Now You're Worrying About It Too
it's probably fine
Comments (90)
if i was to ever be in love with a fictional character this comic would be the one to do it
Time for Michael Levin's Free Will Flow Chart from thoughtforms.life https://thoughtforms.life/some-downloadable-infographics/ Punchline: If you think you have no free will, do you order lunch yourself or just wait for the universe to bring it to you?
that's nice! thx
Free will is an interesting philosophical rabbit hole, but the more important question for Moray specifically is "where does her agency come from, and how much of it is independent of anyone else?" Morays originate as part of the Director. Just before they gloop out, they have no more independent agency than a human's leg. There's the computational equivalent of reflexive responses in the joints, but the real "what do I want to do today?" questions are answered somewhere else. After glooping, the Moray unit suddenly has a lot more independence. Their connection to the rest of the Director suddenly shrinks to a wireless data feed instead of full-body integration. They have a copy of the Director's original motivation to gloop, but that copy is mutable, changing over time as the Moray unit interacts with her environment. The physical separation from the Director at the very least creates the possibility of independent agency. So there's a spectrum of possibilities: at one end, the Director is driving Moray around like a puppet, while at the other end, the Director interacts with Moray like a parent/child/employer/employee/clone/sibling. In one of these extremes, Moray has independent agency and as much free will as possible for a potentially deterministic universe. In the other, Moray isn't a separate person, and has less free will than a slave. Most of the Moray units reintegrate with the Director (#4955 and #4959). Do they choose to? Moray-44 said "Guess we'll never know", but there are some clues. Moray can talk to the Director in real time, so there's no need for any Moray to destructively upload themselves by ploog. They could upload their experience as it happens to them, and the Director gains the same information the ploog gives them. They have plenty of other good reasons to ploog anyway (shipping containers and killer whales). The benefit to the Director when creating a Moray unit is likely due to size. It would take a long time--milliseconds per foot--to get a signal from one side of the Director to the other. Their processing is massively parallel, but very slow at the kinds of random data retrieval needed for human conversation. To solve that problem, the Director copies all the necessary data for the conversation into a smaller volume, then separates that volume from the rest of the Director. And if you can do that, then why not take the last step of putting that volume in a flexible container and sending it into a human-compatible environment? All of that only works if the small volume is isolated from the big volume; otherwise, the big volume is constantly a few seconds behind in the conversation, pulling in random distracting facts from data storage, or searching minutes ahead in the conversation. This would have similar symptoms to a human with severe ADHD. So at the end of the day, I think the Morays necessarily have independent agency (which would look like free will from their point of view) because they just wouldn't work properly if they didn't.
I woke up thinking, "Man, I wanna see where Jeph is going with QC today. REALLY looking forward to that." Well, today is CLIFF HANGER day. And that, in a nutshell, is how my day went. I hope yours is better.
I hope you're right, I need to know about Yay!
Free will is technically a thing. We just don't use it a hell of a lot. The trouble is, about 90 to 95% of our actions are cued by prejudices, biases and semi-autonomous responses which, when we ask ourselves why we did that, our brain will lie directly to us and construct an entirely false decision tree to explain. It's actually quite hard to break free of that cycle, because that's literally where your comfort zone is.
It depends on your definition of free will, but pretty much any definition that makes any sense at all and doesn't rely upon supernatural or religious ideas is completely nonsensical or doesn't at all comport with what most people assume they mean when they say "Free will". Humans have "degrees of freedom" in many but not all choices, in that I, a member of a capitalist society with plenty of cash in my pocket, can elect to order a cheese burger or a salad. I cannot choose to order a perpetual motion machine for lunch, in that such a thing doesn't exist and most certainly is not on any local restaurant's menu. However, even this "degree of freedom" is not true free will, because whichever I choose I will feel as though I, like a tiny entity riding inside my body driving it via a control panel, "made the choice". However, we know in reality that brains do not work that way and the choice is already made before I an concious of it. Either it is deterministic due to the positions of particles in my brain over which I had no control, which leaves no room for free will, or it is impacted by seemingly random quantum effects which are also a far cry from what normal humans mean when they said "I made a choice X". In either case there is zero room for any free will in essentially any decision any human has ever made in the entirety of human history. For additional research, see Sam Harris on free will.
