Personhood
May percieves
Comments (91)
Cute half-down Iris hair!
Hmm. Dale.
I don't know about anyone else but my confusion here goes all the way back to the idea of "companion AIs" that Jeph quietly phased out of the comic at least a decade ago. For humans many people catagorise bonds between adults in three categories - platonic, romantic and sexual. Any connection between two adult humans can anywhere from zero to max on any of these. At the beginning of the strip Jeph introduced another whole category for AIs - the whole idea of being a "companion". Even though that concept has almost completely gone away in QC I find it tricky to read this strip and understand if May means "platonic best friend", "romantic love interest" or "companion AI" feelings when she says "your Person".
I think it's any of the above situation. For Pintsize it was Marten; for Bubbles it's Faye. Zlata is fixated on Claire but suffers from a crush on Marten. May is bonded to Dale in gratitude and friendship but isn't at all romantically interested in him. Iris is... deeply in denial about the nature of her absolute devotion to Willow.
Dumbial ?
...River in Egypt, I think.
I guess May has a kind of samurai life debt to Dale :) which goes with their Swords theme.
Swordale?
iris’ operating system is OS-Iris, created somewhere on a river in Egypt. It was a sort of product-came-first-name-came-second thing.
Hell, if I were an AI company, I'd totally come up with the name first and then tell my engineers to make something to match it!
This is perfect.
This feels like a callback to the older companion AI idea, more nuanced maybe
Loving that the AIs can clearly bond to a Person platonically and/or romantically. Like any relationship, it can be complex and layered.
There's a strip I can't find (yet) where Momo II (not-tall-yet Momo) and Pintsize are talking about their humans, and how there are different ways to do the "job" of being a companion. Pintsize was there for Marten when he had no friends at all, and now he's not as closely involved with Marten's life. Momo and Marigold just have a different dynamic. (edit: it was https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2332)
one day, Iris and Willow are going to have the hottest sex and Iris will die from the irony. ~<3
"What a way to go!"
Called it
I think Everybody called it.
You know, now that you put it that way, it's weird to think that Pintsize considers Marten to be his person.
It doesn't have to be romantic or sexual. It could be best friend. Like Momo and Marigold. Or as May was about to admit, herself and Dale. Pintsize was just a horny little goblin before we knew what Goblins were.
What could go wrong
Someday Iris will learn that despite her belief that she is being completely stealth-mode vis-a-vis her feelings for Willow, there is literally not one single person who has seen them together who has not immediately sussed their dynamic. Except Willow. Probably.
There is no dynamic! She just forgets to hydrate! https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=4729
Iris Be Vulnerable With Any Sentient Entity Challenge: Difficulty Class Epic.
Hey, it takes a lot to admit when you are so clearly wrong.
Good job, Iris, you Great Living Avatar of Ignorance. Truly, you are no Simpering Idiot with romantic interest for Willow. https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=4762
Got to say, that has to be one of my favorite strips in all of QC, in part because of what Jeph does with Iris's face there, where she suddenly looks vulnerable and open for two panels, with just a few tiny changed lines. Then she goes back to her usual tense, sulky, and prickly expression and it's deeply sad.
So the question now is, is she iris' person, or is she iris' PERSON
Nah, just her Person. Can’t go completely overboard here.
Wonder if Momo still feels like Marigold is still her Person even though she’s moved most of the responsibilities of protecting her to May?
Most definitely. Momo would still worry and assist a lot with Marigold’s personal stuff, while May only handles the professional stuff.
It MAY be time to MAYBE let May step forward and MAYke a difference. (No, I am NOT drunk.)
Well, not yet.
They need to gently float down that river in Egypt.
I did that a few months before Covid dropped on all of us. It was heavenly. So, yes, they should do that in an old creaky dhow piloted by the oldest sentient AI ever while they drink fragrant mint tea and smile.
Goblin diplomatic summit.
It would need Liz peeking around a tree to be perfect.
Wow, May finally admitted Dale is her person. Took her long enough. Just to recap: He gave her a name and helped her get out of prison early. https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2495 https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2515 She gave him the push that led to his relationship with Marigold. https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2511 He gave her a place to stay when she was finally released. https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2713 And got her her first job when she couldn't get hired anywhere. https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=2730 She helped him through his and Marigold's first big fight. https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=3685 Yeah, they've been companion-ing the whole time, no matter how much May denied it.
As of this scene, May's arc has, for the moment at least, slid into my top three.
There isn't room for introspection in her level of loathing.
Iris is a master of loathetrospection.
See, when people say stuff like Iris says in panel 5, I assume they're fully aware of their own repression, and their protestations are fatalistic and/or ironic. Not sure that's the case here, even though it's hard to see how it couldn't be.
