FULL DISCUSSION - Star Trek TNG S1E21 - The Arsenal of Freedom
Comments (22)
my flimsy justification for the killer drones being turned off so easily is just that no one before could locate the command center to turn it off :D
Overall I liked it there’s somequestionable stuff, like Logan only being there as a conflict to Geordi. First he wants to leave and when Geordi leaves he screams at him for that. And at the end the battle is just to give Geordi something to overcome. He’s still in the atmosphere when he drops the shields they should have burned up. But good character stuff and the beginning of using Troi correctly
The crew of the Drake, I can understand. They never found the underground control cavern, so they were focused on opposing the flying unit (a no-win scenario as they grow stronger). But the original population didn't make a kill-switch for these things that THEY invented?
For those Gen-X or older "The Lollipop. It was a good ship." is a Laugh-Out-Loud reference to an old Shirley Temple song that's worth the Google. Also this episode has a slow-burn way of sticking with you. I'm betting you'll remember it a little more fondly at season's end.
The menace was kind of dumb. The planet was being killed and nobody thought to tell it they'll buy it and shut it off, but half delirious Crusher figured that out? The whole used car salesman guy reminded me of Jon Lovitz and that's not really a good fit for ST. 20 episodes in I am not sure that this is a show that would stand up to endless rewatching. This was kind of meh, as are most of the episodes. It's charmless, and bizarrely, it's also intentionally mellow most of the time. I listen to Gates McF, Jonathan Frakes, and all of them and I find myself missing DeForest Kelly and the energy he brought to his scenes. 7/10 tops, kind of dull thanks to the enemy.
I think this is one of the less-dumb ones of the season.
There are episodes where the Enterprise is referred to as the flagship of Starfleet. So I imagine they took the legacy of the ship seriously, and must have had a lot of confidence in Picard to put him in charge.
On Riker choosing to serve on the Enterprise over commanding the Drake; yes the name has a prestige to it, even if it's not the OG, but additionally, the Galaxy class ships were at the time supposed to be the most advanced ship in Starfleet. A lot of officers would want to serve on them to be on the cutting edge.
Not to mention the Enterprise is the flagship of Starfleet and clearly has the most interesting assignments.
I think Riker and Tasha could have jumped and let Data catch them..like wee babies..
I can't believe we've made it just five episodes from everyone finally shutting up about Season One!
We want to enjoy the ride as much as possible but yeah agreed
I guess you never heard of The Good Ship Lollipop. Google it for a blast from the past. Apparently Riker is a Shirley Temple fan. Fun fact: the sand in the cavern was infested with fleas so Patrick Stewart and Gates McFadden were getting attacked all through filming those scenes.
Josh, if you already saw Terminator I and II, you're done buddy, you're good.
What are the armaments of the USS Lolipop!? Favorite season1 episode, big breakout for Jeordi. Though I think there was an editing mistake as they had to destroy the Giant Drone ship after Picard had apparently turned it off. Also Fun Fact, Beverly isn't the first main Cast member human born off world, Nurse Chapelle was born on the Moon
And Kirk was...well, let's not talk about that.
I agree with Josh: a solid episode. I give it a B. Makes you think what happened to the crew of the Drake and how dumb were they for not figuring out how to turn off the war machine.
18:10 Yes, none of them figured out how to shut if off. Remember, it was considered invincible.
9:40 I think the story was written just fine. The only thing is the surface unit dematerializing but the one in orbit not is the small questionable bit. And Data throwing Tasha around never gets old. LOL!
1:38 When looking at the bridge from the main viewscreen: the Conn is the left-hand position and steers the ship. Ops is the right-hand position and interfaces all the ship's systems. (These positions were reversed in the pilot.)
Termineighbor. Nice.
Well, you guys are now going to get sued for using the Terminator theme in your video. There goes all that Patreon money.
