Liz Submits
Esmerelda is cool
Comments (113)
Wait, Murderbot is an actual thing? I thought you were talking about a Crushbot movie!
Weirdly, I think Murderbot and Crushbot would get along. Crushbot's motivations are at least easy to interpret.
I've realized from the Rodrigo part of the discussion that my mental picture of Rodrigo and his adventures is heavily colored by imagining a taller, more handsome Dr. Stephen Maturin, the secret agent and Catalan revolutionary of the Patrick O'Brien books. Mind you, Stephen is not handsome, and looks like anything but a swashbuckling romantic hero, but he does some fully dramatic and swashbuckling things anyway, and would be quite capable of drawing a pirate queen's attention.
Maturin_did_ draw the attention of a pirate queen -- well, of a an adventuress, anyway. But perhaps you are thinking of the scene, (I've forgotten in which book this occurs) issuing from the imagination of an incidental character, involving a Rodrigo, a Sophonisba, and an iron maiden. And anyway, I can't see Dr. Maturin in the story. Quite involuntarily, my mind keeps seeing (and hearing) the animated Puss in Boots.
My main initial issue with the trailer is that it really looks like “a comedy”. The books were great because it was pretty straight SF - you just had murderbot’s dry sarcastic take as commentary on top of it. Which was funny, but a different kind of funny. No one else was in on the jokes for the most part, it was a drama aside from in murderbots head.
Murderbot's complete lack of interest in human sexual activities reminds me of that classic QC where the robots are having a group therapy session and one of them says "Why is it always about holes?"
I am here for the discussion of Murderbot casting.
I, too, am sad about the casting of Murderbot :( FFS, at least pick someone somewhat androgynous, not someone with an actual *chin dimple*! (that said, the last two paragraphs of this article (which is VERY spoilery, so be warned) give me a lot of hope that he’s actually done the homework and may do a good job of the portrayal) https://www.vanityfair.com/hollywood/story/murderbot-first-look. Actually, I’ll quote the last paragraph here in case anyone doesn’t want to click on the article: “That’s where the two characters part ways. “The big difference is, Eric reveled in being a troublemaker and stirred the pot—while Murderbot is the opposite. Murderbot definitely doesn’t want to step into the center of things. Murderbot wants to blend into the background and just be left alone to watch its TV shows.”)
I was pretty shocked by the Murderbot casting at first, since it clashed so hard with the image in my head. But after thinking about it for a bit, *of course* the corporations would make SecUnits look like generic bland stereotypical cishet soldiers. TV is a visual medium, and so the contrast between Murderbot's internal identity and external appearance can be a great way to explore the character. So I'm cautiously optimistic.
Cut to six months later, the wildly popular Sins of the Confessor tv series has launched the "Jimbo Cinematic Universe" with fourteen more adaptations in the works, plus plans for a crossover movie in which Rodrigo teams up with Lord Forsythyll, Lady Drusilla, Antoinette Banemoon and Sword-Princess Leinahephara to defeat Doctor Heteronormative and his army of time-travelling steampunk viking space pirate vampires. And then they all fuck, of course.
Absolutely here for it.
I hadn't heard about the Murderbot adaptation, and can I just say Alexander? Not just a cis dude, but out of ALL of the Skarsgård kids, him? Gustaf at least fits the dangerous vibes while Bill and Valter can pull off uncanny valley, but Alexander? He's just so... normal
The last role I saw Alexander in was as Randall Flagg in The Stand and it was pretty crap. Gustaf is always gonna be Floki in my head, but I agree he can absolutely do the dangerous vibe.
So does anyone know good romance books that are actually like Sins of the Confessor?
Can't vouch for too much similarity, but if you like slow-burn romantasy, T. Kingfisher's "Swordheart" and her "Paladin" series are great!
Umm... I don't, like, know about the rest of you but I'm kinda hype to set eyes on this Rodrigo.
I'm certain it's going to be Tai's dad, as written through Jimbo's perspective XD Headcanon cemented
Claire has called Marten "Rodrigo" in bed at least once. We just don't know if she asked him to call her Juanita or Esmerelda :)
Both. Both is good.
I am learning so many fascinating things about the different ways people imagined Murderbot in this thread.
