💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
FULL DISCUSSION - Star Trek TNG S1E23 - Skin of Evil (1 of 2)
FULL DISCUSSION - Star Trek TNG S1E23 - Skin of Evil (2 of 2)
December 20, 2023

FULL DISCUSSION - Star Trek TNG S1E23 - Skin of Evil

Comments (48)

K
Knights Who Say Sledge · January 1, 2024

This is one of those episodes I've been waiting for you to get to from when I started watching your reactions to TOS season one. I watched Next Gen from the premiere as a kid during its original airing on TV, and Tasha was my favorite character right out of the gate at that age. So when this episode hit, it melted my brain - this sort of thing was all-but unheard of with main cast members at the time on TV shows and I had no real framework for it. The fact that it derives from issues behind the scenes remains sad. It remains something I wish hadn't been happening for Denise Crosby. Without question. In show though and, particularly, in the scope of Trek across the decades, losing Tasha just feels really seismic narratively in a way that still looms large all this time later. And that places Tasha, a character who remains firmly secured in my affections even if she's not my number one in Next Gen now that I am well into middle age, in a really special place in terms of the grand scope of Trek. So, its a very conflicting thing, even now, but I see the long term pluses as well as the ambient minuses to us losing her. I don't think there's an easy way to position this loss in any of the contexts it exists within and that keeps it a powerful thing, to say the least.

R
Rich Loga · December 21, 2023

The situation around Denise leaving is kinda of messed up. After the first few episodes Tasha is just kinda of there, and Denise was bored. She had asked to be let go from her contract and they let her go. They didn’t even try to appease her. They were more than willing to let her go. Almost glad she wanted to leave. Part of the reason was that was the main cast ended up being larger than originally intended and having so many characters made it difficult to include everyone in stories. The character of Worf was a very late addition to the main cast, some of the early promotional photos of the main cast do not include him. Originally, Gene did not want to see any of the alien races from TOS at the forefront in TNG, Bob Justman and others convinced Gene that it would be cool to have a reoccurring character on the bridge that’s a Klingon to fulfill the prediction the Organians made back in TOS that the Federation and the Klingons would be friends in the future. Michael Dorn was cast as that reoccurring character, but he was so good while filming the pilot the character was bumped to main cast before filming was completed. Unfortunately, Tasha‘s death opens a lot of opportunities for the Worf character which in the long run plays out well. The Tasha character is never forgotten by the series, even briefly mentioned in the recent season 3 of Star Trek Picard. Denise Crosby also made a couple of documentaries about Star Trek fandom that are quite good.

J
Joe Concepts · December 21, 2023

I do think that Josh has a point that while from the perspective of a viewer watching a story, maybe having that distracting death isn't the best idea. But the idea maybe was to really finally show in this fictional line of work and even maybe in a real world military, after that sudden death their job wouldn't allow them time to process it. Grieving would have to wait with the mission still happening. That would've maybe worked better if the rest of the Armus story was stronger?

N
Numinous2019 · December 21, 2023

This is one of those ideas that sounds better in theory than in actual storytelling. Killing off a main character with shocking suddenness and only part way through an episode. Can happen in real life without time to adequately mourn and resolve. Translating that to fiction......it would take exceptional writing to make it fully work. This episode does feel like this was the result of a very rapid decision as to reconcile Crosby wanting to leave with writing Yar out of the show.

S
Scarpad’s Domain · December 21, 2023

it was in the previews, their on the disk check it out

S
Scarpad’s Domain · December 21, 2023

picard new armus achilles heel was being abadonned and that would cause him to get riled up and allow the field to drop to the level that they could beam the crew out. I think the downside of having to watch these on camera that you miss some stuff, plus the point of a senseless death is played up later and will be paid off

N
Nerd's Gold · December 21, 2023

Listening to the ideas of how they would have rewritten the episode made me like this episode even less (because they are so right). I also had another thought off of that. Why not just have her promoted to be first officer on another ship? They could have had another conversation with Worf discussing whether she wanted to or not, still had her attacked and put into a coma, but ended it with her recovering and having a third conversation with Worf realizing that she needs to take her opportunities when they come up. Writers should always leave a way to bring a character back. Also, only an hour away at impulse and they need to go to warp 8?

