Saturday Music Reaction Poll for May 10th š¶
Hey friends!
Itās time to vote for our Saturday music reaction! šøš¤
Weāre doing something a little different this week. After the poll where David Bowie won, a lot of you mentioned that the song we picked wasnāt the best place to start. That got us thinking, and we agree. We want to dive a little deeper when it makes sense.
So for this week's poll, itās going to be all David Bowie themed! š§āš¤
And after thinking it over even more, we decided weāre going to start doing album mini-series. Instead of trying to tackle an entire album in one video, weāll go through 3 to 4 songs at a time. This way we can actually experience albums properly without it taking forever, and it gives you all something consistent to look forward to along the way.
Whatever wins this poll will be reacted to and uploaded on Saturday, May 10th and will begin our album mini-series.
Thanks for being on this journey with us. Weāre really excited about this next chapter! šš
Anymore suggestions or guidance would be greatly appreciated.
Comments (31)
Okay, so I should definitely read your entire post, Mike and Jess, before commenting! I assume you plan on reacting to EVERY song on an album of our choice? That makes it very simple for us. We've definitely picked the right album to listen to, too. One suggestion though! After you have listened to Ziggy Stardust, how about you react to a documentary about the album? That would really fill in the missing pieces for you.
I love this idea, Mike and Jess! Congratulations! My suggestion: go chronologically, because from his first hit onwards he was a genius leading the way in popular culture, so trying to decide between starting with Hunky Dory and Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars is pointless. We will all bicker until the cows come home about which song or which album is the best and where to start. You might as well short-circuit that and just learn the way we did in real time! That means start with Space Oddity, which is an incredible song and referred back to in his final great album, Scary Monsters and Super Creeps, at the end of the 70s with Ashes to Ashes. Then move on to The Man Who Sold The World, with the hit song the name of the album too. It was covered by Nirvana with an acoustic version. Then Hunky Dory, where he really starts to get into his stride, although you'll have trouble picking a best song, there are so many! Same goes for Ziggy Stardust: Starman, Five Years etc. Try picking one out of all the incredible tracks on there!
I see what you're saying. But I think they're saying they're doing 1 album, not the Bowie discography. Else we'll be on Bowie for the next year+.
I misread the first time. So if we're picking one album to react to - it should be the best of... But joking aside, this is clearly Ziggy. It's about a fictional rockstar.
My favourite 70s Bowie album is either āHunky Doryā or āStation To Stationā with Ziggy being just below at either third or fourth. But I think Ziggy is a decent starting point as thatās the album that brought him fame in the UK. (was going to go full Muso and write a long comment but decided to stop here)
I love Hunky Dory too, although it's a bit of an outlier in a way. Ziggy Stardust was regularly voted as the top or near-top greatest album ever by any artist through the 70s and remains my favourite album of his. Oddly, Station to Station might be my least favourite album of his until the execrable Let's Dance, but each to their own! It's hard to impossible to find a poor Bowie album, let's face it.
Great idea! So, to get this straight, Mike and Jess will randomly select an artist from the ones submitted on the playlist, and select 5 songs to vote on, then do a reaction to the top 3 or 4 in that poll, yes? Sounds like a great way to get artists played that wouldnāt normally get voted for. Iām all for it! And like you said, itāll give you a better feel for the artist. Hope you continue to pick live performances as well though, rather than just official music videos.
And, of course, there are some incredible documentaries about his life too; maybe Mike and Jess could be recoomended one to react to?
They are all amazing choices. Ziggy is the most famous one so will win. But the others are just as valid choices. I think Mike should buy a Ziggy Stardust wig to wear during the reactions š
Mike and Jess, a suggestion if Ziggy wins: Track 4 is Starman. You might consider playing the Top of the Pops 1972 performance of this song instead of just the audio. Although Bowie is miming, this was the moment that launched him from struggling artist into international stardom. I asked ChatGPT about this, and this was the answer⦠David Bowieās 1972 performance of āStarmanā on Top of the Pops is widely regarded as one of the most important moments in the history of British pop culture and music television. Hereās why it mattered: 1. Breakthrough Moment for Bowie Although Bowie had modest success before, this performance introduced his Ziggy Stardust persona to a mass audience. It marked his transformation into a true star and cemented his place in the glam rock movement. 2. Cultural Shock and Inspiration Millions of viewersāespecially young peopleāwere mesmerized by Bowieās androgynous look, bright red hair, colorful jumpsuit, and charismatic confidence. When he slung his arm around guitarist Mick Ronson mid-performance, it sent a subtle but powerful shock through a still-conservative UK. It was a visible challenge to gender norms and traditional masculinity. 3. Inspiration for Future Stars Countless future musicians, including Boy George, Morrissey, Gary Kemp, and Robert Smith, have cited this moment as life-changing. For many, it was the first time they saw someone who looked and acted completely different from the mainstreamāand who made that difference feel like liberation.
I like your backstory on his cultural impact there, but disagree with the choice of Starman. I guess it's tough though: go for the big hits or for the songs with real heft. My personal choice from Ziggy Stardust would probably be 5 Years.
Nobody ever mentions Pin-Ups ........ (Great Covers) ...... š¤ Honourable mentions :- Quicksand - Hunky Dory The Bewlay Brothers - Hunky Dory Unwashed and Somewhat Slightly Dazed - Space Oddity Cygnet Commitee - Space Oddity The Width of a Circle - The Man Who Sold The World After All - The Man Who Sold The World The Supermen - The Man Who Sold The World
The Bewlay Brothers (Hunky Dory) is my all-time favourite song of Bowie's and, to my surprise, I read somewhere that the man himself said at one time that it was his; so, I'm in great company! PS I love your off-the-wall choices. You're clearly a true afficionado!
Diamond Dogs a song so good they listed it twice.
The Prodigal returns (all in jest) :)
Star man and life on Mars
Would love to see you guys react to Zombie by the Cranberries āļø
I wanted to vote for Diamond dogs but I dont see it on the list
š
Special mention for the title track on Young Americans.
I love the Young Americans album
Hunky Dory, Ziggy Stardust and Aladdin Sane is the greatest three-album run of all-time. All released within 17 months while constantly touring. The man was a machine.
Hard agree
What a good choice to make. Personally I picked Hunky Dory even though I agree that Ziggy is the best place to start, because Hunky Dory is the first truly great Bowie record. It deserves at least 1 vote, especially as it's my personal favourite.
It's sad that let's dance isn't on there, maybe in the future
Please no! As someone who never idolised anybody in my life, except Bowie. It was a truly awful album, IMO!
Bloody brilliant! Iām sure Iām dreaming this poll. Iāll wake up in five minutes and it will be disco hits of the 70s. Five minutes later⦠No itās for real. Got to be Ziggy! Thank you, Mike and Jess!
There were some brilliant disco hits in the 70s! Five minutes and you're almost dead...
What a fantastic idea. Love it. :)
Great idea! Bowie is one of my favourite artists of all time. Ziggy is the place to start.
Actually, the first 4 songs on Hunky Dory is probably the place to start and then move on to Ziggy
