FULL DISCUSSION - Star Trek TNG S1E22 - Symbiosis
Comments (57)
The "force lightning" powers the aliens had are a little bit reminiscent of what Bele and Lokai did to each other in "Let That Be Your Last Battlefield." Except nobody ever speculated about how they got those powers.
Commenting drug addiction so openly in a fictional TV show was a big thing back in 88. Maybe it wasn't new but surely it was new to me and my friends. I remember being quite shocked about it.
I always thought that Enterprise came to their rescue because they were obviously a spacefaring society which is generally Starfleet's line in the sand for contacting people at all. Responding to a distress call from another ship is just something they do. They had no way of knowing who or what was on board, their level of technological sophistication or the potential ramifications of saving them. They only had a few minutes. If they would have let the crew and drugs burn up in the atmosphere then the relationship between the planets would've been altered on the spot. Because of that unintended consequence, I always thought Beverly was right in this episode. They should have at least told them. It would've set things back to the way they would have been if Enterprise had never been in that solar system in the first place.
Imo that Picard denied the Onarans the parts for their freighters was an extremely strong scene in the episode. As Picard said, the Prime Directive is a philosophy and it has to be flexible in a way and be applied differently and with reason in every new situation. At first he offered to help them repair their freighters because that's just helping them out, but as he learned about the whole situation the two peoples were involved in, he denied the Onarans the parts at the end because it was the only way to tell them indirectly: "You can learn things for yourselves. You are NOT dependant for everything on others. If you can learn how to repair your own freighters, you can learn many other things, too." So in strengthening their will to research, to learn and to build he hoped to also strengthen their ability to learn to develop medicine that maybe will alleviate the withdrawal sympthoms and probably discover that they will not die. That way it can develop naturally instead of just giving them everything they needed right there. Of course the part that sucked is 1) that they will go through severe pains and there will be suffering from the withdrawal and 2) they can't be sure the Onarans WILL develop that way, but it was a nudge in the right direction. It's a matter of 'Don't give them water but help them learn how to find it themselves'. It was a tough decision and I think they made that very clear by having Beverly be the one who speaks for all the people watching and wanting to help these people as well. But ultimately Picard made the right choice despite the pressure he got from all around him. Also, it might have been difficult to deal with any repercussions the Breccians might bring up had the Federation interfered like that. After all, their entire society was built on producing the drug, had Picard taken that away from them it would have been a huge intereference in these people lives, but now they too will have time to change the focus of their society to learn again to support themselves with doing other things. :) Love and greetings from Germany! :)
Wes has never dealt with this because in Star treks time they have no need for drugs
Their stoned man shot I can’t run my pc after 4:20
Plus Picard knew this was the way to break the breccians hold on them
What’s with all the David hate
Right? David is kind of a whiny character, but he didn't bother me that much. He wasn't a big enough character to annoy me that much.
Back in the 1980s almost every popular show had either a scene or an entire episode like the Wesley-Tasha chat about drugs. Nancy Reagan’s “Just Say No” campaign was even paying networks and producers to include such messages.
I can imagine the Onaran government rationing the final shipment to stretch it longer for the administrators/police/doctors while the poor common folk descend fully into withdrawals...but once they realize no one is dying, the two Brekkians left on the planet are in some deep, deep doo-doo.
Thanks for reading my post, guys! BTW, watching Star Trek in stardate order would entail interspersing some TAS episodes among TOS. The stardates depend partly on location in the galaxy and can't be used to determine the precise order in which episodes take place. (Of course, the general fan assumption is that TAS takes place entirely after TOS -- the Enterprise bridge has been refitted to add a second exit, Chekov has left the ship for tactical training, Arex has replaced Chekov on the alpha shift of the bridge crew, and Starfleet has introduced the life support belts.)
I think the TNG and later stardates are pretty much in order of episode airing. It was TOS that the stardates jumped around a lot, and production vs. airing order already confuses things. Also I think the show with the least stardates must be DS9 as they're in one location, and it's rare to have a captain's log entry.
actually DS9 had stardates in the majority of it's episodes. For some reason though, around 1998-2000, it seems the production crews on both shows just stopped giving a shit about stardates and few appear on either show. They picked up again in the last season of voyager
It's easy to argue maybe Picard was morally wrong here, but the simple act of telling them the truth would have completely overturned the society of two planets. And then the Federation would be responsible for what happened. Interesting though you can argue he realized that helping them repair those ships wouldn't be right either with an extremely strict interpretation. And that sounds like I'm talking about the Constitution or something.
IMO he was absolutely wrong. If Enterprise had never rescued the people on the ship the people on planet would've gone through withdrawal and been freed of their reliance. They screwed things up in the first five minutes in the process of doing what was absolutely the right thing. "It is possible to make no mistakes and still lose." Telling them or even just destroying the drugs somehow would've put things back to the way they would've been had Enterprise never intervened.
as I commented on the reaction post I really like the ending and think Picard's reaction to the way things wrapped up is understandable and shows that even though he is strictly regulated he still feels empathy
This Public Service Announcement was brought to you by... "SHUT UP, WESLEY!"