And NOW I have to buy the Murderbot DIaries series. If ONLY to find out why Rodrigo should have run off with Esmerelda.
I ship Juanita and Esmeralda the pirate queen
Best ship
I was just weirded out by that. Murderbot is obviously femme. At least to me. Dunno about actual gender, but it literally never occurred to me to picture them as anything but. Sigh.
I read that & thought Murderbot was just some throwaway character here I forgot, along the lines of Crushbot 😭
Same here ngl
Oh, I _am_ salty about Murderbot being played by a cis dude! He’s a good actor but so not what I pictured when reading the books. But I have a whole lot of misgivings about them adapting it for TV.
RODRIGO LORE!!
They‘re making a murderbot show‽ nice! But yeah, a cis dude is not who should be playing murderbot
Alexander Skarsgård is playing Murderbot. It's not the worst casting they could have made, at least.
While I like the actor, I was hugely disappointed he was taped for Murderbot. Wells has been approving so I’m hopeful it’s played as nonbinary, but it would have been great to have a nonbinary actor.
The role of Rodrigo *might* be miscast, but in their defense he cannot just be "cast". Rodrigo simply... Is.
I love how wildly thirsty we are all getting with nothing more than a few names and a handful of sentences about a potential story. No, that was not me complaining, I am TOTALLY here for it.
Someone (not me) oughta set up the Rodrigoverse wiki, so we can all start sending in submissions. :D rodriverse? sinnerverse? confessorverse?
Agree entirely on the miscasting of murderbot - they read as femme in the books, I'm sure of it.
They present as female in a disguise in one book.
Liz is a sub?
Who enjoys wearing mitts. Makes it difficult to fire torpedoes.
Wait, this is how I'm finding out Muderbot is being made into a show?!
Same omg
Is there fanfic for Sins of the Confessor yet?
So when is Jeph gonna publish these books? Prime wants the rights.
Liz, how _dare_ you oppose Juanita! We of the Rodrita (or sometimes called "Juanrigo") camp know the One True Ship!
Sounds like if he had run off with Esmerelda we could have had ships on ships (while raiding shipping?)
3/4 of the fandom is Salty about murderbot. The other 1/4 is half people that think murderbot should be healed via finding love/sex, and half people that already referred to it as him and watch the point fly over their heads
Murderbot: "I was created without any reproductive organs. I just want to binge watch thousands of hours of telenovela drama." 15% fanbase: "Oh we love Murderbot HE is so tough and murderous and kewl!!"
I always read Murderbot as a butchy femme, myself.
My conception of Murderbot is an agender version of Henry Rollins. The voice just reminds me so much of Rollins.
We need art. Rodrigo, Esmerelda, Juanita, give us a cast pic!
At this rate, if Jimbo has _not_ signed the contract with the production company, we're gonna have to start on the damn thing ourselves!
I’m sorry WHAT ABOUT MURDERBOT????
In the Apple TV+ show tha comes out next month, it's being played by Alexander Skarsgard.
I see a young Kevin Klein as Rodrigo.
"Don't call me stupid."
Everybody out here going on and on about the Rodrigo/Juanita/Esmerelda love triangle. I'm just happy that Pablo and Antonio finally resolved their "will they/won't they" arc.
Everyone knows that the best solution to a love triangle is a trio!
Moray, my sister, aren't you happy? I read some romance, and boy was it trashy. Rodrigo gonna be in your life forever, We'll have a book club and read it together!
Ok. I NEED this book to exist!
It's been a long time since Alice Grove. Could this be the next side project? Nah. It's already a masterpiece in all our imaginations.
I always kinda read Murderbot with Charlize Theron as the title character, partly because the first book came out around the same time as the movie Atomic Blonde
Fuck. Conflicting headcanon options!!
Right! I don’t get the Skarsgard casting. I always got more of a Asia Kate Dillon vibe from Murderbot.
I don’t who is the actor but the person who plays the table representative in the John Wick movies and that autistic assistant in the Billions tv series probably would make a great Murderbot.
You're just gonna keep blue balling is on Claire, huh?
The Raksura books would be much better cinema. Murderbot is visually boring. And most of the action takes place inside Murderbot's head. Unless they are SERIOUSLY departing from the book it will not be great
I'm confused by this statement. Literally every single novella and novel has multiple large action set pieces.
