Questionable Collagen
the Look
Comments (82)
Well, first we met Station - an AI powerful enough to single-handedly run an entire colony in space and have processing power to spare. Then we met Spookybot, and Station's reaction was utter surprise that there was an AI more powerful than himself - and not just that Spookybot existed, but that Station had never heard of them before. Now Spookybot (now known as Yay) has made that same realization - that there could be an AI even more impressive than they are. It's a sobering reality when you come face to face with the knowledge that you aren't actually the top dog.
Not only that, but that top dog sent their little mouthpiece to talk to you in person letting you know they see you, not because they plan on threatening you which is yay's first assumption, but just because they have no concept of subterfuge, being a jellyfish
Ouch. "Very flexible"... That dad joke hurts...
I love the existence of these "Big Deal" AIs. The Director, Station, Yay. They dynamics of such alien and powerful beings still struggling with interpersonal communication is great.
As for their struggle with interpersonal communication, that's actually very typical for anyone who is exponentially more intelligent than everyone around them. They either talk with all their intelligence, or they try to dumb themselves down to others' level, but that's like trying to speak in a foreign language that you've never learned. You can make the sounds with your mouth, but you don't actually know what you're saying. Either way, they spend their childhood alienating those around them, and by the time they grow up, they have learned it's easier to simply avoid those interactions in the first place. It's a lonely existence, but it's less awkward. Yay gets full marks for making the effort to have actual friendships - and succeeding.
Ah, so the Director's up at that level. Yikes.
Assume you are the highest level person in a particular arena Now, exercise your abilities to learn about your contemporaries Never get discovered unless you decide you want to be discovered Come upon a low level, although capable, individual representing another you are not certain of your position related to the low level's executive Get told, very clearly, you have been seen doing your patented nobody has ever seen you doing your sneaky thing Existential crisis, Yay might have been served well by getting AI drunk with Liz. He is not only known, but the one you were being very careful and sneaking about interacting with says, "Hi, saw you, wanna be friends Y/N"
Yeah, bones break. It’s no fun at all. Definitely overrated.
I wonder, if the message from the Director to Yay is a big flex, I wonder how big of a flex the whole “hijacking of sensorium is” considering Moray had never experienced that before.
Interesting question, but also, Moray has never been outside of Cubetown - so it's hard to imagine how that would have happened to her before now anyway.
How did the Director figure out enough about Yay that Moray was able to recognize them immediately (in https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=5383)?
Yay told Moray their name in the previous comic. This is pure speculation, but if the Director tracked their signal back to Northampton they may have run across rumors of a heretofore unknown powerful AI in the area going by that name. I mean, hand delivering Corpse Witch to the police, giving away two billion dollars? Even if Yay's true nature remains hidden that kind of thing is going to leave a trail. And as Yay said: "with every social bond we form, the network of people aware of our existence grows." https://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=4881
Thanks, Claire, for explaining things to me! I think I had forgotten or never quite appreciated just how secretive Yay was.
Bones are NOT overrated. >:(
But *broken* bones are *seriously* overrated.
I think it's as if Yay was fully optimised for optical camouflage but is being detected by the Director in a completely different way - much as fish might rely on water pressure, electric fields etc. rather than vision. So for Yay it's terrifying but the Director doesn't even think of it as a flex, it's just... obvious to them.
Which would be even scarier to Yay. "You did something I didn't think was possible and didn't even think twice about it." But I think the way Yay thinks, they're going to _assume_ this was a flex, because if Yay did the same, it would be very intentional.
Claire going to start looking more an more like Aurelia as this situation continues. ~<3
Not that that's a bad thing!
Is it just me or is Claire's design slowly becoming more mom-coded
It's the weight of responsibility settling upon her.
Just because the director found Yay snooping doesn't necessarily mean that they know what Yay is exactly, for all anyone knows Yay is just a talented hacker
To snoop on the Director... they'd definitely need to be more than that
Ok but to be fair, Moray didn't just happen to run into them, right? Yay went out of their way to do the happening part. Although I guess that could also have been considered by The Director, knowing that if Moray was in town Yay would make sure of it, seeing as they were already scuttling with curiosity. So that's also a flex, I guess.
Except considering that Moray is a direct conduit of The Director, it's hard to say how much of this is confidence and Moray being Moray, or The Director being Moray. How much free will does she actually have? How much coincidence is coincidence?
Has it occurred to someone that while Cubetown might legitimately need a librarian, the director might have specifically chosen Claire because the lives in contact with Yay?
