Glorified SNES Cartridge
The underground robot fighting ring! God, talk about a story that went some unexpected places. Corpse Witch turned out to be an ACTUAL VILLAIN! Bubbles turned out to be more than a one-note gag character! Yay shows up and does Yay things for the first time! Sometimes you have one small idea (Faye needs a new job) and it ends up completely altering the course of the story. Writing serialized fiction is weird.
For a long time I had sort of shied away from the robot stuff in the strip- I was more interested in the mundane day-to-day lives of the human cast. I think this arc might mark the point where I realized I was having a lot of fun exploring the sci-fi aspects of the comic, and made a conscious choice to spend more time exploring it.
As I write this, I’m still trying to decide on whether to do a big time-skip and jump straight into Cubetown stuff when I get back from this break. The comic’s pacing is so slow and detail-oriented that it can be tough to get actual time to pass. The idea of jumping ahead and seeing where people have ended up in the intervening time has a lot of appeal, creatively speaking. But watching Marten and Claire establish themselves up there would also be fun. WE’LL SEE I GUESS
Also I think I accidentally updated too many times this week? Whatever WE'LL FIGURE IT OUT
Comments (118)
do the time jump and fill in the blank later to challenge yourself
this is still one of my favorite story arcs in the entire comic.
I am REALLY loving this director's commentary, and as someone who writes novels, I completely get you about the "this was supposed to be a gag and now I've got a whole 'nother book to write after this one" turn into left field 😂
Like all good SF, the AI stuff is really all about people ;-)
These are so much fun to read, I hope you are having as much fun writing this commentary!
I am a fan of a good training arc myself. Love the idea of seeing how people turn into Batman or Goku more than what they do when they get there with no context. Also curious if yay may end up being involved at cube town and how that fumbles forward
I love the idea of like multiple time skips. We see them with boxes packing up. saying goodbye and crying. we see them in some sort of unpacked disarray while some silly crisis or diversion comes up. We see them totally unpacked. We see Hanners coming up for a long visit. That sort of thing. Enjoy your break! we will be here when you get back
Jeph, the point of this much deserved break is to relax and retrospect. If you end up enjoying retrospecting and do extra, I’m certainly not complaining. Rest and heal dude.
You could time skip and then do flashbacks…
This eactly.
I vote for a time skip. Lets jump ahead to the next major plot point. We knew those changes were going to happen, nothing is coming out of left field. Let's see what is going on now
Yeah there was definitely an extra post on the weekend. If you come up short at the end just post some pictures of Ollie!
Anything you do will be fine. You are batting 300 as far as I'm concerned. Let your muse guide you.
FWIW I like the idea of a time skip. I love the length and depth of your comic (hey-oh) but a time skip also gives you the opportunity to do a bit of a reboot. It can make it easier for new readers to digest when this incarnation of the comic is just different enough with just enough character re-introduction that new readers don't feel like they need to start from zero to know what's going on. As a reader who's read every comic - I feel like at this point in the comic you've packaged up every storyline and character arc pretty well, to the point where I was a little worried you were about to wrap the whole thing. It's a perfect time to go fresh because nothing will feel like it's super left hanging.
Aw, i freaking loved this storyline! Personally, you could do a joke about how how fast things can move. 6 panels of moving followed by oof ouch my back bones
You know, Jeff, it is precisely storylines like this that made me SO FREAKING EXCITED in my Master's program. I have an MA in English lit, and focused on how to define humanity and identity in fictional settings with androids/human-like AI. Seriously, if I'd gone on to a PhD, I'd have been using a HECKUVA lot of QC for my dissertation, because I loved the way you built your universe. (I compared/contrasted "Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?" and the "Battlestar Galactica" reboot of the early 2000s. So much fun. Also, bizarrely similar.)
I look forward to seeing how the Marten Roast Company shapes up. it wont be a clone of CoD, thats for sure. Quite a different clientele, and a lot of his business decisions offstage will be different from what Dora has to navigate. hmmm…
Faye crossing her arms under her breasts is sexy.
Grrrr... Corpse Witch. There may have been other things too.
Time jump with flashbacks? Best of both worlds?
MORE BUBBLES if you do USA, more MORAY if Cubetown. I enjoy the human/AI interactions. timeskip, just not too HUGE a timeskip.
Also we want to know that Millefeuille and Brun are happy! :) a brief snapshot of their cosy domesticity will keep us going :)
The jump ahead seems like a good idea, but I really want to see how things start out at cubetown! Either way, I love how the sci-fi has been woven into the comic, especially with the AI and human relationships (romantic and otherwise) Cant wait for more!
This arc was 9 years ago? Please, I am but dust.
Is there any way to put a link in these, so those of us who didn't read it originally (gasp) can jump to that story arc and read?
