March 25, 2026

Female NPC popularity contest!

The other day I realized I haven’t done an NPC popularity poll since August 2023! Has it really been that long? Hard to believe…

Anyway, a lot has happened since then, and with Chapter 15 opening with Ian, I got curious: which female characters are at the top of your list?

Who are you most looking forward to spending time with again, or which ones have you enjoyed the most so far? I wonder whether the results of this poll will be similar to the last one, exactly the same, or if we’ll get a surprise upset…

Let’s find out!

There's a second, single-vote poll live for subscribers! Cast your vote here.

Comments (60)

t
the legend snow · May 6, 2026

I'm looking forward to Ian&Zarina and Ian&Lena&Zarina scenes and of course Ian&Lena&Ivy and more Ian&Ivy scenes, damn she's so hot.

S
Saddybub · April 14, 2026

How is Cindy so popular😮, would’ve expected Holly or Cherry to be up top instead honestly

I
Iggy · May 1, 2026

It's the blond thing.

U
Ulta Pitt · April 10, 2026

Minerva!!! More of her please.

I
Iggy · April 2, 2026

1. Holly 2. Cherry 3. Gillian (she's had hardly any scenes but I guess I see potential) Special note: now that Ian and Ivy have had their moment, can a a threesome with Ivy and slutty Holly be far off?

s
somewhereinbarstow · March 27, 2026

I have met several women like Emma, and I guess that helps with her already being quite believable. Very imperfect, funny and bubbly in her own way. Always has been my favorite!

P
PeterRasputin · March 27, 2026

It truly is a crime how low Cherry ranks!!! Besides my top 3 of Minerva, Emma, and Cherry I will now comment on the others. Cindy’s scenes are very hot but the friend plotline makes it not fun for me and she’s a little too stuck up and trifling. Allison is hot but she’s too needy and annoying lol. Louise is just way too annoying lmao like I wanted Ian to get with her when Lena spied on Jeremy or Jeremy showed the pics but now that he can I can why Jeremy doesn’t take Louise seriously at all. Gillian better be worth it for locking some relationship options if we still simp for her lol. Ivy is a top contender no doubt. Holly is amazing but I wish we could have a medium baddie Holly and not just the two extremes. Holly is definitely my Fourth favorite or maybe tied with Cherry

I
Iggy · April 2, 2026

I'm on team Cherry too.

W
Wilson L. Ricks III · March 27, 2026

Holly, Emma, Cindy, and weirdly Minerva in that order

S
Spidey96 · March 27, 2026

I see Holly is in 2nd place but which version is everyone’s favorite😏?

I
Iggy · April 2, 2026

Slutty Holly is mind-blowing.

E
Eldaym · March 26, 2026

lol poor Wade, people really are terrible friends... but better Ian than Axel

I
Iggy · May 2, 2026

Seems like there's Axel action as well. Bad girl, Cindy. Bad! Bad!

J
Jimmy P · March 26, 2026

Need a million more scenes with Cindy and Ian!

B
Brugge · March 26, 2026

Allison, Cindy, Holly, in that order.

P
PeterRasputin · March 26, 2026

1. Minerva. 2. Emma. 3. Cherry.

Z
ZB · March 26, 2026

I would love to see more Minerva, Ivy and Emma for Ian, my opinion I find those routes more fun!

T
Thomas Moret · March 26, 2026

Ivy. The perfect Homewreckers... I hope!

C
Cavalier2025 · March 26, 2026

Holly, Louise, Cherry, and Emma are my top 4 for non-Lena women characters. While I'm really happy with how Holly (especially in the trinity path) and Louise are developing I am also a bit worried about Cherry getting left behind. Also really looking forward to the IanxEmmaxLena 3way that was teased in the previous chapter!

T
Tomasz Derlecki · March 26, 2026

1 Cindy, 2 Holly, 3. Louise

R
RJ · March 26, 2026

Will you have a cameo of Ashley from the original game..?

D
Dennis · March 26, 2026

I really love Zarina bringing in some resentment into the game. She is nice, beautiful, but maybe also dangerous or at least a worthy antagonist for Ivy. Would love to see her behaving and plotting even worse.

A
Arty Whale · March 26, 2026

Holly and Cindy are my votes and an easy top two. Gun to my head to choose a favourite and I think I'd have to take the bullet. Have to give a shoutout to Emma, Minerva, Cherry and Louise as ones that I like too, but more for hookups rather than anything deep. I have multiple playthroughs where I try to get them all one way or another though. I would also love to get the girl from the office who has a boyfriend, but her name escapes me, she is super hot and I'd do basically anything to get the chance with her and hope at some point she will be available for some fun.

A
Anna · March 26, 2026

Holly 💕🌸🙌

L
Lionel Mezzadri · March 26, 2026

Emma and that booty!! OMG we need more of that!!!!!

J
JT Gee · March 25, 2026

Need more Minerva love ;P

s
stoperArt · March 25, 2026

The relationship with Minerva is the kinkiest on Ian's side. The rest are too vanilla for my taste.

S
Spidey96 · March 25, 2026

I'm happy to see more people are appreciating Emma more.

D
Dorian Wainwright · March 25, 2026

Definitely need a one vote only poll!