Gentlemen, welcome to the TNG/DS9/VOY era of "bumpy forehead" aliens! As time goes on we do of course get some cool, very alien designs in the mix over the seasons, but nose/forehead makeup on humans is common. I'm sure it's budgetary more than anything else.
The Prime Directive is an “Umbrella” policy in that Picard saved them in the freighter, but that act alone did not impact the total civilization. But giving them coil technology would solve their issue for them, and directly effects the entire civilization. If Picard took away the drug, that WOULD implicate the Federation in changing the course of their future. Their “natural” end would be that eventually the freighters would no longer work, and they would have to work that out anyway, even if the Enterprise was never there. If Beverly blew the whistle, (she wanted to so bad) she would be violating the PD, and Picard, being responsible for everything on his ship, would suffer the consequences.
A human\alien species did come down, but that is another (brilliant) series! ;)
It really was not in violation of the Prime Directive to help them with the parts and make repairs. They are a post-warp society. They have evolved naturally as a species to warrant being helped in that manor. If they were a pre-warp society it would violate the directive if they actually helped them advance in any way technologically. Regardless in any case it would always be in violation of the Prime Directive to interfere in the social/political order of their society on the planet because they are not members of the Federation.
Ya people talk like the Prime Directive is actually something that is consistently defined from episode to episode...its just not
Picard's solution: He made a humanitarian gesture of saving the lives of strangers (a species who was already in space so they weren't interfering with their natural progression) but then found their culture to be distasteful to his Federation/human sensibilities. With his hands tied on that end by the Prime Directive, at the last minute makes his only move: EMBRACE the Prime Directive. Essentially, the Enterprise, while morally-driven to save the lives of others, was not ethically-driven to do so under the Prime Directive. Whether the crew lived or not, the ship was going to blow in the beginning, and they would be without a means of transport. So Picard evened that playing field again, by refusing the coils. Now the planets are exactly where they would have been at the beginning anyway, save the reprieve of a few people and a final batch of "meds" to hopefully stave off immediate death and give them time to prepare for not having any more. It makes sense to me.
In this episode: Khan's son, Joachim, plays the long game in his revenge against Kirk's lineage...
In regards to the Prime Directive, in most situations it probably wouldn't have prevented them from helping, Picard just interpreted the Law in a way that he couldn't, to screw over the Brekians. You know the whole Trope of the snake lawyer twisting legal definitions to suit his purpose
Wesley learns a valuable lesson on A Very Special Star Trek. This had an interesting problem and they never stopped to consider if they break the drug habit, the right thing to do, what happens to the world that has no function other than making the drug? There is no other industry, so its not like they have options themselves. Without the addicts as customers there options now are to either export the drug to every planet they can, or just die.
I thought that the only thing Wesley learned is that he doesn't understand drug addiction.
Ha! The humanoid aliens with a nose appliance is really a staple of Next Gen. get used to it.
Most certainly
Guys, it’s pretty obscure now but if you can ever catch an early 80s show called “Square Pegs” on streaming it’s worth it. Merrit Butrick played a zoned out “valley guy” high schooler alongside a geeky, glasses wearing permed teen Sarah Jessica Parker. He was actually pretty awesome in it.
Don't forget, Wesley is also theson of a Doctor, he's probably had healthy living rammed down his throat his whole life. And as Dr. Crusher indicates, she can make non-addictive substances to counter-act the drugs effects. The implication are that drugs really are a thing of the past. Personally, I never heard judgement in Wesley's questions, he wasjust curious and wanted to understand. Some fans have taken Tasha's explanation about drugs to have an air of experience to it as well. We DO know she has a dark as heck past. Regarding the opening scenes: I'm not sure either of you have had any experience with heavy, continuous drug users, sadly I have and it getsto the point where cognative abilities just tank and a person does just get so blasie about everything, especially if a person has been hooked through developmental stages of life, which these guys have been. Every man, woman and child has been addicted to drugs since birth, so it's no wonder they go through phases of lethargic apathy, regardless of how naturally intelligent they may be. As for the PD and where it applies, it not about helping or not, but about affecting development. Picard didn't mind giving them the parts when it was just to fix their ships, but when he realized not having the parts would lead to their society changing, forcing the issue naturally via those species' own inabilities, he felt justified in witholding those parts. Giving those parts would have unnaturally furthered the status quo which was about to change anyway. He didn't know that when he first offered.
I really appreciate your post. I had a drug problem in my 20’s (Im 48 now). I became born again, but that was such a learning experience for me. And you’re right. They were either high in the beginning, or, more likely, just starting to withdraw, and were so distracted and had no real experience in ships or technology BECAUSE of their sole focus on the drugs. My favorite scene is when they Take their 1st hit in sickbay, and the slow zoom on Beverly, as she observes and realizes whats happening. Picard with the checkmate. He’s the man. But yeah, your post hit my heart, because Ive been there.
The Prime Directive isn't a ban on helping people, it's a ban on affecting the development of less developed cultures. Picard offers to help repair their ships initially because he assumes that any culture capable of building a fleet of ships would also be capable of repairing them - making it a little easier or faster for them isn't going to make a difference in the grand scheme of things. But once it becomes clear that nobody on either planet is capable of repairing the ships without help from the Enterprise, his hands are tied and he's forced to let things play out naturally.