For now, putting the strip number into the URL will get you there: https://questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=3008
QC before this arc: often horny, sometimes mentions robots. QC after this arc: horny robots 24/7/365.24 :) and we like it that way.
So perfection is having three tit's and your own helicopter,....
I don't think Yay... has boobs (this may have been your point, but just in case it wasn't)
What if you did flashbacks later? Follow your excitement for the time skip, and show us later what went down in the intervening time
I had an immediate reaction of disgust when the image loaded & I saw Corpse Witch (kudos to Jeph). Man, she almost seems on the up-and-up here, as much as she could in that setting. Also, you're updating more than I expected & I'm really enjoying your BTS thoughts & context! Also I'm down w/ time-skips; the first was a little jarring but I can see the appeal as a creator & agree as a reader. SKIP AWAY, OR DON'T
I think it's the mark of a good (rounded) villain that she isn't *wrong* here, it's just.... all the other deeply shitty behaviour and exploitation and oh yeah, indentured servitude via blackmail
Part of me is prepared for the comic to pick up in January and Marten and Claire have gotten married off-panel.
Or Jeph trolls us by making it look like they got married, then zooms out and reveals they are actually at the wedding of Fairy Girl and Floating Black Slab Emitting A Low Hum.
I'm amused at the idea of having a timeskip, but writing a few selected comics in the gap... so that next time you take a break you can do another flashback set like this one, but with the gap comics as if they're selected out of an actual sequence that we all missed :-) (For proper trolling the timeskip would also need a comic-number skip...)
*stern voice* Jeph? Are you sure you're ACTUALLY taking a break?
Other commenters have said that Jeph did all of these commentaries before starting his vacation, and he's actually taking time off. I didn't see him say that, but the commenters here (except for me) are pretty smart.
Take a break from creative project; spend all your time thinking about creative project. Yeah, I feel that. It's the circle of life~
But this time, it's not because you HAVE to! (At least, I hope that's the case <3)
I know I wouldn't object to a time jump with flashbacks where appropriate.
Hmm, if you're a little frustrated with how slowly time passes, would you maybe consider hiring another illustrator so we could have 7–10 QCs a week? You'd still control the story and the style, would just take some of the drawing time off your plate. You could swap off illustrating each mini-arc, or potentially sometimes even do an A strip and a B strip running in parallel, for what different characters are up to at the same time, with some intersections. It'd be a change, but would also help you stress less about taking time off, because there'd be someone else to take up some workload.
I don't think Jeph needs to offload drawing work (unless he really wants to take more of a break), it's the necessary reality of a daily comic where a particular interaction represents at most 5 minutes
”I don’t have three tits and my own helicopter, so no.” With an “everything is awful” shirt. Brilliant.
"I don't have three tits" is a combination of words that I had to reread more than once to make sure I was seeing it right. XD
I had completely forgotten about this part of the arc! Might be due for a reread soon
Get them back, we hear her plans and then have a time skip. But doesn’t need to be a big one atall. Things would surely just get done under her control so maybe a week or two?
What about calling the move to Cubetown (well, departure from Northampton - no arrival) the end of "QC 1.0"? If we were to think of Alice as "QC 3.0", then what happened in between? Given Cubetown's Director, Station and Yay, there's lots fodder for anchoring a huge time leap, beyond the lifetimes of the QC 1.0 humans, relying on the AIs for continuity. In the hobby writing I've done, I've had stories I intentionally killed off just because the step-by-step pace got to me, and I saw no faster path to the end I envisioned. The story was made of good parts, but the parts were too small and detailed, clicking together like Legos. Killing them off was a mercy to myself, becoming creative fertilizer for the next story. But one such story (a novel-length ST:TNG kidnap-mystery fanfic) reasserted itself in my dreams, the protagonist I had killed off somehow managing to be resurrected, living a life totally unlike, but intimately connected to, the prior story. It's like the character was saying to me, "I'm not dead, you know", then leaving it to me to figure out how the hell that could have happened, then write a story (another novel) to make it so. Needless to say, I didn't kill that character off again. No way. I'd already made that mistake once! Instead, I sent him off on a journey of self-discovery and growth, leaving us behind. Fortunately, he hasn't returned or checked in yet. There are many ways to skin this cat, then cook this goose. QC 1.0 has been a truly fun and wild ride. QC 2.0 will do the same, but in its own unique way.
So, are we ever getting the Punchbot of Theseus?
Maybe both? Interleave two time skips that focus on different portions of the cast during the week?