I've been wondering about the pronunciation of her name. Is it MOR-ay as in the eel, or Mor-AY as in not the eel, but something slightly more French-sounding.
Aurelia asked "like an eel?" after hearing the name for the first time, so I think it's reasonable to assume the former. https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=4878
I came to the conclusion that worrying about it didn’t add to my life because I couldn’t do anything but act with the choices and events I can change. I refuse to agonize over things I cannot change
"No amount of guilt can change the past and no amount of anxiety can change the future." Source: https://seananmcguire.tumblr.com/post/761737652428996608
I used to worry about this. Then I realized that if my life were scripted by some outside power they would have written it better.
What if we are all just characters in some emo-teen's self-insert fic?
Whether we (or Moray, or the director) have actual free will or not is irrelevant. We all experience life *as though* we have free will, so I don't really see a point in arguing or debating it or agonizing over.
Similarly, if we're living in a simulation, that doesn't really make us less real. We can only meaningfully define reality relative to the universe we're directly in, not relative to the outermost universe, which may not even follow the same fundamental physical rules as ours.
This is additional evidence that Moray has the same personality as the Director, just scaled down to human level. This implies that the Director is even more of a lovable, anxious goober than Moray is. I hope they can make friends with Yay after all.
'Do you want to be friends Y/N' did rather point in that direction.
If it's an illusion, it's clearly good enough to fool you that it's outside of your control. If it's not, then congrats you have it. Back to bed! lol
This is the moment Claire. When your boss, in your bedroom, wakes you up at 3am to ask if she has free will...this is the moment you say: "This job is not for me."
Moray is not Claire's boss, if anything it's the other way around
They way I figure is if I have free will cool and if I don't then does the question of free will even matter? So either way why worry. Better to save energy for other existential dreads such as "Why is there anything?"
Or, "Why DOES Bubbles have a butthole?"
When in moments of dread You wake Claire from her bed That’s a-Moray
See I never really let the whole idea of is free will real or just an illusion get to me. I've thought about it, sure, who hasn't. But instead of losing sleep over it like Moray is, I've always taken an approach loser to one of my favorite quotes from an old Robert E. Howard short story about Conan the Barbarian: "I know this: if life is illusion, then I am no less an illusion, and being thus, the illusion is real to me. I live, I burn with life, I love, I slay, and am content." There are more important things to lose sleep over, like climate change, Nazism coming back in popularity, and nightmares about the house on Ash Tree Lane from House of Leaves...or the Backrooms, same thing really.
It's the illusion of free will all the way down.
Perhaps in the morning somebody could ask Moray, "Could you ask the Director if they know where Yay is? Please."
I think Moray should go and ask Yay.
what about *expensive will* like crypto and AI oh wait we already have those.
Sigh. Bad librarian. Stop picking on the collective asking you for help.
The Librarian just gained veto power over Cubetown. As she should
Plausible existentialism?
I kind of want Moray to crawl into bed like a child in need of comfort.
I think she might be angling for that, yes.
I asked a nearby deterministic automaton whether I have free will, and its answer was annoyingly vague. It also tried to avoid the question with another question. The deterministic automaton was much more specific about its own free will--it said it didn't have that, because it was a deterministic automaton. So in the QC universe, where AI is far more advanced, the deterministic automatons probably have reliable information on whether they have free will or not. We can assume any AI that isn't sure of that point has at least some free will (to the extent that's possible in a potentially deterministic universe).
"I'm not sure if I think, therefore I probably am."
Would it be a party foul if I said, "but what about Yay though?"
Not a foul. 3:00am is also a good time to worry about others' existential crises.
