sacrifice, love requires protection, and sometimes it requires doing ugly things for beautiful reasons.
Joe put the broken phone back in the shoebox and turned away from the table, intent on making sure that whatever machinations were being made to keep him and Beck apart were thoroughly dismantled.
~X~
“Beck! Beck! Beck, please! I need to talk to you!” Joe said as soon as he reached Beck’s front door, pounding his fist against wood hard enough to rattle the frame.
His breathing was uneven from the run to her apartment, panic and desperation bleeding into every movement as he glanced repeatedly down both ends of the street, half-expecting Peach to appear with police officers behind her.
“Beck, I know you’re in there!” Joe called again, pressing closer to the door. “Please, just let me explain.”
“G-Go away, Joe!” The man felt relieved when he heard Beck shouting at him through the door because it meant she was still willing to speak to him.
“Beck, please,” Joe said, lowering his voice slightly as he rested his forehead against the door. “I know thing seem really bad, but-”
“You outed my best friend, attacked her with a rock, and have been stalking us ever since we first met!” Beck screeched, her voice cracking. “How the fuck am I supposed to believe anything you say anymore?!”
“I know Peach got to you, and I know she’s filling your head with all kinds of bullshit, but you have to let me explain. I didn’t attack Peach, she's lying, she's trying to-”
“I know the truth, Joe,” Beck said, her voice now quieter than before.
“Know? Know what?” Joe asked.
A few seconds passed before Beck responded, “I know about Micheal, and I know about Elijah, B-Benji, and I... I know about Candace. I know what you did to each one of them.”
Joe staggered back from the door, staring blankly ahead as the world around him seemed to tilt sideways.
No, that’s impossible. She can't… she can't know, how could she… Joe’s thought spiraled and he found himself struggling to breathe.
He could understand Beck finding out about Benji, that Peach may have told her about how suspicious Benji’s lack of presence was now becoming or that the man had decided to go on a worldwide bender shortly after she had met Joe despite having just returned to the city, but Micheal? Elijah? Even Candace? Peach could not have known that there was no way that she could have pieced all this together unless she had been watching him for some time.
“Who told you that?” Joe asked.
“R-Rory's parents have been investigating you for a while and they told Rory everything and she told Peach who told me,” Beck said shakily through the door. “And... C-Candace… your ex-girlfriend Candace came here tonight.”
Joe went completely still; his ears buzzing as he struggled to comprehend what he had just been told.
Candace... Candace is alive? Rory... she... she knows too? How is this... But I... I killed...
Over the course of the next few moments, Joe found himself blacking out, and when he finally came back to himself, he heard Beck screaming at him in shock and saw that he was now standing in her apartment, Beck’s front door having been forced open behind him.
Splintered wood littered the floor near the broken lock, and Joe stared at the damage blankly for a moment before turning to look at Beck.
She stood several feet away from him near the kitchen counter, clutching her phone in one hand. Tears streamed down her face, and her entire body was trembling as she stared at Joe horrified.
“Beck,” Joe whispered, scared by the fear in her eyes. “I didn’t mean to-”
“Don’t come near me!” Beck cried, stumbling backward when he instinctively took a step toward her. “Oh my God, Joe, you broke my fucking door!”
Joe immediately stopped moving, raising his hands up placatingly. “I know, I know, I’m sorry, I just… you said Can-Candace was alive.”
Beck stared at him in disbelief. “That’s what you care about right now?”
“No!” Joe snapped before forcing himself to calm down. “No, Beck, that’s not what I meant. It’s just… none of this makes sense.”
“It makes perfect sense!” Beck shouted hysterically. “You killed people!”
“I didn’t kill Candace!” Joe argued desperately. “She’s alive, Beck, you just said she’s alive!”
Beck sharply recoiled. “Joe, listen to yourself!”
Joe ran both hands through his hair, pacing once before turning back to her. “You don’t understand what she’s doing here. Candace is manipulative, she lies, she twists things-”
“She showed me a video of you standing over a dead body!” Beck screamed. “I saw you dragging Michael Lawrence into an alley like he was garbage!”
Joe froze, genuine panic overtaking him as he stood there now stunned by this information. Not only was his long dead girlfriend actually alive, but from Beck’s own words she has been watching him for some time now.
And suddenly, Joe remembered the description Paco had given him of the woman who had broken into his apartment.
I should have known it was her. I mean, I went back to her grave, and I saw that her body was no longer there, but instead of looking deeper, I ignored it. I didn’t want to think that someone found her body and moved it or that Candace could have survived because it was just easier to tell myself a lie. Joe thought.
“Beck,” Joe said softly, taking another careful step forward, seeing the way she flinched. “Please just listen to me for a second, Michael wasn’t supposed to happen-”
“So, you admit it?” Beck whispered, her face crumpling.
Joe’s mouth opened slightly, and he struggled to find his footing. “I... It’s not what you think.”
“How could it possibly be anything else?! Candace told me everything and I didn’t want to believe her, but then I saw that video and now you’re standing here basically confessing!”