S
Scarpad’s Domain · December 21, 2023

tasha's death so early shows the crew has to put it behind them so so theay can do their jobs, i liked that

S
Scarpad’s Domain · December 21, 2023

in the episode Crusher said the creature sucked the life out of her

M
Monty Crawford · December 21, 2023

Actually I think Tasha's death was a gift to the future writers, as they were able to incorporate her death into some excellent future story arcs....which you will find out.

M
Michael Parnell · December 23, 2023

Oh come on.

D
Duane Chancey · December 21, 2023

Hey guys, I figured you wouldn't like this one very much. Josh you took this pretty well, when I saw this in 88 I was so PO'd....alot more than you were! So I guess this makes 2 Not so good or Bad Eps to me out of 23. 😢 🖖

R
Regan · December 21, 2023

I must admit that I was surprised that Alex and Josh had never realised that the pips on the uniform collars are rank insignia. For the record, there are full pips (gold) and half-pips (black with a gold rim) and they mean the following- 1 = Ensign 1½ = Lieutenant Junior Grade 2 = Lieutenant Senior Grade 2½ = Lieutentant Commander 3 = Commander 4 = Captain 5+ = Flag officers (Admirals, Commodores)

K
KatWithAttitude · December 21, 2023

Yeah, I wondered about that, too. I even posted that information myself in one of the Patron Takes a couple months ago and they never mentioned reading it.

G
GamingHour2018 · December 21, 2023

man there is soo much i want to talk about in this series but spoilers and i wouldnt do that to anyone except maybe my most hated enemy lol. all jokes aside, this episode while not greatest was good (not my first time watching TNG i grew up on the reruns) Tasha's death while it sucks doesnt really pull on the heart strings till the end of the episode where she's talking to everyone gathered even to this day i tear up at that point in the episode. Maybe its because i have dealt with a lot of death in my life but episodes with characters dying really makes me tear up doesnt matter if its moves, tv shows, books or videogames. Worf's promotion to Acting security/tact officer was a shock the first time i saw this episode and seeing him declining to go down to the planet and stay on the ship a big move on his part, it shows that even though he wanted to avenge Tasha he knew if went down there and fought Armas only to possibly die himself would dishonor her memory. at least thats the way i see it he could of easily gone full Klingon and probably ripped Armas in half (for all the good that would do) . Coming up to the end of the season, theres an episode in Season 2 that i would love to talk to yall about when you get there as its personally one of my favorite episodes.

R
Regan · December 20, 2023

Tasha's departure is what allows Worf's character to take a bigger role in the show. So some good did come of it. Worf was originally intended as a background character, just there to show that old enemies can become friends. But now he has to step up and become one of the main cast.

J
Jovet · December 21, 2023

I expected them to talk about that in their discussion, as Worf was promptly promoted to, essentially, a main character. I figured they'd be especially excited about that.

S
Strife · December 20, 2023

Recommend you watch Shatner's documentary Chaos on the Bridge when you finish TNG as there are some spoilers IIRC but it breaks down the behind the scenes problems in the first season or two of TNG as it was trying to get going. It was really well done. Shatner is great in it. You will get some answers about Denise and the troubles pretty much everyone was having.

P
Paul Rymer · December 20, 2023

I’d say wait until after all of TNG as it makes a good wrap-up extra.

S
StonyD · December 20, 2023

Of note: The episode was never written to be her death episode. It was a script they modified to allow her to leave before the end of the season. So, remove her death and funeral and you have what the original script was about.

C
Collin Freeman · December 20, 2023

Alex, sounds like you wanted a Kirk to deal with Armis instead of Picard. My complaint is the entire "story" just seemed rushed, like "we need an episode to kill off Tasha and a way to do it", so they came up with it over lunch and wrote it that way. I imagine Denise Crosby's leaving caught the producers off guard and they had to come up with a script rather quick, and it shows.

C
Collin Freeman · December 20, 2023

Amazing what you can do with printer's ink and a 1/2 ton of Metamucil.

C
Collin Freeman · December 20, 2023

Many have complained about Tasha's unheroic death, but the way she died didn't really bother me. It is definitely a shock and catches the audience off guard. In the context of the show, anyone can die from anything for any reason (or no reason) at any time. Tasha was killed in the line of duty, heroic or not. In that sense, it is as true to life and death as you can get.

J
Jovet · December 21, 2023

I agree.

G
Glenn Zigli · December 20, 2023

So I am curious how much you guys have seen before. I mean it would be hard to not to have some prior knowledge and you may have chatted about it before. Just curious going forward.