Z
Zaza · March 25, 2026

Jessica, but I'm a sucker for a good call back lol

V
VHO · March 25, 2026

I’m for Alison, but we need Sonia on these polls!

Z
ZeroOne · March 25, 2026

Single one again, or combo. Emma and Louise with cherry on top #1

F
Finn · March 25, 2026

Need Minerva! This is so hard; I love them all, not you Gillian. Picked everyone from Holly to Minerva. Those are my faves, with Emma in the lead. I would like more polls, I hope we get one about the fellas also.

G
Guno5 · March 25, 2026

This game is the best!! Minerva, Luise and Emma ar good candidates. At the same time I think more spice with Stan, Ed, Boris or Denna must be explored. Good luck with your work!

N
Nonyabiz · March 25, 2026

Emma by a LOT, then holly, then Minerva

M
Mifune · March 25, 2026

I love Holly a lot. She's my favorite girl in this whole game

J
John · March 25, 2026

Always Holly for me, but Cindy's scenes are drawn so incredibly well, and Emma's scenes can be so primal. And I have to admit I love a submissive redhead, so Louise makes the list for that aspect, even if her personality outside the bedroom is something Ian really doesn't need.

C
Chris Joslet · March 25, 2026

Alison was always my favorite, as she seemed like a more natural fit for Ian once he showed interested. Cindy is a close 2nd though

V
VHO · March 25, 2026

Alison, woo! Also, I’d be down for additional polls. I look forward to seeing more of this new outfit on Louise.

N
NonBlondeEmo · March 25, 2026

Although we haven’t seen much of Gillian yet, I really like her character design so my vote will go to her, even if she isn’t my favorite female NPC.

S
Squatchy · March 25, 2026

There is only... Emma... 😵‍💫

C
Chachi · March 25, 2026

Minerva deserves more love😭

W
WhiteWolf · March 25, 2026

Zarina honestly feels like a fresh take and a new great character who is complex in a way and pretty hot aswell but i think its late enough to the overall story that her being a love interest doesn't make sense personally. That said great character who would work in a newer story.

E
Ethereal Twist · March 25, 2026

I think it'd add some dynamism to the narrative to have a late love/sexual option for each main character actually.

R
RJ · March 25, 2026

I like Cherry, Emma , Ivy, and Cindy

M
Markus Johansson · March 25, 2026

Cindy and Alison, hard to pick, but leaning toward Alison...

M
Majortom589 · March 25, 2026

i like the fallen emma, hollly and allison. i like emma that is cares more about being girly now, i like sluttly holly and the bimbo allison is great as well.

H
HelpVanLiving · March 25, 2026

I love all of them its such a hard choice 😅🤣 i sat there for 5 mintues trying to figure it out

H
HelpVanLiving · March 25, 2026

Update, lowkey like crazy lousie vibes

E
Essence · March 25, 2026

All I need is Cherry

P
Pete Miller · March 25, 2026

I love Emma because she’s a guy’s girl, she’s so confident and unapologetic for who she is. Girls like her both in game and IRL are def my “type”

P
Prodigal Paragon · March 25, 2026

Please more Cindy content!

M
Money talks · March 25, 2026

It’s super hard to pick because there’s many that’re written really well

T
Theylo Blue · March 25, 2026

This is a great poll. I don't know how it shook out last time, but I think for me depending on the style I'm playing through, there's no better contenders than Emma, Holly, and Ivy, with a few others worthy of screen time. If we're talking Ian specific, I really like the dynamic with Emma (and Lena at times) and I like her more confident, naughtier outfit options, she's a hoot. I'm curious about the version of Holly that is under Ivy's mentorship and how that could impact an Ian+Holly connection. I think there's some interesting opportunities for what happens if Ian and Louise/Ivy happen while he's with or connected to Lena, both positive and negative outcomes. Further though, if you're talking about Female NPCs and their relationship with Lena, then that's a whole other journey! I love seeing Lena's dynamic with Ivy, Emma, Holly, Louise, etc. Maybe a scene where Lena meets Axel while he's with Cindy, I dunno. You're the master storyteller, haha. Looking forward to whatever you put out!

V
VHO · March 25, 2026

LET’S GO, ALISON!

M
Maverrick00 · March 25, 2026

I'm a huge Cindy fan. She's a goddess next to Lena. A G/G scene between the two of them at the end of ORS, or with Ian as B/G/G, would be the absolute highlight. Alison is still one of my favorites. Ivy and Holly have really caught up with me! Gillian is currently what I'm most curious about. ⚜️

E
Ethereal Twist · March 25, 2026

Seeing Zarina here makes me hopeful Lena will get to have more scenes with her going forward~ Dare I hope for a dedicated route even at this stage of development? <3

P
Penz · March 25, 2026

Since i have a top 3 that i keep cycling as my favorite i appreciate being able to vote for multiple people

L
Lewis · March 25, 2026

All tough choices as I’ve done multiple play throughs for girls to pair with Ian, my faves are definitely Alison, Minerva, Ivy and Louise and Jessica

R
Rodney · March 25, 2026

I've put the 3 I'm most interested in: Holly, Jessica and Alison