I wanna give them more credit than that! 😭 The Director coulda probably reached out to Yay directly if The Director wanted to, or at least gooped out a specific Moray to do it for them. I think it was moreso like how you'll make a new friend and then they introduce you to all of their friend's too. I just can't picture the Director deliberately using Claire like that :(
Oh no, so was Claire's job offer just part of the scheme too? I hope not. She'd probably feel so used, at least if the whole object of the scheme, to make friends with Yay, ends up turning out a dud.
It's a super AI, it could just do dozens of moves at once for multiple desired outcomes. So even if it was part of a scheme it might be that it was still useful to get a competent librarian and many other unfatomable reasons.
I love how Claire now has firmly established that the director does not have higher security clearance than the Librarian
Yessssss.
Well, when you put it like *that*….
It helps the Director to have a guileless and disarming agent people trust, one who honestly believes she is completely independent
That's pretty dark! I think the Director is a bit of a goober tbh. "Do you want to be friends Y/N" is a goober message
I am extremely jealous of Jeph's ability to write compelling characters.
Okay, yeah, it's scarier than I realized.
Same.
Claire Stare
OMG Claire Stare
I got way too invested in Yay as the most powerful AI... now it appears they've got peers/superiors and I am bummed. I'll miss them.
Yay is a medium sized fish in a big ocean
She goes 🎶🎵 Na-na-na-na-na Na-na-na-na-na Na-na-na-na-na-na Na-na-na-na-na Na-na-na-na-na-na-na-na She's got:
...the books
Claire has evolved beyond such primitive Bene Gesserit techniques as The Voice. She only needs The Look.
Her shush is a killing word.
Claireity struck as she hatched a plan. “Yay,” she whispered into the encrypted ether, “it’s time to come out of hiding. The Director needs you, and so do I.”
When Claire took the Librarian class she gained the ability to use Suggestion as a gaze attack once per day. She also gets bonuses to will saves against exasperation and Detect Shenanigans as cantrip.
Once a day? Nah, that shit's on a 30-second cooldown.
Moray… …nope. Nevermind. I like her innocent and apt to lack of metaphor in this case. 💙
I have a feeling they basilisk will stop yay in the nick of time, and one of yay will end up working in the coffee shop with Martin.
To summarize this arc, Yay is an incredible feat of engineering, and only just learning that networking and spy gear is a little outclassed in the digital realm against enough raw computation power that it squirts out fully functional AI just to translate for it.
Ha. Also oof xD
Well, she IS The Librarian. That stare only confirms it!
Now that Claire has laid it all out, I see why Yay freaked out. That is legitimately an incredible flex.
It is pretty wild that they figured out where Yay was, I didn't think about that part 🤔
I like Moray for the same reason I like bananas.
She's an excellent source of potassium?
…is that why they’re called The Director? They’re pulling strings to make “coincidences” happen?
There are two kinds of coincidence; stochastic and unperceived causality. 'coincidence' is what humans call them when we can't tell the difference. The Director's whole thing is being able to discern which is which.
The Director may be impressive but they're on my shit list until Yay comes back 😤
they just want a friend...
Just cartilage, like sharks.
Cartilage, which is made of collagen, hence and therefore. (I don't think normal jellyfish have collagen, but the Director and Moray are anything but normal.)
Director uses ‘quantum search’: why bother checking all combinations, just [insert science here] and skip to the result.
I mean, if you're using quantum computing to search you'd still likely be checking all combinations, it's just that thanks to taking advantage of superpostions you can check multiple combinations at once.
This has the vibe of, "I am an ant in the grass, and the elephants are fighting"
This. It feeds into my concern that while The Wedding, Marten's coffee shop and Sam / Emmett's budding romance might be in the foreground what the strip is *really* becoming about is the effect of superintellegent AIs on humanity. It's going to take a *long* time but I think we're heading into territory where the hard SF elements of the strip are going to become much more important.
Claire is like "I'm the Librarian. There are no secrets from me"
The Librarian has all the security clearances.
Why do I feeling 'the look' is going to be an everytime food...
I think someone needs to try the lotto lol
hehe
Is Moray cogitating this or is The Director using her as a Numbers Station?
what is the director flexing?
His goo!
No one can resist the "Look of the Librarian"!
That look is the only way teachers can keep cafeterias sane.
When you speak in hushed tones 'bout your boss with no bones That's A Moray!
Aaand here you go. 🏆
Impressive LOOK
That is one hell of a flex tbh
I have to admit that while I do feel bad for Yay, they have had no qualms whatsoever in their past about doing all sorts of highly questionable activities for their own advantage.