T
Target Audience · December 20, 2023

We talk a little bit about the extent of our knowledge in the intro of the first TNG video

P
PIG · December 20, 2023

Have a Merry Christmas!!!!!! .. What?

J
Joe Concepts · December 20, 2023

It might be weird for people on camera to see how you can read them, but Alex's reaction looks just like he said he was thinking. He realized right away she must be dead, but didn't want to say anything.

J
Joe Concepts · December 20, 2023

Have to say that Tasha will at least not be completely forgotten by the show. Her crewmates at least remember her.

D
Dan Proctor · December 20, 2023

It’s Interesting that you mention her fan/convention scene presence. It was a while ago, but I believe she ends up being the narrator of the “Trekkies” films exploring the fandom back in the peak era. Does that make her sort of a fan ambassador? That’s certainly something.

K
Ken R · December 20, 2023

This could have been a lot better. I'm sure on YouTube there are countless examples from soap operas of death scenes done with more finesse and drama. Still, sorry to see her go but they kind of ignored her after the first few episodes. After the fight on the monkey bars on the episode that wasn't really racist I don't think she ever got focus again. I was pleasantly surprised to see her 10 years ago on Walking Dead as the cannibal who has the showdown with Carol, but I don't know if I've seen her since.

J
Jovet · December 20, 2023

She's had fairly steady work from what I saw glancing over things. Don't look things up if you haven't seen all the Star Trek series, though.

J
Jovet · December 20, 2023

15:00 The only thing I didn't like about the funeral scene is how Yar's pre-recorded message just happened to address everyone that was in attendance, no more or no fewer.

K
KatWithAttitude · December 20, 2023

She may have left a request for just those people to be there. That would explain it.

A
Analog Mind · December 20, 2023

Similiar to Denise Crosby, Nichelle Nichols had wanted to leave TOS because she felt they weren't doing anything with her character only convinced otherwise when Martin Luther King Jr. personally asked her to stay. With him feeling it was important to the civil rights movement for a black person to be represented as a normal member of a multiracial group. So she soldered through it. Denise would regret leaving show, but the death of her character would have an effect of events throughout the show

T
Target Audience · December 20, 2023

Obviously not on the same level, but it was nice having a strong female character that didn’t have a romantic connection to a male character on the show

J
Jovet · December 20, 2023

6:21 Remember that Armus had teleported Geordi's visor earlier.

J
Jovet · December 20, 2023

4:18 The crew didn't have time to grieve, either. The show must go on!

P
Prof Moff · December 20, 2023

I am with you on leaving the death to the end. How about this: Tosha beamed back up on full life support. They get Troy back up to ship and Artimus instead of yelling kills Tosha as he was still connection with her. BAM then funeral, then end credits.

T
Target Audience · December 20, 2023

Wow that would be excellent! Picard and crew think they’ve outsmarted it and got away but he kills her as one final act. That’s good stuff 👏🏻

P
Phillip Grischa · December 20, 2023

Many fans assume Denise Crosby regretted leaving the show but I've never heard her say that, there's a relatively recent interview from last year and she sounded perfectly fine with the decision, she said she had no kids to feed and no mortgage to pay which would have been reasons to stay despite being unhappy, right after leaving the show she did Pet Sematary and got to meet Stephen King and that was more fun for her than the entire first season of TNG and it would not have happened had she stayed on TNG.

J
Jovet · December 20, 2023

I read it ages ago. But I can't quote it. Alas I can't really respond to this comment until the entire show is over.

A
AzoriusMage · December 20, 2023

Someone cutting onions?

K
KatWithAttitude · December 20, 2023

There are reasons why things were paced the way they were. You'll get lots of behind the scenes explanations in the other thread.

P
Paul Rymer · December 20, 2023

if I were you I wouldn't look up Denise Crosby and TNG to know the backstory as it may impact on your enjoyment of the show. Look up all that stuff after you've finished it all. "Chaos On The Bridge" covers most of the backstage shenanegans.

T
Target Audience · December 20, 2023

Yeah, the thing is even if the Patrons don’t go full into it we already know there will be hundreds of different versions of the story in our YouTube comments lol

J
JD Nevesytrof · December 20, 2023

And once again, one of you guys muse you'd love to see something in particular that we all know you'll get down the line! Little joys whenever that happens.

R
Rich Cirivilleri · December 20, 2023

I’m so sorry guys. Nevermore have I wanted to warn you that something awful was coming up. But I had to honor that no spoilers rule.R.I.P. Tasha🙁