Joe shook his head frantically. “No, Beck, but you have to understand the context-”
“The context?!” Beck laughed brokenly, tears spilling harder down her face. “There’s context for murder now?”
“I only did it because of you!” Joe shouted, the words flying out of his lips before he could stop them. “Because you cheated on me with him! I poured my heart out to you, we had just fixed things between us, and I couldn’t have him getting between us again, so I... so I had to.”
Silence fell over the room as Joe and Beck stared at each other, neither moving as Joe realized what he must have sounded like.
“Y-You said you loved me,” Beck whispered. “Wa-Was any of it real?”
Joe’s panic and anger drained away as his expression became one of desperation. “Of course it was real.”
Beck shook her head immediately. “No. No, I don’t think you know what love actually is.”
Joe felt those words like a knife between his ribs. “Beck, please you don’t-”
“Just stop, stop talking!” Beck said, her voice trembling. You need to leave, I-I don’t want you here. Now get out before I call the cops.”
Joe had imagined this conversation going a thousand different ways over the past few days whenever his mind drifted toward worst-case scenarios, but he never thought that Beck looking at him like he was something rotten, something inhuman at the end of it.
“Beck…” Joe whispered weakly, stepping forward again. “Please you can’t do this.”
Seeing that he was not taking her threat seriously, Beck looked down at her phone and began to swipe through it with shaking fingers, her breath hitching unevenly between sobs.
Joe’s eyes widened. “Beck, wait-”
“No!” Beck cried, backing farther away from him. “You need to stay the fuck away from me!”
Joe ignored Beck and lunged forward, grabbing her hands and yanking them apart before she could finish dialing. Beck screamed, trying to wrench herself free as her phone slipped from her fingers and clattered across the hardwood floor.
“Joe, let go of me!” She cried, panic filling her voice.
“I can’t lose you,” Joe said desperately, tightening his grip without realizing how hard he was holding her. “Beck, please, you have to calm down and listen to me. You’re scared right now because Candace and Peach poisoned you against me-”
“You killed people!” Beck shrieked again, tears pouring down her face as she struggled against him. “You’re fucking insane!”
The word hit Joe like a slap and in that moment, Joe thought that Beck sounded just like Candace did before he killed her.
Joe’s grip faltered slightly. “No… no, Beck, I’m not insane. I did those things because I had to. because people kept trying to ruin what we had.”
“There is no ‘we,’ Joe!” Beck shouted. “Not if you had to hurt people to keep it!”
Joe shook his head. “That’s not true. You love me, I know you do and I know you can feel how much I love you too.”
“I was wrong!” Beck sobbed. “I was so fucking wrong about you!”
Seeing that Beck was not going to listen and that her screaming would eventually draw attention to them, Joe glanced behind Beck and toward her kitchen counter, spotting a heavy ceramic vase sitting beside the sink.
Joe did not hesitate and reached for it, wrapping his fingers around the vase’s narrow neck before Beck could fully process what he was doing.
“Joe-” The vase connected with the side of Beck’s head, a sickening crack echoing through the apartment as the vase shattered.
Beck cried out once before her body crumpled instantly, collapsing sideways onto the hardwood floor as ceramic shards skittering across the floor.
Joe fell to his knees and checked Beck’s pulse, letting out a relieved sigh as he felt her heartbeat fluttering beneath his fingertips, grateful that the woman was only unconscious.
Joe closed his eyes tightly, gripping the sides of his head for a moment before forcing himself to calm down.
No, I would never hurt you, Beck. I just... you wouldn’t listen to me, I had to. You’ll understand when you wake up and I can take you somewhere where we can properly talk to each other, when we’re both calm and relaxed. Joe cupped the side of Beck’s face, staring down at her longingly and lovingly.
Joe grabbed Beck’s phone, shoving it into his pocket before lifting Beck off the floor and throwing her body over his shoulder, carrying her out of her apartment.
Comments (2)
Damn you Paco, your trust in Joe is sadly misplaced, but I understand why he trusts him. Damn it Beck if I saw anyone breaking down my door I wouldn't keep talking with the manic and just call the police 🤦🏻♀️ Also why she gotta name drop Candace too, sheesh I know emotions were high but I would be running or fighting at this point. I'm guessing we are getting close to the finality of this story? Really eager how Rory will deal with all this or will she just be another victim of Joe? But seriously this chapter got me shaking my phone on how Paco and Beck are idiots lol. Paco is more excusable because he's a kid, but for Beck... yeah she was bound to get kidnapped 😭
I mean, I did say that the next few chapters were going to piss you off 😂 Paco loves Joe, and he pretty much completely trusts him, so he's not going to believe the word of a strange woman he doesn't know that broke into Joe's apartment. Joe is like the male figure in Paco's life, so he isn't going or want to believe anything bad about him. Beck has been going through a lot, so she's not thinking all that rationally right now. Although, I did worry that I was making her too much like the person to get killed in a horror movie with how I wrote her😭 And Rory is not going to want to touch this situation with a 10ft pole, her world is already crashing with what she already knows about Joe. But she's not going to have much of a choice.