About your dual comments about "what about...." (the disease, then the transporter issue maybe filtering it out of those affected) - and instantly Picard asked the same questions...... This got me thinking: pretty soon, you guys will be able to collaborate in writing your own Star Trek episode. Hey, why not? What would you write about, you may ask..... (LOL - anticipating your question). Do what all good writers do: Write About What You Know About.
Guys, have you two acquired those S E A T B E L T S which I suggested earlier this week? Now, and starting after Symbiosis, you will find they're needed when watching a LOT of the next episodes .... and throughout many of the rest of TNG. (That's not a joke, fellas, but you can wear them metaphorically, and it will work just as well. I hope.) That last is stated with a knowing smirk, in wonderful anticipation of how you'll react to what's yet to come from The Final Frontier........
:In River Song's voice: *spoilers!*
It amuses me so much that you call her Doctor Beverly. Eventually you'll find out why this amuses me.
Yes; some of us have been thinking of that exact thing, Jovet, every time Josh calls her that. LOL..............
11:04 Wesley's viewpoint is actually really well written. Consider his life up to this point, and how things are in 24th century human society. Drug addiction is a completely foreign concept to him. Not only has he never dealt with that in his life, but he hasn't known anyone who has.
Exactly. You have to remember that humanity at this point has irradicated war, poverty and disease. They are even at the point where currency doesn't exist and people work for the betterment of themselves rather than monetary gain. They are essentially the perfect future utopia. While it does come off as somewhat preachy anti-drug speech, it actually makes sense in the context of the Trek universe.
8:30 Asking for help (as in a distress signal) from a spacecraft negates the Prime Directive's non-interference policy.
There had to be someone at Paramount casting who knew what they were doing when casting Judson Scott and Merritt Buttrick. I thought, sadly, his natural health at the time probably helped with his overall appearance as a drug-addicted alien going through withdrawal. Your comment about Picard at the end reminded me why I didn't like his character during most of the 1st season. I thought he was too stern, to the point of being a dick at times, which is not what I am looking for in the personality of a starship captain. Of course, Stewart and the others get better with their characters as the show progresses, beginning for me with the last couple of season 1 episodes.
That's interesting. I never found Picard ever unlikable. He's firm and fair, decisive, and authoritative. He doesn't let his romantic nature get the better of him.
I said during a lot of the TOS reactions that they would sometimes beat us over the head with a message to be sure we "got it". This was borderline with the talk between Tasha and Wesley, but as others have said, this was pretty typical of 80s TV. You said you're in your late 20s now, and that's how old I was when TNG started. Don't know if that really means anything.
You’re so right about the 80s drug messaging. Typical 80s would have had Wesley going to the holodeck to research why “drugs are bad” and a holographic Nancy Reagan tells him to “just say no!” Ha..so yeah, this was pretty light in comparison.
(the following is light hearted ripping) I have to say, I didn't see you guys not getting why the addicts lost the ability to run and fix ships was an issue. ***news flash*** people on drugs lose the ability to take care of themselves... SHOCKER... take that to multiple generations and maybe the grandkids of the first drug addicts and kid of an addict.... perhaps that junkie is not really all that productive. JUST SAY NO...... (except weed then pass it dude)
This is from the perspective of a child around adolescence in 1988. Drugs were considered something bad. Pharmaceuticals weren’t even lumped into the same group as “drugs”. Lots of shows had a special, dramatic “drugs are dangerous” episode.
Yes. The whole pharmaceutical companies as evil entities trying to get people hooked their medicine is more a recent thing, at least to public knowledge.
Well, Star Trek did hint at aliens coming to Earth in the past. Remember TAS with Kukulkan?
And mentioned in The Paradise Syndrome episode of TOS, if memory serves.
so my take as to why the prime directive seems to not apply earlier but then it does apply later, is simply that at the start the onarans are found piloting a space vessel, poorly but they are in a space vessel nonetheless. one could assume they're advanced enough that the prime directive wouldn't apply. It's only later that Picard learns just how unadvanced they are.. and decides that the prime directive does in fact apply here
… and I also think he considers it a useful excuse to ensure they do go cold turkey and end the addiction
The Prime Directive prevented Picard from taking overt steps to end the dependency between the two planets. However, he used the Prime Directive as an excuse to not fix shuttles, which will indirectly cause the dependency to be broken once the shuttles stop working. In other words, giving them coils would not have broken the Prime Directive, but denying them the coils was the only action he could take within the bounds of the Prime Directive that would eventually result in the symbiotic relationship coming to an end.
I think the main reason why the Onarans no longer know how to maintain their ships is that their entire industry is now converted to serve the needs of the Brekkians. They no longer have the capability to dedicate people to keeping that knowledge going. At least that's the best I can figure.
If the whole "symbiosis" is based on the exchange of the drug and goods interplenetary transport would be at the core of "serving the needs". It doesn't make sense. Also if all people of Onara are junkies how can they be a able to run the economy for TWO societies?
FIRST!!!!