Jeph. Jeph. You must write SINS OF THE CONFESSOR. You must. The world needs it.
While I would pay good money to read that, I don’t think Jeph could find the time. I’m no artist but, I can’t imagine producing these panels is a quick task.
I need this book to exist so bad lol
As I read Marten's line in the last panel, and before I saw Jeph's text at the bottom, I thought "is this a reference to the Murderbot casting?" I also think it's not great, but some of the other actors will be cool to see, and I'm holding out hope that the series will be good. Really the toughest part to adapt will be the main character's internal monologue (hopefully they won't just fill the show with voiceover...)
I hope Jimbo doesn't go full alcoholic when he sees what they did to his creation.
Jimbo is probably has the wealth of the makers of that expensive whiskey that glows when Faye saw it.
When a girl made of ooze Assigns smut book reviews That's A Moray!
👏 👏 👏
PS Is "Liz submits" a double wordplay?
I wondered that myself.
So that would explain why sci-fi sky is tearing a new hole into 🍎 +
Also, the way everyone greeted Adobe trying to have a presence on Bluesky was also delightful to the point that Adobe retreated back to X.
Yeah...Murderbot what?!
The Murderbot Diaries by Martha Wells. Great series of novellas and a couple of novels. Worth the read.
Tai is busy being married. Is Liz the editor Marigold desperately needs?
Liz is far too busy with Science!
I'm with you, but it's Murderbot and the author is excited about the show and it'll have actual filmed sequence of Sanctuary Moon, so I'm clinging to hope they'll pull it off.
If Martha Wells is excited I am excited.
I'm with you on Murderbot, but they probably reckon that if they put an androgene other than Swinton there would be backlash from some neanderthal or another.
You know the primitives. They'll howl even were Tilda to be cast. 'Cause "woman".
At first I thought "I could see him playing Murderbot", but then I started thinking of Murderbot as "him", so now I'm also quite sad about a cis dude being cast. Also, stupid brain.
Is It Jared Leto? Please don’t be Jared Leto
Thankfully not. Claire just believes that selecting anyone but Pedro Pascal to be Rodrigo is criminal.
Is this going to be on Apple+ or Amazon? Because I don’t have either.
Apple+
Murderbot?
It's a book series about a security cyborg that, among other things, becomes more in touch with its "humanity" after being freed from corpo enslavement. The property was recently picked up by Apple+ to be made a series, but the titular character has been cast with Alexander Skarsgard, despite the character itself being canonically a genderless construct (not even having sexual parts and having actually suggested it finds the entire topic of gender and sex uninteresting and kinda gross.)
Rodrigo is life. Do not question Rodrigo. Also I just started reading the Murderbot Diaries, but will not watch the show because it is on Apple TV.
I need this whole comment thread to be about murderbot now
Murderbot Murderbot. Murderbot Murderbot Murderbot! Murderbot ? Murderbot: Murderbot.
Me too, Jeph ;_;
Of course the librarian knows about "The Book"
Exactly!
Who has an accidentally emailed the wrong thing to the wrong person?
Oh gods that Michael posted again...such an antithesis of Murderbot!
With regards to Murderbot I am in the same boat. It could still be good but already the vibe's off.
idk, maybe this show is how we find out that Alexander Skårsgard is agender?
Good looking, so refined Say, wouldn't you like to know What's goin' on in my mind? So let me get right to the point: I don't pop my cork for any man I see Hey, agender: Spend a little time with me
Should I be salty about Murderbot's casting?
You can if you like! It's free :D
The Pirate Queen steals the hearts of all would be Romeo(s)
Dammit, this is how I find out Murderbot news - how could they do Martha Wells' story so dirty?
SAME, LIKE HOLD THE PHONE WHAT? could they really not find a nonbinary actor put there 😭
wait they cast murderbot as a cis dude?? WAIT THEY'RE MAKING A MURDERBOT--
Exactly! Now I have yet another thing to be upset about, regarding a cis het white rich guy who has taken the place of many other more appropriate candidates for the job.
marten has read it...?
Well, he has worked in a library for several years, he is currently living with The Librarian, I bet one is bound to end up reading something like that even if it is not your number one preference anyway. How else will you be able to recommend it to secretly horny moms?