Like interleaved establishment montages, sort of? I agree that sounds like a great compromise. [nod]
It could be funny to jump ahead and then have a Black Widow/Hawkeye gag about something that happened that's never seen... :-P
I think one interesting possible approach to the time skip is to show a few big changes in the interim, not fleshed out, as a montage. Like "here's a picture of Claire and marten saying goodbye to their friends but one, who's going with them! *gasp* *shock* *intrigue*" yeah, that writing's terrible, but I'm not a writer. or comic artist. if you ended up going that way, I'm sure you could write a better caption ...by dropping a typewriter onto an iPad... anyway yeah, basically like 3-6 full page single panel strips showing things we already know are going to happen, each (optionally) with a tease of some detail (vague enough that it doesn't act as a constraint on future writing). Honestly, I just don't want to miss Claire and Marten actually *leaving*, that's kind of it, lol
to be clear, in that example, it's the "who is going with them?" that's the easily changeable detail. with a cast of characters numbering in the... I'm going with nondecillions? that sounds right... surely SOMEONE is going to decide to move with them, or at least that's the kind of "teased information, but not so impactful that it will cause issues" idea I mean.
I mean, we could jump to a week into the move... see them still settling in and dealing with the Gremlin and the Slime... :D
The comment about the participants in the fighting ring having fewer legitimate options is an interesting point, one which was later reiterated by May. Hopefully Punchbot's new legal fighting ring is filling the same need. Perhaps we could revisit him along with Seven and Jeremy at some point to see how that is going. Not a full story arc or anything, just a check-in. https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=3089
I would love an update on the denizens of the fighting ring!
Wow was there some irony in what Corpse Witch explains here. Was that intended subtext? Hey, what if you timeskipped Marten and Claire into Cubetown, but scenes in Northhampton plod along in the past until they meet up again and Dora has a glaring Eye Patch of Character Development and the audience realizes there was some time left unexplored? That’d be fun, but honestly I’d love to see more Dora and Hannelore and Emily and Aurelia and Roko. If Claire has to sit on the backburner because watching her be nervous packing for an extended time isn’t really a ‘character arc,’ while Marten sits idle because Marten, so be it.
I think from the context of the commentary, this may actually be from *before* Bubbles' encryption backstory was determined?
I really like the behind the scenes stuff, you should do this more often!
THERE'S ALWAYS FLASHBACKS lol
The robots (and the queer-friendliness) were what drew me to the strip — but I started from the beginning and spent a very long time going, this is mostly indie rock jokes with one robot who doesn’t do much? Faye’s backstory reveal was where the story took off for me, the space station arc was where I started telling other people to read it, and the Bubbles and Faye story which starts here remains my all-time favourite. (I mean I guess it starts with Faye drinking herself out of a job, but whatever).
Personally, I recommend a very small time skip. I don't think we need to see the trip back to Cubetown. But I think we would like to see them moving in at Cubetown and getting set up. It may be more appropriate to do a time skip after they've gotten settled there a bit.
I think that sounds like a good compromise (especially since apparently we haven't even skipped ahead one day since the wedding, so far)
Time Jump: if you did it, folks would accuse you of copying Willis.
I'm pretty neutral to a time skip overall, I just want to see em crying as they depart. I will not keep it together.
"For a long time I had sort of shied away from the robot stuff in the strip..." Aw, because the robot stuff in the strip is my favorite stuff!
Didn't we just have a time skip for the wedding? Not saying you can't do another one. Hell, there can be a time skip between every arc, no matter how minor. Your story, your rules! I hadn't realized it at the time, but I agree with the assessment that this was definitely a turning point where the AIs became more prominent in the comic. It's not that we didn't have them and that they weren't fully realized characters before, but they had always taken side billing to the humans. This arc (and Bubbles in particular) really started to explore them in the context of the world.
I saw Corps Witch on your patron and thought "She's BACK?!?!" before I realized it was an old strip. Scared me half to death.
But wouldn't it be something if this turned out to be a continuation of the Yay arc (I don't think it's likely, she's definitely been dealt with, but if she re-emerged Yay would definitely NEED to finish her off)
I feel a time skip would be great! You’ve been very judicious with them so I trust you using them. I’ll read either way of course !
I am not going to complain about you posting too many times this week. But I think you deserve it. Do you know how many times have gone back to look at a comic… and then I hit next to see the next one…. And then 3 hours later I am caught the whole may back to now and I am like damn it. Where did my afternoon go.
I vote no time jump BUT am cool with either choice since you've earned my trust.
Where would the third one even go? You could be so unbalanced... The helicopter I can see though.
Middle, I assume.
I definitely want to see the Cubetown adjustment process, especially continuing Marten’s “what am I going to do” phase. That’s my vote. But I also want to vote for “enjoy your break, Jeph!”
There's always flashbacks and montages to cover events passed over.