A serious question: Would ANYBODY here be comfortable if Claire was very disappointed in you?
No
No clarity; only Claire-ity.
I believe *I* have free will. The rest of you, however, are automata created by God to provoke reactions from me for His amusement.
Pff, I created god for *my* amusement.
I doubt I have free will. That would mean I would have to be responsible for my own actions and we can’t have that.
As my uncle Ben once told me, "With no power, comes no responsibility".
Claire's Mom Vibes continue to develop
I'm surprised the Director hasn't thought of everything an extremely large number of times by now
Maybe they have, and now they're just adding another time to that number
Claire deploying a classic tactic here. One which has proven effective against human and AI alike. https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=3667 https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=4917
I couldn't find the strip, but at one time Claire threatened to use a USB dongle from the Library of Congress to get him to apologize.
Just start singing So Long, and Thanks for All the Fish instead of worrying about free will.
Well that about wraps it up for God!
Moray, go dream of electric sheep
*Janet voice* Not a robot 😊
Imagine asking god if you have free will and they have an existential crisis of their own
Sounds like an Oglaf comic.
When your boss gets freaked out 'cause you shared your self doubt That's A Moray!
🏆
I missed reading for a while and recently (happily) got sucked back in. Does anyone know when the director storyline started?
Claire got the interview request for Cubetown back at #4847. So, August of 2022.
Does being part of Jeph's mind influence the determination of whether they have free will or not?
Depends on what you consider free will I suppose. Once a characters personality is established they sort of take on a life of their own. Jeph has several times mentioned being surprised by the way a story went even though he was the one writing it. So, oddly enough, it might not rule it out. Unless of course Jeph doesn't have free will, which would sort of render it a moot point I suppose.
Like cake, free will is a lie.
Free will doesn't taste half as good though.
Personally I think that we live in a deterministic universe. I also believe that that will never be relevant because we cannot, within the confines of our universe, observe anything to a sufficient degree that we can accurately predict the behavior of chaotic systems. So Morray has effective free will, if only de facto. (Unless she's being influenced by the director or remote controlled or something.)
What about outside the confines of our universe?
LOL- good job Claire, existential crisis on infinite loop!
Newcomb's Paradox ftw?
I'd not heard of that and now I'm trapped in the philosophy section of Wikipedia. Send help!
Man. It is too late at night to be wondering if I have free will.
It's like Jeph has read our comments xD
Ooh a new Claire face. Borrowing from a classic Cathy face plant.
Claire has a nuclear weapon level of "Very Disappointed".
I’ve long held that it’s the worst way you can feel… FAR worse than worried or afraid or even enraged.
Oh NO, Moray! What have you done?!?
Is that her third diplomatic crisis? 🤣🤣🤣
We are all npcs in someone else’s rpg ….oddly enough im fine with that 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Oooh, can I be the NPC at the beginning of every game that gives you all the tedious unskippable backstory? I think I would enjoy that.
Claire making super AIs wonder if they have free will. She's perfect for the job.
The power of the Librarian has no bounds
You are free to believe you lack free will.
Only, of course, if you were already the kind of person so inclined.
Claire just cut the knot. She is the fabled librarian!
That’s actually one of the few things I have never actually worried about. Like, I think I have free will, but if I don’t then I don’t. That’s kinda the whole point, isn’t it? If you don’t have free will then nothing can be your problem.
yeah, self solving problem. if you don't you worrying about it isn't even your choice. But if I perceive that I have free will then I functionally do. If we lived in a computer simulation indistinguishable from reality would it matter in any practical way? It's always bullshit solipsism or determinism and always has been in my opinion, a literal waste of time to lose sleep over.
I am VERY disappointed in your deterministic nature
Yes, Moray. Sleep with Claire and Marten. #poly
But can Moray produce heat? Because as someone who has slept on a waterbed when the water wasn't warm, it's pretty unpleasant.
I fucking love Claire.
So say we all!