That's just the mid-epiphany confusion that naturally occurs when May busts through your wall of repressed feelings like the Kool-Aid man of unvarnished truth.
I've been reading the Dumbing of Age comments lately and I just want to say how appreciative I am the comments here are always chill and sane and not about getting in fights with internet strangers about the morality of cartoon teenagers
The reaction to the current DoA storyline is mind boggling to me. Like, does no one remember how absolutely stupid teenagers are? Of course they're going to make terrible decisions and be awful people.
You know, I always just assumed Iris was doing a bad job covering up her feelings. It never occurred to me that maybe she's not entirely aware of them.
O, she knows. Remember when Willow had her epiphany about people misinterpreting her openness as flirting, and Iris gave an epic soliloquy of self-deprecation?
Leave it to May to say what we were all thinking. I think Willow, as lovably dense as she can be, has even picked up on it. I’m hoping by the end of this arc, Iris finally admits her feelings for Willow. Though, maybe not. Willow gives off “ace” energy
I too have long suspected Willow is ace, although I generally avoid mentioning it lest I be torn asunder by hordes of enraged shippers. But being asexual wouldn't automatically mean she's aromantic, so it doesn't necessarily preclude her returning those feelings. She might have a "squish" on Iris, as the ace vernacular goes.
And the entire fandom just let out a collective “fucking finally, Iris.”
Lucky for Iris, May has enough experience with the justice system not to record her confession and play it back at an inopportune moment.
🎵She made her mark on Iris In the big Northampton world She's a softie and a sweetheart Lil Willow dumplin' girl 🎵
Gosh, that May. So grace. Much honest!
May has repeatedly shown a surprisingly astute understanding of relationship dynamics. Maybe Prolapse Monthly has a really great advice columnist, and we've all been missing out.
For an AI having a Person isn't necessarily like having someone you want to bone. It's more like a dog having a Person but without 20,000 years of breeding in the neotenic parent-child dynamic. Boning may or may not be involved. Which it shouldn't be between dogs and humans you sick bastards
Oh no, now I have to consider if dogs had managed to gain human level sentience, how would we have to deal with the embedding of human-child dynamic into our literal genomes when it came to the ability to consent... I feel like I've simultaneously discovered a whole new area of ethical studies AND a horrifying new porn category.
tsundAIre
TsundIris
Hmm. A personal enigma then. That’s kinda sweet.
Iris's creche was on a river in Egypt.
So was Moses's. (The prophet, not the cat.)
Denial... No longer just a river in Egypt.
Lil Dumplin' girl! Hahahahahahahahah!
"Who ordered the noodle and dumpling special?" is one of QC's five all time top lines
I'm not sure if May is saying she wishes to be in a polycule with Dale and Marigold or if she's implying that all AIs have AnthroPC tendencies.
I'd lean more towards column B because she's stated afew times she's not attracted to him like that
"I just wanna kiss her face and cuddle her and curl my entire body around her like a big gay snake, rattling my tail as a warning whenever someone else gets too close. I obviously don't even like her at ALL 😤"
no I'm not imagining lamiaform Iris, everyone shut up
I was unprepared for May's rockin' bod. Also it's probably impolite to compare AI's to dogs, but it did occur to me.
It's not impolite and is probably accurate without the parent - child thing most of the time
May, the way she feels about Willow is the same way you felt about Sven, not Dale. He’s already taken.
I mean, May can still feel that way about Dale. Him being monogamous with Marigold doesn't obviate longing on May's part.
has "your Person" been a thing we the audience heard of before or is this new AI lore?
It's new as far as I can recall. Of course, the authoritative answer will come from BookBeard.
The normal amount.
Oh boy... Iris... You in love.
Head over heels in love. And if there's one thing we know about Iris, it's that she doesn't know how to handle being head over heels. https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=4727
i feel like these are questions that should be asked when someone who might not want to answer is NOT holding a sword...
Totally looking forward to the epic two-week-long sword duel between May and Iris. We learn new and surprising things about their capabilities. I imagine it going just like the epic sword duel in The Princess Bride movie. :D
Having a person only counts as having a person if it's in the Person Region of the AI cortex. Otherwise it's just sparkling friendship.
I mean, a sword literally cannot kill May.
Both. Its both lol
Deffo.
Maybe she started life as an LLM.
That would imply she's prone to wild hallucinations and not actually sentient. Probably the most offensive thing you could say about an actual AI
Dale was her person as far back as the glasses and the sunrise.
His kindness redeemer her. I think she admitted this to, was it Bubbles?
Iris is reminding me way too much of myself when I was in lesbian denial lol
Many of us had our tsundere phases.
Iris suddenly with Emmett hair.
Honestly, I really dig Iris with her hair down, even if partially. But, wearing her hair down might obscure that permanent scowl lol