I'm immensely enjoying these commentary bits, as it's fun to see how far we've come. 💜
Wonder what ever happened to Corpse witch? Dissembly? Memory wipe?
Most likely Robot Jail.
I am very interested in Cubetown however you get there. But please do get there.
Is this going to be a 3D2Y situation?
I genuinely want to see Marten and Claire establish themselves at Cubetown.
TIME. SKIP. TIME. SKIP. TIME. SKIP. [pounding on table] TIME! SKIP! TIME! SKIP! TIME! SKIP!
*shouting from the back of the crowd* ᴡɪᴛʜ ᴛʜᴇ ᴏᴄᴄᴀꜱɪᴏɴᴀʟ ꜰʟᴀꜱʜʙᴀᴄᴋ ᴛʜʀᴏᴡɴ ɪɴ ᴛᴏ ᴘʀᴏᴠɪᴅᴇ ᴀᴅᴅɪᴛɪᴏɴᴀʟ ᴄᴏɴᴛᴇᴇᴇᴇᴇxᴛ
God this was another fantastic arc
Roko and I still have Yay shaped holes in our hearts. Or maybe heads. Just sayin'.
I'm just wondering why Faye would want a third tit. She's got some pretty big tits and a third one is just asking for more back pain and expensive, custom, 3-tit bras.
I never understood the appeal of that particular desire. but a helicopter sounds fun!
...and a very fine villain she turned out to be. So fun to hissssss!
One thing I always liked was when comic compilations are released with author commentary. Great way to pass some lower stress time with your audience!
If I had to vote, it would be against a time skip. It would be more interesting to see Marten and Claire adjust to cubetown life, as well as Faye, Hannerlore and the others adjust to life without them. Besides we have had 2 time skips recently. Before Claire’s interview and the wedding. I think it would b better without one.
I am also loving all these details, but please be spending the vast, vast majority of your break time, actually having A Break!
Just my two cents: my only problem with a post-break time skip is Rokko being left in the dark regarding Yay’s status for that long. Well.. that’s not my *only* problem, but it’s the only one I see being an actual issue. I don’t think Jeph would come back and be like “oh, by the way, Willow and Ayo hooked up, Marten and Claire broke up, Faye and Bubbles adopted three kids, and Pintsize is now human. And you don’t get to hear how any of that happened.”
I think the biggest surprise he has given us via time skip is when Marigold bought a house and Momo got her third chassis. But the house thing had already been discussed, the only real surprise was Momo, who has barely been mentioned since. It would be odd for characters to suddenly be settled into a new job.
I believe in you Jeph!
Has anybody made a kind of index that list which strip? That would be a good way to read up on character /story arcs
Sounds like a great assignment for a future intern for Jeph! (One who could, ideally, also manage to hold down the fort in order for him to take more well-earned future breaks)
Just how much time *has* passed?
5 minutes!
I really hope Jeph has all these lined up to auto-post and he doesn't have to log in every day! Enjoy that time off sir!
I love this arc! I was coincidentally re-reading a portion of it (leading up to the introduction of Officer Basilisk). There were a LOT of serious world altering developments in this time!
Yeah, it's a great period (but I think that about a lot of QC xD)
The thought of Faye with a) 3 breasts or b) her own helicopter (or both) is simultaneously oddly arousing and mildly terrifying…
How are we all feeling about having three tits as the mark of a perfect world? I feel like four would be better than three. Two rows of two.
like MommyMilkers!!
Do what feels right for you, but I have to say personally I hope you don't do a time skip
I dig these but I hope they're queued and you're out drinking a mai tai or something my guy
I love reading these details, keep them coming! I'm excited to read whatever you do, it's been a fun ride so far. A time jump might be cool. whatever you do, I'm all for it. As long as it's continuing the comic.
I have to agree with Faye. I don't have three tits and my own helicopter either.
As a writer, I can really see the benefit of choosing somewhere sort of in between. Say it's a month into life at cube Town or maybe even a year or two. And you do flashbacks as necessary. But giving it a chance of established but not still allows for a lot of shenanigans and hijinks! And obviously take this with an ocean's worth of salt because it is your work and I have been following you since damn near the beginning and I will continue right up until The end.
Id love some initial "settling down" strips before time skips!! Establish a little more of the cubetown world.
Updating too many times in a week? You sure do have funny ideas of what it means to take a break.
No such thing as too many updates
Hush! (please) Of course we’re all needy fiends here, but our QC’s beloved creator’s DECADES of uninterrupted effort demands some time off, at long last!
I love the idea of a time jump but don't leave poor roko alone and talking to empty air for too long
Loving these insights
Jump ahead with random flashbacks! Best of both worlds
Jump around randomly in time! And write commentary on each strip! Oh, wait.
